7 ms·
Well I hope that at least the next lab-made pandemic will insert some beneficial mutations to humanity. In a way, the lab-leak hypothesis is comforting, becaus
by seydor 4y ago
Well I hope that at least the next lab-made pandemic will insert some beneficial mutations to humanity.
In a way, the lab-leak hypothesis is comforting, because it means that nature with its own means did not manage to manufacture such a highly-transmissive disease, despite the facts of modern life, record human population and rates of travel. If it is not lab-made, then nature may do this again soon with another virus.
- goatcode 4y agoIn nature, it makes no sense for a virus to be both highly transmissible and highly deadly. Any such virus would cease to exist after having run amok in such a way in its hosts. Therefore, any extremely deadly virus should be looked at with similarly extreme criticism, especially if / when it adapts and becomes a better behaving parasite.
- tedivm 4y agoNature, and evolution, don't follow motive based logic. Random mutations that are temporarily beneficial but are detrimental to the long term do happen. To put it another way, a cell mutates based off of random chance. It doesn't have desires. We only have to go back as far as 1918 to see an example of a virus that could not have been engineered and was highly transmissible and highly deadly. As you say, in the long term that doesn't work out- the virus in that case mutated to be much more mild- which is why you won't see viruses like that surviving for long. But it still doesn't make sense to assume viruses evolve according to a motivation based logic.
- Moodles 4y agoObviously the person you’re responding to doesn’t think covid is conscious and has motivations…
- goatcode 4y ago> temporarily beneficial This was the crux of my point.
- tedivm 4y agoThen your point makes no sense.
- omniglottal 4y agoPlease work on your reading comprehension and stop being rude.
- HillRat 4y agoYou're assuming that viruses don't have natural reservoirs. For example, viral hemorrhagic fevers, particularly filovirus VHFs, are both highly transmissible and highly deadly -- accounting for their history of rapid, fast-growing, and quickly-diminishing epidemics amongst humans -- but have stable zoonotic reservoirs that allow them to circulate freely across those populations. (Bats' unique immune system, like camelids, makes them a particularly good evolutionary proving ground for viral evolution, so they serve as a reservoir and a source of ongoing viral mutations.)
- bialpio 4y ago> (...) it means that nature with its own means did not manage to manufacture such a highly-transmissive disease (...) I think I'm less optimistic than you in this matter. There's at least one counter-example to that statement: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_flu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_flu that has the same order of magnitude of deaths as COVID-19, but in a world where population was ~4x smaller and I'd expect less mobile / interconnected.
- haswell 4y agoI do think this is an appropriate counter-example, but I’m curious how much modern medicine would change the impact (and preserve the case for optimism).
- bialpio 4y agoRapid vaccine development does indeed give some cause for optimism. Some counters that I'd have to that would be a potential resurgence of polio in the US [1] and the appearance of drug-resistant pathogens (typhoid fever in this case) [2], just to keep us on our toes and curb our enthusiasm... [1] https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7133e2.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/71/wr/mm7133e2.htm [2] https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/travel/notices/watch/xdr-typhoid-fever-pakistan https://wwwnc.cdc.gov/travel/notices/watch/xdr-typhoid-fever...
- 8note 4y agoThe Spanish flu also happened in a much less medically advanced society, that didn't understand how viruses work
- bialpio 4y agoBacteriology was already developing at that time, first vaccines were already in use (for none other than a viral disease!), and the existence of a pathogen smaller than bacteria was already hypothesized. The response to Spanish flu was also eerily similar to what was recommended in the first year of COVID: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_flu#/media/File%3AIllustrated_Current_News-1918-Thompson%2C_Paul.png https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spanish_flu#/media/File%3AIl.... All that aside, your comment does not really prove that "nature cannot come up with something so transmissive", which was the claim here.
- anon291 4y agoNature does not 'manage to manufacture'. Genomic changes occur by random chance. For example, nature did not intend to manufacture smallpox, when that became a thing 4-5000 years ago. Instead, some random pox virus (like monkey pox) infected some people and random changes happened to produce smallpox, which became endemic in the human population. Then, another mutation happened that caused hemmorhagic smallpox to become a thing and to start killing people (the vast majority of smallpox strains do not have high death rates, although they can cause bad disability, although no one knows if they would with modern medicine). So nature can produce anything a human can. But certainly, human intervention to make a disease worse can also make terrible diseases.
- elcomet 4y agoLab-leaked doesn't mean lab-made. Those labs also study natural viruses.
- nradov 4y agoNature certainly manufactured HCoV-OC43, another betacoronavirus very similar to SARS-CoV-2. It is the leading suspect for causing a worldwide pandemic which killed a lot of people starting in 1889.
- igouy 4y agoFalse comfort. "In May [2021], researchers reported that two coronaviruses in dogs recombined in Malaysia. The result was a hybrid that infected eight children." https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/14/science/bat-coronaviruses-lab-leak.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/14/science/bat-coronaviruses...
- throwaway290 4y ago> the lab-leak hypothesis is comforting, because it means that nature with its own means did not manage to manufacture such a highly-transmissive disease We are well past the point where nature is our greatest enemy. A lab leak of such consequences has the attention of every hostile organization out there. Imagine the scale of hurt you could achieve, yourself remaining pretty much immune to detection and prosecution, by doing the same thing but intentionally. Bye-bye unrestricted travel.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jcims 4y agoEh, a rogue planet could convert the earth into a small asteroid belt.
- brippalcharrid 4y agoYou'd need more than a few postgrads over the course of several weeks to synthesize a rogue planet, though.
- dylan604 4y agoLuckily, before that happens, humans will have killed themselves off and turned the planet into Venus 2.0. That way, the rogue planet doesn't have to feel guilty of wiping out an advanced species.
- thegabriele 4y agoNature did in the past many times, didn't it?
- haihaibye 4y agoLab leaks happened in the past, too, including one that was covered up by a communist government for decades https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_laboratory_biosecurity_incidents https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_laboratory_biosecuri...
- chasil 4y agoNot really that many times. I understand that most of the major viral pathogens have emerged in the last 10,000 years, since urban society replaced hunter-gatherer culture. It has not been difficult to bring what naturally evolved under control in developed countries.
- brnaftr361 4y agoNo, it was the neolithic, and in particular animal husbandry that was the culprit rather than simply urbanization which was a later emergence. And when you contrast new world peoples who had very few animals to domesticate, there's only one disease thought to have originated there: syphilis. This is despite the records of highly concentrated populations in various regions in the New World.
- chasil 4y ago"In the world our human immune system evolved in hundreds of thousands of years ago, infectious diseases could not become a major problem because, with a few exceptions, when you survive an infectious disease, you usually don’t get it again. Either it kills you or it leaves you completely immune to it for the rest of your life. For the vast majority of human history our species lived in small tribes that were spread thin and, for all intents and purposes, pretty isolated from each other. An infectious disease simply could not become a dangerous threat and establish itself in our ancestors effectively. Because if it infected a tribe, it would infect every available person in no time and then die off because there would be no one left to jump over. So our evolution did not really have to consider these sorts of pathogens that much. "As we became farmers and city dwellers our lifestyle changed forever—and so did the diseases that targeted us. Living close together created a perfect breeding ground for infectious diseases. Suddenly, in evolutionary terms, there were hundreds or even thousands of victims to infect. As our ancestors were not aware of the nature of microorganisms or even basic hygiene and they did not yet possess tools like soap and indoor plumbing, there was not much they could do—on the contrary, their lack of understanding made things worse. "And when they began domesticating and living together with animals in close quarters, often even sleeping in the same rooms, some pathogens jumped over. Our new lifestyle turned out to be the perfect environment for the pathogens of our new animal friends, to adapt to humans and vice versa. As a consequence, virtually every infectious disease we know today arose in the last ten thousand years. From cholera, smallpox, measles, influenza, and the common cold to chicken pox." Immune by Philipp Dettmer
- dijit 4y ago> Well I hope that at least the next [..] pandemic will insert some beneficial mutations to humanity. Sometimes this is indirect; there is some debate on why some Europeans have immunity to HIV, the current hypothesis is that it’s a result of us surviving the Black Plague. https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2005/03/050325234239.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2005/03/050325234239.h...
- tibbydudeza 4y agoAlso why Africans did not suffer such large number of fatalities per population. A younger population but we are one of the few regions in the world still giving the TB/Polio vaccine at birth. "epigenetic modifications, activate cells of the innate immune system, such as monocytes, macrophages and natural killer cells" https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34983348/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34983348/
- pstuart 4y agoEasy now -- this is how we get zombies.
- stefanpie 4y agoAntihypoxiant by Andy Weir: http://www.galactanet.com/oneoff/antihypoxiant.html http://www.galactanet.com/oneoff/antihypoxiant.html
- pstuart 4y agoMy fave of his of all time is The Egg: http://www.galactanet.com/oneoff/theegg_mod.html http://www.galactanet.com/oneoff/theegg_mod.html
- effingwewt 4y agoJust saw the Kurzgesagt video about this the other say and it was truly amazing! For me it was up there with 'I don't know, Timmy, being God is a big responsibility'[1] by qntm. I had meant to read up some more of Andy Weir but had spaced it. Thanks for the links y'all!
- rajin444 4y agoIsn’t the lab leak hypothesis saying nature did this make this, but scientists who were studying (and allowing) the natural processes accidentally leaked it? Which is the main argument against this kind of function research - there’s little gain compared to the risk.
- roamerz 4y agoIn the end are we not all a product of nature including the scientists?
- oofbey 4y agoThe term "lab leak" is ambiguous (deliberately I guess) as to whether the virus was modified in the lab before it leaked, or if the lab leaked an unmodified virus. But the preponderance of evidence is that the leaked virus was modified before it was leaked. The critical spike protein in SARS_CoV2 is coded uses a sequence of amino acids that has never been seen before in any other coronavirus. I forget the names, but there are certain common amino acids that can be coded using several different functionally-identical DNA (RNA) sequences, and the SARS-CoV2 one looks like the sequences used in labs and humans, and never seen before in natural viruses. One nobel laureate in biology described this as a "smoking gun" that this was a lab leak when they first heard about it.
- rasz 4y agoWuhan scientist working with EcoHealth alliance specifically wrote a grant proposal with intent to: “We will introduce appropriate human-specific cleavage sites and evaluate growth potential in [a type of mammalian cell commonly used in microbiology] and HAE cultures,” They were denied over Gain of Function concerns, and bam a year later the only Sars virus to be ever observed with those exact human-specific cleavage sites at the S1 S2 junction ravages the planet starting 500m from WIV. https://theintercept.com/2021/09/23/coronavirus-research-grant-darpa/ https://theintercept.com/2021/09/23/coronavirus-research-gra...
- ix101 4y agoThe question is whether in the process of studying it they intentionally created modified viruses, and that was what leaked.
- tmaly 4y agoI think we are going to find out soon: https://news.yahoo.com/china-locks-down-65-million-095328796.html https://news.yahoo.com/china-locks-down-65-million-095328796...
- dmix 4y ago> 33 cities including seven provincial capitals are under full or partial lockdown covering more than 65 million people > It said that outbreaks have been reported in 103 cities, the highest since the early days of the pandemic in early 2020. Crazy, it's like the rest of the world moved on but China is still in 2020.
- kurupt213 4y agoTheir vaccine being worthless didn’t help
- eloff 4y agoIt is not very effective from what I've seen. They would have been better off contracting with Pfizer or other Western companies that had effective vaccines. Cheap made in China crap that doesn't work. I kid, sort of.
- 404mm 4y ago
- origin_path 4y agoIrrelevant - our vaccines are also worthless by this point. They don't work against Omicron and there's no difference in infection or fatality rates between vaccinated and unvaccinated by now. There hasn't been for months. Or actually, infection rates are usually reported to be higher in the vaccinated group but by how much depends on age and number of doses. There was a difference at the beginning, although it's unclear how reliable that data actually is (even in the west).
- JaceLightning 4y agoor... if it's a lab-leak then evil governments know they can create world-wide devastating pandemics.
- danenania 4y agoThe main deterrent here is that it's too easy for the leaders of the evil government to end up being infected too. Even if you target a virus at specific genetics or make a secret vaccine, it's impossible to predict how it might evolve once it's out in the wild. At least given current technology, viruses can't be controlled well enough to make good weapons.
- fooqux 4y agoI'm pretty sure evil governments already know this. If nothing else, it's been the plot of many popular stories for decades.
- pvaldes 4y agoThey were most probably aware of that yet
- PointlessLogin 4y ago> lab-made pandemic Lab-leak != Lab-made
- bigodbiel 4y agoI disagree, I hope that lableak confirmation will push for a reassessment on the risk reward ratios for research. It may slow down scientific process, but we can now see that the dangers, if catastrophic enough, even if minimal, may not warrant it.
- kurupt213 4y agoI can’t believe anyone would seriously say ‘it doesn’t matter how it happened.’ That’s like the NTSB holding a press conference and saying it doesn’t matter why the 747 crashed and killed 500 people. They have to determine what happened so they can do root cause analysis and institute procedures to make this less likely to occur again.
- fullshark 4y agoPeople will rationalize any argument as long as their sacred cows are protected (we must defend SCIENCE it's under attack from the ignorant!) or enemies eviscerated.