4 ms·
Caravans faced this problem, but the solution was commercial - the caravanserai. A serai is a corral for animals. A caravanserai is a truck stop - fuel, food,
by Animats 4y ago
Caravans faced this problem, but the solution was commercial - the caravanserai.
A serai is a corral for animals. A caravanserai is a truck stop - fuel, food, motel, parking.
Caravans resupplied at caravanserai. The Silk Road was a chain of caravanserai.
If there's enough local production to supply a caravanserai, caravans can take that route.
The military version of this is a chain of supply bases. This is all too common. A gallon of diesel fuel delivered by the US military to outermost bases in Afghanistan could cost well over US$100. Part of the trip was made by transport aircraft, and part by helicopter, all of it consuming fuel. Bases have to be within helicopter range of each other. The main justification for the Osprey, which is a horrible kludge of an aircraft, is more range, allowing fewer bases to reach a goal.
- schoen 4y ago> If there's enough local production to supply a caravanserai, caravans can take that route. That's an interesting constraint; were there also extra-expensive caravanserai in places where that production wasn't quite local and some of those resources had to be trucked, er, caravanned in?
- samatman 4y agoSort of, mostly yes, but never fodder or water. This is the great advantage of the camel: if a camel train rolls into a caravanserai, and the available fodder at that oasis has been eaten, there's a good change they'll make it to the next oasis with thin, very unhappy, camels. Mules would just die.
- csours 4y agoI had heard of caravanserai from the idle/progression Kittens Game. I wish I had looked it up earlier.
- JJMcJ 4y agoBy no means an expert but my understanding is that if you can't make the logistics work for a military operation then the chances of failure are very high, maybe even literally 100%.
- chasd00 4y agomy 10 year old, out of the blue, told me once "artillery wins battles but logistics wins wars". Heh he's really into a couple youtube history channels.
- trhway 4y agoWatch the Kherson region now - Russia has a 25K strong army on the right side of Dneper river there, and thanks to US supplied high precision missiles (HIMARS) Ukraine has practically disabled the bridges leading there, so that Russian army has only minimal supply using ferries. The railway from Crimea to those bridges and ferries had also been constantly stricken (frequently the strike would be at a large military supply train riding there) In general, across the front, we see David vs. Goliath fight with supply logistics being the Goliath's spot that David is targeting - Russia has 5-10x of old style un-precise artillery advantage, and their main approach is to flood Ukrainians with ocean of fire, and that requires tremendous amount of supply, while Ukraine having only about 40 of those HIMARS launchers has been methodically taking out key Russian targets among which large Russian ammo and fuel depots to the 50 miles depth (the range of those missiles) thus straining Russian supply of the frontline.
- Aeolun 4y agoWe have a very recent example that proves this point.
- FabHK 4y agoJust this June I've visited the caravanserai in Tash Rabat, Kyrgyzstan. A beautiful and somewhat baffling structure in a sweeping mountainous setting, with just a few yurts beside it to host visitors. (Highly recommend a visit to and jeep tour through Kyrgyzstan: the landscape is stunning, and the people extraordinarily friendly and welcoming.) Here some blog posts with pictures (not affiliated): https://silkroad-livinghistory.org/kyrgyzstan/the-lonely-caravanserai-at-tash-rabat https://silkroad-livinghistory.org/kyrgyzstan/the-lonely-car... https://www.timetravelturtle.com/tash-rabat-caravanserai-kyrgyzstan/ https://www.timetravelturtle.com/tash-rabat-caravanserai-kyr...