6 ms·
Armchair defeatist here: Browsers are huge, complicated beasts, the standards are a constant moving target, and websites won't uphold standards. I wouldn't be
by Cthulhu_ 4y ago
Armchair defeatist here: Browsers are huge, complicated beasts, the standards are a constant moving target, and websites won't uphold standards.
I wouldn't be surprised if 80% of the work spent on current webbrowsers is spent on maintaining compatiblity and edge cases.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoIt is true, but it does not change the fact that it is a worthwhile effort just to force some level of differentiation on the browser scene.
- godshatter 4y agoI was happy to see them state that influence over their browser cannot be bought. Mozilla taking $400 million+ a year from Google is the elephant in the room when it comes to browser competition. Not to mix metaphors, but this would give us a large competitor not beholden to Google, the gorilla in the room.
- cfcosta 4y agoYes, they are. And even if the project fails (for any definition of failure), putting hundreds of people in contact with production quality core browser code is worth it. Also, lightweight browsers have been a dying breed for a while, if ladybird ends up as a more modern alternative to surf and Dillo, I'm already satisfied.
- rollcat 4y agoSurf[1] is merely a Webkit wrapper. If you mean NetSurf[2], it's actually doing OK in resource constrained environments, although it's been a while since a release, which is a bit concerning. [1] https://surf.suckless.org https://surf.suckless.org [2] http://www.netsurf-browser.org http://www.netsurf-browser.org
- cfcosta 4y agoSeen it way too late to edit it seems, but you are correct, I meant NetSurf.
- einpoklum 4y ago> the Ladybird browser, based on the LibWeb and LibJS engines from SerenityOS. So, the project does _not_ cover rendering web pages and tracking the HTML, CSS and JS standards. Those are separate projects. What remains, then? I guess that would be the user interface and user experience.
- trashburger 4y agoThey're "separate" projects only in name; Ladybird is under the SerenityOS organization on GitHub.
- einpoklum 4y agoBut SerenityOS was started 4 years ago...
- zppln 4y agoDoesn't Ladybird let you work on LibWeb and LibJS from a Linux angle though?
- rhdunn 4y agoYes. LibWeb and LibJS were written for the SerenityOS. As mentioned in the article, some work was done to make them buildable and usable on Linux in a headless environment. The Ladybird project is then taking that work and adding a Qt GUI on top of it.
- resoluteteeth 4y ago> So, the project does _not_ cover rendering web pages and tracking the HTML, CSS and JS standards. Those are separate projects. > What remains, then? I guess that would be the user interface and user experience. To be clear it uses a novel rendering engine (libweb) that the creators of LadyBird develop, it's just that that rendering engine has its own name and exists as a separate library. This is not just another skin around webkit or chromium.
- throw7 4y agoFirefox can't even keep up/not tested by developers. We sometimes use roll20 to game, but things like blank screens make it unusable. I've had to just use chromium and not worry about it.
- philote 4y agoInteresting, could it be plugins/extensions causing the issue? I've been using Roll20 with Firefox and with Edge for a while without any major issues.
- throw7 4y agoOur last game was about 2 weeks ago... two of us hit the same issue with the screen not "repainting" and being black. No issue with the chrome browsers, so it's easier to just switch rather than bog the game down with debugging/diagnosis. It's usually "ok" and I can deal with performance issues; but these little niggles just makes you want to not deal with it.
- cpeterso 4y agoDid you have an ad blocker or other privacy add-ons installed? Many "website doesn't work in Firefox" issues are related to ad blockers. OTOH, if the page is black and not repainting, that might be a graphics issue (in Firefox or the GPU driver). Firefox uses the GPU more than Chrome for rendering and video decoding, which can be great for performance but unfortunately means users can be exposed to GPU driver bugs.
- midoridensha 4y ago>Did you have an ad blocker or other privacy add-ons installed? How can you possibly use any web browser without an ad blocker installed?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- onion2k 4y agoI wouldn't be surprised if 80% of the work spent on current webbrowsers is spent on maintaining compatiblity and edge cases. I don't really see anything wrong with a browser that doesn't fully support every website and every weird example of HTML and CSS that a developer decided to hack together. If a browser supports the standards well and does a pretty good job of rendering modern websites then I'd happily trade failing to render some ancient HTML for a web browser that was truly open and free and doesn't send swathes of data about me back to some corporation. Web browsers are compatible with old HTML because we choose to make them that way. That is a choice. If the cost of having a free and open browser is a requirement to drop some backwards compatibility with old HTML then I think that's actually quite a simple choice. After all, if people want to view an old website then they can still use Chromium or something. It's not like people have to pick a single browser and stick with it.
- shagie 4y ago> I don't really see anything wrong with a browser that doesn't fully support every website and every weird example of HTML and CSS that a developer decided to hack together. Consider from the perspective of the user. They're using chrome and browsing the web - all their favorite sites work. They switch to a new browser and some of the sites stop working correctly. Is it the fault of the browser? or is it the fault of the site? For most users, if site X works using browser A and breaks using browser B - then it is browser B that is at fault. This is a lesson that Microsoft learned. https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/06/13/how-microsoft-lost-the-api-war/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2004/06/13/how-microsoft-lost... There's no refund involved, but switching back to the old browser is certainly possible.
- zibby8 4y agoThere would need to be a compelling reason to use the browser other than it being "different." For instance, the user experience you describe is exactly what it's like to use Firefox. Many websites don't support Firefox, even big ones like Vanguard. And yet, I continue to use Firefox when possible because I know uBlock Origin will continue to work in the future and I value privacy.
- 4y ago
- Deukhoofd 4y agoI'm fairly certain Andreas knows, considering he worked on Safari before starting Serenity.
- rtpg 4y agoI would say that HTML5 changed the game a lot. There are serious standards now that go into deep detail about how something should work, leaving relatively little on the margins. There are still loads of cross compatibility issues and performance differences based on certain features of course! But I would say the set of "sites that require weirdness" is going down, not up, every day
- redredyupdy 4y agoIt seems like there could be a nice middle man software project. Something that translated the non-standard compliant code on the web to something more standard compliant, and then you could have many different browsers each doing different things with the standard html it output. I wonder if such a tool is extractable from current projects? Disclaimer: I am not a browser scientist.
- IshKebab 4y agoYeah the argument is just about the definition of "browser". Something that can pass Acid3 and render simple sites fine, or even complex specific sites? Totally doable. Something that will work reliably on every site and support the gazillions of APIs that Chrome provides? Hell no. Even Microsoft threw in the towel on that. Mozilla barely manages it. You can make a browser that people can use if they really really want to make a point of using your browser. You can't make one that the average person would choose.
- zzo38computer 4y agoWhat we need isn't to make one "that the average person would choose", since they already have that. What we do need is to make one that you may choose if you want to be able to fully control the system (with fine customization, and interaction with other programs including native codes in C), and is designed for advanced users who have read all of the documents, rather than trying to hide things from the user or believe they know better than what the end user specified, and also it must be one that avoids all of the bad stuff that Google put in.
- IshKebab 4y agoNone of that stuff is about the browser engine. If you want all that you'd just use an existing engine, which is what people do.
- Avshalom 4y agoOne nice thing about html/css/javascript is that a lot of it works even when some of it doesn't. It's not an all (or even almost all) or nothing proposition.
- loudmax 4y agoIf the goal is to compete with Chrome/Edge/Safari directly then yeah some spunky team of ragtag volunteers isn't going to be able to match what the megacorps can bring to the table. Even Firefox struggles here. If the goal is to have something that's usable in limited cases for a self-selected set technically competent enthusiasts, then this is well within reason and not without value. What I find particularly interesting is that there's an intent to support WebAssembly. That may turn out to be overly ambitious, but if they succeed there's a lot of potential upside to having another WebAssembly engine that's independent from the major browsers.
- dmytrish 4y agoWhat's ambitious about supporting WebAssembly? It's very well-specified and minimalistic compared to almost anything in the web space.
- kornhole 4y agoMuch of it is the other way around where the browser compatibility drives the development of sites. Everybody developing a site needs to test on the major browsers before releasing. It may take a while for Ladybird to make the list of browsers to be tested before release, but it can get there.
- soheil 4y agoIt's insane we let Google run the web and be the literal gatekeeper of it. Chrome is literally the gate you use to enter the web and its owned by Google. The solution is surely to make that monopoly illegal. After all we/government constantly blocks mergers that seem much more benign and less impactful (see Amazon/iRobot acquisition) just because they involve money? This is far worse.
- divbzero 4y ago> Browsers are huge, complicated beasts, the standards are a constant moving target, and websites won't uphold standards. This is all true. On the other hand, operating systems are huge, complicated beasts, hardware compatibility is a constant moving target, and manufacturers won’t uphold compatibility guarantees.
- blablabla123 4y ago> Armchair defeatist here: Browsers are huge, complicated beasts, the standards are a constant moving target, and websites won't uphold standards. I think that's the irony here, the standards are pretty much set in stone and just incrementally grow. Some old cruft is beyond obsolete though. On the other hand nobody uses most of the bleeding edge APIs. But JS (and the part that is actually in use) is indeed growing at a solid pace.