11 ms·
Economies, when left alone, are about as resilient as cockroaches and much more brutal about securing themselves. The situation is a serious blow to the pride o
by roenxi 4y ago
Economies, when left alone, are about as resilient as cockroaches and much more brutal about securing themselves. The situation is a serious blow to the pride of the European politicians who look like they've been mishandling energy policy for years (where are the nuclear reactors?). But realistically they'll probably survive in practice. It'll be painful.
The issue is that somehow the West has taken Iraq 2.0 and is turning it into the prelude for a WWIII. We shouldn't be encouraging Russia and China to ally, and we should be giving Russia as many diplomatic off-ramps to calm the situation down as is humanly possible. Demonising people doesn't help. All the face-slapping that has been taking place has been unproductive.
- 1ris 4y ago>where are the nuclear reactors? In France. Mostly idling.
- ben_bai 4y agoTo add: They are idling b.c. 1) some are old and under disrepair and 2) it's so hot right now, that there is not enough cooling to run them at full load.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoI had no idea outputs are hindered by weather. Do you know if this applies to newer reactors as well, or just older ones France is operating?
- modo_mario 4y agoThese things can run in the middle east or India. The concern is that river life will be harmed.
- kennend3 4y agoFrance claims two things: - Reactors are seasonally idle and will ramp back up for winter - During this normally idle time, they do maintenance https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/minister-french-nuclear-reactors-restart-winter-89226525 https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/minister-fren... Perhaps this idea that "half of France's reactors are idle" is partly true, partly scare tactics from the "anti-nuke" group? Nuclear reactors require vast amounts of cooling water so timing your "down time" to coincide with low water levels does make sense. Here(Ontario) we build them on the shores of Lake Ontario and the intake pipe extends far into the lake to avoid any sort of water level fluctuations impacting power production.
- phicoh 4y agoThis summer, France has been importing significant amounts of electricity from countries that burn gas or coal. You don't do that if you have plenty of nuclear power available.
- kennend3 4y agoRe-read what i wrote.. if you know that water levels will be low and you purposely idle your reactors annually.. then you do import power. It looks like this is NOT a new problem (from 2016) https://www.economist.com/business/2016/12/01/frances-nuclear-energy-champion-is-in-turmoil https://www.economist.com/business/2016/12/01/frances-nuclea...
- phicoh 4y agoThis can in theory happen to any steam-based power plant. Using steam to generate electricity is about 30% efficient. So you still need to get rid of the other 70% of heat that is generated, but not converted to electricity. So it would also happen to power plants that burn coal.
- kennend3 4y agoThis! People think this is a "nuclear" problem. .it is a cooling water problem regardless of where the heat came from.
- Thlom 4y agoThe water in the rivers providing cooling water is so warm that the water that comes out the other end crosses a temperature threshold set to protect the river down stream. As I understand the situation at least. Technically the plants can run at full load, but you'd risk harm life in the river downstream.
- thatfrenchguy 4y ago55% of French electricity as of right now: https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/FR?solar=false&remote=true&wind=false https://app.electricitymaps.com/zone/FR?solar=false&remote=t...
- chasd00 4y ago>> where are the nuclear reactors? > In France. Mostly idling. Isn't the problem natural gas and not electricity? If there was a reactor on every corner wouldn't Germany and the other countries still be in the same boat? They can't convert all that natural gas infrastructure over to electricity in a couple months..
- rjzzleep 4y agoWhat you're describing is basically why Kissinger et al lobbied to kick out Taiwan from the UN, lobbied to shut down Taiwan's nuclear weapons program at the UN and worked so hard to intertwine US and Chinese economies. It's also the reason why Kissinger had that speech and the WEF advising the political leadership of the west to change course. It doesn't really matter though, there seems to be no way to have a reasonable discussion on this topic without being attacked as a Putin sympathizer in most places of the "free world".
- starkd 4y agoIn fairness, there are many who got it wrong on China. Not just Kissinger. Many made a lot of money off of China as an emerging market. Trying to calm the situation down in Ukraine is to his credit. Few seem to be calling for a ceasefire. On the contrary, they seem to doing all they can to scuttle any kind of agreement.
- jeromegv 4y agoA ceasefire only benefits Russia, because they are the ones that gained territory in eastern Ukraine and would serve them well to not have to fight for this territory and just make it under their umbrella. It's clearly what they want. I don't know who are the "they" that are trying to destroy any kind of agreement, but there hasn't been any type of close agreement as Ukraine made it very clear that they don't want anything else beside Russia leaving their territory. Any type of territory concession is a non-starter for any agreement on Ukraine side. I'm just going to assume that you are American. If Russia invaded Alaska.. would you advocate for a "ceasefire" and tell people they should negotiate an agreement... that would keep Russia on the sovereign territory of the US? I'm assuming no. Then why are you advocating for this?
- rjzzleep 4y agoI don't like the guy, and I absolutely don't agree with most of what him and his administration did. But the one thing that they got right(which every person outside of the collective west seems to understand) is that only a complete madman would throw the biggest nuclear power, the biggest natural resource country and the biggest missile manufacturer in the world right into the arms of the biggest manufacturing power in the world. They did what they did, so the decisions that are being done now need to be done with the current state of reality in mind.
- starkd 4y agoToo many in charge of policy who have never served in the military. War can be more profitable than peace. They could have had a cease fire, but they squelched it.
- 1ris 4y agoBecause the west was too greedy, and thus to cautious about sanctions when this war started in 2014. For russia war actually looked more profitable that the status quo, and i can see why.
- bhaak 4y agoWhat diplomatic off ramp does Russia need? There is a simple first step towards redemption and that is get out of Ukraine right now. Better yesterday. Western Europe just learned a painful lesson that you can't trust Russia. Eastern Europe tried to hammer that point into the brains of the other European politicians but it didn't work until now.
- roenxi 4y agoThere were a bunch of people making a deal about how we'd gone out and done piracy to Russian yachts, legal questions be damned. If there are any options people are not looking for them. There'll be something. > Western Europe just learned a painful lesson that you can't trust Russia. Do you recall what happened to people who trusted the British? A lot of them died. And they were almost the nice Europeans. Trusting the Americans is foolish, trusting the Chinese is insane. The Indians will turn out to be perfidious in time. Everyone is untrustworthy. There should be more serious grappling with why the Russians did this (and Crimea in 2014) than "Putin bad". The last time a president started trying to calm the situation down he was hounded for it - the whole strategy here is mad and stupid. If the West can deal on good terms with China and the Middle East then we can be friends with Russia too. We need serious attempts and ongoing discussion about how to stop military escalation.
- junofan 4y ago> There should be more serious grappling with why the Russians did this (and Crimea in 2014) than "Putin bad" There won’t be. We are being lied to.
- jeromegv 4y ago> There should be more serious grappling with why the Russians did this (and Crimea in 2014) than "Putin bad". Why don't you give us your explanation? It's just very odd to advocate for an appeasement policy when the aggressor keeps wanting more (first Crimea, then tried to take the whole Ukraine by going straight for the capital). It wasn't just Eastern Ukraine with Russian-speaking population, they went straight to the capital. I'd say the west is perfectly fine with ignoring a lot of their principles for the sake of peace and money, China and Middle East are very good examples of it as you just said. The west was even perfectly happy to roll over their principles just to get the gas they needed from Russia. It looks like it's Russia that self destroyed all those economical agreements for the sake of wanting to expand their borders.
- Schroedingersat 4y ago> where are the nuclear reactors? Same place as usual. Decades behind schedule, 3x over budget, often cancelled, and then sitting idle in spite of near unlimited public subsidy. All while tying up enough money in cleanup costs for a single disaster to double worldwide wind capacity.
- modo_mario 4y agoSomehow this does not seem to be an issue for most nuclear power plants built in the past in Europe or most built elsewhere today. Here in Belgium the reactors were built and gridconnected in 4-6 years and China still seems to pull similar with it's French or more modern designs.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThe EPRs are all going just great https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taishan_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taishan_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinkley_Point_C_nuclear_power_station https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hinkley_Point_C_nuclear_powe... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flamanville_Nuclear_Power_Plant https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flamanville_Nuclear_Power_Pl...
- lawn 4y ago> Demonising people doesn't help. Letting a country get away with genocide with a slap off the wrist will only encourage them to do it again.