3 ms·
> It being plentiful and cheap is a pretty damn important and redeeming quality. If you want to talk about "redeeming" then you need to include externalities,
by Dylan16807 4y ago
> It being plentiful and cheap is a pretty damn important and redeeming quality.
If you want to talk about "redeeming" then you need to include externalities, and those are pretty bad for coal.
> the human cost of just shutting off power completely if it’s not clean like people seem to want to do.
Nobody wants to do that, stop being weird.
- wpietri 4y ago> Nobody wants to do that, stop being weird. It did strike me as a pretty egregious straw man. I don't think I've ever heard anybody argue for just turning off coal plants and sitting in darkness, certainly not the poster being replied to. In the last 20 years, the percentage of US energy coming from coal has fallen in half. Eliminating is entirely achievable.
- didericis 4y agoPeople don’t think that’s what they’re arguing for, but that’s what happens when you go green too optimistically and aggressively. If you sacrifice reliability and robustness for being green, your grid becomes vulnerable. From what I understand it seems reasonable to get rid of coal in the US over a reasonable time frame with appropriate replacements. I’m not arguing in favor of coal. I’m arguing in favor of going with cheap reliable energy and whatever the best and actually practical solutions are for a given area. The fact that coal has fallen by half in 20 years doesn’t mean the other half is just as easy, either. You need a certain amount of supplemental power at night, during bad weather, during usage spikes, etc. The remaining percentage of coal use is going to be more and more concentrated in the supply areas that are harder to replace. That doesn’t mean it can’t all be replaced or that we shouldn’t pursue replacing all of it, all I’m advocating is for a sane transition that takes practical constraints like that into account and doesn’t get perfectionistic about solutions. Frankly I don’t often see considerations like that being made, I see a lot of hysterics and dogmatic assertions about how everything needs to be solar panels and wind turbines yesterday and everyone who wants moderation or other green solutions and more gradual phase in is a greedy oil shill.
- ncmncm 4y agoThe transition will perforce be very far on the side of what you call "sane", to a pathological degree. There is no merit in arguing for what must certainly happen anyway.
- wpietri 4y ago> I’m arguing in favor of going with cheap reliable energy and whatever the best Then you're not doing a very good job of it. For all that you accuse others of "hysterics and dogmatic assertions", I think your posts earn that label way more than the comments you replied to.
- didericis 4y agoGermany already did that. They shut down a whole bunch of power plants to meet emissions quotas thinking they could meet demands with renewables. They made their grid fragile and dependent on the Russians, and now they can’t. They’re planning on rationing and building warming shelters: https://m.dw.com/en/german-residents-make-plans-amid-fears-of-a-winter-gas-shortage/a-62482737 https://m.dw.com/en/german-residents-make-plans-amid-fears-o...
- ncmncm 4y agoNot what happened. Other options were worse.
- didericis 4y agoThat is what happened, and you saying “other options were worse” is precisely the point I’m making. Worse according to who? Climate activists? Or people who are going to freeze to death because those “worse” options weren’t kept online?