5 ms·
This guy says exactly what (certain) Americans want to hear, so he's very popular. But, like his audience, he's swimming in a ocean of misinformation.
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
This guy says exactly what (certain) Americans want to hear, so he's very popular. But, like his audience, he's swimming in a ocean of misinformation.
- djbusby 4y agoWhere can I go for more factual information?
- npc54321 4y agoOf course: CNN, Fox News, New York Times, White House's press secretary (but only when the president is a democrat).
- Grim-444 4y agoIt's hilarious that I honestly can't tell if this is sarcasm or not.
- unethical_ban 4y agoThe account is a troll.
- kergonath 4y agoThe NYT is… not great in its European coverage. Often pushing a narrative along the lines of “look how much it sucks compared to here”. I don’t follow CNN or Fox News, and definitely not the White House’s press releases. If you want decent coverage in English, the BBC and the Guardian are better, though not without blind spots.
- throwaway0a5e 4y ago>Often pushing a narrative along the lines of “look how much it sucks compared to here”. Which seems nonsensical considering their readership is strongly correlated with the subset of Americans who think we should do things like Western Europe. I'm sure they have metrics and have A/B tested it but still, seems weird...
- kergonath 4y ago> Which seems nonsensical considering their readership is strongly correlated with the subset of Americans who think we should do things like Western Europe. In a somewhat myopic way. Social security is great, but laïcité is bad. Scandinavians can do nothing bad, but the rest of Europe is a big mess. Free speech (as it is seen in the US) is a fundamental right, but not for those who criticise organised religion (like those European blasphemers). Reports of anything in places like Germany, France, Spain, or Italy is always ambivalent. From my experience this reflects the majority point of view in American liberals.
- unethical_ban 4y ago>but not for those who criticise organised religion You think American liberals want to silence critics of organized religion? Have you met a liberal?
- dougmwne 4y agoThe NYT has a pretty strong anti-EU bias. I suspect it has a lot to do with American interests and the ownership of the paper. Just about every article about EU affairs has a very negative and skeptical stance. They REALLY hate the EU certification of PDO for food labeling, which in itself I think is a big clue about who’s interests it represents.
- eej71 4y agoI'm willing to entertain the idea that I find him engaging because he reinforces a narrative that I'm drawn to. But he comes with reasonable sounding receipts so its hard to see how he overstates his case.
- scottLobster 4y agoEvery time Peter Zeihan is brought up there's a comment like this, and every time said comment lacks any examples of actual misinformation. Sometimes the occasional mention of one of his past predictions that didn't/hasn't (yet) come true, but no actual examples of misinformation. This lends his argument more credence in my mind, not less.
- causi 4y agoI would feel better about Zeihan's predictions if he ever directly addressed criticism of them. For example, his "China can only do low-end chips, anything you find in a cell phone or a laptop is made in the US" claim he regularly repeats.
- scottLobster 4y agoYeah, how's Huawai doing again since those sanctions in 2019? https://www.statista.com/statistics/271496/global-market-share-held-by-smartphone-vendors-since-4th-quarter-2009/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/271496/global-market-sha... Also he's clearly speaking in generalities as a rhetorical device. Obviously China can do "some" high-end chip work, and obviously not all cell phone and laptop chips are made in the US. But he is correct that the high end IP and design work is US-centric, with a decent chunk of manufacturing as Intel maintains US fabs. It's the same as if I said "France doesn't produce oil, all the world's important oil supplies come from the Persian Gulf nations!". That's technically wrong, as France is currently world's 72nd largest oil producer (https://www.worldometers.info/oil/france-oil/ https://www.worldometers.info/oil/france-oil/) and the US/Russia/North Sea/others are a large chunk of global markets. But it is correct in that the world writ large cannot function without middle eastern oil, whereas it can function without French oil. The reason the US doesn't build low-end chips at scale is economics. The reason China doesn't build high-end chips at scale is capability.
- causi 4y agoThe reason China doesn't build high-end chips at scale is capability. Does it matter though? Sure, China might be three or four years behind the bleeding edge, but does that gap actually make as much of a difference as Zeihan thinks it will? If you replaced all my electronics with an equivalent that was five years older I would be mildly inconvenienced but my life wouldn't change at all. He also ignores some pretty big things. Like I've read all his books and watched probably twenty hours of his talks and not once has he brought up the fact that American Millennials and Gen z-ers are not having children.
- seydor 4y agoI agree - his narrative is largely a lullaby about how great america is. He gets somet things very wrong, like e.g. how china cannot produce anything of high quality. But many of his points are well justified, like this energy crisis or the looming pensions/welfare crises in europe. Europeans seem to care less about these than zeihan does. His predictions are not to be taken verbatim (they are linear extrapolations based on demographics trends), but some of them will surely pan out. (Some of them will not, like e.g. how japan was not ruined despite its abysmal demographics).
- spaceman_2020 4y agoHe does get some basic macro facts very right - stuff that gets overlooked in most analysis. It is true that America has no immediate physical threats, that it has vast tracts of incredibly fertile land, that its demographics are healthier than nearly all of the developed world’s, and that its gigantic landmass makes it easier to build out solar and wind power capabilities.
- marcosdumay 4y agoHe has a lot of factual information, and gets a bunch of crazy conclusions out of it that I can't really imagine how he come with. His talks are surely interesting.