4 ms·
US military involvement in the Middle East is hardly a subsidy to the oil and gas companies that would be impacted by this Act. Most of the oil and gas companie
by nradov 4y ago
US military involvement in the Middle East is hardly a subsidy to the oil and gas companies that would be impacted by this Act. Most of the oil and gas companies in that region are state owned with Aramco being the largest by far. They aren't subject to US laws or taxes. And they don't even export much to the US. Hypothetically, if an armed conflict shut down Aramco production then US oil and gas companies would actually make more profit.
I do agree that allowing oil and gas companies to avoid paying the full costs of environmental damage is effectively a form of hidden subsidy.
- Spooky23 4y agoIt’s all connected. The conflict in Ukraine means my heating bill in NY goes up 40% this winter.
- nradov 4y agoPassing this Act wouldn't make your heating bill any lower.
- Alupis 4y ago> The conflict in Ukraine means my heating bill in NY goes up 40% this winter. Why? The US is the largest producer of natural gas in the world, and by quite a large margin[1]. Europe tied themselves to Russian natural gas, heeding no warnings in the process, and now find themselves cut off due to conflict. Oh, if only this could have been predicted and avoided in advance... It makes sense for Europeans to experience ludicrous natural gas bills, but not someone in NY. Further, the US should not make citizens suffer in order to prop up European nations that couldn't have cared any less about their own security until it was too late. [1] https://yearbook.enerdata.net/natural-gas/world-natural-gas-production-statistics.html https://yearbook.enerdata.net/natural-gas/world-natural-gas-...
- Spooky23 4y agoWe’re shipping LNG to Europe, and limited pipeline capacity in the northeast is a constraint.
- randomdata 4y ago> It makes sense for Europeans to experience ludicrous natural gas bills, but not someone in NY. It's a globally traded commodity. If someone in NY won't pay 40% more, someone in Europe will. Just like you work for who gives you the most compelling offer, so too does natural gas go to who presents the most compelling offer. > the US should not make citizens suffer in order to prop up European nations Given that the US is where most of the natural gas is produced, per your comment, the US will realize a huge windfall by shipping its product to Europe at a high markup. The citizens of the US will be emboldened by it. They may have to pay more for heat, but stand to gain even more than that. Europe loses either way.
- Alupis 4y ago> The citizens of the US will be emboldened by it. They may have to pay more for heat, but stand to gain even more than that. I have to disagree here. The citizens of the US gain nothing from the US permitting natural gas companies to export to Europe instead of filling local demand first. These are private companies anyway... so not sure how this logic holds up. > It's a globally traded commodity. Sure it is... however a nation can and will prohibit exports when local demand exceeds available reserves. Natural gas is a strategic asset after all, and we're already dangerously dancing with inflation/recession - it wouldn't make sense to accelerate that path just because Europe needs gas after a series of terrible, completely avoidable choices.
- randomdata 4y ago> however a nation can and will prohibit exports when local demand exceeds available reserves. Sure. There is no doubt a tipping point. Seeing 100% exports wouldn't work. But the nation of the US is made up of its citizens, so only when the citizens start to feel that tipping point has nearing or has occurred will they take measures to prohibit such exports. Clearly we're not there. There is still more upside than downside.
- Alupis 4y agoI think in theory you would be right, but practically Joe Biden isn't going to ask regular citizens if he should allow export of Natural Gas to European nations. Majority of citizens just accept the half-truth that Putin's War caused high gas (both natural and petroleum) for everyone, and that there's nothing that can be done except end the war. Europe needs to suffer for their poor decisions. Enough of the US swooping in and solving European mistakes... then getting villainized for being the world's safety net.
- Aunche 4y agoEnsuring stability in the Middle East is a subsidy for fossil fuel consumers. It hurts the oil producers, which are the companies targeted by this bill. The war in Ukraine is a good example of this as it's contributing to their record profits.
- Spooky23 4y agoMiddle East stability is a long term policygoal. The United States made Saudi Arabia one of the highest priority allies to avoid a repeat of 1973. On a long term scale, keeping the pumps going is good for the petroleum industry, as sustained high prices justify the capital expense for alternatives. Once you buy an electric car, you don’t really give a hoot about gasoline.