9 ms·
Amazon fails to overturn New York City union election
- black_13 4y ago
- metadat 4y agoI wonder how Amazon views this internally. Is it a "failure", resulting from an $AMZN corp employee or group being ineffective at their "job" to ensure worker unionization is suppressed and not achieved?
- bmismyname 4y agoI don't work at Amazon, but I have a few insights here through insider backchannels. It basically all comes down to numbers and the amount of money spent on opposing the union versus how much money they will save on suppressing wages if the union fails. In other words, it's pretty good ROI to invest in union busting at all costs because the cost of a few lawyers and consultants is much lower than paying living wages. It's unlikely that Amazon employees will be reprimanded or whatever, but they probably will use a different law firm next time around.
- thulle 4y agoDoes the calculation include losses due to people avoiding them? Many boycott them here in Sweden, in part due to their views on unions. And while they often have the lowest price in comparisons, they are not doing to good economically last I heard.
- dannyw 4y agoThe way inflation and wages are going, not many people in the world will be able to choose to boycott whoever is offering the lowest prices.
- hayleox 4y agoIf I recall correctly, they fired managers en masse when these election results came out.
- jimbob45 4y ago
- realslimjd 4y agoIs it really that difficult to imagine a company that treats its workers fairly succeeding?
- bmismyname 4y agoYes.
- nobodyandproud 4y agoSo how does COSTCO thrive?
- bmismyname 4y agoCOSTCO is 1/5th the size of Amazon, even though the company has been around about 20 years longer.
- whateveracct 4y ago> 1/5th the size of Amazon So pretty freaking big?
- bmismyname 4y ago[flagged]
- pie420 4y ago[flagged]
- bmismyname 4y ago
- granzymes 4y agoFor those wondering, this is not a final decision. The case will now go to the NLRB board, and then the courts of appeal. The local administrative law judge (in-house NLRB court) is only the first stage. I would not expect the NLRB to rule for Amazon at the board level, either. The first chance of a friendly court will be at the circuit level.
- Animats 4y agoAmazon isn't even supposed to have a voice in this. The right to organize belongs solely to the workers. Amazon is raising phony claims that somehow, the election wasn't fair to them. Those were rejected.
- seibelj 4y agoAnd whenever the union loses, they say the election wasn't fair to them. It's almost like both sides refuse to believe anyone can have an opposing opinion and everything is rigged
- unethical_ban 4y agoYour comment ignores that one side is a trillion dollar company with a track record of abuse and anti union behavior, documented as fact.
- googlryas 4y agoYou could just say "Your comment ignores...". I don't see much of a problem with seibelj's comment, it seems accurate. Just like in American politics, people constantly decry "That's unconstitutional!" about some proposed law they don't like, as if there is any kind of agreed upon definition of what is unconstitutional(there isn't - even the Supreme Court frequently disagrees within itself and is only decided based on a simple majority-rules voting of the members).
- unethical_ban 4y ago
- ftyhbhyjnjk 4y agoOne genuine question: Will this accelerate the move to more automation by these companies? And of course the answer is yes here, but, what options workers will be left with once that sets in?
- overthemoon 4y agoI can't imagine it'll move the timetable up faster than it was already moving. I couldn't speak to the options workers will have. Historically, the answer is "not many", right?
- joshl32532 4y agoAmazon already trying its hardest to automate as much as possible in their fulfillment center, union or no union. This is such a smug take, that the warehouse workers should not anger the big almighty Amazon, or they'll automate their job. If Amazon need them today, they have their value. This gives the workers even more incentive to squeeze Amazon ASAP, while Amazon is desperate for manpower.
- larkost 4y agoAmazon always wants as much as it can automated, they devote an enormous amount of money to that. This is not going to move the needle on something they were already dedicated to. And that argument is almost always silly. All of these big companies are devoting resources all the time to reducing payroll. It is banged into their heads in MBA schools that "payroll is your biggest expense", and that is a bad thing. With that mindset they are always looking to reduce payroll.
- thfuran 4y agoYes, they're devoting money towards automation, but wage increases absolutely can move the needle. If you're spending a bunch of money trying to get your automation solution's costs below 130% of the cost of labor and suddenly the cost of labor jumps 40%, it instantly becomes profitable to start deploying automation instead of hiring labor.
- ww-picard-do 4y ago
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoFrom a European perspective, it is simply crazy that 1.6M workers [0] failed to unionize so far. Not that Unions are simply great and effective - unions bring their own set of problems. But a company this large shouldn't have been able to fight unionization for so long. [0]: https://www.statista.com/statistics/234488/number-of-amazon-employees/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/234488/number-of-amazon-...
- toomuchtodo 4y agoPropaganda and individual exceptionalism are a hell of a drug.
- macinjosh 4y agoEvery human being is exceptional. You won't convince me otherwise. We are all unique and have something to offer. Your kind of thinking is anti-human and leads to a world where the only options for people in work and society are what someone else has already decided is best for them. I'd rather live my life according to my principals instead of getting the same serving given to everyone else. When I am forced to join a union agency is ripped away from me and given to the collective. Not everyone has the same beliefs and values as you do, so perhaps a little humility is in order.
- archagon 4y ago> Not everyone has the same beliefs and values as you do, so perhaps a little humility is in order. Practice what you preach, mate. “Anti-human”? Yikes.
- butUhmErm 4y ago
- malermeister 4y agoEvery human is unique in their skills and wants, but not their basic needs. We all need food, healthcare, housing etc. and it's unconscionable that some jobs in the US don't provide for those basics. If you join a union, agency is not ripped away from you, it is given to you. Alone, the fast food worker cannot demand a pay raise. Together, they all can. Nobody is talking about "the same serving as everyone else", this is about raising the minimum serving to be reasonable so nobody has to suffer. Agency is being taken away by capitalist exploitation, not by attempts to counteract it.
- favorited 4y ago> we believe having a direct relationship with the company is best for our employees that's too bad, because your employees seem to believe otherwise.
- egberts1 4y agoOf course, now Amazon are closing warehouses, soon-to-be unprofitable warehouses. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-09-02/amazon-closes-abandons-plans-for-dozens-of-us-warehouses https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-09-02/amazon-cl...
- t6jvcereio 4y agoIt's interesting how Americans love complaining that Europeans regulate everything, but Americans regulate unions. A union is just a bunch of people getting together. Isn't this protected by free speech or something? PS I'm a European who loves American culture. Don't be offended by my observations, I mean it with love <3
- smt88 4y ago> A union is just a bunch of people getting together. Isn't this protected by free speech or something? Union activity is heavily regulated in the US in favor of the unions. This is because corporations here have a history of union-busting using tactics like surveillance, disinformation, mercenaries, and even bombs dropped from aircraft[1]. For example, Tesla was just ordered to allow workers to wear pro-union clothing to work. 1. https://www.wvpublic.org/section/arts-culture/2022-09-02/remembering-the-battle-of-blair-mountain-and-its-significance-to-american-history https://www.wvpublic.org/section/arts-culture/2022-09-02/rem...
- _delirium 4y agoI'd describe it as regulated pretty heavily in both directions, with some provisions to protect unions and some to restrict unions. The two primary pieces of legislation reflect that: the National Labor Relations Act (1935, part of the Second New Deal) mostly protects unions, while the Taft-Hartley Act (1947, passed over Truman's veto) mostly restricts unions.