3 ms·
The one thing Linux seems to lack is good tried and tested sandboxing of untrusted applications. And of course an ecosystem of developers (e.g. why I can't run
by amelius 4y ago
The one thing Linux seems to lack is good tried and tested sandboxing of untrusted applications. And of course an ecosystem of developers (e.g. why I can't run my bank app on Linux).
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoThe traditional way to bootstrap this is to support existing apps. Which in theory for Android is easy -- getting Android apps to run on Linux is what they already do. But then they weaponize inconvenience. You can run the app, but if you want Google Play, they stick you with their terms. SafetyNet blah blah. If you don't, the bank owns the copyright on the bank app so third party devs can't give ordinary users a convenient legal way to install it. So third party alternatives get friction on purpose and can't gain users. And without users people don't develop native apps.
- pjmlp 4y agoAndroid apps have no notion Linux even exists, it isn't exposed to userspace as public API.
- AnthonyMouse 4y agoThe Android runtime has a notion that Linux exists and in fact runs on Linux. It doesn't take something like Wine to do it. Compare what it would take to get iOS apps to run on a Linux phone.
- pjmlp 4y agoIndeed, and someday might be using Zirkon instead of Linux. Blackberry, Jolla and several other Linux + Android attempts have proven that being easy isn't enough.
- fezfight 4y agoAs usual, the answer to 'why not Linux' is market share. Linux has numerous ways to sandbox applications. What it doesn't have is an advertising campaign promoting it on the desktop/phones. So it has a small number of users in those areas. Which means companies that dont care about freedom won't support it. And thus: banking programs dont run on the pinephone yet. You can, of course, access your bank from a browser.
- dane-pgp 4y ago> You can, of course, access your bank from a browser. For now. Do you think the W3C would resist if banks tried to standardise a way for sites to determine if you are running with Secure Boot enabled? This would be part of a system to prevent browsers from spoofing their user agent string / version number. They ignored the protests of those opposed to DRM, and I can't imagine there being as much objection to banks trying to protect users from browser vulnerabilities and kernel-level keyloggers. Of course some Free Software advocates would again "cry wolf", predicting that banks would start to block requests from "unapproved" OSes, but those claims would be dismissed as scaremongering, right up until it started happening (and the wolf started eating their sheep).
- fezfight 4y agoI even think MBNA recently started blocking Firefox. It's a dark time for us all.