10 ms·
The super-rich ‘preppers’ planning to save themselves
- nomdep 4y ago*Everyone* plan to save themselves
- mod 4y agoIMO it's the number one responsibility of lifeforms. Survive. And the only other thing is reproduce. The rest we just made up.
- tsimionescu 4y agoBack here in the real world, not some nihilistic invented one, thousands of people risk their lives to save strangers after a disaster. We have entire careers dedicated to it (firefighting, mountain rescue and such). We also know regular people just do this spontaneously, especially after catastrophes - look at the 9/11 first responders, look at efforts after an earthquake or tsunami. Far from "everyone fends for themselves", most disasters tend to bring people together, at least in the immediate aftermath.
- hownottowrite 4y agoMore reasons for a 90% top marginal tax rate
- nivenkos 4y agoTax wealth, not income.
- choko 4y agoTax transactions, not income or wealth.
- pavlov 4y agoMore specifically, tax inheritances. Dynasties are detrimental.
- oifjsidjf 4y agoI wonder what you will say when you will be forced to pay 90% tax on all of the inheritance. Want to keep your parents house? Pay 90% of it's value to the government or the government takes it. Parents will do anything for the children to have a better life, this is a basic human drive that you cannot go against.
- neverminder 4y agoProgressive taxes. Heavily tax those who inherit millions and billions.
- awinder 4y agoIn a lot of ways, the extreme wealthy providing that better life deprives the majority of providing their kids a better life. The state could fund things that meaningfully improve the lives of many kids at the expensive of generational wealth transfer for a few. Conceivably, the kids of extreme wealthy would still have been given a massive leg up — it’s just that they would have to contribute (or eat a tax, realistically they’re still probably able to do nothing in many cases). Also it’s entirely possible to set a floor before a tax kicks in to allow some token transfer of wealth, but yeah there’s a huge difference between a moderate transfer of wealth like a (average) home and rebasing millions and millions of asset wealth, a fleet of homes, etc.
- ben_w 4y ago> I wonder what you will say when you will be forced to pay 90% tax on all of the inheritance. Wouldn’t that be paid by the estate between the death of the deceased and the inheritor getting the assets? > Want to keep your parents house? Pay 90% of it's value to the government or the government takes it. My experience in the UK is the opposite problem exists in reality — the UK has inheritance tax, which my parents’ assets seem to have totally avoided, because my dad looked at the rules at made sure his assets were under the threshold by (1) giving my siblings and I a lot of gifts well before he died, and (2) turns out physical items such as the antiques (not many) and the stamp collection (how much!?!) is the kind of thing the government value (or valued past tense, IANAL) in aggregate as £1. The cunning ploy of giving away money is, practically speaking, quite difficult to solve.
- koheripbal 4y agoThat has been tried and it results in wealth exodus. France reversed that suicidal policy within one year.
- refurb 4y agoMake the upper half pay for the lower half, so hike taxes on anyone making more than $68,000USD (US household median income). Once you hit double the median income (~top 10%) you should be paying >50% in total tax rate. More than 4x median income ($275,000) should be paying 67% of income in taxes. We could fund everything with that kind of revenue.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoYou imagine the state could fund everything with that but it won't because we don't have the kind of voters who vote for that kind of tax policy in the first place. Or even reasonable tax policies that are more progressive than what the US has now. Thank goodness, because even the most progressive countries in the EU realize taxation at that level would be incredibly counter-productive.
- refurb 4y agoThose aren’t far off from welfare-heavy EU rates. 40% marginal rate starting at 50,000GBP in the UK. The EU can afford high public spending because it has high taxes, including on the middle class.
- leetcrew 4y agotax land and nonrenewable resources, not wealth.
- markx2 4y agoThe late great Irish comedian Dave Allen had a sketch on his TV show in the late 70's/early 80's. IIRC: He is shown in a dimly lit bunker fiddling with his radio, hearing static but other sounds. Screen fades. Comes back and he has stubble, scene repeats but there is more static. Screen fades. In the last scene he has a full beard and only static comes from the radio. You see him climbing out of his bunker to a scene of nuclear devastation - and he starts shouting "We won! We won!" For these people who want to save themselves, what on earth do they expect to find after 'the event'? How will they fuel their planes, spend their money, how will they have a future? I'm not saying that your average prepper is wrong, far from it, but the people in this article are on a very different level.
- atoav 4y agoThis. I get a similar feeling when the very people who got nearly mad when they were unable to go to the barber for a few weeks due to an global pandemic suddenly call for a civil war. It is just very clear that they completely lack the imagination how it would actually feel to have the gas running out, no food in the stores and everything you worked for threatened (not to speak of your bare life). In that situation you can prep all you want, but what if your wisdom teeth start acting up? What if you suddenly require medication, that you cannot even know of, because you decided fighting alone is better than actually getting to know the people in your community? The thing with prepping is that the energy you put into one-upping your neighbours should maybe just be put into fizing the issues you might be bracing against.
- code_duck 4y ago> What if you suddenly require medication Or how about people who already require medication? With type 1 diabetes, I'd die horribly within a week without a steady supply of insulin - possibly as little as 2 days. The "let's disrupt society and have a civil war because -tyranny-!!" folks don't seem particularly concerned about issues like that.
- msandford 4y agoThere are really several levels of concern as far as I can tell. 1. Temporary disruptions (short term) 2. Temporary disruptions (drawn out) 3. The World Has Changed 1 is really about everyone hoarding TP, "the wheat runs out" between $whenever and the next harvest, etc. It's annoying, but nobody really dies. Just a lot of discomfort. 2 is more when you have to do a cold start of a national grid after a REAL blackout. No electricity for weeks or months. Maybe some deaths, but in the end society basically stays running even though a big thing happens. 3 is a nuclear war, an air-transmissible disease with a 30% fatality rate, etc. The event will eventually end but the world has definitely changed. Lots of people are prepared for 1, and "the preppers" that folks like to make fun of are in pretty good shape for 2. Almost nobody is prepared for 3 and to try and be prepared for it in a way other than building a self-sustaining community seems like a fool's errand.
- anonymous_sorry 4y agoThese clueless sociopaths trying to figure out how to construct their desperate, grim little dictatorships in the absence of the rules-based system they currently depend on for their wealth. It's almost funny.
- koheripbal 4y agoIt's funny that they want their kids to live? Most of these people have families that they are trying to shelter.
- ameister14 4y agoI think it's more about how they want to maintain a level of extreme power disparity beyond the point where the sources of their power are completely gone. In the article, they dismiss more community oriented ways of living which would actually shelter their families from an inevitable rebellion in these situations in favor of sci fi technical solutions like obedience collars.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoPerhaps preparing for a post-apocalyptic world that they envision would be better served by improving your skills with a shovel, not a Glock.
- oswald42 4y agoThese options are not mutually exclusive as you imply. And certainly a guy with a Glock will be very happy if you only optimise for the shovel route.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoAs you point out though he's likely to have his hands full dealing with the other guys with Glocks. I suppose when they all run out of bullets it's shovel time for everyone.
- episode0x01 4y agoReminds me of Cory Doctorow's last story in Radicalized: "Masque of the Red Death". summary from Wikipedia: A wealthy financier builds and manages a doomsday vault, designed to withstand societal collapse. Interesting story, as are the others in that collection.
- tetris11 4y agohttps://archive.org/download/Cory_Doctorow_Podcast_332/Cory_Doctorow_Podcast_332_-_The_Masque_of_the_Red_Death.mp3 https://archive.org/download/Cory_Doctorow_Podcast_332/Cory_...
- immigrantheart 4y ago> The way to get your guards to exhibit loyalty in the future was to treat them like friends right now, I explained How can you be ultra naive and give talks and publish an article? No wonder the billionairres rolled their eyes. Not defending the billionaires here in case HN hippies make angry noises.
- clydethefrog 4y agoAt the end of the article the author, Douglas Rushkoff, realises they didn't ask him specifically for legit advice but rather performed a philosophical and critical evaluation of their justifications for their (selfish) future safety plans. Douglas is a pretty successful media theorist - he coined the terms viral media, digital native, and social currency. I have a theory they probably all asked "great thinkers" [0] for their opinion. [0] It wouldn't surprised me if they used some thought leader analysis, because Rushkoff is pretty high on that list. https://arxiv.org/abs/1308.1160 https://arxiv.org/abs/1308.1160
- bsenftner 4y agoDouglas Rushkoff concludes the article implying his clients might be on the cusp of realizing if anyone is in a position to slow, halt, and/or reverse the forces leading to The Event it is those clients asking him questions.
- yallneedtogetit 4y agoSounds like our boy Douglas is having himself some delusions of grandeur.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoWhich is odd. Who thinks someone who has a couple or few hundred million from Silicon Valley-type startups and investments has any more pull than say, Madonna? Or a group from Hollywood?
- choko 4y agoThe author chides the rich preppers for their cynicism, then spews lines like: "Never before have our society’s most powerful players assumed that the primary impact of their own conquests would be to render the world itself unliveable for everyone else" I can't help but roll my eyes. This is a very marxist take on how wealth is generated and I can't take this author at all seriously. I shouldn't have to say this, but the current state of affairs is not primarily due to rich people and is far more complicated. They display a third-grade level of it economics and are even more cynical than the people he chides. They also use the "all men" dog whistle at the start of the article. The fact that the group is all male has no bearing on the rest of the story and I suspect was inserted to create a link between this type of behavior and men. When will this type of "journalism" die out? It has become tiresome and a primary reason I don't support rags like the guardian.
- igorkraw 4y agoWhat is the current state of affairs due to if not the conquests of societies most powerful players, who, by definition, are powerful because they can exert power to make shit happen? In your post, you imply marxist takes, imply "all men" being a dog whistle (maybe it just was all men?) and dismiss a very highly regarded acadamic of hacing a "third grade level of IT economics", but present very little arguments for any of these
- SyzygistSix 4y agoIt doesn't sound to me like the people in this group necessarily have much influence on environmental practices and the industries involved or on geopolitics. And one can't assume other people of similar levels of wealth think similarly. Or even what the men involved in this meeting actually think. The entire article is assumptions built upon assumptions, with specious accusations and labeling throughout. It is sad to see much of the same in the comments.
- choko 4y agoFurther, I find myself questioning whether this meeting even happened. This reads like scenario invented so the author could get paid for a "think" piece.
- jmyeet 4y agoDomsday prepping is a really interesting pyschological phenomenon. First, this seems to be way more common in the US than other countries. Second, there seems to be a strong correlation between preppers and certain politics (eg pro guns, anti government). Third, there are a lot of people who have imagined victimhood as a core part of their identity (eg [1][2]). So this brings up to a subset of these: the rich prepper. For me, rich people are the biggest reason why doomsday prepping is a complete waste of time because rich people (who have disproportionate power in politics) have the most to lose. So why would rich people be preppers? To me it shows the power of the underlying psychology (eg the persecution aesthetic). [1]: https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-white-victimhood-fuels-republican-politics/ https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/how-white-victimhood-fu... [2]: https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/08/the-evangelical-persecution-complex/375506/ https://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2014/08/the-eva...
- harvey9 4y agoIndividual prepping might be more common in the USA but Sweden has a big public bunker programme which is being expanded at present.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoSee the sibling comment I just posted. The philosophy behind these kinds of efforts is polar opposite of "preppers" in the US. Community driven and focused on social cohesion and working together instead of the "my family/religion/self above all else"
- seanp2k2 4y agoWe’ve had a preview of how this would play out with COVID — many idiots dying needless deaths because they were so adamant about being selfish, refusing to take even the most basic of precautions, and people who did care about others also dying needless deaths due to the selfishness of the first group.
- spaghettiToy 4y ago
- goethes_kind 4y agoThese same people are the ones who end up jumping off a bridge, because their net worth plummeted several billions, even though they would still be millionaires. Moreover most of their lives revolves around their status. They would not survive a civilization collapse, mentally. They would still lose everything that gives them meaning and purpose.
- bitlax 4y agoThis is a "beautiful women must also stupid" fallacy. These people are much better equipped to withstand a societal collapse than someone like yourself and your family, who might be the victim of a wandering horde or be subsumed into one.
- ngetchell 4y agoWhat value would a billionaire provide? Could they work a field for a day? Work with their hands to make things? They seem too pampered to survive. Some might not even know how to iron a shirt.
- mod 4y agoDid any of the current billionaires grow up so wealthy that they don't know how to function? I think you're being way over the top. I think they're quite likely to be one of the most valuable people. Way, way more likely than an average guy. Same with their health and ability to work. Bodies adjust quickly, their softness will diminish in a month or two. If you don't agree with that, you must be surrounded by really competent, non average people.
- locallost 4y agoWhat are they equipped with? True preppers are people investing in their skills among other things, getting ready for a time where supplies will not be delivered by Amazon. These people have money, and thus power now, but if society collapses money becomes worthless and they will have no power. They will have their bunkers, but somebody needs to keep the lights on there and supply them with food. Nobody will do that, they will just take it for themselves.
- SyzygistSix 4y agoFor coming from a background of supposedly being an influential thinker, the article is incredibly intellectually lazy. The crude labeling throughout is a betrayal of a lot of what Robert Anton Wilson wrote about. About what to expect from the Guardian these days, unfortunately.
- Seanambers 4y agoWhat is this guy on about. The entire article is just filled with pseudo conjecture and hate for some rich guys who want to build bunkers in the desert. What is obvious is that this guy hates society and capitalism - so in that regard he stays true to form for marxists. Checked out his wikipedia page and got none the wiser.
- yallneedtogetit 4y agoI genuinely think this guy made this entire article up. No billionaire prepper is going to invite this nutjob to ask him questions about things like, you know, whether or not their security compound needs an HVAC system. Lol.
- rhipitr 4y agoWhat if the prepper is on vacation when the apocalypse comes and they are nowhere near their stash and safe house?
- bombcar 4y agoOf course you have your bug out team with you at all times, and your helicopter to your jet to your secret volcano lair. If poorer, each of those is replaced which cheaper alternatives until it’s a ziploc bag with a Glock, a few like-minded friends, and some motorbikes to get you back to the farm.
- rhipitr 4y agoI’ve always wondered would most of us, used to modern conveniences, even last very long mentally in an apocalyptic situation (or even want to)?
- bombcar 4y agoPast situations are not directly comparable but it seems that, unless actual necessities dry up, people in general weather it moderately well. When things go horribly wrong (disasters) people pull together. When they go slightly wrong, they pull apart.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yallneedtogetit 4y agoAm I the only one who thinks this author is absolutely full of it? Sorry, but he writes like an 8th grader. 99% of the sentences in this article could be popped into /r/iamverysmart. Why would a group of 5 random billionaire preppers "trick" him into coming to talk about their elaborate doomsday compounds. They gain absolutely nothing by talking to this guy. And why are they asking this random author "Should my compound have its own air supply?" Sorry but I genuinely think this author just made this whole thing up, or is severely exaggerating what actually happened. Do billionaires have preparation for global economic collapse or planetwide warfare, up to and including a security compound for them to flee to? Definitely. Would they talk about it with this pseudointellectual, for absolutely no reason at all.. to ask him questions about their builds, or whether or not they should have their security guards wear collars? Absolutely not.
- denton-scratch 4y ago> I genuinely think this author just made this whole thing up I don't suspect that. But I do wonder how credible the story is; I've not come across Rushkoff before. His writeup in The Graun says he's a "writer and filmmaker on media, technology and popular culture", and teaches media studies. In the article he says he's also "written" a graphic novel. So, he doesn't sound like a reporter, to me. I don't know to what extent he's using the story, whose truth isn't important to him, to make a social point.
- adaml_623 4y agoDoesn't sound like you've bothered googling him. Read his wiki page[0]. This is literally stuff he's been writing about for close to 30 years. Of course you'd talk with him if you're a billionaire prepper. 0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglas_Rushkoff https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Douglas_Rushkoff
- andsoitis 4y agoFrom his bio in Wikipedia, amongst other things: “Douglas Rushkoff has been declared the 6th most influential thinker in the world by MIT, only behind Steven Pinker, David Graeber, Nobel prize winner Daniel Kahneman, Thilo Sarrazin and Richard Florida.”
- hoseja 4y agoMarxist meets people who realize the inescapability of Red Queen's Race. Seriously, learn some history/biology, the one-upsmanship never ends and with the exponential increase in human abilities, the chance of unavoidable/chance apocalypse rises to uncomfortable levels. Is it immoral that prepper mammals survived the asteroid when productive society member dinosaurs didn't?
- adaml_623 4y agoThe asteroid is man-made so the moral question is very different to what you are saying.
- hoseja 4y agoIt really isn't. It's as unavoidable and chance as an orbit of a planetoid. Humans are barely conscious, let alone able to foresee or prevent it. Whoever would strive to deflect it too eagerly will fall back and be eaten alive.
- anigbrowl 4y agoprepper mammals survived the asteroid ◔_◔
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jmpman 4y agoSo, in a post apocalyptic world, all you have to do is take over a billionaires bunker to become the wealthiest person in the world? Sounds simple. Find the air intake. Block it. Wait.
- scruple 4y agoIt's always seemed to me that the most likely scenario for these types is that the mercs they hire for security decide to take it over a month in.
- drewcoo 4y agoLike Wells' eloi? https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Time_Machine https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Time_Machine
- jmoak3 4y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/21/us/kentucky-bunker-civil-war.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/07/21/us/kentucky-bunker-civil-... Repeat after me: There is actually little you can do to prepare for a total collapse, especially to survive the following desperate 0 trust environment. If you think a partial one of sorts is coming: be near family, learn handy skills, and focus on building a local community - great things to have regardless :)
- oswald42 4y ago
- trasz 4y agoGood; those stashes will be useful should something happen. Hopefully those “preppers” will cooperate instead of having to be killed outright.
- kwertyoowiyop 4y ago[flagged]
- kakwa_ 4y ago"Après moi, le déluge" (Louis XV). For ages, people in power position have been at the same time, both nihilistic, knowingly pushing toward the cliff and afraid of an impending collapse. This is both creepy and reassuring, despite all that humanity has survived (with blood and tears but survived). This elites on the other end? Sometimes they did, sometimes they didn't, and at the very least not in the same position of power.
- gdubs 4y agoI haven't seen it mentioned in the conversation so here it goes: you really want to survive a disaster? Focus on building a strong community. This individualist approach to survivalism seems to be based on a complete fear of others, or a selfishness of grabbing for oneself and hoping to ride it out (you won't). The best reason, in my opinion, for individuals to be prepared for disaster is that it takes pressure off the community. One less family for the first responders to have to worry about, more time to focus on the less fortunate. Want to survive a disaster? Be a good neighbor, and start building a strong community today.
- bergenty 4y ago>How do I maintain authority over my security force after the event? Obviously with chips in them that kill them if they disobey.
- stmfreak 4y agoWhat qualities will prevent these billionaires from getting ejected by their security personnel to make room for their families?