7 ms·
It's a really tricky situation. On the one hand, websites like KF and the like are utterly reprehensible. On the other hand, Cloudflare taking it upon themselv
by marginalia_nu 4y ago
It's a really tricky situation.
On the one hand, websites like KF and the like are utterly reprehensible. On the other hand, Cloudflare taking it upon themselves to police the Internet is a nightmare in its own, given their bot-prevention services are effectively mandatory in order to even keep any sort of larger interactive website running.
What is permitted to say is something for the courts, not for the whims of private businesses, to decide.
- fppoak 4y ago
- hammyhavoc 4y agoLike with so many SaaS, CloudFlare has perhaps become too many digital eggs in one digital basket, so inevitably it will result in disappointment and bad decisions ala Twitter, GoDaddy etc.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoIt's also sort of hard put the cat in the bag, for the service that instituted the policy and for competitors. If you start a competing free-speech twitter competitor, you're effectively "twitter for InfoWars fans, QAnon and assorted holocaust deniers". Likewise, the headlines if Twitter themselves softened their line would hardly be about standing up for free speech ideals...
- kmeisthax 4y agoThe problem is that all those bad decisions inevitably spark from these platform companies not wanting to enforce their own AUP. We point out a particular bad actor in violation of their own policies, and they do nothing. We complain loudly about it in the news, and they vaguely commit to "fighting" the problems that were already against their AUP... but not any specific named bad actors. Automated systems are chucked at the wall, but the actual people people are angry about are exempted in the name of "free speech" until it costs the company business. This cycle repeats until a politician gets a bug up their butt about it and passes a law mandating platforms have more censorious policies.
- philistine 4y agoThe fact that Clouflare has decided it is in the better interest of the Internet that one website gets to break their AUP because they've become a cause célébre is so amateurish. Business to business relationships don't work that way. You break the contract, you're out. That's what's in the interest of the Internet. Upholding business contracts.
- kmeisthax 4y agoReminds me of Twitter's world leaders policy they trotted out around 2017 to keep Trump on the platform. If I remember correctly Trump was even immune to DMCA 512 takedown notices, which is an absurd level of risk to take just to say you have @POTUS.
- mschuster91 4y ago> On the other hand, Cloudflare taking it upon themselves to police the Internet is a nightmare in its own, given their bot-prevention services are effectively mandatory in order to even keep any sort of larger interactive website running. Maybe we should additionally also focus on that problem as well. It should not be the case that you need to pay a protection racket just to be able to survive on the Internet. We definitely need more, also international, efforts to establish: - baseline requirements on IT security (to reduce the impact of stuff like hacked IoT devices) - quick and fast cooperation between governments to identify and contact owners of hacked equipment to get them off the Internet and patched. Maybe something similar in operation to firefighters - you don't have to pay for their assistance unless you actually created the fire or were grossly negligent? - procedures to get nation states that are a clear and consistent threat to everyone else off the Internet either because they actively attack others or because they are shielding hacker groups, and judging by where a lot of attacks originate, that is Russia, China, North Korea and Iran. Particularly regarding the last point, I'd also advocate to take factual declarations of war as what they are and strike back.
- pjc50 4y agoWe are not going to war with nuclear armed states. At least not to a level we can't plausibly deny.
- mschuster91 4y agoHeh, I'm not calling for tanks rolling on anyone else but the Russians at that moment. But taking down national assets? Hacking them back to steal information just like they do against us? Why the fuck not? If you let bullies bully around without consequences, they will only escalate, and it's high time someone takes on these four.
- derefr 4y ago> Heh, I'm not calling for tanks rolling on anyone else but the Russians at that moment. But taking down national assets? Hacking them back to steal information just like they do against us? What makes you think the US military + CIA aren’t already doing plenty of this to Russia et al? They don’t talk about it, because plausible deniability is an asset. And because the US has so many allies to route traffic through, that plausible deniability can be very plausible.
- prvit 4y ago> given their bot-prevention services are effectively mandatory in order to even keep any sort of larger interactive website running. This is bullshit, there are a plenty of alternatives.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoSuch as...?
- prvit 4y agoOVH, Voxility, ddos-guard.net and many more. Shit, even tiny providers like BuyVM offer good enough DDoS protection.
- marginalia_nu 4y agoDDoS-protection is only part of it. You also need the ability to distinguish automated browsers from real ones, or you're going to have several full time jobs' worth of cleaning up spam comments from everything that even slightly resembles an input field.
- prvit 4y agoTestcookie handles this just fine, Voxility and DDoS-guard can both offer the browser bot detection reverse proxy too. Of course you could also just integrate a CAPTCHA service of your choice.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- phillipcarter 4y ago> What is permitted to say is something for the courts, not for the whims of private businesses, to decide. To the contrary, in this case it's exactly for Cloudflare to decide. They're not a utility.
- fjordelectro 4y agoThey've decided they want to be seen as a utility. You undermine your DDOS protection business if you drop controversial customers. They are exact type of customer who need DDOS protection the most.
- sealeck 4y ago> They are exact type of customer who need DDOS protection the most. They (KiwiFarms, Daily Stormer) would be better not on the internet. > They've decided they want to be seen as a utility. This isn't how law works - just as you can't say "we don't have a banking license but we'd like to be seen as a bank and provide banking services" you can't say "we're not a utility but we'd like to be seen as one". Note that being a utility also comes with a host of other legal restrictions.
- judge2020 4y ago> They (KiwiFarms, Daily Stormer) would be better not on the internet. Who should decide that? Cloudflare? you?
- phillipcarter 4y agoCloudflare. It's in the TOS. They're not a utility, so yes, they get to decide.
- judge2020 4y agoOk then: they have decided, and they decided not to take KF down. Their TOS gives them the lateral autonomy to decide what breaks the TOS, whether or not something violates their TOS, and how harsh of a punishment to enact.
- sealeck 4y agoExcept that they don't respect court verdicts - e.g. in one case they lost against an Italian court "US-based Cloudflare disagreed. It countered that the Italian court didn’t have jurisdiction and that the e-Commerce directive didn’t apply to foreign companies, but those objections were rejected." How can you argue that a legal ruling is legally invalid (besides appealing it) and use this as a supposed justification for not complying with a court judgment? Even in that article they say "While we will generally follow legal orders to restrict security and conduit services," - how can you say this? No other business says "while we will generally accept court judgments..."
- judge2020 4y agoTheir point for not respecting verdicts is: > Unfortunately, these cases are becoming more common where largely copyright holders are attempting to get a ruling in one jurisdiction and have it apply worldwide to terminate core Internet technology services and effectively wipe content offline. Again, we believe this is a dangerous precedent to set, placing the control of what content is allowed online in the hands of whatever jurisdiction is willing to be the most restrictive. It is pretty hard to suggest that someone can sue Cloudflare in a random country with either a corrupt or weak judicial system (not saying that's the case here, but in general) then get it taken down globally. To add, taking things down in a single country might not be super effective with the way the internet works, and the court might see someone browsing from a VPN and claim that a geoip-based block is insufficient for compliance. Although, I don't know the exact case you're referring to or if it's covered by this statement.
- jackson1442 4y agoHow can we leave something for the courts to decide while at the same time dismissing all courts other than the US? Especially when you consider neither the hosting provider of the site in question, nor the target of this wave of harassment are from the US.
- NoraCodes 4y agoYep, I think this is a critical point. People in this thread keep saying things like, "If KiwiFarms is doing illegal things, prosecute them!" while ignoring that it's Cloudflare and other infrastructure providers that enable them to do those things across borders.
- hnbad 4y agoExcept it's absolutely up to the whims of private businesses, if you want to be consistent with how businesses are understood in the US. In the US corporations are people and money is speech. Cloudflare can try to become a public utility if they want but right now they're a corporation and they're making a political decision to continue to take money from customers that use their services to operate harmful social spaces that are used to coordinate targeted harassment campaigns and drive vulnerable people into suicide. They frame selling DDoS protection as a neutral and good thing because it prevents cybercrime. But would you accept the same argument for selling ballistic vests? Plate carriers? APCs? Clearly selling defensive equipment to both sides of a conflict is still involving yourself in a conflict. If you want to be neutral, you don't involve yourself, you don't sell. And to make matters worse, the general consensus is that the party they're selling DDoS protection to are "the bad guys" in this conflict. The guy operating it literally had to create his own hosting company because he ran out of hosting providers willing to do business with him. He had to resort to crypto wallets because payment providers have long banned his site. Even if there wouldn't be any evidence that he encourages and participates in the harassment campaigns his site is known for (a site, by the way, that was literally created to harass one specific individual), the person maintaining that site still took a principled stand to allow this behavior to continue despite what it cost him. And now Cloudflare's CEO took the same stand to continue doing business with this person.
- abigail95 4y agoWhy do you think it makes a difference whether Cloudflare meets California's public utility law? The law, which could change, doesn't solve the moral objections you have here. Or does it? Do you think it's OK to provide network protection to Kiwi Farms is California politicians say so, but not if Cloudflare says so? Corporations are people because you can sue them. This is good. Money is not speech, but spending money on your speech is legal (and good), just because money flows through a corporation doesn't mean speech that would be legal otherwise can be restricted. This is good. Whether Cloudflare meets the legal definition of a public utility doesn't matter. Nobody, including Cloudflare alleges they have to provide the service. The provide the service becauase they want to prevent network attacks from everyone. This position is mutually exclusive to protecting people from other, non network attack harasssment. From their words they want to address and remove the negative externalitiies of network attacks, and you can't do that if you pick and choose at all.
- killyourcar 4y agoIt's really not that tricky. Few sites are peers of 8chan, kiwi farms, and the daily Stormer. When you become their peer, you have a serious discussion about whether you want them as customers with several people in the company, and you can choose "no". They can absolutely drop kiwi farms and still be in the clear, ethically. It's not like kiwi farms is even remotely close to some sort of slippery slope. It's the goddamn burning trash pit on a FOB of internet sites.
- phpisthebest 4y agoit is a slippery slope. 8Chan was banned for illegal content, Daily Stormer was banned for Direct Calls for racial violence Kiwi Farms is being called for banning on the nebulous "harassment" charge, based on non-US Legal definition of the term Harassment. if you can not see how this is a continuation of the slippery slope then I am not sure what you would need to be convienced
- killyourcar 4y agoKiwi Farms has killed and swatted people and had resulted in many direct threats of violence to individuals. It's not really a slippery slope at all. All three sites are way, way beyond the pale. Calling it harassment is like calling the moon a "space rock" - technically true I guess, but missing the magnitude.
- MockObject 4y agoAs someone who fears and despises Kiwi Farms, I would be dishonest if I didn't recognize the slippery slope certainty that the bar of acceptability would decrease over the next few years.
- killyourcar 4y agoYou realize the fallacy here, right? Terminating commercial agreements with three origins of stochastic terrorism is not some ratchet towards new speak. It's just three cases where Cloudflare decided that sheltering terrorism wasn't in their best interest.
- ranger_danger 4y agoWe should be so glad that sites like KF can even exist, where free speech is not only practiced, but the owner of the site actually stands up for their users' rights and even goes to court to fight for them when people wrongly sue and try to take things down that is not the responsibility of KF to even be policing. You may not like the content its users choose to post, but I for one am glad sites like it exist as it gives hope that the First Amendment continues to be respected and legally tested... otherwise I fear that censorship will keep creeping up until it has gone too far.