12 ms·
The Trouble with 5G
- ofou 4y agoGood studies on 5G-human health long term exposure?
- 0xbadc0de5 4y agoThe Signal Path has done a really good job breaking this down - skip to 3:00 if you want to avoid the preamble. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R0xwyVlqsRo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R0xwyVlqsRo
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoNo, that was not good at all. He’s not talking about any studies, only his theories, which only talk about non-ionizing radiation. There’s already plenty of studies that show there’s reactive oxygen species created in the skin from millimeter wave technology. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1438463917308143 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S14384...
- 0xbadc0de5 4y agoThe "studies" of the type you link to typically require exposures of many orders of magnitude higher power than what is produced by a phone in order to observe any effect. This is the crux of Shahriar's analogy of not worrying about getting a sunburn in a dark room. > He’s not talking about any studies, only his theories, which only talk about non-ionizing radiation. mmWave, by definition, is non-ionizing radiation. To talk about ionizing effects of mmWave is to fundamentally misunderstand the topic being discussed. And as a scientist specializing in 5G and mmWave technology at Bell Labs, I think he's more than qualified to have an informed opinion on this topic.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoThere are other ways for EMFs to affect a biological system besides the ionizing radiation. One of them is by disrupting voltage gated ion channels.
- 0xbadc0de5 4y agoAt the mmWave power levels used in mobile handsets, the RF power is insufficient to penetrate the human body to any significant degree. Even airport mmWave security scanners can barely scan through clothing - and they operate at much higher power.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoYou are making several assumption which have not been scientifically studies, which is the only point I am making. mmWaves do penetrate the skin and the eyes, that much we know. What effect it has on the body system as a whole we do not. You can make all the assumptions you want but until they are studied they are just assumptions. And I do not mind walking through a mmWave security scanners for less than 10 seconds. But would you want to stand in that for eight hours a day while you were at work or home sleeping? And again and again I have to point out that saying it is nonionzing radiation is pointless if there is another method by which it make disrupt biological systems, as in triggering voltage gated ion channels.
- gus_massa 4y agoAs far as we know, non ionizing radiation is safe for humans, if the intensity is not too high. * if the intensity is not too high Don't put your head inside a microwave. Don't hug the transmisor of a antena that broadcast tv or radio. ... * non ionizing radiation Gamma rays, X rays and some UV rays are dangerous. Try to avoid them and keep a low dose for important medical treatments. Use solar protection to block UV rays.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoAre you kidding? Didn’t you even see the video? You people think that there’s all the studies out there saying it’s safe and if there aren’t any good quality studies saying it’s safe. You have no grounds to see what you did.
- gus_massa 4y agoFrom the transcription: > Now, as I said, there’s no reason to think that five G is harmful. Indeed, there’s good reason to think it’s not [harmful], because millimeter waves have been used in medicine for a long time and for all we know they only enter the upper skin layers. Are you afraid of red leds? Each photons of a red les has like 1000x the energy of a photon of 5G. Most of the damage is caused by the energy of each photon, so red photons are more dangerous. Also, a red led against your skin has more power than a 5G antena far away. You can get hurt when there are really a lot of photons, but both have very low power to be dangerous. And a normal light lamp has even more power and higher energy photons, and they are safe. And sunlight has even more power and higher energy photons, and it's safe if you filter UV-B rays that are the ones with more energy.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoSince a red LED has a lower wave length then even 4G, by definition it has less power. I don’t know what you’re talking about here at all. And neither of us can say it safe because as she pointed out there are enough studently to conclude that it’s safe.
- Sin2x 4y agohttps://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2021/690012/EPRS_STU(2021)690012_EN.pdf https://www.europarl.europa.eu/RegData/etudes/STUD/2021/6900... The review shows: 1) 5G lower frequencies (700 and 3 600 MHz): a) limited evidence of carcinogenicity in epidemiological studies; b) sufficient evidence of carcinogenicity in experimental bioassays; c) sufficient evidence ofreproductive/developmental adverse effects in humans; d) sufficient evidence of reproductive/ developmental adverse effects in experimental animals; 2) 5G higher frequencies (24.25-27.5 GHz): the systematic review found no adequate studies either in humans or in experimental animals. Conclusions: 1) cancer: FR1 (450 to 6 000 MHz): EMF are probably carcinogenic for humans, in particular related to gliomas and acoustic neuromas; FR2 (24 to 100 GHz): no adequate studies were performed on the higher frequencies; 2) reproductive developmental effects: FR1 (450 to 6 000 MHz): these frequencies clearly affect male fertility and possibly female fertility too. They may have possible adverse effects on the development of embryos, foetuses and newborns; FR2 (24 to 100 GHz): no adequate studies were performed on non-thermal effects of the higher frequencies.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ac29 4y ago> cancer: FR1 (450 to 6 000 MHz): EMF are probably carcinogenic for humans, in particular related to gliomas and acoustic neuromas I looked into their data for glioma (see page 51, table 4). They used 8 total studies. 3 studies showed glioma to be more likely in mobile phone users, 2 showed no difference, and 3 showed glioma less likely in mobile phone users. From this they concluded "probably carcinogenic for humans, in particular related to gliomas"? This is a long paper and I didnt read it all, but I'm not sure I see how that conclusion is supported.
- Sin2x 4y agoI think you misinterpret the words. Equivocal means that it's unclear from the study if there's a causal association while negative means no association was found, not that EMF reduced incidence of gliomas. Also, an important quote in the description following that table: "The association of glioma and acoustic neuroma is stronger among long-term heavy users of mobile phones, which is also the most extensively investigated exposure source, and in some cases the onset of tumours was related to the side on which the device was handled."
- jay_kyburz 4y agoDon't we also need to confirm that long term exposure is also safe for everything else in our ecology? Soil Bacteria, Insect populations, and all the other plants and animals we depend on?
- whyoh 4y agoLong term is difficult, because it's a relatively new thing. Even 4G and 3G haven't been around very long. So we don't really know, but there are legit concerns about its safety: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/we-have-no-reason-to-believe-5g-is-safe/ https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/observations/we-have-no... https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31991167/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31991167/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7727890/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7727890/
- guerby 4y agoThe weather/5G frequency use conflict reminds me of the FAA 5G filter fiasco 8 monthes ago: FAA Shows ‘Sample NOTAMs’ for Possible 5G Restrictions https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29694085 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29694085 My comment at the time https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29696273 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29696273 This is all ridiculous, there's still a 200 MHz band guard between the FAA band and the 5G proposed band. Here is what a $1 ESP wifi dongle has to follow: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11 "The mask requires the signal to be attenuated a minimum of 20 dB from its peak amplitude at ±11 MHz from the center frequency" So 2 dB/MHz filter. I let you do the math. FAA is just ridiculous here if they let old junk radio hardware handle safety landings for airplanes, but well after 737 max what do you expect... And obviously this was in line with reality, FAA finally admitted it didn't do its job of preventing crap filters to be kept in planes for decades: https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-statements-5g https://www.faa.gov/newsroom/faa-statements-5g Airlines and other operators of aircraft equipped with the affected radio altimeters must install filters or other enhancements as soon as possible." Now I haven't looked in details yet on this new frequency use conflict and Sabine mentionned a scientific study that seemed legit. One thing is different: around 20 GHz there's lots of frequencies available (vs 5GHz) so we could have larger guard band without significant impact.
- mlyle 4y agoThe technical analysis you're putting out here is a bit of a canard. Yes, better filters help, but radars are really, really picky. After all, there's an inverse fourth power relationship between return strength and distance. So we have our doppler weather radar transmitting at 450kW, traveling out a big distance to a storm (inverse square), and reflecting at very low efficiency, and traveling back (inverse square). Compare to a base station putting out 40W that's closer and just subject to inverse square law. It can easily be 10 orders of magnitude stronger. You need pretty good filtering for this. > One thing is different: around 20 GHz there's lots of frequencies available (vs 5GHz) so we could have larger guard band without significant impact. You need a much larger guard band. It's easy to make a 1MHz wide filter at 10MHz, and really hard at 100000MHz. Another important thing: parasitics start to matter a whole lot, too. You can have a filter that sharply rolls off around your fundamental, but then above the resonant frequencies of your passives/filter elements become transmissive again. It's pretty hard to keep 20GHz out of a receiver that was designed for a lower frequency before 20GHz was a major concern.
- Beltiras 4y agoSabine has been so rock solid on everything I've seen from her that I tend to take her seriously.
- Animats 4y agoThe real problem with 5G is that it only has a few use cases. The big one is stadiums. Tens of thousands of people watching the game on their cell phones, each needing an independent video-bandwidth channel. (Anybody ever consider WiFi multicast for that? Most of them are watching the same stream, after all.) To get all that bandwidth in one place is the use case for line of sight millimeter microwave with large numbers of small base stations. The first places to get 5G base stations were stadiums. After that, it tails off. Convention centers. Busy downtown intersections. Of course China is ahead in this. They need it. China has ten cities with more people than New York. Most of the US has nowhere near the population density of coastal China. Not much of a use case for short range millimeter microwave.
- secondcoming 4y agoI've replaced fibre internet with 5G. It's great, short duration contracts with 500Mps speeds (I even got 1Gbps at one point while on holiday), and I can take it anywhere
- Dig1t 4y agoDo you play video games at all? I imagine the latency is much worse on 5G vs fiber. Have you noticed that?
- yardstick 4y agoJust did a speedtest.net run on my 5G link- 14ms ping, 1ms jitter, 500Mbit/s downlink. It’s pretty good.
- secondcoming 4y agoIt’s definitely worse, you’re not going to get single digit pings. That said, I used play Battlefield a fair bit on it and it was largely fine but crapped out occasionally.
- abdullahkhalids 4y agoWhen my wifi breaks while playing Dota 2, I quickly USB tether my phone and use my mobile internet to continue playing the same game. Even with 3G connections, I only get an additional 10-15 ms of latency.
- nayuki 4y agoThe text transcript could be improved: > The fourth Generation of wireless networks, four G for short, is now being extended to five G, and six G is in planning. Spelling out "four G" does not improve clarity. The sentence should be: The fourth generation of wireless networks, 4G for short, is now being extended to 5G, and 6G is in planning. > GigaHertz ... Giga Hertz Must be written as gigahertz. > four hundred Mega Hertz Should be written as 400 MHz; using number words doesn't improve clarity. Also, the factual content could be improved in a few places: > If you want to transfer more information through a channel with a fixed noise-level, you have to increase either the bandwidth or the power. There's also beamforming and MIMO. > If you took all the water in the atmosphere and put it on the ground you’d get about 2.5 cm. The clouds alone merely make a tenth of a millimeter. To make the comparison easier, it should be written as 25.0 mm and 0.1 mm. Ironically, she linked to an original video that indeed uses millimetres. > The European Commission has agreed on –42 decibel watts for 5G base stations. The FCC in the US set a limit at –20 decibel watt. This is a logarithmic scale, so this is more than 30 orders of magnitude above the limit the meteorologists ask for. No, it's 3 orders of magnitude, or 1000×.
- johnklos 4y agoI suppose it's a sign of how good her articles and videos are that the only stuff you can find that're wrong are details. In the spirit of being pedantic (don't take too seriously): "There's also beamforming and MIMO" No. Beamforming attempts to increase apparent power by changing parameters. One could just as easily say "moving sender and recipient closer". MIMO is also manipulation of sending and receiving antennae, and therefore irrelevant to the discussion about transmitting through a channel with a fixed noise level. She did make a mistake about the number of orders of magnitude, though.
- xphos 4y agoYeah 200MHz band guard is a massive guard. You can fit all of the FM band 4-5 times in that range. Also the resonate frequency water has a high attenuation factor so radio waves wouldn't be used there because they transferred a huge portion of there power to heat vibration water. As for use cases it's a faster network in latency terms. There might be fewer use cases for it now but there were no use cases for WiFi before wifi exist. Once that infrastructure is built people will use it. By definition it's impossible to get a latency of less than 10ms on a large portion of LTE networks. If you have a sensor that requires a response that fast you simply won't use LTE because it's not possible to meet those mission requirements. 5G also has that beam forming whose goal is reduce congestion and solve the penetration issues but that is still being proven
- charles_kaw 4y ago> There might be fewer use cases for it now There are massive use cases for it, but not at the people level. Low latency tasks such as edge AI classification, IOT interaction, and game streaming are all currently limited to WiFi only. > Once that infrastructure is built people will use it. This is a fallacy.
- xphos 4y agoI would argue that that statement is true because it's talking about 5G whose features vastly outcompete LTE in many areas. I suppose there is a chance people won't use 5G but I think it's really unlikely considering the standards already been adopted and being used by many big name players. All of this was to say that 5G has applications even if they might not appear to the OP and that it's only going to be used more once people can actually access 5G technology. It's still in the early stages even in areas which claim that are on 5G for the most part its 5G NSA mode where the backing core network is all LTE still. I also feel as though OP was really talking down 5G trying to bring nonsensical technically problems and unproven medical problems that have no evidence. You yourself pointed out several applications but your quoting the very advantage I was talking about which was latency. Which we both agree is extremely beneficial but the over arching point is that we don't know all the things that will benefit from 5G because we have not observed them and while IoT, AI, and streaming will absolutely benefit the benefit does not end there. There absolutely will be more areas that benefit which is what I'm trying to communicate
- zzzeek 4y agothis seems to be a well written and rational article and it's really too bad that a thing like "5G" is so prone to mass culture conspiracy hysteria, that it's impossible to have a discussion about concerns like these without everyone retreating to "Their corners" - which snuffs out the "middle" where things like, "hey 5G might give us problems with weather forecasts, how do we work that out"?. I can just see the "debunking" blog posts already "debunking" things like "5G will ruin the weather!" or some idiocy.
- dane-pgp 4y ago> it's impossible to have a discussion about concerns like these without everyone retreating to "Their corners" Which means that not only do advanced economies fail to reap the full benefit of the technologies they develop (because people resist them for wrong reasons), but also the people in those societies get harmed by flaws in the technology that could have been addressed if a proper open conversation were possible. This means that conspiracy theories and misinformation ends up doing double damage, making it the ideal weapon of authoritarian regimes which have more control over their country's media and less of a technological advantage (so holding back technology in other countries helps them close the gap). I'll leave it as an exercise to the reader to imagine how this might apply to the online discourse around Covid and vaccines, but I'll give a clue about which country might have the most to gain from misinformation about both that topic and about 5G technology: https://www.nbcnews.com/business/consumer/factory-lies-russia-s-disinformation-playbook-exposed-n910316 https://www.nbcnews.com/business/consumer/factory-lies-russi...
- tolmasky 4y agoIs 5G good for super-short distances that you can’t for whatever reason use a cable for? Imagine needing to go through a solid wall, (of wood and drywall), and only 2 to 5 inches thick, then Ethernet on either side of that. Would 5G be the ideal way to not drop too much in speed, or is there something better for that sort of scenario?
- kriro 4y agoI see two things that are valuable in 5G. Number is campus networks (basically run your own cell network company wide) which makes sense in some use cases (production plant with a lot of IoT devices) and number two is the (potential) low latency. I feel both could be solved by different technologies but a cell based approach isn't a horrible idea.
- Lammy 4y agoThe trouble with 5G is that it will be the final nail in the coffin of location privacy, assuming most people carry their phone with them at most times. LTE is already very "good" at this, but 5G brings centimeter-precision. https://www.ericsson.com/en/blog/2020/12/5g-positioning--what-you-need-to-know https://www.ericsson.com/en/blog/2020/12/5g-positioning--wha... sez — “The arrival of 5G delivers new enhanced parameters for positioning accuracy down to the meter, decimeter and centimeter.” “Positioning of users and devices across general indoor environments, such as offices, shops, logistics, etc., was a focus area of 3GPP Release 16.” https://venturebeat.com/mobile/sk-telecom-will-use-5g-to-build-centimeter-level-accurate-city-maps/ https://venturebeat.com/mobile/sk-telecom-will-use-5g-to-bui... sez — “While current [2019] smartphones can under some circumstances send and receive location data with 3-foot accuracy, it takes an external GNSS receiver to access location services with centimeter-level accuracy.” https://www.fastcompany.com/90314058/5g-means-youll-have-to-say-goodbye-to-your-location-privacy https://www.fastcompany.com/90314058/5g-means-youll-have-to-... sez — “[5G network positioning] data can also enable advertisers and data brokers to see the exact routes you take each day and even which buildings you go into. And anyone with access to your mobile network’s cell tower data will now be able to track your movements in real time.”
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoWhich 5G does these are talking about? The sub 6GHz 5G aka relabeled LTE or the mmWave/UWB 5G? Because the UWB does not really penetrate anything, so it might be working good in lab, but useless in practice.
- charles_kaw 4y agoIt's not in the general, constant sense that you have to worry about, but rather in specific applications. When you're out in public, "they" will have 3-meter-accuracy, more than enough. But when you're in stores, and malls, and other venues where UWB is set up, then that's where real problems begin. They'll be able to track which advertisements you linger around, and which sections you visit. It's going to be a whole new category of passive location tracking.
- mikotodomo 4y agoYeah it could hamper weather predictions, but it also enables us to receive emergency notifications in the first place!
- jc_811 4y agoI have T-mobile in the Pacific Northwest and noticed very poor service with countless dead spots over the past few years. I got a tip from a friend last month to try disabling 5G and use LTE instead. It’s cleared up 90+% of the issues I was experiencing. 5G to me is a marketing joke which made my reception significantly worse
- aftbit 4y agoI remember doing the same thing (minus one) during the 4G/LTE transition. I forced 3G for several years for better battery life and more reliable signal.
- wildzzz 4y agoSome aspects of 5G do improve normal cell bandwidth which for internet, basically improves reception. Other aspects of 5G really only make a difference when you are right nearby an antenna, like walking down a city street. The problem is that 5G isn't rolled out everywhere and your phone might try to connect to a 5G antenna when a 4G antenna is much closer and would provide a more robust connection. I rarely see more than 3/5 bars when on 5G but can get much better reception wherever when only using 4G. Only exception was a recent road trip on I-95, there was near constant full 5G coverage.
- darksaints 4y agoThat's because T-Mobile has been slow to deploy 5g in the PNW. Still one of the slowest markets to deploy, but it is getting better over time.
- snthd 4y agoCan water vapor be measured using the 5G background noise as a radiation source (akin to passive radar[0])? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_radar https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Passive_radar
- rcarmo 4y agoFunny, only today I tweeted these parody lyrics to “Welcome to 5G Networks” (a parody of a parody linked in https://twitter.com/rcarmo/status/1566402880504041472?s=21&t=rxwMmXIxYm5kLtAI-auz5g https://twitter.com/rcarmo/status/1566402880504041472?s=21&t...): Welcome to 5G networks, please enjoy your stay Endless discussions about the state of play We’ve got endless features, some good, some weird And lots of little quirky bugs that we’ve engineered Welcome to 5G networks, log on and take a chance You can have your phone roam or do the coverage dance Your radio is abysmal, It’s… not optimized But throw it up on 3GPP and we’ll call it standardized Welcome to 5G networks, you’ll never feel alone Debug chinese radios or inspect packets whole Ericsson? Nokia? Which one do I choose? Just pick a third party that has the least SKUs Welcome to 5G networks, be sure to run your fiber Duplicate an incumbent network at the whim of the regulator We’ve got timelines and roadmaps and radio test plans So you can bill for ringtones nobody wants Edit: why the downvotes?
- psd1 4y ago> why the downvotes? That gets an instant downvote
- yodsanklai 4y agoA trouble with 5G that nobody has mentioned in the comments is that we'll be redeploying hundred of millions of new devices, which has a significant cost on the environment for very little benefits.
- dane-pgp 4y agoHow do those costs and benefits compare to something like, say, coffee? In general, how should society decide whether a technology/product/service has too big an environmental cost?
- abdullahkhalids 4y agoThe sober answer is that if you are living a 'regular' middle-class life in the developed world, your C02 emissions are likely far far above sustainable thresholds as set by the UN. As such buying a new phone before the old one has completely died out is too big of an environmental cost.
- yodsanklai 4y agoGood question, ideally we'd integrate environmental cost in prices, and the market would determine if it's worth or not, but currently not the case. Also I think the ratio marginal_benefit/environmenal_cost for 5G is probably one of the lowest in history. If you think about it, it's almost caricatural.
- UncleEntity 4y agoI think people mention that for literally every single article which involves the physical world…and plenty that don’t.
- ksec 4y agoI can't believe what I just read from Sabine. But then if she dont gets it. No wonder why 99% of HN still don't get 5G. Like I said in my HN bubbles post [1], which had lots of upvote but the only disagreement was on 5G. 5G isn't mmWave. mmWave isn't REAL 5G. This is the most common misconception on the internet inclusive but not limited to HN. AFAIK, till late 2021, no county other than USA has used or plan to use mmWave for their mobile network. The only usage outside of USA are for residential Wireless Internet. And those were on trial only. Even the biggest proponent of mmWave, Verizon are backing off mmWave expansion. 5G has lots of things other than mmWave. As a matter of fact mmWave isn't even 1% of the initial 5G ( 3GPP R15 ) spec. And the same goes to 6G, which is NOT about higher frequency either. Another misconception is you need higher frequency for more bandwidth. Which is true in Shannon's law [2]. But we dont need more maximum bandwidth, we need higher capacity, or same bandwidth in ( e.g 1Gbps ) available to more people at the same time. i.e Network Capacity. And that, is what 5G ( Massive MIMO ) and 6G ( Distributed MIMO ) is about. ( Along with dozens of other things ) [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32635268 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32635268 [2] I still remember my professor told me the exact same thing in the 90s when I was doing work on 3G. How we will soon reach those limit. So for people who has not worked in the Wireless / Mobile industry space. A lot of what we take for granted today were essentially miracle or black magic not that long ago.
- fomine3 4y agommWave is also deployed at least here in Japan since 2020. I have Galaxy Z Fold3 with mmWave (though I don't need), it seems that only US/JP models have mmWave antenna. It's natural to misunderstood as it's only in the US since iPhone supports mmWave only for the US IIRC. Where I could test it is only on mobile phone shop becaues I'm on local, and I got 2Gbps. No use case for now.
- FollowingTheDao 4y agoIf what you’re saying is true then my meter should not be picking up any signals above 4 GHz correct? So why is my meter picking up signals up to 40 GHz from the towers in my small tourist town?
- 4y ago
- mey 4y agoFor those of you that have migrated to 5G, have you found it useful? Do you feel bandwidth limited by 4G? Do you run into oversubscribed areas where you don't also have WiFi as an alternative? My biggest hurdle, has always been access in remote areas, not bandwidth.
- dddddddd111 4y ago
- notananthem 4y agoPosts like this remind me most of HN just likes to hear itself talk. Health conspiracy, incorrect information, linking posts to incorrect information...
- temp0826 4y agoThere's no trouble, just purchase one of my patented tin foil helmets to prevent the transmitter that was installed during your covid vaccination to prevent it from reporting your thoughts to The Agency
- walterbell 4y agoApple's USA iPhone SE3 does not have mmWave radio/antenna support. Previously, all USA 5G-enabled iPhones included support for mmWave.
- irthomasthomas 4y agoThis post was near the top of page one, a few minutes ago, now it's page 3 or 4. If you think this article, by a renowned scientist is wrong, or misinformation then the way to deal with that is to address it and explain why. Not bury it.