7 ms·
The Fate of Rome
- DoreenMichele 4y agoHow devastating viruses, pandemics, and other natural catastrophes swept through the far-flung Roman Empire and helped to bring down one of the mightiest civilizations of the ancient world I will suggest that intentionally strengthening local communities and limiting travel and such is a potential antidote to presumably repeating this scenario. Edit: I'm not sure I mean "denying people the right to travel." Maybe I mean something more like "Bring back blimps and other slow travel so germs don't race around the globe in 24 hours."
- pdonis 4y agoIf the book's claims are correct (and I haven't read it so I can't give an opinion on that), then apparently travel by foot or horseback is fast enough to spread a pandemic that can bring down a civilization. So I don't see how limiting the speed of travel to blimps will help.
- DoreenMichele 4y agoThey didn't have the internet. Speed of information is incredible these days. It's feasible to message the blimp that quarantine is recommended, something Rome lacked.
- pdonis 4y ago> It's feasible to message the blimp that quarantine is recommended It's just as feasible to message an airplane, so again I don't see how limiting the speed of travel is what needs to be done. What needs to be done is to use the speed of information to enable people to take appropriate action. Unfortunately, our society's institutions massively screwed this up. They were telling us in February 2020 that COVID wasn't a big deal, no need to worry, go about your business as usual--at exactly the time when, as we now know in hindsight, we should have been doing things like shutting down international travel and quarantining people who were entering countries until the incubation period had passed. Fortunately for my wife and me, we didn't buy the story we were being told and started taking our own personal precautions months before any so-called experts were recommending it.
- nradov 4y agoNone of that would have helped anyway. Highly contagious respiratory viruses can't be contained.
- ravel-bar-foo 4y agoThey can't be contained, but time can be bought to develop a vaccine, and that time is measured in lives. With fully closed borders, Australia and NZ managed to have no increase in overall mortality. South Korea didn't even close borders, just imposed entry quarantines with strong test and trace, and was able to obtain a much lower net mortality than North America and Europe also.
- kyleee 4y agojust to note; fully closing borders was not possible for most countries, so while it may help, it was never realistic
- ravel-bar-foo 4y agoSure, but every barrier to movement reduces transmissions, makes contact tracing easier, and buys more time for vaccine distribution.
- acjohnson55 4y agoThe fastest way to cover long distances in those days was by water.
- jaclaz 4y agoYes, and (while the concept dates back to much earlier times) the actual term quarantine (quarantena) was actually invented by Venetians for ships, which were at the time if not the fastest way to spread a virus/disease, particularly those coming from far countries, surely the more probable one (by volume): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quarantine#Medieval_Europe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quarantine#Medieval_Europe
- nradov 4y agoLimiting travel would be pointless. The speed of travel doesn't matter much for disease. There was a worldwide pandemic (probably caused by a coronavirus) starting in 1889. It's better to just accept the risk.
- wudangmonk 4y agoSure all of those things contributed but the main problem seems to always be bad leadership. I wouldn't be surprised if they ever had people trying to convince the proletariat that all those barbarian invasions, pandemics and catastrophes were hoaxes promoted by the rich land owning Romans.
- mathlover2 4y agoInteresting, though it would be extremely hard to find records of this outside of maybe graffiti, and Roman historians if anything loved to record salacious things like this about prominent people, especially ones the individual historians themselves detested. My impression is that it was less common to outright deny reality and more common to blame at least the disasters and pandemics on those one found troublesome supposedly offending the gods.
- galaxyLogic 4y ago> problem seems to always be bad leadership The root-cause then must have been lack of democracy. Rome once had a democracy sort of right? But when the authoritarian emperors took over, you could say sayonara to "civil society". Bad leadership is caused by people's inability to hold leaders accountable. In other words by lack of democracy.
- boomboomsubban 4y ago>But when the authoritarian emperors took over, you could say sayonara to "civil society". Rome had Emperors for either 400 or 1500 years, depending on what you call Rome, while the Roman Republic lasted about 400 years at most, with a tiny percentage of the population having voting rights for most of it. So blaming a lack of democracy is a huge stretch.
- thom 4y agoWhile it's true that Rome never really came close to being a democracy, that's not to say that representation and accountability weren't relevant. The questions of who represented the interests of the plebs and the military were central to the crises at the end of the Republic (the Gracchi, the Marian reforms, Clodius, Caesar etc), and again in the late empire (all the barracks emperors).
- somenameforme 4y agoI seems to me that Rome is more of a Rorschach test than anything else. Because there was no single cause that definitively ended the empire. Ask 20 historians to tell the prioritized story of Rome's decline, and you'll get 21 largely distinct tales. If you want to blame moral decline, you can. If you want to corrupt political systems, poor monetary policy, immigration, disease, war, social dis-integration (hyphenated only to emphasize the meaning), wealth inequality, or even self inflicted accidental poisoning - you can. And the worst part of all is that even if we had complete and absolutely perfect information on the decades leading to the end, you probably still couldn't find "the cause." Empires fail long before they collapse - inertia. One can easily argue that the Soviet Union failed decades before 1989. But for anything so monumental, inertia was enough to keep the corpse of a system moving forward for decades to come. And in the time of Rome, when the speed of dictate was that of carriage, sail, (and on rare occasion - pigeon) - this effect would have been magnitudes greater, which is difficult to even begin to appreciate the implications of. Perhaps the most interesting, and telling, thing of all is how empires towards their end tend to share not just one of the "symptoms", but many.
- tomcam 4y agoI believe we're watching the USA collapse as you describe, and that despite much wider coverage our understanding of its collapse will, too, be more about the beholder.
- jaza 4y agoHow fitting, then, that so many of the USA's capital city buildings boast heavily Roman-inspired architecture.
- bmismyname 4y agoFirst it's slow, and then suddenly it's all at once. We're still in the slow phase, for the time being.
- throwaway6734 4y agoHow many SPY puts are you holding?
- sndean 4y agoTom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook had Kyle Harper on their podcast recently [1] and he went over topics in this book for about an hour. He brought up that people that lived in railroad towns in the US in the 19th century were shorter than they were elsewhere, resulting from more stressors related to living in a population-dense area with higher rates of disease transmission. And the same applied to urban parts of the Roman Republic/Empire. But, here [2], another group make the case for pollution being the cause of stunted growth in the UK, which reminds me of this article in The Atlantic pointing out that pollution in parts of the Roman Empire of ~150 AD was only surpassed >1500 years later in the industrial revolution [3]. So maybe the higher density-shorter (and generally less healthy) population relationship is a combination of factors. [1] https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/217-plague-and-the-decline-of-the-roman-empire/id1537788786?i=1000574949041 https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/217-plague-and-the-dec... [2] https://openresearch-repository.anu.edu.au/bitstream/1885/241633/1/Heights_Pollution_R2_F2_Complete.pdf https://openresearch-repository.anu.edu.au/bitstream/1885/24... [3] https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/05/scientists-reclaim-the-long-lost-economic-history-of-rome/560339/ https://www.theatlantic.com/science/archive/2018/05/scientis...
- blfr 4y agoIn Europe the shortness of early city dwellers was tied to lack of refrigeration. They didn't have access to the cheap source of protein: milk.
- sndean 4y agoOh, yeah, that'd be factor for city dwellers in ancient Rome as well. But I've read that educated Romans associated milk drinking with barbarians, so there'd be a social component to avoiding milk, too, even when it was available. Though I suppose those educated (and probably wealthy) Romans would have plenty of other sources of protein.