5 ms·
> But it’s still depressing how both the options and defaults replicate a very heteronormative and male gaze I don’t understand this particular aspect of frett
by vlovich123 4y ago
> But it’s still depressing how both the options and defaults replicate a very heteronormative and male gaze
I don’t understand this particular aspect of fretting. Do the people making such comments think this won’t be applied eventually to all sexual preferences? Given that heteronormative male gaze drives the vast majority of porn consumption, doesn’t seem surprising that that’s where this kind of thing starts at first.
The bigger concern to me by far is revenge porn and use by children and that has nothing to do with gender.
- makeitdouble 4y ago> Do the people making such comments think this won’t be applied eventually to all sexual preferences? I’d see two aspects of this: - it cements the status quo. This technology isn’t bound by the availability of actors, real life societal issues etc, so I understand the disappointment when it follows exactly all the same lines as the current industry. And a lot of people aren’t happy with the current industry, to say the least. - there’s a decent chance that yes, that technology won’t be applied to other genres before a long time. Satisfying the majority first means lowering way way down the needs of the minorities. We’ll probably see incremental technical improvements before inclusiveness improvements, except if enough members of the minority become core participants in the development.
- Waterluvian 4y agoI guess capitalism (or really: resource optimization) is often incompatible with social equality? You’re going to optimize for a proven market. Indeed, it’s absolutely plausible that the existence of that market drowns out other possible markets from emerging. But how do you get an organization with limited resources to make the less optimal choice? I guess we need government AI porn.
- makeitdouble 4y agoOn porn, I'd argue it's probably the other way round as well, creating a cycle. Traditional norms dictated where the money go, and people wanting to chase that money now repeat the process, even as norms have shifted and they could address a bigger market. There is of course a case to make for places with religious laws, but it doesn't looks like the AI devs are thibking about that at this point.
- joe_the_user 4y agoThis technology isn’t bound by the availability of actors, real life societal issues etc, so I understand the disappointment when it follows exactly all the same lines as the current industry. It will follow the same lines as current industry because is the almost literal (if very complex and sophisticated) average of current industry input. An unfortunate quality of AI simulation output is it "freezes" the structure of it's training set, maintaining societal preferences exactly as-is.
- collegeburner 4y agohey man i get arguments about stuff like access to equal education and police brutality as real problems. but are you really trying to make the case that unequal access to porn is a social woe or oppressive?
- makeitdouble 4y agoI wasn't going to these lengths in my comment, but yes I actually think porn is pretty important to our society in many many ways. It depends on your country, but most western societies have piss poor sex education. I think it got a lot better, but we still mostly expect parents to have "the talk" (like it was just a single conversation...). There is unlimited amounts of media touching on relationship dynamics, but comparatively way few fewer touching on sex itself, as we commercially punish that depiction. What we have left to cover that is porn. So yes, I think what porn touches on, what's depicted, and having a broad landscape matching as many orientation as we can accept actually matters. Porn restrictions are bound to a society's moral compass, I don't know if improving porn can bias toward a better direction as well, but at least we could try.
- Analemma_ 4y agoMaking comments like this is just obligatory throat-clearing now, especially if you're in academia, which the quote source is. At this point I just fnord right over them and move on.
- sixQuarks 4y agoThis is what happens when virtue signaling takes precedence over reality. Did the person who is so depressed over this seriously think it would be male nudes specifically targeted to a female audience that will first make it into production?
- hackerlight 4y agoMoreover it's intellectually lazy. Male genitals being external mean they're legitimately harder to draw and we know how much these AIs struggle with intricate anatomy like hands. Super disingenuous woke virtue signalling.
- prox 4y agoEspecially since the author of pornpen states he just hasn’t gotten around to it. I mean it’s virtue signaling before giving the author a break; that is truly lazy picking an angle for your clickbait needs.
- hackerlight 4y agoI predict that we're not going to hear any complaints from the woke types when all the AI-generated images of men are 6'3 with 10% body fat and 9 inch cocks.
- sixQuarks 4y agoExactly. Woke culture never seems to mention women's preference for tall men, which is actually a lot worse than men's preference for skinnier women, as the former is not something a person can change.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> Woke culture never seems to mention women's preference for tall men, “Woke culture” isn’t an actual thing, it's a propaganda terms that applies to a fiction deliberately created for partisan political purposes. But the real world social justice and DEI communities do in fact talk a fair amount about height bias as an aspect of physical. appearance discrimination, and it is by no means limited to women, though that may be where it shows up most in mate selection (it's very prominent, outside of mate selection, as a bias in assessments of competency across the board, and shows up a lot in the workplace.)