4 ms·
I forget if there’s a term for this, but I once read (and subsequently discovered) that a large portion of disagreements are simply because people are working w
by Waterluvian 4y ago
I forget if there’s a term for this, but I once read (and subsequently discovered) that a large portion of disagreements are simply because people are working with different definitions for things.
This seems like an example of that: depending on how you define “book” these claims are accurate or not.
- mihaic 4y agoYes, I've also struggled to pause many disagreements just to clarify terms, ironically because the other person didn't get what I was doing since there is no common word for this sort of disagreement. If anyone has a good one, please chime in.
- Waterluvian 4y agoSemantic mismatch? Miscontextualization?
- mihaic 4y agoI like the suggestions, I do think it need to be a bit shorter to be viral. Riffing on this, how does "we've misdefined this" sound?
- therealdrag0 4y agoWhy not just “let’s define ours terms so we don’t talk passed each other? What do you mean by X?”
- ajhurliman 4y ago#letsdefineourtermssowedonttalkpassedeachother?whatdoyoumeanbyx? is sorta hard to type out, a shorthand term may lend itself to a common understanding of the situation. Like "a picture of yourself" got coined as a selfie, it seems obvious now through constant use, but there was a time when the phenomenon existed and we had a lexical gap in describing it.
- ambrose2 4y ago“It’s semantics” is the briefest way I usually describe this phenomenon.
- tbrownaw 4y agoSounds like a version of what I've heard called "talking past eachother".
- Winsaucerer 4y agoI think it's called semantic disagreement. I have a background in philosophy, and I suspect a lot of disagreements are the result of disagreements over the meanings of a word, and the fact that we are using words differently is so very easily missed when we do disagree. For example, we can argue endlessly over whether esports are 'sport', but it's really quite simple. You tell me what you mean by 'sport', and then I'll tell you whether or not esports are a sport. In some cases, it might be a little weirder. For example, because of the discovery of the nature of visible light, 'light' now has more than one meaning attached, and these meanings are incompatible. If it's dark in a room, we might say "there is no light", but on the other hand it could be bathed in EM waves outside the visible spectrum (such as the cosmic background radiation), in which case it's full of 'light'. Light has these two meanings: one to do with whether I can see or not, and the other to do with EM waves. Context can help determine which meaning is being used. As we grow and learn and communicate, we pick up how words are used by other people, and we try to match our usage to the way everyone else uses these word. But sometimes we don't pick up quite the same meanings even though there's significant overlap (semantic extension). There lies confusion and a great deal of pointless disagreement. I think it's mostly pointless (from a philosophical perspective) to debate about what a word should mean. If there's disagreement, stipulate how you're going to use words, or invent new ones for the conversation, and move on.
- zdragnar 4y agoIn high school debate, it was referred to as "grounds"- essentially, laying out definitions for terms important or relevant to the topic established the terrain, to use a battle metaphor. If you're using the same words but with different beings, it's like two opposing forces not being on the same field of battle. Two ships passing in the night is another metaphor, and is probably more common in English as a phrase.
- idiolects 4y agoIs “idiolect” the term you’re looking for? Everyone has an idiolect, which is the language unique to the speaker.
- Waterluvian 4y agoSometimes, yea. But I more mean there’s an argument or debate and the two sides simply don’t have the same facts. And twenty minutes in you find out, “oh you thought I meant 22.1. I was taking about 24.0!”
- ChuckMcM 4y agoThis and context. It is weird finding oneself in an extended argument only to find out you were talking about two entirely different contexts. Saturday Night live's "Emily Litella" skits on the weekend news[1] used this situation to good effect. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZLeaSWY37I https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fZLeaSWY37I
- psnehanshu 4y agoBut the point is that most people will take the literal definition of "book". They wouldn't differentiate between hardcover, paperback, ebooks, audiobooks. If an "expert" said "90% of books sell less than 99 copies", without any context, most people will assume that the book sold less than 99 copies across all its manifestations and in a lifetime. The article puts light on the fact that there's more to that statement than what it means in a first glance.
- matwood 4y agoThere's a reason contracts start out by defining terms.