3 ms·
The trick is that heat pumps are using energy to move heat. Let's make an example calculation: When heating your house to burn coal, you release 1 Joule when b
by crote 4y ago
The trick is that heat pumps are using energy to move heat. Let's make an example calculation:
When heating your house to burn coal, you release 1 Joule when burning the coal. It's a small plant, so it is not very efficient. You probably get 0.85 J of heating out of it.
If we instead burn coal in a large-scale modern power plant, we release the same 1 Joule, but capture 0.95 J of it in electricity. Let's say we lose 10% transporting it to your home, leaving 0.855 J remaining. Now, we use that energy to move heat from outside into our home, at an efficiency of about 300% - so for every joule we consume, we move 3 joules of energy. This means our house is heated with 2.565 J. But the energy the heat pump consumes doesn't disappear - it becomes heat too. So your house gets a total of 3.42 J hotter!
So 1 J of coal gets you either 0.85 J of heat by burning it directly, or 3.42 J of heat by burning it in a power plant and using a heat pump. And of course don't forget that for climate reasons it is trivial to replace that power plant with a solar farm or wind turbine.
The worst-case scenario for a heat pump is that it is exactly as efficient as burning stuff directly. But in virtually all cases, it is way better.
- aftbit 4y agoPretty good assessment, except I think your figure for heat efficiency of power generation is way off. I would expect to convert around 30-40% of the heat energy to electricity.
- hedora 4y ago95%+ efficient coal boilers have existed since the '90s.
- aftbit 4y agoThis is fuel to electricity efficiency? That seems unlikely to me, both based on sources[1][2], and the thermodynamics of the Carnot equation. A Carnot cycle heat engine (which is most efficient possible AIUI) has a maximum efficiency of 1 - Tc/Th. Given a Tc of 300K (STP-ish), achieving an efficiency of 0.95 would require a Th of 6000K, well above the melting point of steel (only around 1800K). 1: https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=44436 https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=44436 2: https://www.energy.gov/fecm/science-innovation/office-clean-coal-and-carbon-management/advanced-energy-systems/transformative https://www.energy.gov/fecm/science-innovation/office-clean-...