3 ms·
Does a physician have a globally optimal understanding? Do you actively read medical journals? Developments in biochemistry? Even amongst the best read physici
by echelon 4y ago
Does a physician have a globally optimal understanding?
Do you actively read medical journals? Developments in biochemistry? Even amongst the best read physicians and researchers, I would bet my life that we're doing a lot of things suboptimally or have improper understanding of many diseases.
I'm not trying to belittle your understanding or your credentials, which I understand to be far better than untrained laymen.
The current state of medical care leaves a lot to be desired. We have a long way to go to detect and cure every disease state.
If more money is spent on developing better tooling, assays, imaging, etc. we will undoubtedly improve patient outcomes.
- PragmaticPulp 4y ago> Does a physician have a globally optimal understanding? I’m far more inclined to trust a trained physician than a random HN commenter whose first four citations are just random ultrasound device manufacturer websites. The parent comment makes bold claims and tries to overwhelm the reader with non sequitur citations, but it’s clear they don’t actually understand the subject matter.
- adventured 4y agoWhile I agree with your premise, how the hell do we know the parent is a trained physician? This is an anonymous forum. Without a long, elaborate history on HN or public credentials, to be of meaningful value in terms of trust (in the context we're discussing) the reply needs to bring a lot more to the conversation than a one line statement and claim of being a doctor. Maybe they are a doctor, great: they can add a lot more to the counter reply if so, information that they are in theory particularly equipped to discuss.
- DanBC 4y ago> While I agree with your premise, how the hell do we know the parent is a trained physician? We don't know, but it doesn't matter. We can go to websites like the BMJ and see trained physicians and researchers saying the same thing across a range of different articles. We can go to research organisations like NICE, or Cochrane, or the UK National Screening Committee to see doctors and researchers saying the same thing. For mass screening, the harm often outweighs the benefits.
- lazyasciiart 4y agoA globally optimal understanding would involve far more than biochemistry and medical journals - population analysis, behavioral economics, regular economics, risk analysis, and a crystal ball would all be needed to avoid "doing a lot of things suboptimally". The fact that you haven't even mentioned those fields of study makes it clear you're not familiar with even the scope of the problem, let alone how to solve it. Hell, we could improve patient outcomes enormously by paying for everyone to receive basic dental care, today.