3 ms·
The only way I could be sane as a scientist (I'm an ex-scientist) is by ignoring large parts of the literature. In fact, I think one of the greatest skills a s
by dekhn 4y ago
The only way I could be sane as a scientist (I'm an ex-scientist) is by ignoring large parts of the literature. In fact, I think one of the greatest skills a scientist can have is to know when not to read a paper or even really consider the title.
My own work in science was deeply quantitative and the bar for evidence was very high. Nearly every time I read a clinical paper (with the exception of professionally run clinical trials with a good statistical design and rigid adherence to protocols), it takes only a little time to find an "invalidating statement"- a description of methodology or a core assumption or a common mistake- for me to realize that investing further time is simply not worth it.
It doesn't mean that I necessarily believe the opposite of the paper, but rather fall back on my own prior assumptions/null hypothesis explanation.