11 ms·
HashiCorp’s multi-product strategy
- conqrr 4y agoAnything to show growth. While I appreciate and understand having a vision, I'd have loved some of these products to just be as it is. With solid feature and we'll maintained. Alas that probably motivates no one and definitely not wall street
- yellow_lead 4y agoArticle is locked to members but the part that isn't doesn't convince me much.
- DannyBee 4y agoThe narrative is hard to buy into when they've lost >50% of their value since IPO so far. I can buy they are doing awesome in the abstract sense, but ...
- metadat 4y agoNot $600B. Yeah.
- jen20 4y ago> The narrative is hard to buy into when they've lost >50% of their value since IPO so far. Many companies on NASDAQ have lost 50% of their value in that time window. It just happened to co-incide with a global downturn.
- DannyBee 4y agoSure, but that's also kind of the point - they aren't special in any meaningful way. If you look at their reports - they are going to have to massively cut costs somehow.
- Koffiepoeder 4y agoIf you look at their EBITDA and EPS and compare with their growth, future is not looking all to bright. They either are going to have to massively cut expenses (thereby potentially losing their R&D advantage), increase their conversions/sales or greatly raise their prices. Not saying that it's not possible, but it's a high risk bet to be fair. Nevertheless, a stock with a great upwards potential if they execute rightly. But that's a big if.
- dasil003 4y agoAlthough there's a paywall towards the bottom (is it 25%, 60%, 90% through the article, who can tell?), the above-the-fold resonates and is a reasonable narrative about HashiCorp's success. Certainly HashiCorp shines in the UX department. That said, I think there's a another angle: HashiCorp is provider agnostic. HashiCorp tooling naturally lends itself to a multi-cloud strategy because they aren't owned by a cloud provider. Current requirements aside, coupling your business to the whims of Amazon, Google or Microsoft is always a risk. Even Kubernetes, the closest thing to an orchestration standard at scale makes me nervous because Google's needs are not the needs of most businesses, and what happens when they decide to throw their weight around? As long as HashiCorp remains independent, I think it will attract a lot engineering-focused businesses that want to control their own destiny. I hope they can resist the urge to chase the enterprise money dragon to its logical conclusion. We are all better off for having some smaller-scale competition to the cloud behemoths who will only care about developer experience as long as they have to.
- ec109685 4y agoKubernetes is managed by a foundation so less of a risk than a tool owned by one company.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tuckerman 4y agoI think one way in which it plays out opposite to this is that Kubernetes, among companies I’ve talked to, is being deployed as EKS or GKE with cloud provider specific extensions/integrations while Nomad is much much easier to self manage on top of bare VMs. Even being owned by a single company, there is something about being to self host that feels more “free”. Obviously this could make a 180 easily because of how much control HashiCorp has, but, thus far, they have been pretty good stewards.
- adra 4y agoWanting to turn on just one more server to find months of lead time and a bunch of red tape to get stuff done, yeah I don't miss "owning the hardware" one bit. In times of economic hardship when finding skilled labor to manage infrastructure is easier to achieve, trading hardware costs for labor costs may make more sense, but I don't see that happening in today's economies for most western economies.
- throwaway787544 4y ago> There’s company-wide alignment on delivering the best user experience possible. That means sales, marketing, product engineering, product design, and customer success all channel their efforts into creating a product that provides an unparalleled UX. Product development puts all departments on the same wavelength in terms of the end goal. Who the fuck are they talking about? Clearly not HashiCorp. The most popular tool in HashiCorp's ecosystem that wasn't written by them was written by a consulting firm who hated HashiCorp's UX. Hashi is like Amazon: shitty UX, but features that capture a market early, and so they remain a dominant player despite shitty UX and unnecessary overcomplicated bullshit. There are only two things that you need to succeed with open source. 1) solve a problem nobody else has solved yet and drive massive adoption. 2) make it so that eventually people realize they can't get any farther without paying for enterprise features, and their lock-in and over-confidence from the free product will make them convince their bosses to pay you.
- truffdog 4y ago> The most popular tool in HashiCorp's ecosystem that wasn't written by them was written by a consulting firm who hated HashiCorp's UX Which tool is that? On a related note, Vault has a really excellent API. A joy.
- jen20 4y agoI'm assuming this is Terragrunt, which itself perpetuates all kinds of horrific practices which are absolutely unnecessary if you apply basic software engineering principles to infrastructure as code/config.
- bayareabadboy 4y agoI use terraform everyday, and I’m not exactly Warren Buffet but it is kinda funny juxtaposing this article with the current stock price and trajectory since IPO.
- yomkippur 4y agoI never use terraform. I use web console first and then if something really needs to be automated I use bash script to string together aws cli. If anything gets more complex than that I do not automate it, instead I use CDK to essentially write infrastructure just like any code. There is a lot of time wasted in learning a DSL and than wrestling with the limits of what it can do. For most infrastructure scaffolding you can get away with just CLI and anything longer should require something as natural as CDK. I also will never use Azure or Google! Why should I waste time learning DSL and it's syntaxes when I am using the best Infrastructure as Code provided by AWS? The UI is familiar and I can always reach into CLI to quickly experiment and web console for learning what each parameter does. Sure there is value in using Terraform but I think all it does is just another Kubernetes type of busywork. 20% gain for 80% investment. Not really a good way to spend your hours, sort of like writing tests before you write code from scratch. We will disagree but I trust my experience than what I'm told to do exactly because I realize these standards are largely just dog whistling junior developers eager to please their managers to get them on a "free" solution that ultimately bubbles up to the C-suite with some McKinsey or Forrester branded market analysis pdf attached with setting up next steps. Not only has big corporate interests invaded consumer interest, they've hijacked the open source movement, into just series of raising money and hoping for a large IPO payout or acquisition by other corporate whales. This is why these days avoid popular opinions/standards, especially when large number of people push for them on social media. TLDR; HashiCorp is a good example of how to use open source offering as a trojan horse to boost the personal wealth of it's investors and founders and I am increasingly wary of "standards" or generating voluntary champions within companies to parrot and becomes salesman for a bit of glory and recognition. THIS NEEDS TO STOP. Very few end up surviving the test of time. Relational database and Java is stronger than ever. Javascript took a good decade to become recognized but it's still treated as a different class than boring technology. Boring and straight forward is resilient, novelty and complex is not.
- swyx 4y agowhy is this absolute dreck on HN? nothing in this piece gives any indication that the authors have any idea what Hashi even does. the extent of analysis is "hurr durr cloud computing is big" and then a long nondescript "Open Source is Key to Product-Led Growth" buzzword bingo that reads like a noob discovering how bottom up open source works for the first time i need a downvote button at the post level, i want a refund on my time spent reading this shit
- yomkippur 4y agothink a lot of saas/developer tools/open source in corporate clothing are manipulating opinions, flagging, censoring criticisms. you can buy HN votes/aged accounts like Reddit. noticed this especially when a YC company is in the submission. its funny because all they are doing is selling to the same buyers (many who are also YC companies) creating a sorta ponzi scheme where you constantly have a supply of "IPO ready" to take advnatage of the bubble which is now bursting and you have increased astroturfing HN used to be above this. I feel increasingly that many submissions are just purely marketing hidden under a FREE sign.
- simonebrunozzi 4y ago> nothing in this piece gives any indication that the authors have any idea what Hashi even does. Yep, quite fully agree with you here. (to be mentioned that I worked at AWS, I am very familiar with the industry, I met Mitch and other people in the team several times early on, and have extensively used their products until 3-4 years ago).
- jeffwask 4y agoEspecially considering Hashi is down around 60% from IPO and has an earnings call this week.
- hericium 4y agoVault is great. But if I were to start learning Terraform now, I'd probably ditch it in favor of Pulumi. Terraform was supposed to make writing DRY easy. It's often more reasonable to copy-paste parts of configuration than to try make it DRY. HashiCorp seems to have the approach of "if something can be hacked around, even in a very convoluted way, we can ignore any feature requests for that thing to be doable in a normal fashion". Instead of fixing Terraform, Hashi is creating more and more products that likely will be increasingly unpleasant to use and won't get reasonable fixes, just as Terraform. The way HashiCorp approaches creating an ecosystem, makes me want to stay away.
- raffraffraff 4y agoI found a way to make Terraform code completely dry by using Hiera as a data source and writing every stack and module to be entirely data-driven (ie: only ever use "for_each" to iterate over a data map, never hard code anything, use strict naming conventions). However there are some major obstacles to using Terraform this way, that emerge from it being a clunky DSL with hidden "special rules", instead of behaving in a consistent way like a proper language. Like these: https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/issues/31072 https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/issues/31072 https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/issues/24476 https://github.com/hashicorp/terraform/issues/24476
- sshine 4y agoI find that HCL (Terraform's declarative resource specification format) is an excellent target for a compiler for a DRY description of my resources. :-D
- erik_seaberg 4y agoHCL doesn’t interop with anything. In a moment of weakness I once generated HCL using M4 (because passing a DynamoDB key schema into a module used to be impossible), but now I think it’s better to generate the JSON equivalents they also parse. Their gRPC API for plugins looks pretty tough, and I keep hoping for an SDK for custom resources that doesn’t require writing Go.
- 4y ago
- jillesvangurp 4y agoOpen source rules the world. A lot of people use HashiCorp's OSS products; not a lot pay for them. I certainly haven't and I don't think I've ever met a paying Hashicorp customer even though I know lots of people that use their products. They are a consulting business ultimately. And like many such companies they thrive on complexity. They are doomed to become part of the problem they are trying to solve. If they succeed in their mission, the result is OSS software that is so simple to use that nobody needs their consulting services. Like many OSS companies, they confuse control over the software with controlling the wider market. Amazon, Google, MS, etc. don't provide just software but their 630B dollar industry that is enabled by their massive data centers and infrastructure. That's what people pay for. Hashicorp is a small fish in that pond as they don't really own or control any such infrastructure. I'd say they might end up being gobbled up by a bigger consulting company. Oracle and IBM come to mind.
- sverhagen 4y agoHonest question/suggestion: don't you think many big companies are more than happy to pay for the consulting to give them a feeling of comfort and safety, someone to turn to if there's an outage in the middle of the night? Not that I'd need much Hashicorp folks on my "bridge call" when my Websphere cluster runs out of memory, but since IBM and Microsoft are on speed dial (in their million(s) dollar support contracts), we may want the same for Hashicorp. This "we" is not "me", but I did work for this sort of company in the past. Open source made them uncomfortable, consulting may help with that. And sure, it lasts only as long as it does.
- nine_k 4y agoAnybody can go and install Linux on almost anything that computes. How do Red Hat, Canonical, Suse even exist? I'd say two parts are key: support (you can see it as a kind of technology insurance) and customized, tailor-made solutions in more demanding cases. Those who use Hashicorp products for free mostly would never pay for them. But some of those people will work in larger companies which would pay, and it is important for Hashicorp (Microsoft, Google, etc) that those people, as technical experts, would suggest buying the tools they know and love.
- caycep 4y agogranted, not that I follow this all that closely, but I just remember vagrant. Then boom, all of this cloudy infrastructure stuff...
- KronisLV 4y agoI can't comment on all the marketing aspects, but the idea of creating products to handle all of the concerns of application development and deployment seems like a really good one: everything from provisioning infrastructure with Terraform, to running containers with a combination of Nomad and possibly Consul. In my eyes, that's enough to validate HCL as a viable language, versus it just being a weird DSL for a single product instead. Also, the other day someone suggested that Nomad doesn't have a future when compared to Kubernetes, though it would seem that there are plenty of orgs also investing in HashiCorp's offering and quite possibly benefiting from the somewhat simpler architecture. That said, I can't help but to wonder why the cloud vendors don't embrace Nomad as well - after all, if many of them can offer managed Kubernetes, then surely managed Nomad would be both cheaper and easier to implement. Most of those platforms already offer a variety of databases (e.g. MySQL/MariaDB and PostgreSQL), so it's not like the idea could be dismissed on the grounds of duplicated effort alone.
- PaywallBuster 4y ago> $630B Industry They're not actually competing for the $630B
- simonebrunozzi 4y ago> This multi-product strategy of creating a consistent cloud foundation has launched them to a successful IPO in December 2022, is driving their $5.6-billion valuation, and helps them bring in some high-value customers like Lufthansa, AstraZeneca, Ubisoft, and thousands more. (Source: https://foundationinc.co/lab/hashicorp-product-led-growth https://foundationinc.co/lab/hashicorp-product-led-growth) I don't agree with this assessment. Yes, the IPO was successful for the first few weeks [0], reaching $90 at the end of 2021, but is now down to ~$36. Seems to me that the market is not too excited about them, or any other high-tech company right now. [0]: https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/hcp/ https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/hcp/