10 ms·
Android seems to be growing inferior to iOS in almost every way, which I find sad. I prefer to root for the underdog. * Privacy * Security * Efficiency I h
by metadat 4y ago
Android seems to be growing inferior to iOS in almost every way, which I find sad. I prefer to root for the underdog.
* Privacy
* Security
* Efficiency
I have a personal Android S22+ and an iPhone 13 mini. The iPhone gets better with every update, whereas there's always something funky going on with my droid. Every update does something weird, fixing one thing and breaking something new, and managing to offer no significant privacy improvements.
In fact, today it is Samsung, the world's second largest phone vendor (outside of China), who is the one getting hit by data breaches, leaks, and hacks on an ongoing basis.
- throwaway2056 4y agoDid you install all the same apps that you have in S22+ in iPhone 13 mini? Likely not. Please do fair comparison. If you install 100 + apps in iPhone it is also terrible.
- metadat 4y agoYes they have as many apps in common as possible. Both 256GB versions. The Android does get more use, but there's no denying the camera lag has been there since day one with the S22+. Previously I used (and still adore) the S10e. It's camera lag actually seemed slightly better than with the S22+, but still inferior to any recent iPhone (10x or newer).
- Ninjinka 4y agoI prefer to root the underdog
- andrew_ 4y agoOutstanding pun
- andrew_ 4y agoDid people not understand that the lack of "for" in that sentence was a pun about rooting Android?
- permo-w 4y agoI think it’s more about what makes a substantive comment while it may be an outstanding pun, commenting that it is doesn’t really add to the discussion. it feels rather like a reddit comment chain, which isn’t inherently a bad thing, but also isn’t really the culture on HN
- andrew_ 4y agoI see enough replies containing only compliments on HN to suggest that positive reinforcement is a segment of the HN culture.
- codq 4y agoMost popular mobile OS in the world is the underdog?
- metadat 4y agoIn terms of UX and mindshare, Android is the underdog.
- sergers 4y agoSubjective opinion. My wife won't switch to iOS device due to UX in iOS
- metadat 4y agoNeither will mine, but not for any rational reason. She's just an Android Freak.
- nikau 4y agoI find the supposed iphone simplicity argument fascinating. I had to help a family member open a PDF file of a ticket sent via email on an iphone. It was opened via webmail in safari, it just downloaded the file, that was it. No way to open it. No way to find the downloads from Safari. Eventually I figured out how to drag down from the home screen, search for downloads, scroll down a bit, then found the downloads folder with the file inside it to open it. Contrast to android where it downloads the file, then offers to open it. The whole "iphone is easier to use" seems like a bit of a myth.
- gpt5 4y agoI don't disagree that iOS handles downloaded files terribly (Safari does notify you when your file is downloading/finished, but in a very subtle way by adding a download icon navigation bar). However, using an anecdote of an uncommon use case being bad hardly supports the conclusion of your last sentence.
- 4y ago
- gpm 4y agoApple has literally proposed using the phone you bought and paid for to spy on you and report you to the authorities if you do bad things. While they backed down from that plan, they went out of their way to make it clear that they were only backing down temporarily. To suggest that iOS is ahead in privacy is ludicrous. I'll keep buying phones that only use cloud services that spy on me, instead of spying on me directly. At least that's somewhat defensible as it's not my hardware acting against me.
- cortesoft 4y agoUmm, Google also reports you to authorities for bad things https://www.nytimes.com/2022/08/21/technology/google-surveillance-toddler-photo.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/08/21/technology/google-surveil...
- gpm 4y agoGoogle reports you to the authorities, the phone you purchased from Google, but now own, does not.
- jeromegv 4y agoSo basically. As of now, Apple does nothing as they backed down from that plan. And google reports you to authorities and never stopped and also never went public about letting you know they were doing it (at least apple published a freaking press release to announce it and ask for feedback!) And somehow that makes Apple worse.
- gpm 4y agoTo be clear, Apples current actual activities is the same as Googles current actual activites. They scan files uploaded to their cloud services and report you to the authorities if they discover illegal material. Both companies are of course unable to detect CSAM in encrypted files, and Apple encrypts more files by default meaning that the impact of their current policy is somewhat less than Googles. Neither company has ever felt the need to make splashy press releases about this. Apple additionally has said that they will (though have backed off on the timing to "some time in the future") said that they will use your hardware to scan your photos and have it report you to the authorities.
- ekianjo 4y agosince when the most profitable company on the planet gets called an underdog? words have no meaning anymore?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThey were implying Android is the underdog.
- ekianjo 4y agoGoogle is not the underdog either by any measure...
- tpetry 4y agoBut Apple is basically only their devices, and the iphone the biggest one from all of them. Google is a myriad of services and their money is made from advertising and cloud. Android is just a very small part. So when you compare smartphones then Google is the smaller player, it‘s only a small fraction of the company while the rest is doing totally different things.
- bfrog 4y agoI mean, Private, Security, and Efficiency may not be so orthogonal if you consider what sort of data collection is desired for ad targeting, its basically everything. What apps are installed, which are used most, when? where? Which bluetooth and wifi devices are nearby? Truly the data scraping could be enormous, needing resources and lots of them.
- gpt5 4y agoData collection is not the reason that Android is a bloated mess.
- MBCook 4y agoJohn Gruber (yes, an Apple person) recently re-voiced the opinion that Google seems to have lost interest in Android and I keep coming back to it. Yes it exists, they add features. But they used to trumpet it a ton, add tons of new stuff. Try to keep expanding it like to tablets and other things. Now it’s basically phones, they don’t seem to try anymore on tablets. Phone makers come up with the new things (like folding) not Google. It sort of seems more reactive than proactive. I don’t know. I’m sort of spitballing as someone who doesn’t follow Android closely.
- andrewinardeer 4y agoIf I recall properly, Google adapted Android for folding screens prior to Samsung's release of their Z series.
- oxff 4y ago> Android seems to be growing inferior to iOS in almost every way Crazy statement. I have iPhone for work and it is horrible to use. I haven't met a single thing from UX point of view in iOS that is better than whatever is in Android. It's a complete downgrade IME.
- philliphaydon 4y agoI could argue the same. The UX experience on android is horrible and about the only valid point that people have with android is that is more customisable.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoNo offense to the two of you but I recently switched to iOS for my personal phone and still have an Android phone at work. The UX of both are now basically the same and they keep copying each other every time one of them does something good. I was actually shocked by how close they are.
- wiseowise 4y agoNot really. Android is a clusterfuck of features and inconsistency. Even back gesture is bolted on. On iOS it is part of OS framework.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoIf you say so. Swiping left goes back on the two of them in a way I have trouble distinguishing. I lament the absence of intent on iOS but the integration with the rest of the Apple ecosystems is nice. Apart from that, well, can’t say I have seen much of a difference personally.
- Gigachad 4y agoIt’s possible to view any OS as horrible to use really. Usually it comes from a mindset of “anything that isn’t how I’m used to is bad”. Which is especially likely if it’s only used a bit for work.
- ulfw 4y agoI am sorry. By what definition possible would Android be 'the underdog'? It's the most used mobile OS worldwide, by far. Owned, developed and release by the world's largest ad and web company.
- lultimouomo 4y agoOTOH these is a wodespread sense that people who can afford iStuff will get that, and only the poor will get Android. In that sense I don't think it's crazy to call Android the underdog.
- sofixa 4y agoIs that an American thing? It's definitely not generically widespread, and there are non-iPhone devices that are premium and even sometimes cost more (check any of the Fold designs).
- spacechild1 4y agoI think it is.
- xtracto 4y agoThat sounds pretty American. In my country there's lots of people that will gladly spend for a Galaxy S22+ whatever and never turn to see the iPhone even expensive Xiaomi phones have a lot of customers.
- ulfw 4y agoThere's tons of expensive Android phones too, not just cheap ones. Honestly you need to widen your horizon a bit. A Galaxy Z Fold4 - Samsung costs $1800 before tax. Form factor only available on Android. Even a Xiaomi 12 Ultra Phone costs over EUR1000 in Europe.
- matheusmoreira 4y agoIt's getting more locked down too. It used to be great for hackers, we could root the phone and do all sorts of things. Now there's stuff like hardware remote attestation getting in the way. I'm thinking there's no point in owning an Android phone anymore. They aren't trustworthy devices, they offer increasingly less user freedom at the cost of a less refined experience. It seems like they're just gonna become worse iPhones, all the problems and none of the benefits.
- f6rhdfgvr 4y ago[dead]
- voidfunc 4y agoI've been an Android guy for a long time and I briefly switched to an iPhone from 2020-2022 but went back to Android. The reason? Being forced to use Safari or a re-badged Safari because Apple refuses to let other browser engines on the platform. On Android I can run proper Firefox and get uBlock Origin.
- NLPlatypus 4y agoDoes uBlock Origin do a better job than the Ad Blocker extension on iPhone’s Safari? I use uBlock Origin on my desktop and Ad Blocker on my iPhone. Honestly, I can’t tell any difference. They both seem to block everything.
- RussianCow 4y agoYou can’t use ad blocker apps if you use any browser other than Safari. I use Firefox because I want to sync it with my desktop, which is not a Mac, so I have to choose between syncing and ad blocking.
- thiht 4y agoDid you give Firefox Focus a try? I guess it gives you Firefox Sync + ad blocking
- gorbypark 4y agoYou can even install Firefox Focus and use it's ad-blocking in Safari. Focus installs their ad-blocking as a system-level blocker (I assume due to iOS rules/requirements) which allows you to just toggle it on for "all browsers" (aka Safari and the Safari based browsers, which is all of them).
- curt15 4y agoHow does Safari's blocking compare with what uBlock Origin can do in full-blooded Firefox? For example, does it support CNAME uncloaking?[1] [1] https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-best-on-Firefox https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-b...
- albertopv 4y agoI've a S10e, up to date, zero issues whatsoever with phone updates. Data breaches is another story, but I don't use Samsung services.
- spaghettiToy 4y agoWhat's the android security flaw? As far as I've read pegasus has 0 click exploits on iOS that has successfully infiltrated hundreds of people. I couldn't find documented android examples. I've read android has some malware that you need to click "allow from web" and manually install. I have some sensitive stuff on my phone so security is my number 1 reason for getting an Android.
- Nathanba 4y agothe exact opposite is true, Apple iPhones have never been worse than now. 1. almost every generation has some kind of hardware defect that you only find out later that lots of people report in enthusiast forums. Be it the loading cable, display bending, weird issues around refresh rate straining your eyes.. it never ends. And no, the hardware doesn't even feel better than the competition anymore. I had the iphone 13 in my hands and it felt like any cheap plastic phone. 2. The UI is horrible, the false perception of iOS being "simple" is perhaps the biggest marketing success in human history. I had an iPhone 13 for a few hours and there were already countless things I found incomprehensible. E.g Undiscoverable gestures or extremely hard to achieve gesture to swipe up to remove an opened app. For one ui menu on the right middle side I had to press part of the hardware button on the right (what on earth, a hardware button to activate a touch ui!). Since when is the point of using a touch device to: ignore the touch interface and instead use a hardware button. Not even considering yet the weird annoying popup ui in the first place, why would you ever put something like that on the middle of your screen. 3. scrolling is slower, they have some kind of terrible human-like algorithm where you have to gear up the scroll speed as if you're manually accelerating a dial every time you want to scroll down. This is why they had to invent all these little tricks to scroll back up to the top of a page with a shortcut. Scrolling is just too slow, on huge pages it's fingerhurting work to get to the bottom. 4. The notch is objectively terrible, it was never good, it was never acceptable to put camera holes or notches into the display but the notch is the worst, most biggest affront to visual consistency. It almost has comical qualities, "oh yes, please put a huge black block directly into my visual field and make it so I am forced to look at it, I can't even install an app to hide it". 5. The amount of popups when I open any kind of app or the appstore is incredible. I think I had at least 4 consecutive popups before it lets me do anything. 6. The prices are a riot, it's a designer luxury item. I guess in the US the prices seem somewhat acceptable but anywhere else in the world the value for this phone does not match the money you pay for it. 7. [insert here every other criticism, e.g about iTunes being required or any other of the dozens and dozens of legitimate problems] This list is nowhere near complete. Meanwhile when I use my Android, my only complaint is that Samsung installed some default apps I don't want. That's literally it. Everything else works fine for me. I had an iphone 5s for years, while I was using it I liked it but nowadays when I have a comparison with a fluid, new android phone it cannot compete. To me it is clear that the success of Apple is a psychological success of two things mixed together: speed and beauty. The ui is always fast, therefore there is a false impression that it's simple and good. Beauty likewise gives a false impression that the ui is good in a general sense when in reality it's not better.
- gerash 4y agoI don't buy the privacy advantage. Security wise also it seems it's the other way round as long as you can have your device up to date. That is, even though iOS gets regular updates there seem to be more zero day vulnerabilities in it. Efficiency, esp when it comes to UI animation not stuttering is where iOS has done a tremendous job.
- thefz 4y agoI have a cheap-ish Pixel 4a bought at launch. Never had a complaint with it, went through all the updates, I use it for mapping and listening to music daily as well as reading RSS. Never a slow down or any glitch, except for connecting some Bluetooth devices. As with all software, YMMV. At least Google is not throttling its CPU behind my back. Also, Snowden has outed Apple as one of the corps complying with any government for customer data so don't get too high on your horse.
- drivebycomment 4y agoiOS is not better than android when it comes to security. It's at best equal, and in most perspective, slightly worse. Compare Zerodium's payout for iOS vs Android: https://www.zerodium.com/program.html https://www.zerodium.com/program.html iOS security was bad enough in 2020 that it even lead to: https://www.macrumors.com/2020/05/14/zerodium-pauses-acquiring-ios-exploits/ https://www.macrumors.com/2020/05/14/zerodium-pauses-acquiri... > Zerodium this week announced that it will not be purchasing any iOS exploits for the next two to three months due to a high number of submissions. In other words, the company has so many security vulnerabilities at its disposal that it does not need any more. Android FCP zero-click has been keeping higher price than iOS for a few years now. iOS iMessage RCE+LPE has been lower price than SMS RCE+LPE on android for a few years. In almost every comparison, iOS has the same bounty as android or cheaper. This, despite the fact that iOS bugs have more demand because of more premium targets.
- rozab 4y agoThere could be loads of reasons for this price difference other than supply. Android's higher market share, the ease of further exploiting any priv esc, the fact any zero day will patched much slower for a majority of devices...
- drivebycomment 4y agoiOS used to fetch higher price years ago - that was when they had less market share as well.
- howinteresting 4y agoNo, it's because it is much easier to find security vulnerabilities on iOS than on Android.
- type0 4y agoCan you rollback updates on Android?
- nicbou 4y agoI will not buy an iPhone until I can put uBlock Origin on it. My iPad is nearly unusable as a web browsing device, although it's outstanding in every other respect.
- metadat 4y agoI completely agree, having Firefox with uBlock on Android is really great! I wish more Android users knew and cared about personal security so they'd take advantage of this awesome capability. Apple's entire platform is so locked down, it definitely comes off as somewhat user-hostile to me. That said, my mom doesn't care about this aspect in the slightest.
- deergomoo 4y agoiOS supports ad-blockers. Granted they're not uBlock Origin—they basically just giant dictionaries of domains to block—but they do work and work well.
- nicbou 4y agoThey don't buy YouTube ads, newsletter popups and cookie notices, among other annoyances.
- musictubes 4y agoUnusable? A bit hyperbolic no? Ad Guard worked fine for me. I've moved to 1Blocker for cross app tracking protection.
- nicbou 4y agoNo, it's unusable. YouTube has ads. Other websites have ads and cookie banners. The web with uBlock is entirely different. I've grown used to it and I'm not going back.
- jakobbouchard 4y agoyou can actually use ublock origin through the Orion browser! it’s still relatively new, but it’s a nice browser. it’s also available on macos and supports syncing. you can use chrome and firefox extensions with it
- jacooper 4y ago> Privacy The company that wants to force CSAM, doesn't encrypt iCloud backups so it can remain as a backdoor to WhatsApp, cares about your privacy?. I can't even install and app without an apple account. Apple doesn't care about your privacy, its just marketing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r38Epj6ldKU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r38Epj6ldKU On android I can use it without a google account, with newpipe for zero ads on YouTube, infinity for zero ads on reddit, glider as a client for HN. I use CalyxOS for better privacy with usability, and you can switch to GrapheneOS which is one of the most secure mobile OSes. (Only on Pixel). While on iOS, there is nothing even close to it, and the FOSS scene is totally dead. However I only like stock android, Samsung, or the million other IOS clones from Chinese companies almost all suck. > Security IOS has more vulnerabilities than Android https://www.theregister.com/2020/05/14/zerodium_ios_flaws/ https://www.theregister.com/2020/05/14/zerodium_ios_flaws/
- tandr 4y agoWhat phone do you use, that allows that many choices of android variants, sorry?
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>However I only like stock android, Samsung, or the million other IOS clones from Chinese companies almost all suck. I used to like stock android but since 12 it's been going down the drain in terms of looks and feel. Now I prefer the Samsung UI since they're at least consistent with previous versions and don't make huge changes for the sake of changes like Google does. So this is one of the main advantages of android: vendors can rejected Google's ästhetisc choices and just keep the under the hood improvements.
- pentae 4y agoHow good is the 13 Mini, I think it might be the most underrated iPhone ever made
- alerighi 4y agoI tried to go to iOS just for curiosity since 2 years but I think the next device will be an Android again for these reason: - you cannot simply install applications outside the AppStore - developing applications even for personal use requires macOS, an Apple developer account, etc - it lacks of decent applications, such as an email client that works, thanks to limitations imposed by Apple on what the applications can do in background - it comes with stupid limitations. Such as you can't to a software update on a mobile network (why? To this day with cheap plans that gives you 50G or even unlimited data for 10 euros at month a lot of people no longer even have a landline internet connection and thus Wi-Fi at home, and have to use another phone in hotspot mode to download an update, this is pure insanity of Apple!) - it works well if you are all-in in the Apple ecosystem, for example you have also a Mac, but it doesn't integrate with Windows (the Windows phone companion that lets you to receive notifications on the PC and other stuff is only available for Android, since iOS doesn't have APIs to do that stuff such as read notifications). - the only browser allowed is basically Safari and this to me is very wrong for the open web (it's true that in Android you have Chrome, but you can install whatever browser you want, such as Firefox). Safari doesn't support progressive web apps for example for no reason, so you are forced to install an app while you could have used its PWA enabled website. - you are forced to use Apple services, while in Android using Google services is an option (you can have an Android OS without Google Apps, even if it can be impractical I like having this possibility at least in theory). For example the only way that I found to backup my photos was to pay iCloud, since Google Photos (that did give you unlimited space back then) didn't work in background and thus you have to open it to sync (something that is pretty useless for a backup tool that you want to be always running...) - it's less user friendly, there are things that are complicated for no reason. This was confirmed by a lot of people that transitioned to iOS and find it more difficult to use - to this day it's practically impossible to mod (jailbreak) an iPhone to overcome its limitations. In the past there was jailbreak that really did solve many of the issues, but this day it's nearly impossible - lack of support for open standards, such as the usage of the proprietary lightning connector instead of USB-C (something that is now a requirement in the European union by the way) From the hardware perspective, it's well built for sure, but I find it too expensive for what it offers. The iPhone that I actually have (an iPhone XS bought new for 600 euros) it seemed expensive when I bought, now to get an iPhone of a similar range (that is an iPhone Pro) you have to spend at least than double that price! A decent Android that is enough to me for my daily tasks can be bought for 200 euros, a top spec one for 600. To me the added cost of an iPhone is not justified.
- rejectfinite 4y agoYea but atleast I can use a real web browser on Android. And still change almost everything.