10 ms·
Unequal consumption lies at the heart of the climate crisis
- Kenji 4y ago
- arcanus 4y ago“The richest 10% of people are responsible for 52% of cumulative global emissions — and the 1% for a full 15%.” "Of course, many Americans are wealthy in global terms. Oxfam has defined the world’s 1% as the 60 million people earning over $109,000 a year. They defined the 10% as the 770 million people earning over $38,000." The vast majority of those reading and posting on HN are in the highest global wealth bracket(s). Myself included. This article isn't about billionaires and sports icons. It is about what Americans (and many Westerns Europeans) consider middle class.
- Swizec 4y agoHeck, HN constantly gives rise to bickering about how $109k is a very low salary to make. The fact that puts you in the global 1% blows my mind edit to clarify: This is not a value judgement on money. Just saying it blows my mind – the human brain (at least mine) wasn’t made for the power law
- ideamotor 4y agoIt’s the very effective and ubiquitous psychological trick of seeing yourself as being in a relatively compromised situation in order to justify acquiring ever more comparative advantage. I find it far less appalling to actually recognize how good you have it, continue to seek further wealth, but seek wealth in industries that are net benefits to society.
- o_1 4y agoid wager the 0.1% of the world or the .5% of America are the worst offenders. Policy only affects the poor.
- ideamotor 4y agoWhat is your point? That middle class Americans don’t have it easy and also contribute plenty to global emissions? Both are true, not only in a global context but in a historical one. I just don’t see why we can’t acknowledge that and frankly be grateful.
- mechanical_bear 4y agoIt is though…relative to the expenses necessary to live in certain areas.
- nickdothutton 4y agoThis is why it’s always important to consider purchasing power parity.
- OrvalWintermute 4y ago$109k in Manhattan, or Silicon Valley is pretty poor.
- haswell 4y agoThis further highlights the reality of lower income brackets relative to that.
- ch4s3 4y agoIf you make that in Manhattan, you are probably young, or live in Queens/South Brooklyn/Jersey City and you’re doing fine. You get pinched if you make just enough to live in Manhattan or trendy nearby neighborhoods, and your career requires it, but not enough to save and prepare for retirement.
- wyre 4y agoLooks like median income in Silicon Valley is $126k [1] and median household income in Manhattan is $93k. I wouldn’t call $109k “pretty poor” in either local. [1] https://siliconvalleyindicators.org/data/economy/income/personal-income/per-capita-income/ https://siliconvalleyindicators.org/data/economy/income/pers... [2] https://www.city-data.com/income/income-Manhattan-New-York.html https://www.city-data.com/income/income-Manhattan-New-York.h...
- throwaway09092 4y ago
- jmoak3 4y agoAmerica is freaky rich - how many people in this forum grow food of any kind (outside of a hobby) for example? I'm not too surprised on the % of share of the footprint, people making (or spending) at least $40k drive a lot of worldwide consumption (and shipping). I'd wager a lot of the carbon emissions of the $100k and above group come from flights. Travel among that income level has become extremely popular in the past 50 years. For example, I used to live in California, and it was surprising when I did the napkin math to find the emissions generated to visit family near the Appalachians (just for my seat on the plane). I calculated that a given person's portion of a round trip cross-American flight generated as much kg C02 as a typical American generates by consuming a year's worth of meat. My two round-trip flights a year were undo-ing the climate savings of two typical American vegetarians. Given ~400 passengers on a 747, each plane that darts across the whole of America undos 200 Americans who gave up meat for a year. The FAA claims to process 16mil flights a year of various lengths. EDIT: some phrases EDIT2: more EDIT3: even more content
- avgcorrection 4y ago
- bobthepanda 4y agoIf it’s any consolation, no US domestic carrier operates the 747 or A380 today, and their 2-engine cousins are much less thirsty.
- multjoy 4y agoHow was it surprising? The carbon footprint of flying has been known for decades.
- jmoak3 4y agoI suppose I was sheltered until several years ago.
- eastbound 4y agoJancovici famously made the calculation in public in 2003: If you divide permissible emissions (3Gtec/yr) by Earth population, each human can EITHER: - Use one Paris-NYC flight per year, - OR eat meat, - OR heat their home, - OR drive to work. Choose one. All EU calculations about emissions are based on this target, but it’s too early to tell people. It’s based on: Earth absorbs 3 gigatons-equivalent-carbon by night, so we can emit as much. And that’s what humanity emitted in 1990, so it’s achievable. Since then, we’ve double or trippled. For myself, I consider that the only flaw in this reasoning is that dividing the global permissible emissions by population “is communism”, because it assumes that every human should be given the same pay. I consider it’s normal that some earn much more. That’s the only flaw, and that’s because I’m a capitalist, but it’s great to have the ballpark figure of what would be FAIR to consume for everyone. (I also have doubts about scientists’ reliability when topics are heavily politicized, but that’s my affair, at least I’m repeating their conclusions as-is, so you can judge).
- ryukafalz 4y agoYes, many of us on this forum are extraordinarily wealthy by global standards, myself included. I think that gives us some responsibility to reduce our impact on the planet where we’re able. I don’t think we can justify asking those who are already struggling to do more individually, but in this highest income bracket I think we certainly can.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eastbound 4y agoOnly because India and Africa skew the average by having extremely large population. Given a certain amount of wealth, they chose to divide it between more kids, of course each will have to consume less. Western countries chose low-density, i.e. have few kids per family, which means each can afford more. It was our sacrifice. Fewer kids. Smaller extended families, even for Christmas. Less human happiness. Everything bet on each kid. But at least each of them can afford housing, and our girls can leave home without having to find a husband, if ever. China, on the other hand, deserves a much larger share of emissions, since, despite being overpopulated, they sacrificed themselves to be able to control overpopulation, and they work like crazy. Summary: Divide carbon emissions by country, not by headcount, because if you calculate by headcount, you give incentive to reproduce like rabbits, which is causing global warming.
- rat9988 4y agoSummary: Divide carbon emissions by country, not by headcount. This is what happens when you read statistics wrong coupled with some preexisting bias that show in your choice of words.
- shagie 4y agoRegarding China, I would suggest reading https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-57018837 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-57018837 (2019) and consider that it hasn't exactly shown itself to be responsible with development. And while 2021 and 2022 are seeing a drop ( https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-chinas-co2-emissions-see-longest-sustained-drop-in-a-decade/ https://www.carbonbrief.org/analysis-chinas-co2-emissions-se... ) there is every indication that it will pick right back up and accelerate. > Even as China’s coal demand is falling, the output from domestic coal mines is increasing rapidly. This resulted in a major overall drop in coal imports in the first quarter of the year, as reported by China Customs, and allowed coal plants and other operators to fill up stockpiles that were depleted during last year’s coal shortage. > Investment in new coal- and gas-fired power capacity is also continuing at a high level. In the first four months of the year, at least 18 thermal power projects started construction, with a total capacity of 12.8 gigawatts (GW). Another 19 projects with a total capacity of 13.0GW were approved for construction.
- kcplate 4y agoFunny how this stating facts as the (blank) contributes (blank)% of (blank). Can be either political correct or not depending what the (blank)s are.
- draw_down 4y ago> “Driving” signifies something very different for the American worker at a big-box store who is forced to commute in her car to the mall versus the private equity manager speeding a gleaming Lamborghini around the cliffs of the Italian Riviera Good grief. Feel free to write out your resentment as much as you like. But there’s no need to pretend this is about helping or changing anything.
- culi 4y agoA third of Pakistan, a country 1.2 times the size of Texas, is underwater due to climate change related flooding. Can the first world ever really fully repay for all the damage they've done. It seems that a genuine effort to would completely bankrupt them. How much growth in GDP would be wiped away if we truly put an effort into internalizing these "economic externalities"?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- the_jesus_villa 4y agoOn the other hand, a lot of GDP would be saved if we stopped putting countries one third underwater!
- ghouse 4y agoIt will only get worse from here. Maybe instead of arguing whether externalities should be internalized, maybe we consider how much of the externality should be internalized.
- closewith 4y agoA recent episode of the podcast More or Less addressed that statistic. It turns out that 40% of provinces in Pakistan have declared an emergency due to flooding. Only (a still enormous and heartbreaking) 10-12% of the country is actually under water.
- riley99 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- wikitopian 4y agoNo. We need to divorce the public policy conversation about climate change and carbon emissions from all of this inflammatory and polarizing rhetoric. Promote policies that target the worst sources of environmental pollution without coding your speech in a manner that causes everybody who voted for trump or itemized their taxes or whatever to stop listening in the middle of what you're trying to say.
- wikitopian 4y agoWhat if I tried to have a conversation about violent crime that opened that we need to talk about how registered democrats commit dramatically more violent crime than registered republicans? We would end up arguing about everything but the ostensible topic.
- wikitopian 4y agoThe growing failure to speak about science, technology, and policy without politically coding the speech has caused irreparable damage to public science, technology, and policy discussion. Perhaps the most egregious example was the liberal coding of vaccination during the pandemic, with the self-fulfilling prophecy that vaccine skepticism is for the other tribe of people who are bad. You had people with preexisting conditions terrified of making a private medical decision because of the extreme political coding that both sides egged on to hysterical extremes.
- PKop 4y agoIt is a delusion to presume that politics can be avoided, escaped, or isolated. That institutions of power or prestige within society ever can or ever were devoid of politics, that they can exist and operate in a vacuum. This ideological faith clouds judgement, more realism is necessary to navigate these issues.
- wikitopian 4y agoI'll see your realism and raise you one. The belief that science, technology, and environmental policy can transcend partisan politics is necessary for western society to function. If you step over that in your eagerness to apply postmodern analysis, you'll introduce even greater challenges than the ones we're already barely capable of addressing.
- goblinux 4y ago“ Even if every individual person on the planet reduced their discretionary carbon footprint to zero, the electrical, industrial and agricultural systems of our economies would continue to emit greenhouse gases and make global heating worse” So we don’t need to talk about individual’s footprints?
- tromp 4y agoWe need to talk about everybody with big footprints, not only individuals but industrial, agricultural, and other sectors of the economy as well.
- sambull 4y agoIt's pretty much the only acceptable thing to talk about, probably on purpose.
- RockingGoodNite 4y agoHow do you eat an Elephant?
- ghouse 4y agoSo internalize the externality. The status quo is that the non-rich subsidize the carbon footprint of the rich. I have no problem with <celebrity> flying privately. I have a problem with subsidizing that flight.
- kevinpet 4y agoWe only need to talk about the carbon footprints of the rich because the environmental movement has positioned everything in terms of asceticism and sacrifice. No one talks about the unequal consumption of high end furniture, art, entertainment, or spa visits because all of those things are managed by price signals. The whole point of being rich is to be able to consume more. The problem is that we aren't pricing environmental impact.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thro388 4y agoIf we reduce global population to 100M, most of those problems would be solved.
- rufus_foreman 4y agoWhen there's a person, there's a problem. When there's no person, there's no problem.
- sebastianconcpt 4y agoAgent Smith agrees with that. Also it's a manifestation of utilitaristic induced psychopathy, of course.
- ls15 4y agoHow do you reduce the population to 100M in a way that does not make you look worse than Hitler?
- sebastianconcpt 4y agoImagine being a problem to figure out how do you look (propaganda) instead of having done an unspeakable evil while envisioning yourself as a savior of humanity. That's precisely how the Stalin/Mao/Hitlers types are fabricated.
- thro388 4y agoMake food and energy expensive, forbid agriculture, release genetically designed disseases...
- timbit42 4y agoExpand access to birth control to every woman world-wide.
- bongoman37 4y ago
- 4y ago
- Noumenon72 4y ago> But in these past 30 years, the emissions of the poorest 50% of people have grown hardly at all: They represented a little under 7% of global emissions in 1990, and they remain a little over 7% of global emissions today In other words, their emissions grew over 60%, enough to keep pace with the emissions of everyone else.
- houstonn 4y agoYesterday I saw a graph that blew my mind: https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-co2-emissions-per-country https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/annual-co2-emissions-per-... I had no idea.
- FredPret 4y agoCapitalism works. CO2 became uncool, so big money is to be made from selling green things.
- lwouis 4y agoThe market is not working. What you see on the graph is a global growth of emissions. CO2 is a global problem, and we haven't improved on it yet, in any significant fashion. If you are implying that the market has reduced emissions in developped countries, i believe you're reading the situation wrong: China has become the world's factory, and its emissions have exploded, but the products manufactures are exported and consumed in the most developped countries. So effectively, developped countries emissions have grown. It's trivial to understand this when you observe the explosion of goods and services available in these countries, at the press of a button. There was never in history that many objects around us, in developped countries. Our footprint on the global world is growing rapidly and has never decreased. The market is failing to deal with climate change because the environment costs (sometimes called externalities) are not part of the market dynamics. The market uses money, but has a blind eye to anything physical. Business is just money and human labor. No mines, no pollution. It's all dollars. Polluting a lake is a X million dollars fee, not an irreversible loss in a one-time resource.
- FredPret 4y agoOf course it’s working. It’s just not done yet. How else did the US and EU lines turn sharply down in the mid 2000’s? Outsourcing to China has been going on for decades prior. Now people have caught on to the fact that we need locally made things. There’s a huge push among my peers for things that are Made in USA or Made in Canada, and food grown within 100 miles, and things that are durable vs things that are plastic. My colleagues who work in manufacturing automation cannot keep up with the insane demand for onshoring production. I’m talking about everyday objects, but to further illustrate the idea: which car brand is currently the coolest, and why, and where is it made? All of this is just here - remember they have a sort-of-free market in China. Once they reach the GDP per capita where most people care about such things as the environment, the same dynamic will play out there. I agree that we should price in externalities though.
- ianbutler 4y agoThe interesting yet potentially unpopular discussion I find here is that if the US which represents the large majority of that 1% were to really become introspective and start to break down all our ecologically destructive habits any country who doesn't share that level of self scrutability would breeze right past us on the global stage. So we won't because it threatens our hegemony and there's no way to enforce this on every country in a way that actually matters so that it doesn't threaten their standing. So we're in a lock step dance into oblivion unless we can technology our way out of it and not rely on human nature. That's why more efficient green technologies that don't also threaten a country's position on the world stage are important. Hopefully fusion works out!
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoThe hegemony of the USA is not threatened. It’s a pipe dream and has been for at least a decade. The world is firmly multipolar now and if the USA refuses to help in tackling the problem we all face, it’s just going to find itself more and more marginalised on the global scene which is exactly what has been happening since the Trump presidency.
- ianbutler 4y agoI think that's more wishful thinking on your part than truth frankly. And even if I grant your point, then you can sub in China or any other nation with sway on the global stage instead of the US and my point will still stand: If going green undermines the growth of that nation or it's political dominance then going green won't happen.
- avgcorrection 4y agoCarbon footprint is a term invented by BP to deflect blame away from entities such as themselves onto individuals. Individuals as in regular people of course. But really, so-called carbon footprint is more of a systemic issue than some naughty sin/indulgence that the rich commit.
- kisamoto 4y agoWhile it may have been popularized by BP this is by no means a reason to ignore the emissions caused by an individual. Call it something else if you'd like but individuals do cause emissions and they should take responsibility to lower and remove them.
- avgcorrection 4y agoIndividuals cause emissions but it’s not rational to make that the locus of attention. Not rational if you want to lower emissions, that is. It is rational for BP’s marketing department, however.
- lwouis 4y agoThe top of the pyramid are important because they set what the majority of us will want to emulate. If Swift is flying her private jet, then young high-schooler and adults will calibrate on that and fly to Thailand for the holidays because they perceive it desirable to fly around. If we had influencers who would take a stand, it would be very beneficial at global scale actually. Let's say the top football/soccer players would decline to attend the world cup because having A/C'd stadiums in Qatar, and flying both the athletes and the fans there is generating large emissions. If they took that stand and shared it to their 50M followers-each mimetic fanbase, the benefits for society would be wonderful. It's worth pursuing exemplarity of our elites because it sets the flagpost for everyone else. Redefining success from rolex, sport car, big house, to let's say skilled handcraft, raising horses, and living in a small rural community; that would really be beneficial to us all.
- 4y ago
- mlinksva 4y agoDoes not contain "tax" therefore not serious.
- odiroot 4y agoOn a similar note, I'd also like to see the conversation shift from taxing the labour to taxing the wealth.
- Jerry2 4y agoThere's actually an automated Twitter account [0] that tracks celebrity jets and occasionally calculates CO2 emissions of the rich [1]. The biggest culprit is the singer Taylor Swift [2]: >Swift topped a list of celebrities, with 170 flights emitting 8,293 metric tons of greenhouse gases. If you scroll through these tweets you will see celebs taking 10 min flights several times a day. Yet these people have no qualms telling others to curtail their CO2 emissions, eat less beef and host of other hypocritical nonsense. [0] https://twitter.com/CelebJets https://twitter.com/CelebJets [1] https://mobile.twitter.com/CelebJets/status/1522979709277335553 https://mobile.twitter.com/CelebJets/status/1522979709277335... [2] https://www.newsweek.com/taylor-swift-rep-excuse-private-jet-drama-sparks-viral-memes-1729980 https://www.newsweek.com/taylor-swift-rep-excuse-private-jet...
- potamic 4y agoIf climate change was truly accepted to be a global endeavour, then the only reasonable metric by which to track progress is the per capita footprint. Today the per capita footprint of the first world outweighs the rest of the world by orders of magnitude. And yet, the focus always seems to be on a country's total emissions, thus putting more onus on highly populated third world countries. How do we expect those people to buy into this bargain? The hard truth is that, if we are to make any progress on climate change, then first world countries must drastically cut their consumption and downgrade their lifestyles. That kind of a lifestyle is simply not sustainable across 8 billion people. But we cannot say that only some people are privileged to access that lifestyle, while the remaining must sacrifice to save the planet.
- jacknews 4y agoYou could argue that having more children, leading to a larger national population is also a 'lifestyle choice'
- potamic 4y agoThe people who made the lifestyle choice to have more children are long gone. We are not appealing to them. We are appealing to the people born today who are not responsible for the size of the population. It's ultimately a consequence of human progress that we face such population problem. A more reasonable approach towards this would be to share lands and resources and spread people out a bit. But that's a whole different problem and the first world would rather have policies to increase their own population size than immigrate people into their lands.
- jacknews 4y agoThe same with the west's polluting infrastructure, built decades ago. Focusing on how dirty the rich world is per capita just gives other nations an excuse to do nothing, even though some of them are now actually the bigger problem because of their huge population. The most telling measure is the growth (or otherwise) in emissions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- PKop 4y agoWhat if it's about who can make others sacrifice, and just not do so themselves? What if we don't want to reduce impact? What happens when the strong do what they can, and the weak suffer what they must? It's inevitably going to be a conflict over resources and power, like all of human history. Those who willingly self-sacrifice will get dominated by those who do not. Then what? Appeals to universal morality will only work to diminish those who agree to follow them and strengthen those who don't.
- poszlem 4y agoBecause "Eat the rich" has never ended in a disaster?
- avalys 4y agoIf you're serious about making sacrifices to stop climate change, don't have kids. Oh, you're not that serious? Too much of a sacrifice to make? You think other people should make sacrifices, but having a family is important to you? I see. How about this - you don't tell me what to do, and I won't tell you what to do.
- Proven 4y ago
- closeparen 4y agoClass warfare environmentalism seems especially counterproductive in the American context, where low-carbon behaviors are elite coded and the righteous middle class Everyman drives a lifted truck in the exurbs. At best there’s no constituency for this stuff. At worst, it encourages blocking decarbonization efforts as being too much in the interests of the rich / threatening to the middle class.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- issa 4y agoI've been concerned about climate change for decades and I think it is important to point out how certain fundamentals have changed in the past 30 years. Until recently, all that individual people could do was make sacrifices. the main things you could do to make a difference: - give up certain foods - not drive a car - limit heating/air conditioning - limit consumerism / waste But recently, things have changed dramatically. - giving up meat in 2022 leaves you with many delicious options. From plant-based milks in every supermarket, to vegan options at every restaurant, to lab-grown (or otherwise convincing) meat if you want it - Solar panels on your roof and an electric car solve a lot - Limiting consumerism and air travel remain problems My point is this: The way we need to talk to people about personal actions related to climate has changed a LOT. Now, you CAN make a real difference by making some easy (and often even economical) choices.
- avgcorrection 4y agoHas things changed or did market forces just adapt to the emerging profile of slightly guilty-feeling, upper-middle class Westerners? That now get to feel green for buying overpriced chickpeas and investing in a charging station for their home and a solar panel roof (wow—I get to increase the value of my property, save on my electricity bill when amortized over twenty years, and save the planet at the same time??) This isn’t really a rhetorical question. It looks one way to me, but it’s hard to know. You pretty much have to dedicate yourself to a mini research project in order to honestly answer that question. That’s how capitalism obfuscates things for us and alienates us from what was ostensibly our original task, namely to save the planet.
- issa 4y agoThat is a good question. I would answer by avoiding it completely and just pointing out that I used to have to say to people: "Hey, give up something you love to save the planet" and now I can say: "Hey, get solar panels and then you can blast your A/C this summer for free!"
- avgcorrection 4y ago
- braingenious 4y agoI’m interested in seeing how the tone of the comments changes after the title change of this thread. I’ve noticed posters bringing up two concerns: A) Framing anything as being the fault of “the rich” is divisive or offensive. B) Anything that’s divisive or offensive is counterproductive. without explaining the bridge between A and B: A2) People are willing to support policies that hurt the climate out of spite because they believe that everyone votes entirely out of emotion.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoPersonally, I think it’s more the traditional HN egoism which in a lot of way is the traditional American egoism. Most HNers seem very happy to talk about fighting climate change as long as you don’t point out the role of their own privilege life style in it.
- braingenious 4y agoI agree. It’s interesting to see people make big lofty statements about “the nature of the climate movement” or how climate change is the result of some inherent economic flaw in the way consumption is priced, or (to me, most comically) internalizing externalities. In reality, these seem like a fancy and pedantic way to avoid saying “I am willing to leverage both my wealth and the looming threat of the deaths of poor people from climate change to secure the fealty and deference to my feelings that my status entitles me to.”
- fred92 4y agowhy does there seem to be this false dichotomy in the comments here of, if climate change is caused by individual actions, it cannot be caused by cooperations and vica versa? Both of these are true and they are entangled. And the solution is obviously on both fronts as well. We need people to not fly long distance for team offsites and family reunions once a quarter, we also need to have changes in legislation/political system to make it easier to go to work without a car, have changes in legislation to require flight companies to carbon offset helping with the first point etc etc etc. Why does the focus have to be on either or, I don't see it.
- fred92 4y agoor in other words why does everyone here think that the moment we talk about individual responsibility nobody will ever think or talk about cooperations responsibilities and large scale legislative solutions anymore? What is the precedent here that I am missing?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoNo, fossil carbon lies at the heart of the climate crisis. Equalising consumption is entirely othogonal and people who are arguing that fossil carbon and 'consumption' or 'quality of life' or 'energy' or anything else that isn't fossil carbon entering the atmosphere are the same thing are either not helping or actively hurting everyone, including those with low consumption now or in the past. The policies to help climate change help the rich. They also help the poor. There's basically no-one that would be harmed by them in any meaningful way, and literally Billions who would benefit which is why it's so frustrating that we're not fixing the issue, and instead inventing reasons to not fix it.