2 ms·
in contrast to the american idea of free speech which limits what the government can censor, germany has a concept of the freedom of opinion which among other t
by em-bee 4y ago
in contrast to the american idea of free speech which limits what the government can censor, germany has a concept of the freedom of opinion which among other things limits the right of companies to censor opinions they disagree with. the blocking of trump for example raised some eyebrows. the kind of moderation done on hackernews would be just fine in germany too though.
- wawjgreen 4y ago
- em-bee 4y agothe following is a response to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32771479 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32771479 which is dead, so i am writing here instead, since it fits. The problem is, the mods at Twitter may have a disagreement with a user and ban them arbitrarily, like they did with Peterson. Pretty soon, you will not be able to read anything except what appeals to the Twitter mods. Your thinking will be forced and re-defined and you won't be able to say what you think, because of the repercussions. [...] In a world where you can only say what you are allowed to say, people will stop thinking and everybody will say similar things. I hardly call that "freedom" and "pursuit of happiness". i agree with your general sentiment, which is why i pointed out the difference of how germany treats its freedom of opinion. a few years ago a new law was enacted that requires the swift removal of online hate speech and one of the first people blocked because that law was someone making anti-muslim comments. so no, there is no allowed hate speech there. the difficulty is to figure out what is to be considered hate speech and what isn't. some of that we may have to learn through trial and error. the new law is controversial because it forces companies to act on mere notification without a court order. which, while considered normal in the US, is not how germans like to do things.