4 ms·
Wouldn't that just put the journals in control of what studies get performed (as well as what gets published)? Seems weird to give all that power to the journal
by latchkey 4y ago
Wouldn't that just put the journals in control of what studies get performed (as well as what gets published)? Seems weird to give all that power to the journals.
- marcosdumay 4y agoWell, they are already in control of what studies get published, what isn't much different. I do think they shouldn't control that, but it's a deeper change, for a different gain.
- latchkey 4y agoIt is a lot different because if the study isn't published in one journal, it could always be published in another. In this situation, the study wouldn't be done at all until a journal agreed to publish it.
- hiptobecubic 4y agoYou could submit your proposal to other journals as well though
- latchkey 4y agoIf I was a journal, and I was promising to publish a study once it is completed, I'd ask for exclusivity rights. Which goes to show the whole issue with this idea.
- marcosdumay 4y agoAgain that didn't change anything when compared to the current situation. Journals do ask for exclusivity when they publish things. The don't ask for it just for submission. And the same reasons for why they don't now (nobody would submit anything to them) apply for the OP's idea. In fact, all the changes only make the life of the researcher easier, because he would only have to present a proposal for the journals to deny. Now he has to complete his research before he gets the denial. (It also makes the life of the journals much harder, for the same reason.)
- latchkey 4y ago> Again that didn't change anything when compared to the current situation. Journals do ask for exclusivity when they publish things. The don't ask for it just for submission. You contradict yourself. It absolutely changes things. > Now he has to complete his research before he gets the denial. It could degrade the incentive for the researcher to do great work, if they knew that they would be published.
- watwut 4y agoThere are already pre-print servers where you can pre-register your studies. It is not mandatory, but it is a think.