4 ms·
>If you ever find yourself about to say that Nixon did something that a non-evil person would do, you’d better triple check your facts. Actually Nixon did seve
by coldtea 4y ago
>If you ever find yourself about to say that Nixon did something that a non-evil person would do, you’d better triple check your facts.
Actually Nixon did several things "a non-evil person would do", Nixon as evil is a carricature.
Like giving back Native American lands, or green-lighting the first major environmental protection legislation, or to get talking with China. And of course the Vietnam war itself was escalated by the "good" JFK, and even more so Johnson.
Later presidents did things many times worse than Nixon (his Watergate business included) and got off scot-free. But Nixon had an ugly mug, and was an old-style politician, in an era when the boomers were young and "rebellious" and wanted someone more trendy.
- beebeepka 4y agoI've never been into history, so my perception of the guy was "formed" almost entirely by Futurama. So, in reality I don't know anything about Nixon except I do not want him to get Cambodian on my ass
- oblak 4y ago> It is estimated that between 50,000 and 150,000 people were killed during the bombing of Cambodia between 1970 and 1973.[152] I guess Wikipedia is all wrong again, huh
- mcv 4y agoHe very nearly signed a Basic Income law. I originally read that the Democrats voted against it because it was too low, but more recently read that someone convinced Nixon that a Basic Income would have terrible consequences based on some faulty historical information about the Speenhamland system, which turned Nixon against BI. But it was close; he could have made history in a much more positive way than what we currently remember him for.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoThe seventies were an odd time - the generation who had come of age during WWII were in power. And WWII had the strangest historical anomoly - wealth was most evenly distributed post WWII than at any time prior. And it was working. It seemed a great idea to experiment with other ways to keep wealth fairly distributed. What a shame power and wealth found it's way back to the few. We will have to fix that. preferably without a global war
- roenxi 4y agoEveryone was equal because they bombed most of the existing capital until there were only smoking craters left and set the poor to killing each other. It should be a great example of why inequality is a good thing - everyone wants to solve inequality by raising the poor up to be billionaires, but the only way we actually know how is to destroy all the capital that the billionaires own so we all have access to nothing. Someone else being well off doesn't have to make life worse for anyone. People need to live with that truth.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoThroughout human history someone being wealthy almost always meant someone else being exploited - from obvious chattel slavery to less obvious trading networks That these exploitations often created empires that created institutions that themselves promoted higher efficiency in trade (like protecting from piracy and brigands) was a good thing. But trade, whilst always a win win, can be and for empires always was structured to win more towards the centre of the empire This structural inequality is found everywhere. In strong and weak forms. A weak form is commonly known - wealthy people "cheat" to get their kids into MIT or Harvard, (or even being wealthy is a cheat) and then the networks formed their help with access to resources later (see VC funds two kids from MIT with idea for ...) Strong examples of structural inequality are found in say the Russian Federations army where the head of the armed forces has multiple houses and yachts and oddly the conscripts are fighting on a dollar a day and often come from rural impoverished areas. None of this your fault. But we choose our structures, our institutions in the same way we choose our built environments. If we have Houston-like 20 lane highways with nose to nose traffic when we could have please t walkable cities with electric trams and steeet cafes then yeah, none of that is the fault of the people in the traffic jams. But it was a choice. A choice made in these cases in a democracy. And we just assume that if people were given informed choices they would not have gone "hell yeah 20 lane highway". So the solution to bad structures, bad institutions, bad urban environments is democracy. Is people making their voices heard and choices being made that are the informed choices people want (I assume most people will vote for "more equal") Yet the next step is a leap of faith. Faith in democracy and human intelligence The networks will work to keep themselves in power and are a centralising force (gather more power to self) but human wealth now depends not on control of land but intelligent use of excess energy and political stability So does someone have wealth today? That's nice. Is the structure of how they got it a fair one? Is it right that someone who has capital today should continue to direct the use of that capital? Is it fair that a founder gets 80% of the shares but the first engineer gets 1%? I know it was a trade but capitalism is structured like the above empires were structured - to benefit the capital city. Is that the only way to structure the allocation of resources in the planet? The use of coal and oil has seen an outrageous chnage in human wealth. Fantastic. And the conditions for that industrial revolution are so weird that tinkering with it seems so risky. but the two world wars showed that it is a fairly robust revolution- and if we want to get out from the oil / CO2 trap and into a sustainable future we need to overcome bad resource allocation - it's time to try new options. Private Companies are undemocratic and control about 50% of western wealth, is a hierarchy like that the best way to allocate and motivate resources? Most western nations are highly centralised - does that make for th best local decisions? There are options
- masonic 4y ago>He very nearly signed a Basic Income law. What such law ever passed Congress during his tenure?
- anothernewdude 4y ago> to get talking with China. What a waste of time that was.
- coldtea 4y agoIt was quite the opposite. It gave the US capitalism a new lease of life in the 90s, and of course it helped China (that's 1.6 billion people and counting) grow.
- roenxi 4y agoIt was one of the early events in the greatest material bettering of human existence in the history of history. You have high standards.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoYes. The first thing the chinese government did after Nixon ended sanctions and allowed trade, was to order 12 fertiliser plants from R W Kellogs (not the cornflakes one). Giant things that squeeze ammonia out of the atmosphere. That meant climbing out of a starvation cycle. Nixon going to China probably saved 100s of millions of lives. Chinese lives of course but lives. Sadly for Nixon the lives he saved did not vote in Chicago. Nixon was not evil. People arent evil. Decisions people make are evil.
- Aeolun 4y agoPeople are definitely evil. Just never from their own perspective.