8 ms·
I was taught that Ronald Reagan ended the cold war and gave us the longest lasting economic boom.
by bediger4000 4y ago
I was taught that Ronald Reagan ended the cold war and gave us the longest lasting economic boom.
- flavius29663 4y agoHe did. It's just that leftists in the US won't accept that and pretend that the Cold War just "ended" one day, because of the goodwill of the Russians, not because the US policy forced them into bankruptcy.
- the-smug-one 4y agoDang, good move to force a whole country into bankruptcy.
- zmgsabst 4y agoSeems to be working for China, as well.
- bediger4000 4y agoShould I have been taught Ronald Reagan did that as well?
- kenned3 4y agoI suggest you look at the external debt of China vs other nations, you may be surprised with what you find.
- _-david-_ 4y agoThe US did the opposite with China. Instead of trying to bankrupt China, the US opened up trade in hopes of creating a liberal democracy in China.
- CRConrad 4y agoYeah, and it seems to be working for China -- not on. The US opened up trade with China, and since then China has managed to have the West dismantle its industrial base. It's working great for China! (Except hopefully the rest of the world is finally waking up to what's going on).
- the-smug-one 4y agoIt's not like China forced the west to dismantle its industrial base. The west was happy to do it! And now we're living in a globalized world, where the worker has won less than their masters.
- woodruffw 4y agoThere's a disconnect here: the US policy in question took place over decades, not the 8 years that Reagan was president.
- avmich 4y agoIt's easy to argue that it's USSR people, not Western, who benefited most from the end of the Cold War.
- woodruffw 4y agoAre you responding to the right comment? That's sort of unrelated to the GP's remark (that Ronald Reagan can be credited with ending the Cold War). (It's also hard to assert that generally: Russia is by many metrics worse off than it was under the USSR, while most of the rest of Central and Eastern Europe is better off.)
- avmich 4y ago> Are you responding to the right comment? I was adding to your comment, perhaps too tangentially - the GP remark may suggest that USA benefited more than USSR. > It's also hard to assert that generally: Russia is by many metrics worse off than it was under the USSR Economical, cultural, political environment were greatly improved as the direct consequences of the end of the Cold War, up until ~2010, so I'm not sure why do you think the Russia is worse off. What metrics do you choose?
- woodruffw 4y agoMy bad! I understand now. > What metrics do you choose? I was thinking of life expectancy and the generally high overall mortality rate in Russia, some of which is attributable to rising alcoholism. But it looks like their life expectancy has also improved somewhat over the last decade, so I can't claim that unequivocally.
- romwell 4y agoSome did, some didn't, the way it happened. The Cold War wasn't a good thing, but it didn't have to end with the dissolution of the USSR, and the dissolution of the USSR didn't have to end with a coup, followed by chaos, which nevertheless kept all the appartchiks in charge. 30 years later, we can see how the people who were in charge of the USSR are the reason if fell apart: because they are still running Russia, and are running it into the ground (Putin, Shoigu, Lavrov, etc are all USSR apparatchiks). Thieves and criminals, the whole lot of them. The USSR ate itself, because it didn't succeed in figuring out a way to refresh the power structures. And so that fish rotted starting from its head.
- romwell 4y agoYeah right, because the USSR had never before gone through hardship, and it's the "bankruptcy" that led to ousting of Gorbachev in a coup after his reforms (including a de-facto Prohibition, in Russia of all places!). Let's also ignore that little thing that Russia is now doing in Ukraine, and put up a "mission accomplished" banner on the clusterfuck that happened in 1991. The USSR didn't fall apart because of any goodwill, but it did fall apart because Gorbachev fucked up. Reagan deserves as much credit for this as Obama does for the eruption of Eyjafjallajökull in Iceleand in 2010. If you disagree, note that the burden of proof is on you here; and you're welcome to point out which specific effects of actions of Reagan's administration caused the collapse of the USSR, along with an explanation why much more severe hardships experienced by people of the USSR in the earlier decades did not.
- avmich 4y ago> Yeah right, because the USSR had never before gone through hardship, and it's the "bankruptcy" that led to ousting of Gorbachev in a coup after his reforms (including a de-facto Prohibition, in Russia of all places!). Hardship is something USSR went through many times - until it didn't. And there were many reasons, on many levels, why the situation in late 1980-s was bleak. What was with the oil prices at the time? > The USSR didn't fall apart because of any goodwill, but it did fall apart because Gorbachev fucked up. One of his phrases was "socialism with a human face". Before Gorbachev, Andropov tried to "rule as it should be done", but, as a popular joke states, "has proven that if you rule seriously, you can't live longer than a year". Stalinist times have ended, and more soft, Brezhnev-like ruling turned out to be too incapable. Gorbachev managed to do few mistakes, while trying to rule mostly well - and ended up with opening the country, in the form of many states, to the beneficial external world.
- romwell 4y agoI'm not saying that Gorbachev's ideals were flawed. It's the approach he took to putting them in place. In a way, he was putting "the human face" on socialism in the same hamfisted manner that the "should be done" socialism was pushed down people's throats before. His bright idea to solve the alcoholism problem by having a Prohibition 2.0 is a prime example. What with the oil prices? Forget that, look at the vodka prices. That's solely on Gorbachev. And it worked as well as you'd expect. https://www.nytimes.com/1985/08/27/world/soviet-liquor-prices-up-in-drive-on-alcoholism.html https://www.nytimes.com/1985/08/27/world/soviet-liquor-price...
- ajsnigrutin 4y ago> not because the US policy forced them into bankruptcy what?! It was pretty much the USSR policies that forced them into bankrupcy.... as it did in every other socialist state. source: am from another former socialist country, that also doesn't exist anymore.
- avmich 4y agoUS definitely were helping to bankrupt... but then just before the putsch in August 1991 USA got really worried that USSR will split in parts, and the nightmare of managing relations with multiple nuclear states led them to support Gorbachev and USSR, until it actually broke. Then the work of gathering all nuclear armaments into one state - Russia - was going on, along with support of Russian scientists (lest them go to places like Iran and help them with their projects). That's one of the big reasons we have ISS now...
- flavius29663 4y agoMaybe you're not aware how much the USSR was spending on defense, espionage, space programs...By the end of the decade they ended up spending 14% of the GDP on military, trying to keep up with the US
- INTPenis 4y agoI think the truth lies somewhere in the middle, in the sense that it never ended. It only took a back seat in the media while Russia was disorganized.
- flavius29663 4y agoit ended for 150 or so million people in Eastern Europe, that were freed from Russia.
- jen20 4y agoEastern _and_ Western Europe.
- ProAm 4y agoEnded or postponed?
- avmich 4y agoThe Cold War has definitely ended for Eastern Europe.
- ProAm 4y agoI dont think it really ended. Shifted. But there is a reason the US is funding fission and new Moon rockets, there is a reason the US is concerned about Taiwan. I think we're still deep in it.
- aaaaaaaaata 4y agoHe ended, Trump sorta suspended?
- jjtheblunt 4y agoAren't their countries still filled with Soviet era (or even more recent?) environmental hazards, like ubiquitous asbestos and who knows what else? When i took Russian, we watched a Soviet propaganda film : it bragged about asbestos exports as a sign of Soviet strength, and i think the teachers (one native Russian speaker) perhaps showed it to emphasize what a disaster had already been created (this was shortly pre 2000).
- insane_dreamer 4y agolong live trickle-down economics! /s
- insane_dreamer 4y agodon't get the downvotes; do people here actually believe in trickle-down economics or just fail to recognize the sarcasm?
- mturmon 4y ago/s, I assume? (you never know!) Having read a couple of Cold War histories, most recently Tony Judt's excellent Postwar, I learned that what's often missing from American pop-level summaries is the work put in by the people behind the Iron Curtain to bring it down -- for examples, the Polish Catholics and union members, and the Czech dissidents such as Vaclav Havel. Generally American pop-level accounts like to emphasize American agency in what happened.
- jltsiren 4y agoReagan didn't end the cold war. He applied economic pressure, which created the conditions that allowed the cold war to end. Gorbachev played the critical part. He let the East European satellite states go rather than sending troops to restore status quo. Within the USSR, his reforms gave the democratic opposition some room to breathe. Once Gorbachev's power started to fail, that allowed the opposition to win, rather than the hardliners who attempted a coup. With another kind of leader on the opposite side, Reagan's policies could have won but not ended the cold war. The USSR could have become something like North Korea, but much bigger. It would have been stable but no longer a global superpower. (That may also be where Russia is headed today, as there are no viable alternatives to Putin's regime.)
- InTheArena 4y agoNot just economic. Reagan believed that the Soviet Union itself should fall, and would fall. Neither was consensus among the politicians and diplomats in America, to say nothing of Europe. he applied economic, military, and diplomatic pressure to make it so. He understood what would happen when the soviets started to relax their control. Something Gorbachev didn't understand or couldn't fight. Why do you think the key phrase of the end of the cold war is "Mr. Gobachev, tear down this wall!". Reagan challenged him to dismantle something that they both knew couldn't stand, and that would result in the eventual collapse of the GDR (it was, after all, built to save the GDR from all of its citizens voting with their feet to abandon communism and leave for the west). Ironically, the "domino theory" ended up being correct, but it was the east and the soviets that couldn't sustain the effects of satellite states being lost, not Asia and America. Gorbachev gets a lot of credit for not behaving like his predecessors had, with violent crackdowns and marching armies whenever the rule of the party was threatened. Most say this was due to Gorbachev not understanding - but I think it's simpler. Gorbachev simply knew that the state could no longer do so - and in fact the one time he tried, it completely failed on him. Gorbachev also lied (and changed his story) vis-a-vis NATO expansion something that Putin has used to build a "NATO betrayed us story" to justify his invasion of Ukraine much as Hitler used the "stab in the back". Does that take away from Gorbachev? Maybe not, but Gorbachev was presiding over a failing state the second he took power. He simply rode it out, with as little violence as possible. That's something to be celebrated. https://www.rferl.org/a/nato-expansion-russia-mislead/31263602.html https://www.rferl.org/a/nato-expansion-russia-mislead/312636...
- sbaiddn 4y agoReagan did a lot of things wrong, but he understood one thing better than anyone in DC - nuclear war cannot be won. With this conviction he was able to defuse tensions. He was a great, if flawed, president (and as a Latino, Im on the receiving end of his mistakes)
- thrillgore 4y agoI was also taught this and then I actually had something more than a school textbook. Lech Waleska started the fall of the Soviet Union, the Autumn of Nations finished it. Stop acting like the US is important.