15 ms·
A third of Pakistan is underwater from floods, climate chief says
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- andsoitis 4y ago> That would mean an area about the size of Colorado is underwater. Pakistan, home to about 220 million, has a land mass of 307,000 square miles. I cannot imagine living in a population density of of 742 people per mi² (287 per Km²). [edit/assumed/obvious, as implied by the full quote: ".... and then have a third of the space flooded, i.e. a very sudden change"].
- ejb999 4y ago>>I cannot imagine living in a population density of of 742 people per mi² (287 per Km²). Can't tell from your comment - do you think that is higher-density or lower-density compared to where you are now? That is high compared to the USA as a whole, but 742/sq mile is low compared to ~50 other countries, and is lower than many states in the USA - i.e. DC, MA, NJ and CT.
- andsoitis 4y ago> Can't tell from your comment - do you think that is higher-density or lower-density compared to where you are now? Ah. I live in California, population density 254 per mi², so about a third. California is also 2 times smaller than Pakistan - since a lot of California is inhabitable (contrast with Pakistan) and the surrounding areas easily accessible, it translates to a lot of "breathing room", even if you live in a densely populated county like San Francisco or Los Angeles. > That is high compared to the USA as a whole, but 742/sq mile is low compared to ~50 other countries. Made me look up https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependencies_by_population_density https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_and_dependen...
- saalweachter 4y agoAmusingly, Trantor -- the Galactic Capital World in Asimov's Foundation series, a world covered by one giant city, so populous it was -- only works out to around 534/sq mile.
- OgAstorga 4y agowhat's your county population density? http://www.usa.com/rank/california-state--population-density--county-rank.htm http://www.usa.com/rank/california-state--population-density...
- wongarsu 4y agoCalifornia is kind of unusual in that it consists almost exclusively of places that are either extremely dense or extremely empty [1]. Compare that e.g. to Germany [2], with 2.4 times the average population density but much more evenly spread out. Pakistan is a bit of a mix of both: three quarters are pretty empty, but the population is spread somewhat evenly over the rest [3] 1: https://www.researchgate.net/figure/California-population-density-based-on-2010-United-States-Census-Bureau_fig11_329198565 https://www.researchgate.net/figure/California-population-de... 2: https://i.redd.it/oz7m4lfy37b51.png https://i.redd.it/oz7m4lfy37b51.png 3: https://i.pinimg.com/originals/8e/fb/11/8efb11c1d9cc698ddca2e477a5f4c98d.png https://i.pinimg.com/originals/8e/fb/11/8efb11c1d9cc698ddca2...
- bombcar 4y agoThis is very important - local population density matters much more than some sort of "average" - if California ordered their army into Nevada and added it to their territory, the population density would drop from about 253 to about 154. But nothing at all has changed! Population density is only one aspect of "what it feels like to live somewhere" - local density, land usage, etc all play into it.
- 8bitsrule 4y agoIn Mountain View, California (~Silicon Valley) the density is 6,700/sq mi.
- 4y ago
- mattkrause 4y agoFor context, Montreal is about 4,517 people per km², and New York is about 11,000. I would guess that your number for Pakistan isn't really representative though: it's got dense cities and vast open spaces too.
- xeromal 4y agoI'm not the person you're replying to, but I live out in the country and enjoy the quiet of nature. Seems like it would be hard to have a lot of wildlife, trees, and space in an area where it's 287 per Km^2. I'm not judging btw. It's just not my cup of tea. I live on 5000 M^2 and prefer to have my space. I'm sure that will need to go sometime in the future but we still have plenty of space in the US to fill so I'm hoping it takes some time. lol
- ejb999 4y agosame here - where I live (my town) density is 53 ppl/sq mi - thats what I like - but I also happen to live in a state that has a much more dense population in other areas (one of the top 5 most dense states) - so I live in a dense state, but you wouldn't know it if you looked around the town I actually live.
- seszett 4y ago> I cannot imagine living in a population density of of 742 people per mi² (287 per Km²). That's a significantly lower than here in Belgium (376/km², and 490/km² here in Flanders). I'm not sure which country you live in, but although I would absolutely move back home (at about 100/km²) if I could, it's not the urban hell you seem to imagine.
- Nokinside 4y agoOnly part of Pakistan is habitable. Pakistan has large inhabitable areas. Including three huge mountain rages: Himalaya, the Karakoram and the Hindukush. In these areas people live only in narrow valleys next to river. (when the the river floods, they are screwed).
- kurupt213 4y agoThis is the way people have always lived (except for very modern times)
- bobthepanda 4y agoI think they mean to say that comparing the Pakistani figures (which include low population mountains and deserts) to Belgium (which is pretty much entirely arable and flat as a pancake) is a bit silly.
- kurupt213 4y agoHuman societies have always crowded riverbanks. Until very recent times.
- bobthepanda 4y agoBoth statements can be true at the same time * this is a common pattern of settlement * the different geographies of two countries make a very simple (population / land area) density figure misleading, because Belgium is nearly 100% riverbank or floodplain and Pakistan is not This is such a known problem that the US Census already has a different density measurement method, population-weighted density: https://www.smartcitiesdive.com/ex/sustainablecitiescollective/census-bureau-embraces-weighted-density/69236/ https://www.smartcitiesdive.com/ex/sustainablecitiescollecti...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- clint 4y agoThat's significantly less than Manhattan which is perfectly fine.
- colechristensen 4y agoI grew up on a square mile where 4 people lived. Cities are weird.
- pjc50 4y agoThat gets significantly less comfortable when a third of that area is under water.
- pepperonipizza 4y agoTo make things worse, the population will double in the coming decades, it's one of the fastest growing country in population. The government is too scared to put in place efficient 'family planning', Pakistan being one of the most religious country in the world.
- adolph 4y ago> The government is too scared to put in place efficient 'family planning', Pakistan being one of the most religious country in the world. How do you know that Pakistan's 'family planning' is not focused on increasing instead of decreasing the population? What about religion in Pakistan is incompatible with 'family planning?'
- plasticchris 4y agoFamily planning usually means birth control and or abortion access and religions usually oppose this as it leads to fewer followers.
- adolph 4y agoPoint being that there isn't evidence that Pakistan: * doesn't see 'family planning' as increasing population * has religious traditions incompatible with any interpretation of 'family planning' If Pakistan has a strongly increasing population then it will be in good position to take advantage of depopulation in China and elsewhere.
- nfca 4y agoIt isn't quite "religion" as much as it is vast numbers of the poorly educated population using "religion" to support their highly conservative views. Religions, including the dominant one in Pakistan, have a component of social responsibility. Pakistan too has a trend of decreasing birth rate with increasing economic power across the economic classes of people, even though all ascribe to the same religion.
- cool_dude85 4y agowatching some extremely poor guy's mud hut get washed away in a flood made more likely by all my carbon emissions over my whole life: Wow. According to wikipedia the country this guy lives in is more densely populated than I'd want to live in.
- andsoitis 4y agoI think we are too many people on earth, with each of us with an expanding carbon footprint. Including me. With a third of Pakistan now flooded and an expanding population all wanting a better life, it is pretty sad and I have tons of empathy.
- dougmwne 4y agoI have worked in the environmental advocacy community for a long time. There is a reason this talking point is radioactive and never talked about. You have the environmental footprint of many, many Pakistanis. The moment you start talking in the terms of the population being already too high or the increasing footprint of people from poor nations being a problem, the obvious solutions become terrifying. And if you read through your first comment, I think you will see why. It’s always “too many of them,” not “too many of us.” And I’m not even saying that’s incorrect, just that there is a reason it’s not talked about.
- andsoitis 4y agoConcur. > The moment you start talking in the terms of the population being already too high, the obvious solutions become terrifying Perhaps there are good solutions worth talking about, such as what kinds of crops and foods we incentivize and disincentivize, with concomitant impact on the environment and, ultimately, the space we need to thrive. Or another is giving women access to birth control so that they can make decisions about what they perceive to be an improvement to their own lives and that of their families.
- futureshock 4y ago
- Mvandenbergh 4y agoIt's actually both better and worse than you think. Better in that many places which have comparable population densities on a national level like the UK or Italy are mixtures of villages, fields, and forests with substantial areas of wild space with a few very large cities set amongst them - though obviously not with the kind of wild space of, say, California. Worse in that those countries have most of their land area flat, well watered, and temperate and Pakistanis are packed into a few river valleys.
- galdosdi 4y ago1 square mile is 640 acres, so this is very close to an average 1 acre per person, or perhaps 4 acres for a 4-person household.
- Brajeshwar 4y agoReadable version at https://archive.ph/c4VeH https://archive.ph/c4VeH
- LecroJS 4y agoHow do these archive links work exactly? I always see them getting around paywalls but don’t really know the specifics
- Bhilai 4y agoThis article does not mention why climate change is the probable cause of this extreme monsoon. I tried to search other places and found this Guardian article[1] which explains a bit more. > Basic physics is the reason rainfall is becoming intense around the world – warmer air holds more moisture. > Scientists are already trying to determine the extent to which global heating is to blame for the rainfall and floods. But analysis of the previous worst flood in 2010 suggests it will be significant. That “superflood” was made more likely by global heating, which drove fiercer rains.[2] > And according to a 2021 study global heating is making the south Asian monsoon more intense and more erratic, with each 1C rise in global temperature leading to 5% more rain. > A natural climate cycle driven by temperature and wind variations in the Pacific may also have added to the Pakistan floods [1] https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/aug/29/monster-monsoon-why-the-floods-in-pakistan-are-so-devastating https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2022/aug/29/monster-... [2] https://progearthplanetsci.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40645-021-00431-w https://progearthplanetsci.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186...
- colechristensen 4y agoIt is a disservice to mention global warming every time there is a major weather event. Climate is not weather, it is about statistics over decades and centuries. If you can’t say global warming is bogus because it’s particularly cold out today, you also can’t blame global warming on it being hot or rainy. People need to understand it’s not about single events, they don’t when you take every opportunity to mention global warming with bad weather.
- simonh 4y agoTrue for weather events that are within the previously established long term range of variability. When you have completely unprecedented events, that have no known historical equivalent and it happens more than once in recent history, then I think it's legitimate. There's a clip I remember of an interview with the CEO of an oil company from I think the 90s, where he says something like "They keep saying hurricanes will become stronger and more likely. Where are they? Where are these hurricanes?". IIRC it was several years before Katrina. I wish I could find it on Youtube. Well, now those extreme weather events are happening with increasing regularity. I think it's reasonable to say, you know those extreme weather events climate scientists have been talking about for decades? There they are!
- Maven911 4y agoWith the deaths and displacements, there's also an estimated $10 billion of damages ready In case anyone interested, UNICEF New Zealand is looking for donations: https://www.unicef.org.nz/appeal/pakistan-flood-emergency?utm_term=pakistan&utm_campaign=2022:+Pakistan+Emergency https://www.unicef.org.nz/appeal/pakistan-flood-emergency?ut...
- a_square_peg 4y agoFor some perspective on recent droughts and floods: https://twitter.com/oikoweather/status/1338691244470403075 https://twitter.com/oikoweather/status/1338691244470403075 Since 1950, the warming climate has evaporated about twice the volume of Lake Erie - that's a lot more water in the atmosphere to rain hard when it comes down.
- frozencell 4y agoSounds like mining is partly responsible. This time they can’t blame colonialism.
- killyourcar 4y agoWhat do they mine, and what do they do with the mined resources? Usually, extractive industries result in resources flowing to former colonial powers (because those powers tended to have strong economies, which were often a result of colonialism). Just like how making redlining illegal didn't immediately fix the problems it introduced, moving to a post colonial government doesn't immediately address problems and systems introduced by a colonial past.
- seanw444 4y agoThat's one of the rules of modern society: people will find any way to blame anything on colonialism. Scapegoats are nice because you don't have to fix anything yourself.
- rayiner 4y agoAs someone from that part of the world, this is one of those reasons I think western liberals are actually a threat to the prosperity of south Asia. It’s a double whammy because anti-colonialism also keeps us from adopting efficacious social patterns from western countries. (Not invented here syndrome.) Let white people in Britain fight over how many trillions colonialism expropriated from India. It’s irrelevant to desis. Britain is a shadow of its former self. They don’t have the resources to do anything about what happened.
- wizofaus 4y agoPerhaps it's human nature though for at least part of your cultural identity to be defined by the degree to which you differentiate yourself from other cultures. I'd think that must at least explain a lot of anti-Western sentiment in the world even in places that would seem obviously able to benefit from adopting at least some of the institutions and basic principles that have proven themselves successful in the Western world. The fact that so few places have successfully done so (Japan and S. Korea being two obvious examples) is telling.
- ryzvonusef 4y agoA previous thread on the same topic: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32645836 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32645836
- Havoc 4y agoJikes. I seem to recall that Pakistan's finances are also looking rather shaky at the moment. Hope things revert to normal asap on both fronts
- Sharlin 4y agoThere won't be anything close to "back to normal" for Pakistan anymore. It's in the top three countries most vulnerable to climate change (as in, most affected, least able to adapt) and there will likely be tens or hundreds of millions of climate refugees in the coming decades.
- hedora 4y agoYour statement is technically true, but there are 33 million today, just from this one event.
- wizofaus 4y agoIs there a serious expectation that millions will be attempting to relocate permanently just from this one event? Adapting to a new normal where extreme flooding happens far more regularly seems intuitively slightly less problematic than trying to adapt to frequent extreme heat/drought, storms, fires, outbreaks of disease etc. - indeed the ancient Egyptian empire is often presented as having thrived partly because of regular flood events, and there are entire cities in countries like Bangladesh that routinely cope with flood events that would be considered extreme in most other parts of the world. Having said that Bangladesh itself has been seeing huge levels of internal migration (primarily to Dhaka) triggered by recent flooding, so clearly there's some point at which continued adaptation in a given area becomes impossible, at least not without massive investments in infrastructure that are beyond what many such countries will be able to afford. Still, if forced to choose between a neighborhood that suffers frequent mega-floods and one that has to deal with regular droughts or super-cyclones or uncontrollable bushfires or indeed a permanent increase in water levels due to sea level rise, the former seems the least worst option. Interestingly two of the most deadly natural disasters in history were flooding events along the Yangtze River in the late 1800s and then the 1930s, killing millions. Yet people still live there in huge numbers today...
- SilasX 4y agoSearch feature broken for some? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32645836 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32645836
- kurupt213 4y ago
- hedora 4y agoThese floods devastated Pakistan's cotton and rice crops. In related news, Spain's ongoing worst-ever-recorded drought is devastating their olive and sunflower oil crops this year: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-62707435 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-62707435 I wonder if the rain hitting Pakistan is "Spain's water" or if it's coming via a different atmospheric route.
- locallost 4y agoThe drought hit all of western Europe hard, not just Spain. To my admittedly vague understanding of this, it's expected and related. Even the drought areas are now suspectable to floods as the land is so dry it lost the ability to soak up water. It's a vicious circle.
- koheripbal 4y agoIt can be misleading to pull individual data points on crop performance. US and Canadian wheat and corn crops are doing great this year.
- AareyBaba 4y ago<I wonder if the rain hitting Pakistan is "Spain's water" or if it's coming via a different atmospheric route. > By golly, you might be onto something. If you look at a map, there is a straight line from Pakistan across the Arabian Sea, around Yemen, up the Red Sea through the Suez Canal and right across the Mediterranean to Spain. So it is conceivable the rain in Spain stays mainly in the Balochistan plain!
- Kalanos 4y agodidn't the same thing happen in 2010? https://www.criticalthreats.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Pakistan-Flood-Severity-by-District-High-Quality-8-26-2010.png https://www.criticalthreats.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/P...
- hedora 4y agoAccording to wikipedia, that left 300,000 people internally displaced: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Pakistan_Floods https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2016_Pakistan_Floods 33 million are currently being impacted by the floods. I'm not sure how comparable those two statistics are. However, it seems unlikely that there will only be 300,000 displaced people once the water recedes. Also, the map you linked shows districts that were hit by flooding in red or orange, and about 33% of the map is colored. I assume that they colored a district if any significant fraction was under water. That's very different than the current situation, where 33% of the land is under water.
- koheripbal 4y ago33% of the land isn't underwater. A simple view of the flood map makes it clear the headline is exaggerated.
- verisimi 4y agoIf 1/3 of Pakistan is underwater I'll eat my hat. That has got to be BS of the highest order. If it said 1/3 of the country had been rained on - perhaps. What a ridiculous lie as the headline.
- hedora 4y ago15% of the people in the country have been evacuated.
- emporas 4y agoPakistan is a ridiculously flat country. As a greek, i cannot stand flat terains even one bit. Maybe flat terrains have the downside of flooding. I am not a priest of the climate religion, but maybe it is the case that flat ground doesn't guide the water to that one place, a river or something, and the water spreads all around. I am not familiar with water falling from the sky anyway, maybe a priest of the climate religion is better informed than me.
- selimthegrim 4y agoUm, there are these mountain ranges called Kirthar, Salt Range, Hindu Kush, Himalayas…
- pengaru 4y ago> This year we saw that the flood waters are not receding, it's not > flowing. People are criticizing government that they have allowed > developers to make the buildings and the residential plaza just on the > waterways so the water is not going anywhere so this is increasing the > severity of this flooding in across the pakistan and it's become every > year it's become very very means a serious problem for pakistan - Amar Auriro, Environment Journalist in Karachi [0] [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdVgaOdV5xM&t=220s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gdVgaOdV5xM&t=220s
- mrtri 4y ago
- Maursault 4y agoThat is a 113,503 sq.mi. surface of water, which is about 80% of the surface area of the Caspian Sea, or roughly the surface area of 3.6 Lake Superiors, or the surface area of all the Great Lakes combined plus nearly another Lake Michigan. With an average elevation of nearly 3000 ft., one must consider, "what countries are down the hill from Pakistan?" [0] https://www.npr.org/sections/pictureshow/2022/08/30/1119979965/pakistan-floods-monsoon-climate https://www.npr.org/sections/pictureshow/2022/08/30/11199799...