11 ms·
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline... The author is right that: 1. Eve
by paxys 4y ago
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge%27s_law_of_headline...
The author is right that:
1. Every single website and app regardless of whether it is specifically built for kids or not is covered by this bill, and
2. It is virtually impossible to identify and segment your user base and apply the bill's protections to only those you can 100% confirm are under 18.
So, the likely outcome is that this bill becomes an enhanced CCPA and something businesses have to generally comply with for every user.
Looking at the actual contents of the bill though, my response to that is – great! I do want to be treated like a child online. I want sites to present terms of service in a language I can understand. I want them to set my account's privacy settings to the highest offered by default. I want apps to remove dark patterns that get me to spend money. I don't want them to store my data unless using it to provide a service. I want them to tell me up front if my browsing is being monitored by someone else. I want actual consequences if a company decides to leak all my personal data. (All of these are provisions that will be enforced).
The author is critical of the bill as a whole but I don't see any argument against any of the individual provisions. I also don't get where the "eliminate anonymous web browsing" in the title comes from. If anything it will make it less likely for sites to track you.
- Alupis 4y agoThe collection of identifying information for every user on your website is antithetical to the goals of CCPA and anyone that values any resemblance of privacy. Further, business do not want to be in charge of validating PII information, nor do they want to place roadblocks to casual users. The darn cookies and GDPR popups are already annoying enough. Are we trying to make the web unusable? This is just insanity, and will lead to a bunch of ecommerce businesses and website companies leaving CA. ie, no one will comply unless they have absolutely zero other choices.
- zepppotemkin 4y agoWhere is the need to do that specified in the actual bill? https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220AB2273 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm... the majority of the bill is restrictions on collecting personal information in general I'm not sure most ecommerce sites would meet the criteria as something marketed and targeted at children I agree that 'likely visited by children' is nebulous but this seems to be heavily aimed at live streaming/recording services(twitch, tiktok .. etc), large public social forums (discord) and things like youtube kids
- Alupis 4y agoIt's spelled out everywhere in the bill. They make it so scary to serve content to children (knowingly or not, since it's so vaguely defined) that you'll either have to A) Verify age (which requires identity) or B) Lock it down for everyone. Making a person/business predict someone's age over the internet is just absurd... and fallible... so you will have verify identity.
- sidewndr46 4y agoIs it correct to say that even my personal blog is covered by this?
- polski-g 4y agoOnly if you have a nexus in California.
- Alupis 4y agoHere's who it applies to directly from the bill[1]: A business that provides an online service, product, or feature likely to be accessed by children. Child is being defined as[1]: "Child" or "children," unless otherwise specified, means a consumer or consumers who is are under 18 years of age. Meaning all websites, including your blog. No one will be capable of making a bullet-proof argument their site is unlikely to be accessed by a child. [1] https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220AB2273 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
- TulliusCicero 4y ago> "A business that provides an online service, product, or feature likely to be accessed by children" This seems stupidly vague.
- Alupis 4y agoAs with many of these types of laws in California, I suspect they are deliberately vague. If people/businesses have to guess at what's compliant, then they will often choose the most restrictive form of compliance out of an abundance of legal caution.
- dane-pgp 4y agoPossibly even unconstitutionally vague.[0] If a law requires someone to accurately predict the future actions of large numbers of people they've never met, then that seems (to my non-expert understanding) like an unreasonable burden on citizens. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vagueness_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vagueness_doctrine
- gfodor 4y agoAny legislation that is known up-front to affect all websites on the Internet associated with any business is, to me, bad legislation. I'm surprised you can support any kind of regulation that is consistent with your #1. Fundamentally any kind of regulation of internet websites ought to be at least partially directed by the counterfactuals. In other words, big sites and small sites are different things, and should be regulated differently in almost all cases. Otherwise you will eventually stop having small sites, since the regulated needed for big sites will be imposed on them too, until it is too burdensome for them to exist. This would effectively kill the Internet/WWW as it is today.
- Robotbeat 4y agoYeah, I think people underestimate that risk and what it means long-term. Do we want to solidify the web as purely just an access point for one of a dozen huge platforms? There are several web forums I’ve visited that allow anonymous accounts to be created and allow commenting. They are well-moderated. Some were also very niche and run by like one person. Making a law like this is a one-way street that could potentially destroy that capability, some of the best parts of the web.
- pascalxus 4y agoThis will force you to log into every single web site that has commenting. So much for privacy. Privacy will go out the window. Discussion and commenting will go out the window. This bill is deeply undemocratic and very much against a free and open society. I hope your comment was just being sarcastic.
- paxys 4y ago> This will force you to log into every single web site that has commenting Says who? You just made up a random scenario.
- shadowgovt 4y agoThat's the sense of the bill, essentially. If sites are required to confirm you aren't children before you're allowed into adult conversations, they have to be able to authenticate and authorize you.
- svnt 4y agoWhat is the practical implication of this anywhere beside eg 4chan? Almost every place with any quality of discussion requires logging in. In theory anonymous and instantaneous commenting is an ideal of free speech. In practice it repeatably seems to just become wasteland.
- anotherrandom 4y agoAre you suggesting the lack of it is a preferable alternative?
- idontpost 4y agoI'm suggesting that it's utterly irrelevant.
- nomel 4y agoLogging in and verifying age are very different. See the new account creation process for the comment you typed, as an example.
- seti0Cha 4y agoI guess you never consume content that is considered adult. I suspect those who do will feel differently about the issue.
- Goronmon 4y agoI guess you never consume content that is considered adult. This law doesn't appear to cover content, just what information you are supposed to collect about your users.
- seti0Cha 4y agoI guess I made a leap in assuming that if a site assumed for data collection purposes, that a person was a minor, they'd have trouble justifying showing adult content to that person. Looking back on the article, I see I read something into it that was not there. Ironically, I posted another comment pointing out that a poster had missed something in the article. Guess I better remove the mote from my eye before I post more such comments!
- LinuxBender 4y agoDoes this include collecting or displaying their real name? Is that considered PII as it pertains to this law? I ask because if I run a forum it will be difficult to force people to use fake names unless I generate names for them. Some people would be upset if I force them to use a randomly generated name, though some would be happy to be anonymous.
- k1t 4y ago> I also don't get where the "eliminate anonymous web browsing" in the title comes from. If anything it will make it less likely for sites to track you. Presumably the author is assuming that websites would prefer to offer no functionality at all to age-unverified visitors than to offer the child experience. In such a world, every website would presumably require you to login (to prove your age) before offering even basic functionality. With such a system, private/incognito browsing would be obsolete.
- paxys 4y agoWhich is a weird thought process. Would a site rather get rid of 99% of its user base overnight (by making them go through identity/age verification) or change some basic privacy policies to be compliant with the law?
- svnt 4y agoI think I’d really enjoy competing with those who force logging in for viewing a website.
- VLM 4y agoIn the usual submarine fashion the actual text of the bill includes "privacy, safety, and well-being". So its rather unlikely that political censorship will be enforced via the privacy clause, but everyone wants to "save the children" so there will be massive government censorship via the "safety and well-being" clause.
- ryandrake 4y agoWe had the same complaints when GDPR was starting to gain steam: "Surely websites would rather just 'go Galt' and shut down than lift a finger to comply with any regulation!" In fact, that's a pretty standard (and IMO ridiculous) talking point from all kinds of businesses when it comes to regulation. We'd rather stop making money than comply with new laws! I mean, 1. if respecting user privacy means you actually have to shut your doors, well... bye. The web is probably a better place without such a site. And, 2. that's almost never the case. As soon as the regulation takes effect, companies all of a sudden find ways to comply and go about their business making money. It's all knee-jerk complaining.
- collegeburner 4y agoThis has been california's strategy for about the past 30 years, trying to write laws so it is too onerous for businesses to only comply with them in CA. It's a violation of the principles of federalism and should be smacked down, and california should be harshly penalized for doing so.
- hirundo 4y ago> It's a violation of the principles of federalism and should be smacked down I see your point, but smacking down a state for having different principles is a violation of the principles of federalism. If federalism means anything, it includes the freedom for a state to make its own experiments in democracy as long as they don't cross enumerated federal powers. If this bill treats people from different states differently then it is vulnerable to the commerce clause, but that isn't clearly the case.
- collegeburner 4y agoRight, but a state can't e.g. cut off a river to do something with the water then be like "lmao it's an experiment in democracy, cry about it". The internet is an interstate "thing" where we can't even 100% say who is where so this kind of regulation absolutely violates federalist principles.
- hirundo 4y ago> The internet is an interstate "thing" where we can't even 100% say who is where so this kind of regulation absolutely violates federalist principles. California regulation has affected people outside of the state since long before the internet. If that's enough to toss out federalist principles and to handcuff a state beyond constitutional justification, then federalism is quite weak. Your argument seems to be that federalism should be ignored here in order to protect the integrity of federalism. I'm not understanding how that works. BTW, I very much disagree with California's direction here. I moved out of the state after growing up and living there for 37 years because of this kind of policy making. But as a federalist I value their independence more than their correctness.
- zepppotemkin 4y agoreading the bill it seems fairly pro-privacy and generally contains things I'd imagine most folks want like limitations on collection childrens data, notifications if you're use is being monitored and controls over how childrens information is stored
- orangeoxidation 4y agoThe article makes a decent point: Websites will have an incentive to prove their visitors are not children. > It is virtually impossible to identify and segment your user base and apply the bill's protections to only those you can 100% confirm are under 18. Doing this might be(come) possible by completely destroying anonymous web browsing. How? Idk and it wasn't mentioned, but you could imagine Credit card checking, Electronic IDs, post-ident maybe backed into the browser for a one-click identification. Though it's all a hypothetical on unwanted side-effects. I don't think it too concerning as people value random websites less than their personal data and I'd expect websites using the "everyone is a child" approach to have the advantage.
- api 4y agoIt could be done by requiring client side certificates and creating issuing authorities for them.
- bloppe 4y agoThis is a fascinating idea. The only way to preserve a modicum of privacy would be if the certificates are issued by a privacy-regulated authority, are not directly attached to your identity, and are trivial to renew / replace, but seems doable
- tragictrash 4y agoYeah I agree, but doubt the senate's ability to understand the concept, much less draft regulations that enact it.
- happyopossum 4y agoThe how isn’t the point - the point is that the what means the end of anonymous casual web browsing. No more firing up incognito mode to view some YouTube video you’d rather not feed your algorithm. No more browsing the ‘other side’ on twitter privately. No googling for information about embarrassing rashes without Google and webmd knowing exactly who you are. This is not cool.
- guywithahat 4y agoBut the result of this is only big companies will be able to comply, in which case you'll be faced with a worse privacy future than if this bill had never passed
- paxys 4y agoThat argument is used for every new law that is ever considered. Did GDPR kill startups? Did CCPA? COPPA? They will survive this one as well.
- Robotbeat 4y agoGDPR made the web noticeably worse than Before.
- veilrap 4y agoThey all certainly made the web a worse experience for those using it. Wether that was avoidable or not is moot compared to what happened in practice.
- guywithahat 4y agoWell that's because it's the trade off for new regulation; the bar of entry will be raised ever so slightly, and a small percentage of struggling/hobby companies will not be able to compete. Eventually with enough regulation the regulated industry becomes effectively an oligopoly. I mean this bill is being pushed in the home state of Facebook, Apple, and other tech giants where they donate the most money. This is not in spite of them but because of them that a bill like this is being pushed through, and I bet if you checked up on who's donated to 5rights or the bills authors you'd see people bought with big tech money https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220AB2273 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billTextClient.xhtm...
- cryptonector 4y ago> ...great! I do want to be treated like a child online. I want sites to present terms of service in a language I can understand. I want ... That's what you want, but you may not get it. What you might get instead is: - no service unless you "prove" you're over 18 then, to add insult to injury: - privacy-invasive age proof Also, you might instead get: - no service at all if you're in CA Being cynical for a moment, I'd say: you'll never get what you want.
- paxys 4y agoIf a service wants to place these restrictions then sure, a competing one will pop up to take its place the next day. I will happily build one myself.
- nomel 4y agoThis becomes an issue when ad companies put unverified users on a lower tier. And, the user experience will be restricted (no commenting, video uploads, and who knows what "safe" means).
- cryptonector 4y agoI admire your optimism.
- godelski 4y agoIt's worth mentioning that there was also a very controversial post on HN about Chinese game companies having to do exactly this. There were discussions about things like using cameras and machine learning to verify someone's age but that also is putting a camera into the room of a child (nothing can go wrong here...). There are people condoning as well as advocating for these systems. But I think we're coming to a turning point in our society where we are going to either abandon privacy all together or shift away from surveillance capitalism. Either option will have dramatic changes on our society. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28356141 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28356141
- VLM 4y agoUnfortunately your list of benefits is not in the bill, and the bill uses language like "safety, and well-being" in section 1798.99.29 I suspect this will be used for selective political censorship.
- mgraczyk 4y agoJust want to chime in that ads-based network effects are a huge boon to the economy and ability to be innovating and build business on the internet. It's important to recognize that with "privacy" regulation like this will likely come an unexpected chilling of the online economy. I wouldn't be surprised if regulation like this reduced PPP growth for Americans by around 1-2% on average in the long term.
- sillystuff 4y agoIf the choice were really all ads going away and all ad supported websites going with them, or pervasive tracking, I'd gladly give up the minority of ad supported sites that provide value to rid the Internet of the scourge of the remaining ad supported trash. The truth is that there is no such dichotomy. Ads do not need tracking/"personalization", and if tracking/data collection were made illegal, there would be no commercial advantage for the scummiest "ad tech" company. (I'm not commenting on the California legislation, but just generally in response to parent)
- StanislavPetrov 4y ago>I do want to be treated like a child online. Many of us don't want to be treated like children, much less have the government mandate that we treat everyone has children. We already have a mechanism for protecting children and filtering what they are exposed to, this mechanism is called parents. If this mechanism is broken, then we should work on ways to fix the mechanism instead of deciding that we will simply treat everyone as children and absolve parents from their parental responsibilities.
- gernb 4y ago> I don't want them to store my data unless using it to provide a service Isn't providing a server you can access "providing a service"?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]