7 ms·
Amazon Puts Your $1000 Kindle Library 'On Hold,' Apologizes, Shrugs
- kmfrk 15y agoPaging all e-book sellers, this is a chance to get great publicity for the one-time-only price of $1,000.
- absconditus 15y agoI do not believe that any other e-book seller has the selection that Amazon does. It would be terribly embarrassing if some seller tried to use this for PR and then realized that they do not have some of the titles.
- ernesth 15y agoReally? From a "rest of the world" point of view (I am speaking for France where Amazon is now officially selling kindles and kindle books, but it is also true for Germany), it is more the contrary: Amazon has the smallest selection of e-books compared to the other generalist e-book sellers.
- kmfrk 15y agoI don't really subscribe to your argument in a cloud-based market where - to me - the biggest looming threat is to lose access to all your data. There was another incident (Amazon again) where they lost a person's annotations for the Jobs biography in a software update[1]. Amazon seem to be botching the cloud aspect of e-books, and while their selection is orders of magnitude better than iBooks in my country (because I can buy from Amazon.com), the reason I buy e-books in the first place is because of what the cloud offers - with marginalia/annotations being the best selling point over dead-tree books. Annotating e-books on the Kindle app on iOS is also a ridiculous pain in the ass, but that's for another time. I love the selection Amazon has, especially the self-published articles from bloggers, Ars Technica, newspapers or magazines and such, but the way Apple keeps screwing these things up, I plan on choosing the iBooks version, if available. I honestly think I might have thrown my phone against the wall, if all my Isaacson biography annotations had been wiped. But that's just me as one customer. I am sure that some people have the priorities you do, but I wouldn't exactly predict an unequivocal PR failure. :) [1]: http://mjtsai.com/blog/2011/11/21/kindle-annotations-lost-in-book-update/ http://mjtsai.com/blog/2011/11/21/kindle-annotations-lost-in...
- phuff 15y agoAmazon usually has really good customer service all the times I've called. It seems like this really is a fell through the cracks thing. I'm glad venues like Consumerist exist to publicize this kind of thing.
- rickmb 15y agoBuying DRM-ed content is a contradiction in terms. Period. It should be made illegal for sellers to pretend this constitutes the purchase of the content itself. Call it a lease, call it a service, but stop scamming consumers.
- zotz 15y agoIf they called it Digital Permissions/Privileges Management, sales would suffer and we all know that's worse than the winds of Hell.
- jamesbritt 15y agoDigital restrictions management
- cageface 15y agoLast week Apple locked me out of my iTunes account, and I can't even update the apps I already have installed on my iPad. I'm done with cloud-based content. I'll continue to use dumb storage like Dropbox and S3, and I'm ok with subscription services like Netflix and rdio. But any service that pretends that I "own" content that can be yanked away with the flick of a switch to be restored only after weeks of haggling with an understaffed and indifferent bureaucracy can go fuck itself. Of course, once again, it's only the people that play by the rules that suffer.
- notatoad 15y agoi feel like there's a part of this story that we're not hearing. given amazon's excellent customer service reputation (including my own experiences) it's hard for me to believe that this could happen without there being a reason.
- JonLim 15y agoI'm inclined to agree. My own anecdotal experiences with Amazon customer service aside, something feels amiss about this whole situation. Why did they not call/email Amazon after a full 24 hours had gone by? Why are they disputing Amazon charges to their credit cards? I just feel like something is wrong here.
- cultureulterior 15y agoWhat? You always call websites whenever you can't log into them? You don't allow for downtime at all? They are disputing the charges because amazon stole their content!
- JonLim 15y agoNo, I call websites whenever my content that I paid for is broken or inaccessible. Not to mention they already did it once, and were told to wait 24 hours, but instead they waited a month? I understand why they're disputing charges, but that seems silly if they haven't made some concerted effort to figure out what's going on. At least that's my take on it.
- pyre 15y agoI think that it's silly to blame the user because they waited a month. You have no idea what was going on in that person's life to cause them to wait that long. You also don't know that person's personality. Maybe they are a major procrastinator. Maybe they are phone phobic. To say that the person was obviously in the wrong/doing something shady/to blame just because of how long they waited seems like you're really stretching to give Amazon the benefit of the doubt.
- jordan0day 15y agoI just received a Barnes & Noble "Nook SimpleTouch" (the basic, e-ink screen one), and while I like it, this sort of thing has me very worried about using most of its (limited set of) features. That is, while the Nook has something like 1 gb of internal storage for books, about 75% is reserved for content you have to purchase through Barnes & Noble. That leaves about 230 mb for your own files. (The Nook does feature expandable storage via microSD, but these don't get placed into your "Library" on the device in the same way files on the internal storage do). I'm sure many of these same concerns apply to the Kindle. (And more, since Nook books are EPUB format, while Kindle seems to use a variety of formats, including some proprietary formats & DRM). I really like the convenience of an e-reader, and the e-ink screen really is fantastic, but so far I've only loaded files from Project Gutenberg and some e-books from Manning (who provides free pdf and sometimes EPUB format e-books when you buy the hardcopy). I'm already bumping up against the (artificial) 230 mb-or-so limit for books not purchased directly from B&N. I'd be more open to buying e-books from B&N if I wasn't afraid of a scenario similar to what's described in the article. As far as I can tell, B&N ships their Nook books with DRM, what guarantees do I have that I can still read those books if B&N goes under, or my account gets screwed up in some mix-up? Edit: I must have phrased something in a confusing way. The Nook allows you to load 3rd party, non-DRM'd EPUB and PDF's (although as I mentioned, you only get about a quarter of the device's internal storage to use for 3rd-party content). My concern re: DRM was the books you buy directly from Barnes & Noble.
- JonLim 15y agoTo be 100% honest, I've bene nothing but very very happy with my Kindle. Purchased a book by accident? Refund instantly or done within 5 minutes. Switching devices? No problemo, pages are synced up to the last page you read. Wiping your device? All your books are online and available for download. This seems like a fringe case that I'm not too worried about. I have a full purchase history on Amazon.com and if anything fails, I am pretty sure their customer service wouldn't become huge pricks to me for no reason at all.
- jordan0day 15y agoI don't doubt I'd probably have a very similar experience to yours with my device. It's entirely possible that I could use it as intended for the next ten years and never experience a single hiccup with the service. I guess worrying about those edge cases just kind of comes naturally, perhaps a little too much personal experience with Murphy's Law? Perhaps really my chief complaint boils down to the stereotypical issue with DRM: If I paid for a book, why do I need your permission to read it?
- RyanMcGreal 15y agoThis, of course, is the difference between ownership and permission-to-use.
- estel 15y agoNo ebook license (or any other "virtual" good) will ever have a license that confers 'ownership'. A license can be more flexible and allow free transfer, copying and backup; but I don't think the law allows for a concept of the ownership of trivially duplicable data.
- TillE 15y agoI'm not a lawyer, but I really don't see a fundamental difference here - photocopiers have existed for a long time. You can own a book. You just don't have the right to make copies of that book. Why can't you own an ebook?
- estel 15y agoThe way I see it: you own the book itself, but don't own the writing and story - the information - contained within it. In my mind, ownership as a concept for non-physical goods is much closer to the idea of copyright. Oddly enough, I suppose every book I own here has legalese in it saying that I don't have the right to lend, sell or "otherwise circulate" it without the publisher's consent.
- officemonkey 15y ago>No ebook license (or any other "virtual" good) will ever have a license that confers 'ownership'. You've forgotten about the public domain.
- brazzy 15y agoActually, I'd say that the underlying issue is that the very concept of "ownership" simply cannot be made to apply consistently to goods that cost basically nothing to replicate. All the hubub about IP and DRM and piracy follows from this mismatch.
- interknot 15y agoSo we've definitely arrived in Stallman's Right to Read future: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.html
- matdwyer 15y agoThis is how you "get things done" - complain online to get the most PR you can, the company finally listens, and will fix it within 24 hours. It's too bad it has to come to that.
- dangrossman 15y agoExcept you need to do it before charging back the past 6 months of purchases from the store. I doubt even going up a few levels of management can get that account unlocked after that. Even very big retailers have to treat chargebacks as an attack on their very ability to do business, since riding the 1% limit can be so hard. He's proven he's not a customer they can take money from, no matter the facts of the situation. Once I read that line, my first thought was "chances are his account was locked by the fraud/risk department".
- gte910h 15y agoHonestly, they should have contacted him before removing his ability to access his content. I view the chargebacks as no more severe than what they did. They removed access to the books, he removed access to the money. They said they'd contact him in 24 hours, they didn't.
- matdwyer 15y agoChargebacks are not a quick process (at least in my business). It would take well over 1-2 months before the chargeback was completed, and with the volume Amazon likely has to deal with I doubt they are tied to his account already?
- cube13 15y agoThat's probably the reason that it's still locked. If he initiated a chargeback, Amazon should put a hold on his account while the entire process gets completed. Chargebacks are supposed to be a last resort consumer tool, when every other option has been exhausted.
- bcl 15y agoYou can backup the files from your kindle easily. I also hear it is pretty simple to strip the DRM. I don't see why this belongs on the front page. There are no real details here.
- nobody314159265 15y agoWith some technical knowledge and violating federal law - you can get access to stuff you already own? That's like saying your banks' ATM network going down isn't news because you can always get through the vault door with some C4 and take your money that way.
- bcl 15y agoThat's not an accurate analogy. You have the books on your kindle (and in your backup if you made one). They're yours, you bought them. I have the right to access material that I own, even if that means removing the DRM from it. The article is really light on details. Without more information I really don't see why this story has legs.
- nobody314159265 15y ago"I have the right to access material that I own, even if that means removing the DRM from it." Not according to the DMCA you don't. Accessing material you bought - what are you? Some kind of terrorist?
- Karunamon 15y agoWhy is everyone downvoting this? There is quite literally no proof or any corroboration of any kind for this story. The only reason we're seeing it is because it's been widely circulated for a while. It's a legitimate concern.
- mikecane 15y agoHe'd still have access to his books if he'd installed the Kindle desktop application and had synced all of them down to his desktop. In fact, something is a bit weird here, because whatever books were on the Kindle itself should still be there. There's no mention of it having been remotely wiped. Edited to add: I don't want to minimize this issue, though. Because being locked out of your account means you can't buy books or grab the freebies that pop up. Right now I'm suffering a bit like that due to account confusion I need to resolve with Amazon. Seems I have an older account they won't delete and from time to time Amazon gets confused and sends me to it -- and the first time that happened, I thought all my books were gone (the older acct never had books). A phone call straightened it out. And now I must do that again.
- heelhook 15y agoI don't want to be the "yeah, same thing happened to me!" guy, but I had an awful experience with E*trade, back when their stock went down I decided to move some of my money to Bank of america... That wire took about three years to complete, only a few months ago they freed up my $100k account, which was not getting interests from them or anything, they could never tell me what had happened, they said "something" went wrong with the wire and so they locked my account. Needless to say, I'm not doing business with them any time soon!
- matwood 15y ago3 years and for a fairly substancial sum of 100k? None of that sounds right. If it really took as long as you say, then a lawyer should have been called.
- moskie 15y agoIs it safe to assume that eBooks will eventually go through a similar lifecycle as mp3s? Where, at first, publishers force DRM on items sold, but eventually give in because of customer complaints and demands regarding stuff like what happened in this article?
- dangrossman 15y agoI hope so, though what a waste of money for the people that bought in early. I spent way too much money legally purchasing music during the DRM days... I can't play any of those WMA files anymore since the license servers to authenticate my "rights" are no longer online.
- timwiseman 15y agoThat is possible and also my hope. Unfortunately, I think there are a number of differences that will make that harder with ebooks than regular books. Most significantly, people consume the media different. Excluding a few reference books and the Bible, I tend to read a book once and then I am done with it, and I think most people are like that. Even people who reread books only do it a few times with some spacing in between. With music, I keep adding to my collection, but I still have songs I found years ago in my MP3 player. I want to listen many times, so I have a big push to preserve every song for a long time and to be able to take them with me across multiple generations of devices. The push to have full control, while present, is much weaker for the average consumer. Another lessor factor is that music was in an unprotected format (CDs) that could be easily made digital long before DRM existed for music. With books, the truly unprotected dead-tree form is difficult to digitize, so they have a different history in terms of consumer expectations.
- felipemnoa 15y ago>>I tend to read a book once and then I am done with it This may be true for novels, but science, engineering and math books are usually used for a long, long time. I still have all of mine for reference and every once in a while I do come back to many of them.
- pppp 15y agoWhenever I buy a book from Amazon, the first thing I do immediately after the purchase is strip the DRM and store a copy of the unprotected .mobi file. I'm concerned about Amazon's new announced ebook format that I'll lose the ability to do this. If and when that happens, I won't purchase anymore books from them.
- cdmoyer 15y agoI was always very religious about backing up my music purchases, and generally removing the DRM, but had never done so with eBooks. Your comment (and this article) just inspired me to figure out how to do this, and backup all me eBooks in a DRM-free format. Turns out, it was pretty painless.
- Symmetry 15y agoThis is why I back up all my Kindle purchases to my hard drive with Calibre. They're DRMed still, but I know I can crack the files if something like this happens to me.
- aw3c2 15y agoThis is why I do not buy DRM-ed things and rather become a criminal who has control over the things he "owns".
- azov 15y agoWhat happened to the books on his device? $1000 worth of books should easily fit on one Kindle, even if he can't login to his account - how did he get locked out of his content? Did Amazon remotely wipe out his purchases? Did he buy books on site and never synced them? Does he have access to them from some other app or device, but can't sync a new one? Is he using a device at all? Is he using Kindle for the Web? Or, can he still read all/some of his books? Consumerist could really give us more details...
- ajross 15y agoIt's that an irrelevant technicality though? Say he reads only on his phone, and lost it. Does that make the case more or less important? What if some nice person buys him physical copies to replace the DRM'd ones? Does that get Amazon off the hook? There's a principle here. The specifics aren't really the point.
- azov 15y agoIn principle I doubt anybody thinks that "trick you into paying for books, close your account, and run away with your money" is Amazon's new business model. Obviously it is some sort of mistake/miscommunication and they will eventially sort it out. It's the details that make the story interesting.
- jsilence 15y agohttps://www.xkcd.com/488/ https://www.xkcd.com/488/
- noonespecial 15y agoNote to google, amazon, paypal, anyone with a feature that can freeze, ban, hold, or otherwise disable accounts containing things that are valuable and especially paid for by customers: You need a department that can take responsibility for account lockouts and resolve them! STAT! It is not acceptable for no one in the company to know why an account was disabled or how to go about reinstating it! If piracy can be called "stealing" and no one bats an eye, I'm going to go ahead and call account lockouts with resolution refusal stealing as well. $1000 is well within the bounds of small claims courts in most jurisdictions.
- maratd 15y ago> You need a department that can take responsibility for account lockouts and resolve them! STAT! They already do. It's called legal. I've been in this situation numerous times already with PayPal and a few others. They won't even look at the matter until your lawyer sends a nasty letter. At which point they'll look at it. And then either cut you a check or kindly tell you to go fuck yourself, politely.
- noonespecial 15y agoLegal is what happens when the other functions of your company throw an exception that you've got no event handler for. Its the default handler that returns a meaningless "An error has occurred" as your program crashes. If legal has to talk to your customers directly, your business is broken. Its an unrecoverable runtime error. Gurus are meditating.
- nekojima 15y ago> You need a department that can take responsibility for account lockouts and resolve them! STAT! Most companies have teams similar to this, but they are often used wrong, have the wrong type of staff, bad/poor procedures and processes or are under/over-utilized for escalated problems (so too much or too little goes to them). Additionally, you might be surprised by how difficult it is to find quality staff (especially at the relatively poor salaries often on offer) that has the "right" mindset to be successful for a role like this. The level of customer service, problem resolution skills, knowledge of possible problems & their resolution (without checking a manual, notes, colleagues), quick response and thick skin/hardheadedness for the abuse you will get, when you are trying to help. Sometimes customers are irrational, make mistakes, blame the company for their errors and won't accept it was their error. More often the case (when I did this role), it was a joy to help customers to resolve the problem so they are happy (or happier) with the result.
- chrisjsmithuk 15y agoSeriously just buy a damn hardcopy. You can get them cheaper than most Kindle books as well. I find a fair amount of my reading material for less than 1 GBP in charity shops.
- bdrocco 15y agoSimple solution. File a small claims court case for the cost the replace your library. The less offensive option that I've used in the past is finding the corporate contact from the Better Business Bureau and going directly to them. It works fairly often and fairly well because most companies value those reputations. I agree with some of the comments here, simply because your company is an 'internet company' doesn't mean a 'Help' webpage is all you need for support. Actual personal support handling is virtually non-existent from large scale web companies and it's a disappointment.
- rweir 15y agomoral of the story: if you're going to give money to a company that uses DRM, make sure the DRM is pwnable, and make pwning your own purchases a habit.
- FilterJoe 15y agoThis makes for a great story but how do we know it wasn't totally made up? There is no link from the consumerist article to a post from the original source (someone whose purported first name is Ryan). Searching for word-for-word sentences from the article on Google, I just find this consumerist post and pages that quoted from it more recently. Even if Laura Northrup was really given this information by someone who is really named Ryan, how do we know that Ryan isn't making this story up? Or perhaps there's a part of it that is true but important parts of the story are omitted or exaggerated? This kind of thing seems to be happening more each year on the internet - widely circulated stories considered credible just because it's widely circulated. All that being said - I own both a Kindle Touch and Nook Simple Touch but have spent a total of $0.99 on content, for the same reasons cited by many in this thread. However, I'm very comfortable with a Netflix model. I've used the Nook to read in stores a little and I intend to use the Kindle Touch with my prime account to read borrowed books. I predict that some day, Amazon or Barnes and Noble will come out with some kind of "content guarantee: you buy it, it's yours, forever." And I think this guarantee will quickly be copied by all competitors. The market for e-content will then be extended to nervous Nellies like me.