5 ms·
I think it’s interesting how long it took for the industry to accept that it’s really the OS’s responsibility to protect against malware and viruses. I remembe
by Waterluvian 4y ago
I think it’s interesting how long it took for the industry to accept that it’s really the OS’s responsibility to protect against malware and viruses.
I remember it being such a ^%#*show on Windows until I think it was called Microsoft Security Essentials? And then that got folded into Windows?
I recall as a teen how hard it was to recommend antivirus because so many of them were garbage. And then MSE made it effortless.
- 7speter 4y ago>I recall as a teen how hard it was to recommend antivirus because so many of them were garbage. Spybot Search and Destroy + Adaware were always a knockout combo until maybe 2010?
- Waterluvian 4y agoAh yeah I remember those. I also vaguely remember Adaware turning to garbage near the end of that.
- causality0 4y agoSpybot has also been subsumed into some bloated "security center" type software. As far as I know there's nothing out there that does as efficient a job at hosts-level blocking as Spybot did back in the day.
- imwillofficial 4y agoI remember Spybot, it saved me with so many customers when I worked at a small shop in Hawaii as a teenager. Magical time. Our stack was Spybot, web something, it was yellow, and Eset Nod32 Those three got almost everything possible at the time
- johnebgd 4y agoI remember having to run a tool that deleted then replaced the winsock registry entries on the machine with the default ones from XP to fix infections. Even if you got the binary files with spybot you’d still have a broken winsock half the time. Those were the days of the amazing Royale theme for XP… awesome theme.
- userbinator 4y agoWebroot Spy Sweeper
- imwillofficial 4y agoYes!
- leeoniya 4y agoEset Nod32 was easily the best. it used the least system resources of them all, by far. and was really tweakable, similar to uMatrix and uBlock Origin
- sizzle 4y agoMalwarebytes lifetime license, still works till this day and no longer available for purchase, love it!
- rootsudo 4y agoYep adaware, and spybot, circa 2005 and a bit earlier were the tools that removed plugin bars and more. Takes me back, can't believe it was forever ago.
- gitgud 4y agoIt's amazing how easily a child could accidentally infect a PC with malware in those days. Consider this common workflow, which would infect a computer in a few minutes: Open up Internet Explorer, type "free song download", click first link, popup ads begin, malware begins...
- userbinator 4y agoI wonder how many learned how to remove malware and/or reinstall Windows too, thus gaining quite useful practical skills and becoming more comfortable with tinkering with the OS. I've read plenty of stories about kids accidentally doing so on their parents' computer, then while desperately attempting to fix their mistake, learned about such things as the registry (in particular, the location of autorun keys...), batch files, the command prompt, etc.
- Waterluvian 4y agoYup. I was wiping and reinstalling my PC by age 10 or 11.
- rootsudo 4y agoThat's what I did, now shy of 20yrs later, I'm thankful for it as it was a great door to an ending era of computer fluency and troubleshooting/learning. Nowadays, it's different. Less poking and proding in an OS and that is sad.
- allset_ 4y agoYep. About once a month after I broke something badly or got malware for the millionth time. Shoutout to my friend's dad who worked in IT and gave me their WinXP corporate serial number so I could reinstall without having to phone Microsoft! Still have it memorized to this day.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoLuckily they've now taken on the responsibility to provide malware as well.
- heavyset_go 4y agoThe industry is still pretending that it's actually app store platforms' responsibilities to protect against malware and viruses, as opposed to the operating system's responsibility.
- userbinator 4y agoI think it’s interesting how long it took for the industry to accept that it’s really the OS’s responsibility to protect against malware and viruses. It's not about "acceptance", unless it's about the increasing acceptance of authoritarianism --- because after all, it's really about control of the platform. They realised they could start calling everything they don't like "malware", that doing so would convince many if not all users, and thus found another way towards becoming the eventual arbiters of truth. Don't like something that your competitor does? Implement restrictions in the OS, and then when your competitor finds a way around that, start calling it "malware" and detecting and deleting it. We've already gotten disturbingly close to that reality: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17967243 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17967243 (in particular, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17968992 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17968992 ) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29579994 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29579994 Those of us who have been in this for a while may remember a time when a lot of Windows AVs would classify binaries compiled with GCC as suspicious or even quarantine/delete them, while those compiled with MSVC from the exact same source code were fine. We know what things like this can and will be used for. AVs were in bed with antipiracy groups and Big Tech before it was even called Big Tech. We've seen past abuses of centralised power, and know that this is not going to end well.
- pjmlp 4y agoIf that means I don't get requests to clean up computers from others, I am happy with it.
- prox 4y agoYou know “my platform, my rules” wouldn’t bother me so much if we didn’t go to a freemium model. Freemium is just usually to worst combination of commerce/ads there is. So suddenly I am no longer the client they are serving.
- crooked-v 4y agoMacs are explicitly the opposite of a freemium model, though. The business model is such that the software is just a supporting element of the explicitly premium hardware.
- quitit 4y agoThe core function of trusted computing was to lockout malware, so it does make sense that this needs to be handled by the OS. That said, and as many others have pointed out: with great power comes great responsibility. There are definitely two-sides to this. If we look at the iOS platform we have many developers who complain about the approval process, but we also have the platform with the least amount of malware by a significant margin despite the large/valuable install base.(1) It’s also why I find it a bit crazy that the new EU rules will crack open a lot of that protection. They should have mandated for 3rd party approvals, not for a weaker anything-goes security model. 1. https://atlasvpn.com/blog/over-30-million-new-malware-samples-found-in-2022-as-cyber-threats-evolve https://atlasvpn.com/blog/over-30-million-new-malware-sample...
- ornornor 4y agoInstalling apps from another AppStore on android is a somewhat more advanced concept. Enough that most people who think that computers are magic I know only use the official play store. To enable third party stores you have to explicitly enable it, and if you’re doing that you probably know what you’re doing. Why can’t it be the same on iOS? All I really need on the iPhone is something like newpipe and I’d be happy.
- mildmotive 4y agoApple preventing “side-loading” is an essential part of controlling the platform, and it’s making them tons of money. Apple wont let go of that, at least not willingly.
- ornornor 4y agoThey won’t. Which is why regulation is needed.
- quitit 4y agoApps can be side-loaded directly from websites. One doesn’t need another app store - the reason why competitor app stores fail is because they’re untrustworthy and crap. There isn’t a need for another app store if what one wants is already on the play store. The only secondary model that makes sense is direct downloads from websites, which unfortunately is also malware territory. This is why the EU rules fall on their face: it’s all the security holes with none of the perceived advantages, only a few big names will make bank because they’re big and trusted enough to advertise directly to consumers. As i said before, the EU should have just mandated that approvals are spun off to a 3rd party entity. That way it would solve the usual line of attack “apple didn’t approve my crashy spyware calculator app because they want to get rich on their own free calculator.”
- flohofwoe 4y agoI think it was inevetiable, because the OS features needed to implement virus scanning are indistinguishable from the features needed to hook malware into the OS (and apart from those technical details, most 3rd party antivirus solutions became actual malware over time, or at least actually increased the attack surface because of the shady shit they're doing). What's funny though is that I always thought that Apple/macOS is doing things differently because they are a decade ahead of Microsoft when it comes to securing their OS, but it turns out that Apple is actually a decade behind (also see the Windows Vista style confirmation popups on recent macOS versions).
- okamiueru 4y agoI'll add to this that as a long time Windows user, and occasional Mac OS (work related), I'd say Windows is a decade behind gnome. How Windows still doesn't have good ways to record or capture the screen, of moving and resizing windows is still requires focus and skill, is beyond me. Also, different UIs from different generations, with partially overlapping features. Not to mention internal key value store that makes it impressive that it doesn't stop working suddenly more often than it does.
- unsafecast 4y ago> a decade behind gnome You mean macOS? Seems kind of random.
- okamiueru 4y ago> "I'd say Windows is a decade behind gnome." ^ I thought this made it clear I was referring to Windows? I honestly do not care about anything related to flame wars. Just that whenever I use Windows and want to do OS related things, it all feels clunky and annoying. It's not consistent. It's slow at start for no good reason (likely due to telemetry, or other online stuff). Updates are annoying and I'm glad I don't have do do anything professional on Windows. The windows api is ugly. The only saving grace it has for technical productivity is WSL2. But, at that point, there is zero incentive to use something so clunky, when you can use linux/gnome and have a much, much, more enjoyable experience. Again, everyone to each theirs. Ship buoyancy and all that. edit: Ah, I think I understand my misunderstanding. I wasn't commenting so much on the previous post about Windows vs MacOS. But adding that if something is a decade old compared to Windows, I consider windows to not have had any consistent improvements since Windows XP. Everything after that has been a mess. Some things better, but with a mix of old. "Need to fix something os-related", looks through new control panel. nope. looks through old control panel nope. Maybe it was in computer management?
- benhurmarcel 4y agoI wonder why it's still not the case in enterprise. They still typically buy a third-party antivirus like McAfee.
- sizzle 4y agoYou can pry my lifetime Malwarebytes license from my cold dead hands, can’t even purchase this as an option anymore.
- calhotel 4y agoIs it? If this could be disabled, the performance would be so much better, it can be truly called Windows 12. But now M$ forbids user to do that without probably jumping through big hoops.