8 ms·
California Isn’t Backing Off Bullet Train
- fragsworth 15y agoAs a resident of Los Angeles, I don't see why we are funding this project ahead of advancing L.A.'s pathetic rail/subway system. Traffic in L.A. is so bad during rush "hour" (which lasts several hours) that you can't travel by car faster than walking speed. It routinely takes 30+ minutes to travel 3 miles or so. Car is your only option in most locations. The state would benefit from a solid metro system in L.A. FAR more than one between L.A. and S.F. I can only hope that this metro will link Downtown L.A. to West L.A. and spur local metro development.
- beagledude 15y agoagreed, by 2033 it's going to be a disaster here if no solutions are completed by then.
- ars 15y agoThese things fix themself to some degree. If it's that bad people move out (or don't move in). Then it becomes not as bad. You end up with a steady state where things are as pad as people are willing to tolerate, but it never reaches "disaster".
- iFire 15y agoBecause SF is more important than LA, in terms of wealth generation.
- iFire 15y agoIf SF is the center of the technology universe, it would make sense to make LA the place where you live and SF where you work. This is why the Japanese commute to Tokyo by trains from the suburbs.
- prodigal_erik 15y ago380 miles is a hell of a commute. That's going to take two hours each way (plus travel to/from stations), unless we manage to build a maglev or something. I do expect large-scale airlines to be infeasible to fuel someday, but by then I don't think we'll be able to operate this either. I just don't see the use case. Edit: They're actually figuring 2.5 hours and 430 miles, due to an excursion through Freno and Bakersfield: http://www.cahighspeedrail.ca.gov/trip_planner.aspx http://www.cahighspeedrail.ca.gov/trip_planner.aspx
- waterlesscloud 15y agoIt's also going through Lancaster, I guess because Tehachapi Pass is easier to navigate than the Grapevine, which is probably true. But it does add some miles.
- _dps 15y agoAccording to http://esa.un.org/wup2009/unup/index.asp?panel=2 http://esa.un.org/wup2009/unup/index.asp?panel=2 (cited at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_GDP#America.2C_North http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_cities_by_GDP#America.2...), Los Angeles is behind only New York in GDP, and San Francisco isn't even in the top five. Sure, you can throw in Santa Clara and maybe get something close but I haven't done those calculations. Los Angeles has essentially all the entertainment industry west of the Mississipi, the tech industry that supports it, the logistics/distribution businesses based out of Long Beach, the "cradle of aerospace" businesses like Raytheon and Boeing, and of course a huge diverse population doing lots of diverse things.
- iFire 15y agoHow far would the commute be from LA to SF to Cupertino? If there's a local transit network, I would include Apple's revenues. OED: 1. they commute on a stuffy overcrowded train: travel to and from work, travel to and fro, travel back and forth, come and go, shuttle. Travelling home during the weekends and then back on weekdays continuously would be commuting.
- melling 15y agoWhy didn't LA fund mass transit 40 years ago instead of building more roads? The US now has 100 million more people, so building bullet trains is going to be more costly. However, in 40 more years, I imagine that it will be even more difficult with 400 million Americans. We really need to invest in moving people and goods a more effectively now.
- hemancuso 15y ago> Traffic in L.A. is so bad during rush "hour" (which lasts several hours) that you can't travel by car faster than walking speed. It routinely takes 30+ minutes to travel 3 miles or so. Car is your only option in most locations. Bicycles? Have you heard of'm?
- bravura 15y agoHave you tried to bike from Venice Beach to Silverlake? 90 minutes. Santa Monica to Hollywood? 1 hour. For long journeys, public transportation.
- benjiweber 15y agoIf only there were some way to combine them http://www.brompton.co.uk/ http://www.brompton.co.uk/
- waterlesscloud 15y agoEvery person I know in L.A. who uses a bicycle as one of their primary transportation options has been hit by a car at least once. No thanks.
- uuilly 15y agoFor the last two years I worked on autonomous cars. The one thing everyone in our company agreed on, regardless of political persuasion, was that robo-cars were going to thunder fuck the high speed rail. A 2033 deadline makes this all but certain.
- cletus 15y agoI tend to agree that autonomous vehicles will revolutionize not only transport but society. That's how big I think they'll be. Say goodbye to the vast majority of automobile deaths every year. But that still doesn't address the problem facing most large cities: gridlock. Whether the cars are automated or not won't drastically change that (although it may well reduce arterial traffic clogs due to accidents and rubbernecking) because there are still more cars than the roads can handle. I really don't know why California is pursuing this. Planes are entirely valid solution to the problem of travelling between LA and SF. Why spend billions on an alternative that's going to take twenty years? If anything, spend the money on public transport to reduce reliance on cars. The situation is decent in SF, poor in the Valley (Caltrain covers a limited area and runs quite infrequently) and woeful in LA. The 101 out of SF tends to be a car park at certain times (although not as bad as LA). The big problem is that LA isn't really space-constrained. It has the ocean on the west but has sprawled far north, south and east. People like their big homes and that's a recipe for disaster when it comes to public transport. The only places public transport seems to work at all are those areas densely population or that have existing infrastructure (eg the commuter belt around NYC). But Dallas? Atlanta? LA? Chicago? Very limited public transport.
- stretchwithme 15y agoActually, the robotic car will make for very cheap cabs that can be much smaller. Most will only need to carry a passenger and can have a much smaller engine without the need for speed that human drivers have. So, smaller vehicles almost always moving and not parking will take up a lot less room per person-mile.
- ars 15y ago
- VladRussian 15y ago>But for many Californians, struggling through a bleak era that has led some people to wonder if the state’s golden days are behind it, this project goes to the heart of the state’s pioneering spirit, recalling grand public investments in universities, water systems, roads and parks that once defined California as the leading edge of the nation. well, why don't we return the golden days and invest these billions in the universities, water systems, roads and parks ... And if there some money left - for healthcare and basic school education. That would definitely put CA back on the leading edge of the nation.
- nobody314159265 15y agoInvest in roads - presumably for cars powered by oil to drive on? Now that's a long term vision of the future!
- VladRussian 15y ago>Invest in roads - presumably for cars to drive on powered by oil. Now that's a long term vision of the future! roads are presumably for wheeled vehicles. Until you can show a good prospects for flying cars, we need roads. Edit: Despite the lobby and being favored by the political system, the use of fossil fuels in cars is going away. Even today, the 30KW batteries weighting 500kg will get you 150mi range at the price $10-20K - about the price and weight of ICE engine + transmission. The avalanche is starting ... The argument that there is no infrastructure to fill-up the electric cars is BS - the electricity is everywhere, including existing gas stations. Some upgrades may be necessary though - this is exactly minor (compare to the rail system) investment that would provide huge return.
- nobody314159265 15y agoTo be pulled by horses or mexican immigrants ? Edit: well you might get the range if you want to drive tiny little Honda golf carts at 30mph. But what about real men that want to drive a 5000hp electric train at 300mph
- mkramlich 15y agoPublic transit: more efficient on the macro scale, but less on the micro (individual) scale. Close that gap and you'll have me, and probably a lot of other folks, and not before. As others have mentioned in this thread, perhaps robo-cars can fill that role.
- curt 15y agoThere are only two profitable high-speed rail lines in the ENTIRE WORLD. One in Japan and I believe the other is in France. High speed rail just doesn't make sense especially in the spread out urban centers that make up the US. The last mile problem is huge. Someone commented on the airports being near capacity. That's only because our air traffic system is horrible. If they updated the system and automated much of it, we could drastically increase capacity since the planes could fly straighter routes instead of the current zig zap pattern and fly much closer together safely. Sadly the air traffic controllers union won't allow the changes since they'll lose jobs in the productivity increase.
- wiredfool 15y agoNo, right now the big constraint on air travel is runways. You need 3,5, or 7 miles between planes depending on size, and that works out to one flight every minute or two per non-conflicting runway. Seattle just completed a third parallel runway, that gives them three simultaneous ops in good weather, and two in bad. Atlanta has 5 or 6 now.
- easp 15y agoWhat's your point, re profitability? Are highway systems and surface roads "profitable?" And the airline industry (as opposed to the aircraft industry) has generated little or no wealth in more than half a century of existence.
- StuffMaster 15y agoThe point of high-speed rail isn't to be profitable, it's to transport people. You won't believe how unprofitable interstate highways are.
- vacri 15y agoI visited California in 2009 and found it very strange that there wasn't a daily direct train between the two largest cities. Every second day there was a connecting bus between LA and Bakersfield. Two largest cities in the world's eigth largest economy, and there's no daily train between them. Very odd.
- waterlesscloud 15y agoThere's daily trains from LA to San Jose (which is actually bigger in terms of population than SF). You can then connect on commuter rail to SF. Not ideal, but an option. I think the reasoning is that SF would be either a dead end for a train line, due to the whole peninsula thing, or an expensive place to build a rail line out of, across the bay.
- Sanddancer 15y agoSan Francisco is not the largest city in the area (San Jose has about 200,000 more people), let alone the state (San Diego has more than San Jose), and has a number of geographical problems with any associated train system between Los Angeles and San Francisco. Because it's at the edge of a peninsula, getting from anywhere else requires fairly significant engineering feats, and due to the slowness of Amtrak, most people don't want to take an 8+ hour train trip; both flying and driving are faster than the train.
- vacri 15y agoWe may measure city populations differently - where I am, we go by the metropolitan area. Wikipedia lists SF as a metro population of 4 million, San Diego 3, and San Jose only 2. The bulk of the trip is outside SF though - that 8+ hours has little to do with the very end of the trip... something a bullet train might help with.
- leoh 15y agoIt's not a terrible idea, but our Public university system is crumbling on 3 billion a year and Brown wants to invest 98 billion (an average of roughly 4.6 billion a year) on a train. Sounds like a bad long term strategy to me. Then again, epic public projects are huge sources of pride and tell the world "California is not falling into the past," unlike so many other aspects of a country in mature decline. I think that free or 1980's level-priced UC education would easily be on par with a train, if not even better; especially what's been said about autonomous driving. For all we know, if states play their hand right, there could be a ton of never-before-seen widespread private fundin for road systems, if this whole autonomous thing takes off.
- callmeed 15y agoMy family owns a 320 acre ranch in the valley and one of the proposed rail routes runs right through it. I've yet to hear details on how the state plans to handle compensation.
- Anechoic 15y agoIME the state won't start talking compensation until after the Final Environmental Impact Report has been accepted for your segment.