15 ms·
Amazon's Global Quest to Crush Unions
- black_13 4y ago
- robin_reala 4y agoSubmitted this a couple of days ago, but it’s relevant reading: https://www.gmb.org.uk/news/amazon-workers-ready-strike https://www.gmb.org.uk/news/amazon-workers-ready-strike “Amazon workers at a Coventry warehouse have voted they are ready to take strike action over pay. More than 300 workers voted in the consultative ballot at the fulfilment centre in the West Midlands, with 97 per cent saying they were ready to walk out.”
- xhkkffbf 4y agoI just wanted to offer this warning to the younger set who seem to think that unions are one piece to fixing the problems that ail the workplace: in every place I've worked with a union, the union did little to protect me or my colleagues. They were sort of a junior, parallel branch of management that would usually favor some groups more than others. I have friends who were essentially targeted by the factions in the unions. So the idea that unions are some how always thinking of the worker has been untrue in my experience. There was probably a time when unions made more sense. When much of the work is exactly the same and people are just cogs in a big machine, well, I think the idea of collective bargaining makes sense. But while Amazon warehouse workers and delivery teams are doing pretty similar work, there are still differences. Some people just do more work and I don't see anything wrong with rewarding them. Now all of that being said, I can see a better argument for breaking up Amazon to ensure more competition. I feel like an open labor market is the best way for workers to earn good treatment. When the market was tight, Amazon responded with higher pay and more benefits-- without the need of a union to get in the way and collect dues.
- sofixa 4y agoYou can't say something like this without specifying the country under an article about Amazon's global anti-union strategy. Going off what you said, you're probably talking about the US, which really isn't in any way comparable. You have shit labour laws and dynamics all around and nothing which could be useful when talking about other countries.
- chrisseaton 4y agoThe younger American middle-classs hate their HOAs but want unions at work. If you don’t like your HOA telling you how to cut your grass you’re also not going to like your union telling you how to do your job. Both are ostensibly democratic but in practice oppressive.
- subsuboptimal 4y agoI'd take Democratic but imperfect over authoritarian any day. The company can also tell you how to "cut your grass", only you have no say at all in their leadership. My union is fighting to raise my stake in the business I work for. Even if that means there are a couple new rules from the union it's still a hugely net positive.
- chrisseaton 4y agoPresumably these are the arguments that led to the HOAs? ‘More democratic’, ‘everyone has a say’, etc. In practice it’s a tyranny of the majority, right? Same in a union, the majority have power and may act against your interests.
- acdha 4y agoThis is a common anti-union talking point but I’ve never seen anything like it at that anywhere I’ve worked - the unions have been what shut down those actions by management. I’m sure there are some bad unions but that doesn’t mean we should give up on the concept any more than bad moves by companies means we should give up on the concept of private business.
- kennend3 4y agoTHIS! i use to like r/antiwork on Reddit but dumped it over a year ago. It isnt about "antiwork" but "union drives". The answer to almost any workplace issue seems to be "join a union" but what about the major Union failures? Here (Canada) we had an issues with a meat processing plant in Alberta. It didnt take long for the striking workers to lash out at their union as well for lack of support. The union felt there were not enough people for them to get involved. while they were content to take their union dues, they were reluctant to get involved in costly legal battles? Unions are also a business as well, subject to the exact same "corruption" charges as any other organization, so it is ironic that r/Antiwork advocates them? Look at the recent news from the head of the very powerful auto workers union (which also includes clergy?) here and his mystery $25,00. Naturally his excuse is his "prescription medication and alcohol abuse made me do it". People complain about the "CEO" pay, but how much do union leaders earn? Unions were very good in the past and did a lot for the country, but people would be far better off changing laws instead of joining unions. This is what really kills me about r/anitwork. Not everyone can join a union, but legal changes apply to everyone. I actually had someone tell me once "why should my union fight to help ohters"?
- Cupertino95014 4y agoThanks. You have experience with unions in the real world, which the vast majority of American "progressives" don't. The union often turns into another bureaucracy which has forgotten its original mission, and now exists just to feed itself. Your meat processing plant example is a good one -- the union leaders apparently just want to keep their cushy life and avoid trouble. Nonetheless, as I said, if you're an Amazon warehouse worker and the company doesn't give a shit about you, then yeah, a union could look like the least-bad alternative.
- kennend3 4y agoNot sure where you are, but spend a few mins and see all the not-so-good things the unions have done here (Ontario, canada). The idea of "forgotten its missing" really rings true here. Every election they create some sort of "working family coalition" or such and spend millions on attack-ads. They have their guy in government and want them to win? Why exactly are unions involved in politics? Why is this even allowed? Is this something the dues-paying members support, having millions of their dollars used on attack-ads? Finally the party the unions seem dislike won a majority and passed laws to prevent this in the future: https://www.blakes.com/insights/bulletins/2021/ontario-passes-new-third-party-advertising-restric https://www.blakes.com/insights/bulletins/2021/ontario-passe... The law was struck down as "unconstitutional" so the leading party used the "notwithstanding" clause to make it pass. Look who was fighting it - "Working Families Ontario " This is not families, but unions. I dont know why they dont simply say "Ontario unions" instead of "working families"?
- Jensson 4y ago> In Sweden, the company uses third-party workers I never understood why Americans thinks this is bad. This means that the local company can handle labour laws and you pay extra for the workers to avoid having to learn the laws of yet another country. The local company could even be labour owned and negotiate with the employer as if it was a union, and even if it isn't the workers will likely be unionized anyway and they can easily organize against Amazon if Amazon abuses them.
- acdha 4y agoMany U.S. companies have a distinct social hierarchy where people who matter are direct employees and everyone else is outsourced. That lets them keep their reputations cleaner while blaming abusive conditions, various forms of discrimination or harassment, etc. on the other company. This improves their stats for employee compensation, job satisfaction, workplace injuries, labor complaints, etc. If that company unionizes, they drop the contract and avoid their name in the headlines.
- Kiro 4y agoIn reality it's bad because Sweden has no minimum wage and unionizing is voluntary. It's full anarchy in the 3PL sector and impossible for unions to use traditional conflict actions forcing companies to sign collective agreements.
- becquerel 4y agoThe fact that businesses are anti-union should be all you need to know as to why you should support them. Workers and employers have nothing in common.
- legitster 4y agoWhy would a business support a union? It's inherently going to be an adversarial relationship. I completely get why unions are necessary. But it would be like me hiring a divorce attorney for my own wife. A business is almost never going to want a union. And it seems weird to expect them to.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoThere are things I don't want, and things I prioritise to get rid of. The fact that for amazon getting rid of unions is a priority, suggests that unions are effective
- roenxi 4y agoAmazon sees the unions as a direct threat to their profits, but that doesn't mean that unions are effective. Amazon's profits going down doesn't guarantee that workers pay & conditions would go up. I think nearly everyone agrees that unions are going to have a negative impact on profits, that hasn't a point of contention in the debate.
- epups 4y agoAnd where do those profits go, when a union shows up, if not to better pay and work conditions?
- randomdata 4y agoTo downtime. The one and only lever a union brings is a withdrawal of services – i.e. strike. An employer won't take a union seriously until it has demonstrated that it will strike, so if it is more than a bluff among workers a strike is inevitable. This is also why unions have largely fallen out of fashion except in industries where the workers are well off. Unless you are wealthy enough to burden several months, if not years, without work striking isn't an option and thus the union becomes toothless.
- aborsy 4y agoComing from a French perspective, in addition to corporate, workers should also oppose union. Unions will crush work and life conditions for anyone, but a small group of people. They will morph into a cancer, nothing like advertised initially. I hate them. They made me (and many others that I know) miserable.
- oifjsidjf 4y agoThis seems to depend on the sector. Eg Hollywood vs some other union. What sector do you work in?
- desindol 4y agoComing from Germany they are fine.
- christophilus 4y agoYeah. Germany got it right (as far as I can see). Anyone know why the situation seems so different there vs here in the US?
- candiddevmike 4y agoAFAIK German unions are very diverse and workers can pick and choose which one they want to join, vs the US where it's typically a 1:1 relationship between workplace and union.
- hef19898 4y agoGenerally, yes. Detauls a bit more complex so. There are industry specific unions for employees, e.g. IG Metall for everything electronics and hardware or Verdi for public services (covering a staggering amount of jobs). On the othet side of the table you have associations of employers for the same industries. This makes, overall, negotiations straight forward, unions negotiate with employer associations and the results are then adopted, with regional modifications, acroos Germany. Of course employers are free to quit thosr associations, there are also dedicated agreements betweens unions and specific employers, usually covering things like extended working hours and so. And we have specialized unions, e.g. Cockpit for pilots or the equivalant for train conductors. The latter is funny, because there is more than one union representing those at DB. On a more general note, all employees benefit from the conditions negotiated between employers and unions (if there are any that is), regardless of union memebership. Legally, unions obly negotiate for members, technically rmployers don't make a difference. All that of course up to a certain salary sealing, everything above is outside union territory.
- Cupertino95014 4y agoThe fact that it's mostly about Europe is a genuine contribution. I had the (false) impression that in most of Western Europe, unions had won the political debate decades ago and this stuff didn't happen. As for Amazon: they are the poster child for unionization. They treat their workers as disposable pieces of meat with no rights, and if you want to get unionized, that's how you do it. People who have actual experience with unions in this country have a more jaded view of them: they tend to be run by cliques of people who enjoy the high life on their members' dime (cf. Teamsters). "Filing a union grievance" is often not at all a wise career move. However, I can still totally understand an Amazon warehouse worker voting for a union.
- gkodpgfdgf 4y agoUnions are crushing the European economy with the constant work stoppages. Why would you think European unions have won the political debate?
- slively 4y agoI think they are referring the initial debate of whether or not to have a large union presence. In the USA that’s still a big debate, and the fact that there are large scale work stoppages in Europe only further proves the point that they decided having a large union pretense is good. After unions are established, then new debates will surely arise which seems to be what you are referring to.
- Cupertino95014 4y agoAs the other answer says: "win the political debate" doesn't mean "everyone loves them." It's not a value statement. It means "unions are highly encouraged, and companies pretty much have to recognize them."
- hef19898 4y agoAnd that's why the US are technically in a recession and the EU isn't yet, right?
- traceroute66 4y ago
- __del__ 4y agounsurprising (but disappointing) that hn readers are well compensated and lukewarm about unions
- koheripbal 4y agoI think it's because we're older and have had the unfortunate experience of having to actually work with a union. It's a nightmare. Do not ever engage a union worker if you ever want to get anything done.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- legitster 4y ago> The “Amazon Way” manifests differently country to country. In Sweden, the company uses third-party workers; in France and Italy, collective bargaining is predominantly sectoral, and Amazon chooses to identify itself with the sector that pays the least. Everything in this article points to European labor laws working exactly as intended. The "weakening of norms" seems entirely confined to a) low strike participation and b) that Amazon continues to find people willing to work for them.
- AlbertCory 4y agoA (deeply) personal note: "Albert" is my pen name, not my actual name. Albert was my dad's brother, who was killed in his very first day on the job at Swift & Co. in the Chicago stockyards. He either fell off a scaffold, or it collapsed, I'm not sure which. Was there a meatpacker's union then, and did Albert belong to it? I don't know. Worker safety is a sine qua non of unions. In some industries, the union enforces safety regulations rigorously; in others, the workers' comp laws force the companies to watch out for it. Before unions, the companies didn't have to care, and there were no laws. As other people have pointed out here, safety laws protect everyone whether or not they belong to a union.
- koheripbal 4y agoThis is why OSHA was created. It turns out that the centralized government can conduct safety inspections and enforce safety rules. It's one of the reasons unions fell out of favor in America. They never enforced safety, and many fell in with the mafia instead to shake down companies while providing no service.
- nakor 4y agoI have very conflicted views on unions. I worked for ~2 years as a contractor for a government entity in Canada. ~3500 headcount of employees. What I observed there was sickening. This was a place that had white-collar unions for all non-management employees. This union had completely hijacked the mission of this institution. It was no longer about serving the people that this entity was created to serve, but rather to protect the union and its contributors. The software we were in charge of writing had direct, material impact on the physical and mental well beings of people in the province. Life and death. And at times I saw things like a deployment of features being delayed by weeks/months because a union member who was responsible for _manually_ deploying the changes was on vacation. To automate that deployment meant automating a union employees job and was impossible. These features directly served the needs of people that were in critical need of them. On the other hand, I have family friends who work for UPS and other delivery services and see the brutal toll it takes on their body and mind. Pushed to absolute limits and exploited because they don't have a union. But to me, it seems unions can and often do exploit people. After witnessing all of this I've developed a very dim view of humanity. We all just want to exploit someone.
- throwawaywu 4y agoUPS is fully unionized and has been for a long time.
- nakor 4y agoI may be wrong about exactly what company he worked for. Also it could be they're not unionized in Canada. Anyway I don't think it changes much.
- koheripbal 4y agoThis explains why they lose all my packages.
- xyzzy_plugh 4y agoThis mirrors my experience with unions pretty closely. I would much prefer that the sort of workers rights unions provide were instead at a government policy level. That being said, there will always be some need for collective bargaining. I only wish it were possible to limit these extreme union grabs for power.
- riffraff 4y agoIn Italy Amazon reached a decent agreement with the unions a year ago, and as far as I know workers are reasonably happy. The article says "they choose to identify with the lowest paying sector", but that sector in Italy is "logistics" which makes pretty much perfect sense for warehouse workers.
- franczesko 4y agoPeople outside of EU tend to demonize unions through the lens of their own economic environment and lack of knowledge of the matter. The truth is that they should unionize, as this would be the best way to secure their rights (advice from a former Amazonian with exposure to operations). Amazon would s*t bricks, if the same standards would be implemented in US, as in UK, Germany or France. That's the reason why they're so afraid of it.
- ozzythecat 4y agoAmazon’s game is squeezing out every ounce of value they can. I worked in one of the Seattle buildings. It was still a culture of people crying at their desks, incompetent managers being checked out or just stressing out everyone around them. Then you had the more seasoned people who figured out how to play the game. Something is broken or had some outage? Find a way to blame another team. Think of the most sleezy used car sales manager you’ve met in the finance office of a car dealership. Now give them a “Sr. software development manager” role. That’s Amazon for ya. Managers going on vacations to Hawaii while their teams are slaving away over the weekend to meet unrealistic deadlines. Utter lack of leadership. A house of cards held together by H1Bs and other visa situations where people put up with it out of fear of losing their jobs and having to leave the country. I pray the government breaks up that scam. It’s a stain on humanity.
- ChildOfChaos 4y agoInteresting. So not knowing a lot about the situation, is this actually a hiring strategy? Hiring people into the country on Visas, because then they have to perform to very high levels and crazy demands else they have to go back home? That's evil genius stuff right there.
- LEDThereBeLight 4y agoIt’s not so much that it’s explicit strategy. It’s more that tech companies look for high performers, and the H1B situation creates high performers through extortion. The companies are happy to take advantage of it.
- ozzythecat 4y agoIt absolutely is a hiring strategy. Come visit Amazons campus around Denny Triangle and SLU in Seattle. The majority of the foot traffic (Amazon employees) are #1 Indian nationals. If you sponsor someone from Bangalore or Chennai, you pay some up front costs. But that person is going to work double/triple time and deal with a huge amount of shit. Otherwise, they have to pay themselves to move back to India within a limited amount of time. If you see organizations like Prime Video, Alexa, Kindle - pretty much the entire org is Indian. You want to tell me white, black, Hispanic people can’t code? The HR pipelines are set up where most new recruits come through specific colleges that have an abundance of Indians studying abroad. If someone from Chennai has to be on a miserable on call, they’d rather do that and send their kid to a school in Seattle or Redmond, instead of moving back to India.
- Montaque 4y agoThe general positive rhetoric on HN for unions is a jaded. Take it from someone that lives in a country with very strong Unions that ultra strong unions are all they're cracked up to be.
- koheripbal 4y ago... unless you need to actually get work done. You've never dealt with American unions. Trying to get a union worker to help you do something means filling out paperwork to do things like moving a chair from one room to the next room. At the company level unions in the 1980s became synonymous with organized crime. They would call strikes whenever they wanted a bribe.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- andrekandre 4y agoregardless of ones feelings about unions, instead of trying to crush unions, why don't they try to just make the workplace/pay better so people feel the need?
- lastdong 4y agoIt’s so embarassing for a company that championed customer services improving quality of day to day life for so many people is now putting the basic rights of everyone (yes, market leaders tend to influence the whole game) at risk