4 ms·
I know this is hacker news, but I think the idea of hacking general purpose compute infrastructure on top of graphics/gaming hardware is starting to get out of
by amelius 4y ago
I know this is hacker news, but I think the idea of hacking general purpose compute infrastructure on top of graphics/gaming hardware is starting to get out of hand.
When will we flip it around?
- nerdponx 4y agoWhat's wrong with it? It turns out that graphics hardware is perfect for certain kinds of non-graphical scientific computing. Dedicated GPGPU hardware already exists, but people don't have those at home and/or on their regular computers that they use.
- amelius 4y agoWhat is wrong with it can be summed up by Henry Ford's quote: “If I would have asked people what they wanted, they would have said faster horses.” (In this analogy horse=GPU, car/truck=general purpose compute hardware)
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI really don't see the issue. GPU is specialised hardware for certain computations - faster and/or more energy-efficient. Your analogy is weird too; if a CPU is a car, then a GPU is a specialized car that can go 1000x faster under certain specialized circumstances. That said, your original issue was with general purpose compute infrastructure on top of GPU, which can be applied to this analogy too; using the Thrust SSC to transport a container is probably not the best. Possible, but suboptimal.
- pjc50 4y agoHow? And who is we? So long as the GPU remains closed and proprietary, we can't port a general purpose OS to it and have it take over the boot.
- Cthulhu_ 4y ago> When will we flip it around? Do you mean software rendering? Or more like baking GPUs into CPUs (already done decades ago, see SoC or integrated graphics hardware).
- tormeh 4y agoIt has already. Chips that are ostensibly for graphics are containing more and more silicon dedicated to general purpose workloads. Turns out doing it like this this is usually cheaper than manufacturing dedicated parallel processors and GPUs separately, since the requirements have so much overlap.
- unconed 4y agoGPUs are already pretty generic. The main diff is that a GPU will execute N threads in lockstep, where N = 32 or 64, like a very wide and always-on SIMD. The dedicated render pipeline still exists, and is still needed for things like Z buffering and interpolation, but you'd be surprised how much of what used to be fixed hardware is being emulated by the driver.