6 ms·
I find it difficult to imagine life without air conditioning. I'm generally hot and without it ... can't imagine how I'd make it. I sometimes think I"m not fa
by duxup 4y ago
I find it difficult to imagine life without air conditioning.
I'm generally hot and without it ... can't imagine how I'd make it.
I sometimes think I"m not far from living life like the people in WALL-E, tied to my machines (in their case chair) unable to manage otherwise.
- colechristensen 4y agoJust spend a couple of weeks without it, you’ll be fine and come out the other side much more tolerant of heat. This is the case of most “I can’t imagine” situations, just do it for a bit and your fear will prove mostly unfounded.
- kixiQu 4y agohttps://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6924a1.htm https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/69/wr/mm6924a1.htm
- acabal 4y agoThat link says that there's an average of 702 heat related deaths per year. In 2020 there were 38,824 car accident deaths.[1] Yet everyone keeps driving, without question. Is it so much to ask to see if it's possible to tolerate living without AC for a while, just like humans did for several thousand years? Or is a tiny fraction of the number of auto-related deaths enough to make us throw up our hands and say "it's impossible, AC and climate change for everyone!" [1] https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/2020-traffic-crash-data-fatalities https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/2020-traffic-crash-data...
- kixiQu 4y ago> see if it's possible to tolerate living without AC for a while, just like humans did for several thousand years? Ah, do you have evidence that >65s weren't dying because of heat stress for those thousands of years? That'd be cheering. Deciding the excess heat often now caused by climate change should be allowed to kill large numbers of the elderly when AC can prevent it is quite a take. I certainly hope everyone holding such a belief does so because they have already eliminated all sources of emissions in their life that are not literally life and death.
- fomine3 4y agoJust add a datapoint in Japan 2021: 1,528 vs 2,636
- colechristensen 4y agoThere is quite a lot of distance between discomfort without AC and dying of the heat. If you're not doing heavy labor all day somewhere hot, living in death valley, or aged or otherwise health compromised there is a whole lot of room between "I'm hot" and "I'm dying". Heat dissipation is one of the major advantages of being human.
- kixiQu 4y agoWhere I live, elderly people who are used to not having AC (esp. from the time when intense heat was rarer here) often do not appreciate the importance of keeping their own climate controlled. It isn't actually always easy to tell when you're causing already-impaired organs a lot of stress. A lot of the heat-induced deaths occur as "sudden" heart attacks or strokes. I think you and I agree that for e.g. a young healthy person it's bad and wasteful to keep the same temperature control. However, the comment to which I responded doesn't have the disclaimers you've added; it contributes to a "people should be able to tough it out" narrative that we shouldn't perpetuate when in reality, people are dying unnecessarily.
- colechristensen 4y agoYes, if you are elderly or have otherwise compromised health, heat will kill you, because that's just a thing. As your body degrades you get less good at regulating your temperature and need support. That's just a different topic from "I can't live without air conditioning", which, healthy people can. And specifically, pushing yourself to be in a particularly hot environment for a couple of weeks can significantly expand your heat tolerance.
- kixiQu 4y agoSo then this becomes a question of: is it responsible to talk about this with the general "you" as though unhealthy young people or healthy elderly people don't exist, as the parent comment did? To create a perception of AC being generally decadent that discourages it for all, including those who may not know they need it? I'd say it's not a small caveat to elide. Something like one out of ten people around the world is over 65. In the US, something like one out of four. That's a huge chunk of humanity, not a corner case to handwave.
- dont__panic 4y agoI tried going without air conditioning this summer, after moving to a new state and town in the spring. I'm relatively far north in the USA, but even where I am, I found the 85F+ heat waves unbearable for WFH and sleep. I grew up without AC and grew to hate summers as a result. This summer I discovered that I just do not function intellectually above 80F indoors. It's a bit different if you're outside with a breeze, enjoying nature, hiking, walking, biking, etc. I seem perfectly capable of reading a book or having a stimulating chat in those situations. But even with a fan going, there's a pretty low temperature ceiling for me where I can't work productively. And if it doesn't get below 70F at night, I can't sleep well, which has even more impact on my happiness and productivity. So I can survive without AC. But I broke and got an AC unit a couple of weeks ago. This heat wave for the past week or so in the northeast convinced me that I was right to do so. I'm just not happy without it.
- colechristensen 4y agoYeah, absolutely. It's not "nobody needs AC", but the "oh my god I can't live without AC" is mostly fear. If you push yourself into situations where you're uncomfortably hot/code for a while, you'll find your dependance lessened. That's all. I'm quite happy with my well-air-conditioned apartment, I have no problem with using it, and it's helpful. But I'm also fine with being outside the perfect temperature bubble sometimes.
- bombcar 4y agoPart of it also has to do with us getting fatter on average; it helps in the winter but not so much in the summer. A trick that can help with that is have "cold rooms" and let the other rooms raise in temperature. I'm very comfortable above 80° if I haven't been moving around a bunch, but after I come in from outside work I like a cool room for awhile.
- pivo 4y agoI spent six weeks last summer working in my place without AC because the AC had broken and for various reasons it couldn't be fixed right away. I can say for certain that I did not become more tolerant of heat and my productivity was extremely low because I was lethargic all the time. I may have become slightly less uncomfortable in the heat but that didn't help with the lethargy.
- aperson_hello 4y agoI'd prefer going without heat... And I'm in the north! Other than the certainty of frozen pipes
- stevenwoo 4y agoIt is extremely location dependent. I don't have A/C, just use fans for a few days a year.
- anotherman554 4y agoWindow ledge air conditioners weren't invented until 1932. There are still living seniors (like my grandmother) who for all practical purposes grew up in a time before air conditioners were affordable and generally available.
- readthenotes1 4y agoThe population growth of the south and southwest came after AC. 1950, 10% of Americans lived in NYC
- jefftk 4y ago> 1950, 10% of Americans lived in NYC The share of Americans living in NYC hasn't fallen all that much: 12M in 1950 to 19M in 2021 [1], during which the US population has gone from 151M to 332M. So 8% to 6%. [1] https://www.macrotrends.net/cities/23083/new-york-city/population https://www.macrotrends.net/cities/23083/new-york-city/popul...
- a2tech 4y agoMy grandmother grew up without electricity--let alone AC.
- yamtaddle 4y agoMy dad remembers when they finally got electricity and a (party) phone line—some time in the 1960s. I'm not sure they got municipal water service until after he was out of the house, probably in the 70s. They used hand-pumped well water, and had an outhouse. From his stories about his childhood and young adulthood, it seems lots of poor folks and especially the rural poor were still kickin' it like it was the 1920s, well into the second half of the 20th century.
- Sharlin 4y agoHundreds of millions of rich Westerners live in places where air conditioners are… well, they might be affordable and generally available, but still considered a luxury. That basically includes the whole Europe. The sentiment is changing now that heat waves are becoming more common.
- paulcole 4y agoI grew up in the inland swampy portion of north Florida. My dad didn't believe air conditioning was necessary and I grew up without it from birth to 18 when I went away to college and then from 22-24 when I moved back home. He designed and built our family home to essentially be one very large room (with bedrooms off the main room) with a huge number of screened windows and ceiling fans. I assure you, in that climate, it's miserable. After a few years though I guess you just get used to it. Take a shower and never get dry. Sleep with every window open and still sweat constantly and be covered in bugs, too. I remember during a hurricane the power went out and stayed out for nearly a week in mid-August. We pretty much spent that time in our neighbor's swimming pool. Our refrigerator couldn't handle the heat or humidity and more than a few times we'd pour the milk and it would come out solid. That said, I survived. You'd be surprised what you can get used to and live through, even if it's unpleasant.
- jefftk 4y agoWhy covered in bugs if the windows were screened?
- paulcole 4y agoFirst, there's a lot of bugs in the world. Second, many bugs get through gaps/holes in window screens. Plus houses have gaps that aren't air-tight and bug-proof. Trust me, the amount of bugs would be shocking to you if you haven't lived in that kind of area before. We even got the occasional snake indoors (maybe once a year or so)! Basically screened in doesn't mean bug-proof, unfortunately. You might be thinking of mesh bug nets which are very fine and do provide more protection.
- a2tech 4y agoMy grandmother grew up just down the road from where she lives now. They didn't have electricity when she was little and remembers clearly working outdoors in the heat. Summers used to get cold enough that when they'd go fetch the cows in the morning they'd run barefoot through the grass to the back pasture and their feet would be so cold that they wanted to cramp and it was a race to see if you could get the cows up and moving (so you could stand in the warm spot from them sleeping) before your feet cramped up. A handful of nights a summer they'd sleep outside because it was too warm inside (there was a banked wood stove running of course) for comfortable sleep. It would be cold enough overnight that they still needed blankets outside. Now its so hot that she can't imagine not having air-conditioning. An elderly woman (you know how they love the heat) that worked in the fields and cannery her entire life thinks its too hot outside.
- refurb 4y agoYou can acclimatize to pretty high heat levels. Europe gets to 35C and people die. In poorer SE Asian countries they have no AC and temperatures regularly hit 35C with far more humidity, but they do just fine. Hell, you see workers doing construction work in full gear at those temperatures.
- yamtaddle 4y agoI'd have to move way North to be able to sleep OK without AC. Or maybe to a desert area with high elevation, for those nice, cold nights. Discovering how much better I sleep when the temp is in the 62-66F range has made a big difference. I'd hate to go back to trying to sleep with temps over 68F, certainly. Over 72F and I basically can't sleep. I mean I'm sure I'd acclimate to some degree, but it's not like I was already used to sleeping in colder temps before I tried it, so I'm pretty sure that range is absolutely better for me, regardless of what I'm accustomed to or able to tolerate.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoI converted it to celsius and just realized it means you can't sleep if the temperature is above 22C. IMO, that's a reaching the level of a physical handicap: it's a very mild temp.
- renewiltord 4y agoThe unspoken variable in many of these cases is body fat percent.
- yamtaddle 4y agoEh, seemed to hold true even back when I still had the good ol' six-pack.
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoNot sure about this, I'm 110 kg (242 pounds), and I sleep fine with temps up to 30C (86F). Higher than that is less comfortable, but not to the point of not sleeping. It starts to suck above 35. I think it's more a about if you have lived with AC most of your life or not. While being fat does mean I get more heat, I have witnessed drastic differences in body temperature adaptation that are independant of the weight of the person. Your ability to change your blood vessels dilatation, produce sweat, and work out your mitochondrias probably plays a big role, and I would imagine they are worse when you are overweight, and better if you lived in Africa or Canada.
- elil17 4y agoIt's not your fault, it's your house's. Modern houses are designed to be mechanically ventilated. Older houses were designed to have better thermal mass and better airflow. I have a friend who lives in an 1800s-era "summer home" (designed specifically for the wealthy to live in during the summer). It is quite comfortable during the summer without the AC on.
- bombcar 4y agoThis is a big part of it. Almost anyone who lived in a large house in the past would have "summer rooms" and "winter rooms" - rooms that were more comfortable during those times. They'd take more to heat because they often leaked, but they were cooler in the summer also. Now we heat and cool all the rooms, even on those same older houses.
- elil17 4y agoYep! And that's part of the reason many places probably shouldn't go back to the old way of doing things. Yes, you use more electricity for AC vs. natural ventilation. However, you gain so much efficiency during the winter with better insulation, and heating power use generally exceeds cooling power use above a certain latitude. Now, there are some indoor air quality drawbacks associated with mechanical ventilation, but new standards around higher rates of fresh air intake and new technologies like energy recovery ventilators (which now even come in ductless options) are fixing that.
- bombcar 4y agoThe main thing is to know what you have, what the house was designed for, and keep it maintained. Trying to "add" complete house sealing to an existing house without considering things like ventilation leads to sadness.
- Cd00d 4y agoI'm in the process of updating my home including whole house sealing. Part of it is an air exchange system that brings in outside air and matches that air to the interior temp and humidity before circulating.
- bcrosby95 4y agoI grew up in San Jose without AC. But it didn't regularly hit the 90s in the summer, it was a dry heat, and we had cool nights. I used a fan. On especially hot days I would have a bowl of water with a wash rag to help cool me down.
- r00fus 4y agoOnce I went camping in 95+ weather (tent gets hot!) and we would do things like wear wet clothing and occasionally wet our hats to cool off. Amazing how much wet underwear cools you down!
- DanTheManPR 4y agoI never had A/C at home until I moved to the US Midwest a few years ago. In a hot and humid climate, you just have to design buildings and communities for the climate and adapt your lifestyle so that you're avoiding the heat. In a tropical climate, tree cover and designing for capturing the prevailing wind does most of the work. Urban heat islands are a challenge to be sure, but my apartment was fine. Once your body is used to it, you feel fine going outside and doing things without feeling like it's unbearably hot. Living in the Midwest in a climate controlled house has definitely changed my tolerance for the heat, and I find it difficult to sleep in the heat when I travel back to my hometown.