6 ms·
Given that he's already written an entire OS, I don't think he's being too ambitious. It already passes Acid3, which is more than can be said for Dillo and NetS
by userbinator 4y ago
Given that he's already written an entire OS, I don't think he's being too ambitious. It already passes Acid3, which is more than can be said for Dillo and NetSurf, the two other prominent "alternative browser" projects. Those aren't even capable of passing Acid2.
The Ladybird browser came to life on July 4th
Coincidence or not, that's a great date.
- andrewmcwatters 4y agoAcid tests are not strict standards test suites. You should not be looking to adhere to them.
- bastawhiz 4y agoNo, but they're good signals for the capabilities of a browser engine. Passing Acid3 means you've got a browser that would have been pretty damn good in 2010 or so. It's a good mark of progress for any three month old browser engine.
- asddubs 4y agotwo years and 3 months
- coldtea 4y agoThey're better than strict standard test suites, because they exercize real world useful stuff AND give a fun visual representation of the maturity. Wish we had such "acid test" for later CSS features like Flexbox too...
- andrewmcwatters 4y agoNo, they're immediately provably worse. If you started work on a CSS rasterizer today, there are zero test suites you can use for reference comparison. I'm talking about easy stuff, too, like normal flow, margin, border, padding box alignment. The existing official test suites are entirely manual. Edit: What you're describing requires you to make the entire world first, then finally test something. Here's an example: I want to test the white-space property. How do I test that? Oh also, font rasterizers are all different and standards don't dictate what happens after box layout. It's acceptable that glyphs render with different dimensions. How do I test that? A casual HN reader isn't going to care. Someone actually writing this stuff, will.
- coldtea 4y agoSure, but I think you have a misconception: that those are like compliance tests for developers or have that role. Rather, those acid tests were tests that test the rendering engine (in multiple aspects at the same time), and are meant for the end users: to give them a nice visual representation of the browser's progress, or lack thereof, and to push browser developers to fix issues that cause visual glitches (with features drawing the test image selected to be nice for layout writers to have) and have them race each other to pass them...
- andrewmcwatters 4y agoI don't have any misconceptions about the state of web technology testing, or how WaSP made an impact on the miserable state of the industry at the time. I work on browser technology.
- tannhaeuser 4y ago> there are zero test suites you can use for reference comparison. What about W3C's web-platform-tests suite [1]? [1]: https://github.com/web-platform-tests/wpt/tree/master/css https://github.com/web-platform-tests/wpt/tree/master/css
- dillondoyle 4y agoTo test white space, quick thought have not tried, perhaps render some text that hits a chunk of the differences. Start default/normal. like perhaps text has a lot of tabs. JS measure offsetWidth. Or maybe use canvas export image see if base64 is same Do it again with different CSS settings.
- w0m 4y agomy local FireFox is only 97/100; which susprises me...
- aidenn0 4y agoTry this version: http://wpt.live/acid/acid3/test.html http://wpt.live/acid/acid3/test.html
- mrweasel 4y agoThat's also "only" 97% in Firefox.
- actuallyalys 4y agoHuh. I get 100% with 104.0.2 on Ubuntu.
- everforward 4y agoI get 100% using Firefox 104.0.2 (64-bit) on Windows 10. Maybe it's related to the platform or addons? Could it be uMatrix or something blocking some kind of behavior that would be questionable on a normal webpage?
- jszymborski 4y ago100% on FF 104.0 for Ubuntu
- inversetelecine 4y agoI get 100% also, using Librewolf fork of FF (104.0.2). RFP is on and uBlock Origin enabled. edit: MacOS and Windows.
- memorable 4y agoAlso 100% on Firefox Mobile 104.2.0
- jvalencia 4y ago
- Y_Y 4y agoI haven't used it, but it seems that Flow[0] is also a plausible modern alternative browser which passes the Acid tests[1], unless you disqualify it for being closed source and borrowing its JS engine from Firefox. [0] https://www.ekioh.com/flow-browser/ https://www.ekioh.com/flow-browser/ [1] https://www.ekioh.com/devblog/acid/ https://www.ekioh.com/devblog/acid/
- bumblebritches5 4y ago
- svnpenn 4y ago> unless you disqualify it for being closed source Yes, I do disqualify it for that reason.
- sph 4y agoJuly 4th is only celebrated in the US of A. The author is Swedish.
- avgcorrection 4y agoI tried to find some July 4th where something Swedish happened: > 1708 Battle of Holowczyn: Swedish King Charles XII defeats superior Russian force in surprising vctory That must have been it.
- jonathankoren 4y agoJuly 4th occurs worldwide.
- hh3k0 4y agoYou'd be hard-pressed to find it occuring in Iran.
- bla3 4y agoLadybird doesn't pass Acid 2 either. It does pass Acid 3.
- userbinator 4y agoThat's surprising. I'd expect Acid3 to require far more effort to pass than Acid2.
- deaddodo 4y agoWhy? Acid3 just requires basic CSS support and a someone ES5 conformant js-implementation. Acid2 was specifically built to call IE out and to put browser builders on notice. It tests the most nuanced little quirks of some specific specs; and, because of some changes in the modern standard, doesn’t actually conform anymore.
- rthomas6 4y agoFirefox passes acid2.
- olliej 4y agowhat's the failure? I _think_ some stuff got changed in spec land which makes acid2 no longer "correct"
- jzig 4y agoSafari on iOS only scores 98/100 on Acid 3!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- senko 4y ago> Given that he's already written an entire OS, I don't think he's being too ambitious. Also, he actually did work on web browsers previously: > Until that point, my career had been focused on web browsers (WebKit at Apple & Nokia). So he knows exactly what he's doing. Based on those two datapoints, I'd say he (and other contributors) have a good shot at it.
- AlecSchueler 4y agoCame to Hacker News expecting the top comment to be a critical one outlining the inherent problems with this project and why it was doomed to failure, so this whole thread has made for quite pleasant and exciting reading! Thank you! Yes, I am aware also that HN has blindspots, eg with Show HN Dropbox
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hackernewds 4y agoWhy is July 4th relevant?
- patmorgan23 4y agoBecause of LadyBird Johnson former first lady of the United States.
- Archelaos 4y ago>> The Ladybird browser came to life on July 4th > Coincidence or not, that's a great date. Especially if considering that St. Ulrich is also the saint of the dying.
- userbinator 4y agoWas thinking more along the lines of "browser independence" (from Big Tech) day.