4 ms·
> Australia had big problems with over-supply of solar at certain times and I believe the rate went negative to try and stop people feeding it in. This is almo
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
> Australia had big problems with over-supply of solar at certain times and I believe the rate went negative to try and stop people feeding it in.
This is almost certaintly untrue, in both the wider and narrow senses.
Basically, solar alone will never cause negative prices or 'oversupply', because solar can switch itself off fast enough that any solar bidding a negative price to the market would just turn itself off rather than pay money to someone who uses the power. The same is true of wind turbines.
Because you reference Australia, it was almost certainly coal plants that were bidding negative because it would cost them more to ramp down and back up again as demand changes.
There's some incentive regimes, that can lead to renewables offering to pay people to take their power (if they get paid $X for each used watt, then they can pass some of that subsidy on to a user rather than stop providing) but that's a good thing, not a bad thing. It's just a price signal that rewards flexible demand.
In the words of an Australian coal energy producer:
https://www.stanwell.com/our-news/energy-explainer/negative-prices/ https://www.stanwell.com/our-news/energy-explainer/negative-...
> Negative prices are a signal to either increase demand or reduce supply. Intermittent and fast response energy sources (such as solar, wind, peaking generators) can stop and start in relatively short spaces of time to avoid negative price periods. Coal-fired generators however, incur significant costs stopping and starting and require many hours to restart. This means they continue generating throughout negative pricing periods as it is more cost-efficient to incur the costs of negative pricing than shutting down and then starting up again. This ensures that they are available to meet peak demand in the late afternoon and evening once the intermittent sources such as rooftop solar and large-scale solar are no longer available.
- poopypoopington 4y agoEventually we can have grid scale carbon removal systems that can soak up all of the extra electrify on the grid. Probably the same when large industrial processes are electrified, like generating fertilizer.
- Scoundreller 4y ago> because solar can switch itself off fast enough that any solar bidding a negative price to the market would just turn itself off Wouldn’t this make the panels hotter? I’m guessing they’d accept (or should accept) a slightly negative price but because that’s better than dumping the energy through the panels themselves via excess heating.
- sp332 4y agoI hadn't thought of that, but if the difference is only 5-10 C I don't think it going to hurt that much.
- cesarb 4y ago> but because that’s better than dumping the energy through the panels themselves via excess heating. That's not how solar panels turn themselves off, however. To turn a solar panel off, you just disconnect it. It will produce a voltage (which is why handling an uncovered solar panel can be a shock hazard), but no current. It's not dumping the power, it's actually producing no power in the first place (voltage times current is zero when the current is zero).
- Scoundreller 4y agoWhere does the sun’s energy go that is no longer going down the wire?