15 ms·
Not the person you are replying to, and I'm not 100% sure they are correct, but I think I understand where they are coming from. The SLS+Orion architecture is a
by adastra22 4y ago
Not the person you are replying to, and I'm not 100% sure they are correct, but I think I understand where they are coming from. The SLS+Orion architecture is a colossal waste of Spruce Goose proportions. It was a project designed by congress to be maximally inefficient (AKA employ the most contractors in key districts) and without any regard to actual exploration needs. And since use of SLS and Orion is literally mandated by law, NASA has designed its entire Artemis architecture around this pointless rocket which can't even reach the Moon. That's the real reason NASA is building a space station in a bizarre near-rectilinear halo orbit distant from the Moon itself: that's as close as Orion can actually get.
Back at the beginning of the Obama administration NASA had a blue-ribbon committee to investigate what should be done about the over-budget exploration program that was supposed to replace the Shuttle. The conclusion was that NASA should scrap the Shuttle-derived launcher it was working on and develop a "flexible path" program of exploration where rides are bought on commercial vehicles, used to explore whatever the frontier is that is reachable with off-the-shelf commercial technology. This would be paid for by cancelling the rocket and Orion capsule that was being worked on. The legacy aerospace companies that were making bank obviously didn't want the gravy train to end, so they got their bought and paid for congressional reps to literally write in the NASA authorization law a mandate for NASA to design and use their own rocket (the SLS) and the Orion capsule. Congressional staffers even wrote in the exact specifications of this rocket without consulting NASA about whether the specs made any sense at all (they didn't--they were designed to ensure sole source contracts to existing contractors, but with enough changes that lucrative development work would be needed). As such we went from a rocket that was supposed to launch 2-4 times per year, to one which costs 10 times as much and launches once per every 2 years. And one that is even incapable of getting its spacecraft payload to the Moon.
Furthermore, because use of this rocket is mandated by law the entire exploration program around it had to be adjusted to accommodate its inefficiencies. Since the rocket can't get to the moon, a whole space station (Gateway) is built in a totally useless deep space orbit to serve as a destination and staging area for lunar missions. But because of orbital dynamics this prevents many portions of the moon from being accessible to lunar missions, and limits options for direct abort, making lunar missions significantly more dangerous. Also all the effort that could go into making a permanently occupied based on the moon is instead being spent on this useless tollbooth in the middle of nowhere.
My favorite anecdote about the absolute waste of this program is regarding the SLS main engines. The SLS uses 4 modified space shuttle main engines on its first stage. The SLS rocket that is currently prepping for launch in Florida actually has 2 engines on it that were pulled off Shuttle Atlantis before it was put in a museum. These are historic engines that flew many missions in space and arguably ought to be in a museum themselves, or at least cut apart in cross section as teaching tools in engineering colleges. Instead these fully reusable engines, which initially cost about $40M each, were refurbished at a price of $150M(!) each to make them expendable(!!), and are going to be unceremoniously chucked into the ocean a few hundred miles off the coast as part of the SLS launch. That is not a typo: they spent $150M to make a $40M already reusable engine single-use. Actually they spent $600M, over half a billion dollars, to throw away 4 of these engines. Madness.
So the argument goes: this insanity is doing nothing but wasting national treasure and distracting NASA from any meaningful exploration. The SLS is a cancer which has mestasticized to infect the entire human spaceflight program. It needs to be cancelled ASAP, and all the architectures built off it rethought from the ground up if we are to have a national spaceflight program that is in any way meaningful.
(The counter-argument is that cancelling the SLS + Orion programs won't free up money for other exploration projects. This is congressional pork. If you cancel the program, NASA budget will be reduced in the process. Arguably for the taxpayer and the nation this is a good thing, but not for NASA. From the perspective of NASA the SLS + Orion is a free gift of a corrupt congress, and beggars can't be choosers.)
- bayesian_horse 4y agoThat is a very narrow-minded viewpoint I think. There is currently no comparable rocket system comparable to SLS even with all its warts. If it flies today, it's the only operational Human rated heavy lift system. Starship is promising, but still a lot more speculative. Using the shuttle systems reduces the engineering risks. This means that SLS may be more expensive than something scratch-designed, but there is also a lot less insecurity in the schedule (though there was enough ...). I don't think there was a way for NASA to start the Artemis program sooner than with SLS. I don't think it's a good idea to entirely depend on SpaceX for heavy lift rockets or human rated space flight. I also don't understand your point about Orion not being able to go to the moon. Of course it "could" get as close to the moon as it wants. But it is basically a command and reentry module, not a lander. There are more potential missions for the Orion than for a combined lander and reentry module. So you'd have some kind of rendezvous in any case which also saves fuel.
- panick21_ 4y agoSLS was never needed for a moon program. I don't knew where people get this idea. You can use commercial rockets to go to LEO and stage of from there. I don't know why this is hard to understand. NASA knew this in 2011. > I don't think it's a good idea to entirely depend on SpaceX for heavy lift rockets or human rated space flight. They wouldn't have to. You have Crew Dragon and Starliner, both have potentially multiple rockets they could go on. > I also don't understand your point about Orion not being able to go to the moon. The point is that the Orion Service Module developed by ESA is seriously under-powered and NASA has to design around those constraints (and btw its an additional cost of SLS/Orion as this is paid for by NASA not ESA). Orion can't go into LLO and back.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- adastra22 4y ago> There is currently no comparable rocket system comparable to SLS even with all its warts. If it flies today, it's the only operational Human rated heavy lift system. Starship is promising, but still a lot more speculative. It's human-rated only because NASA says it is. It has literally never flown. The NASA rules for human-rating its own internal-designed craft are way looser than the rules for human-rating commercial craft. SpaceX and Boeing had to jump through way more hoops to get their platforms human-rated by NASA. Artemis could just as easily be done by launching Orion + service module, and upper stage to LEO on separate Falcon Heavy launches, then launching crew on Dragon or Starliner. No starship required. It would be 3 launches, but with autonomous LEO rendezvous there would be no risk to the crew, for about 1/10th the cost (or alternatively, 5 missions a year instead of 1 every 2 years). This, btw, was NASA's plan before congress mandated the use of SLS! > Using the shuttle systems reduces the engineering risks. The extensive changes made for SLS and the fact that ~none of the original engineers were involved invalidates all that heritage. Or at least it would if NASA held the SLS program to the same standards as commercial industry. > This means that SLS may be more expensive than something scratch-designed, but there is also a lot less insecurity in the schedule (though there was enough ...). SLS has had more budget and timeline overruns than anything else out there. Even SpaceX's famously optimistic "Elon time" is not as bad as SLS's delays. > I don't think there was a way for NASA to start the Artemis program sooner than with SLS. Again, this was the plan before congress got in the way. I remember it vividly as I worked at NASA at the time. > I don't think it's a good idea to entirely depend on SpaceX for heavy lift rockets or human rated space flight. ULA would be happy to develop a super-heavy Vulcan. Or Rocket Lab. Or Relativity. etc. Do the same as COTS: fully fund two providers, and if one drops out then fund a 3rd. > I also don't understand your point about Orion not being able to go to the moon. Orion has insufficient fuel to enter circular LLO (like Apollo) and still get home. It's too heavy and under-powered compared with the Apollo Command and Service Modules.