9 ms·
You forgot the launch cost! One of their single-use engines costs more than any SpaceX rocket… which are all reusable.
by jiggawatts 4y ago
You forgot the launch cost!
One of their single-use engines costs more than any SpaceX rocket… which are all reusable.
- syntaxing 4y agoAren’t rockets to the moon vs LEO and GEO on completely different levels of requirements?
- criddell 4y agoI’m curious about this too. Are any of the private companies anywhere near ready to send a ship to the moon and back?
- XorNot 4y agoSpaceX is closest, but no. Not until Starship flies. If history is any guide and they haven't missed any big blockers though, then they'll get there - but I think a 10 year horizon is probably a reasonable expectation.
- gpm 4y agoFalcon Heavy (existing SpaceX rocket, not human rated) can get a ship to above the moon and back today, but probably not within enough margin to land on the moon in one launch. Making a lander which launches on top of it would require substantial development work anyways, so not really close (and not planned). Starship is a SpaceX rocket reasonably late in the development cycle, and is planned to land on the moon in an uncrewed demonstration flight no earlier than 2024, and with people during NASA's Artemis 3 mission no earlier than 2025. According to the plan this will be the first mission to land people on the moon since Apollo. SLS at this point is not planning on launching a vehicle that lands on the moon, instead just a very very expensive taxi to a starship in lunar orbit which could have easily carried the astronauts there itself...
- killyourcar 4y agoThat said, it seems unlikely that a vehicle will go from "has never reached orbit and has a novel refueling model" to "is rated for human spaceflight" in a year or two. I think the Starship is cool as hell, but realistically we're probably looking at 2027+ before we see substantial missions on it.
- gpm 4y agoNo earlier than dates are optimistic by nature. I could believe the dates if everything (from launches to environmental approvals) goes well, that is unlikely though. Regardless of the dates, Artemis using starship as a lander seems practically guaranteed at this point, so SLS really is relegated to the role of unnecessary taxi...
- adastra22 4y agoOn-orbit refueling is neither very complex nor untried.
- killyourcar 4y agoReally? We've loaded that much cryogenic fuel before on a manned mission? Pretty sure it's untried. Theoretically easy, just like launching starship is theoretically easy.
- adastra22 4y agoFuel transfer is mechanically the same whether there are people around or not, and whether you are talking 1 ton of propellant or 100 tons.
- killyourcar 4y agoIt does matter if people aboard, there are more rules and procedures. You need a vessel with safeties that can allow them to eject safely if there's an anomaly. Of course it's more challenging. And it does matter if there's more fuel, you have to have valves and pipes that won't freeze after lengthy contact with cryogenic fuel. And you need larger pressure vessels, which scale in volume differently from surface area. It's not at all the same whether you move one ton or a hundred.
- elurg 4y agoYes. If you send stuff to orbit you can probably also send stuff to the Moon, it's just a payload penalty. Several Moon missions were launched on commercial rockets. Even tiny RocketLab launched one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAPSTONE https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/CAPSTONE
- WWLink 4y agoTo send starship to the moon takes 5-10 more starships to refuel it first. Of course, comparing orion to starship is like comparing a dragon to the space shuttle. Starship is enormous and that's why it needs so much fuel lol. I'm not saying there's room for improvement, but I think people neg Artemis way too hard for what it is. And people give Starship too much credit for what it is (so far). (And I DO like the idea of Starship and hope it succeeds). If it succeeds things will be awesome!
- midasuni 4y agoStarship hasn’t made orbit yet. I’m hopefully it will, even factoring in Elon time (wasn’t he talking about reaching Mars unmanned in 2024?) it’s slow going. I’m hopeful it will meat here falcons success, but until then compare what’s actually possible today.
- Veedrac 4y agoThat is a very unfair comparison. You are giving numbers for Starship going to NRHO, then landing the whole upper stage on the moon, then returning it to NRHO. That is a completely different ballpark to SLS's ‘dump a capsule in a lunar flyby which itself can't even get to LLO’. And if the SLS/Orion architecture wasn't so underperforming, Starship could waste less energy making up for it.
- panick21_ 4y agoNot really. If you have enough payload to LEO you can also throw something to TLI, just less. All commercial rockets like Falcon 9 or Atlas 5 can throw lots of payload to the moon as well. Even tiny rockets like Rocket Lab Electron have launched moon missions. Now what is true that the further out you go, a hydrogen RL-10 based upper stage will win out better then a Falcon 9 based kerlox upper stage. So while the payload to LEO between rockets can be pretty close, the payload to a moon orbit can be quite different.
- Aeolun 4y agoEh, once you get to orbit you are more than halfway there. Once you get to the moon you need only very little deltaV to make it back. But yeah, they’re on completely different levels.
- wumpus 4y agoI've seen a lot of people claim that, but it's misleading. Falcon Heavy is the most powerful rocket to LEO, GEO, TLI (trans lunar injection), and higher energy orbits like the ones you use for Jupiter and beyond. When SLS finishes development, it will also hold the record for all 3.
- mlindner 4y agoNo. Falcon 9 can launch objects to the moon as well.
- killyourcar 4y agoNot to and from the moon. It has a Delta v budget a little low for a full round trip that includes a landing and ascent, iirc. It could hurl something at the moon though.
- panick21_ 4y agoSLS can't do that either ...
- killyourcar 4y agoThe Artemis 3 will launch on SLS and land humans on the moon?
- Aloha 4y agoCosts will come down - while yes, it'll still be more expensive because its a heavy lift vehicle - comparing it to SpaceX is comparing Apples and Wednesday. The way SpaceX does programatic accounting, and the way NASA does programatic accounting are I suspect, wildly different. NASA itself estimates costs of about 800m+ each (depending how you account for program overhead). Also, if SLS is used to launch stuff to LEO, its a cosmic waste of money. None of the Falcon rockets can really meet the program goals of SLS.
- panick21_ 4y agoA whole number of things wrong here. First of all, that 800m number is mostly a very optimistic estimate that might come true sometime around 2030 or later. And even then its only true if you completely ignore amortization of development cost, something SpaceX can't really do. Some of the items that are getting ordered now are for rockets in the late 2020s and if you look at those unit prices its not close to 800m yet. 1b will also need a new upper stage, the price of that is as of yet pure speculation and anybody that has watched the SLS program knows that will happen before its done. And the unit price will also not be there. SLS will almost certainty be canceled before they reach anywhere close to 800m a launch. > None of the Falcon rockets can really meet the program goals of SLS. That is simply not true, or rather, its only true as so far as the whole Artemis program was designed to use SLS. When the NASA administrator suggest that Falcon Heavies could be used some in congress threatened him and seriously suggested he should resign. He shut up quite fast after that. Many at NASA in the early 2010s didn't want SLS, simple because such a rocket is not required. And even today with a few changes and tweaks it wouldn't be required. But of course if you spend 45 billion into a specific solution it will be better then the solution you spend 0$ on. But even so, its still not to late, even now canceling SLS and redesigning Artemis would be worth it. Artemis assumes that Starship will exist anyway, and human transport to LEO is fixed already. Starship is the lander already. So really, only thing you need is somehow to get humans from LEO to the moon. And guess what, Starship already has to fly that anyway.
- Aloha 4y ago> SLS will almost certainty be canceled before they reach anywhere close to 800m a launch. Thats, speculation, one covered in the source article, that notes, because of the spread of the project - virtually every state makes something for it, its proven itself more or less immune to budget cuts because of this. Beyond that, there is a dearth of heavy lift rockets out there, the idea of a single source from SpaceX is.. one, contrary to normal federal procurement rules, and two, not a sane idea - if for no there reason than it doesnt match the mission profile for a lunar mission. I'll note, that even a Block I SLS launches 30t more into LEO than Falcon Heavy does, the numbers go up even higher for later blocks, presumably this advantage is even high for lunar missions.
- Dalewyn 4y agoIt's worth mentioning the "single-use engine" you refer to is, in fact, the Space Shuttle Main Engine. Yes, those reusable engines used on the Space Shuttle.
- gammarator 4y agoBut Artemis does not, in fact, reuse them.
- Dalewyn 4y agoIndeed, my point exactly.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoNothing SpaceX currently has can bring Humans to the moon. Yes, SLS is expensive and inefficient, but it is ready to fly.
- amself 4y agoFalcon Heavy could send Crew Dragon to the Moon. They’d just have to rate it for human space flight.
- bayesian_horse 4y agoWhich means they don't have anything that can take Humans to the Moon. That certification requires the technology to be much more proven. Also Falcon Heavy only carries 26t into LEO so I actually doubt it would be enough (don't know for sure). At the very least you need a transfer stage of course. Next problem would be Crew Dragon itself. It's probably not able to return from the moon, the speed and thus the temperature is higher so you need a capsule designed for this. Which Orion is and Dragon isn't.
- adastra22 4y ago> That certification requires the technology to be much more proven. Human rating certification is more about paperwork, not technology demonstration.
- panick21_ 4y ago> Which means they don't have anything that can take Humans to the Moon. Neither does the SLS/Orion stack. What are you even comparing here? A lander is required anyway. > Also Falcon Heavy only carries 26t into LEO I assume you don't mean LEO. > Next problem would be Crew Dragon itself. It's probably not able to return from the moon, the speed and thus the temperature is higher so you need a capsule designed for this. Which Orion is and Dragon isn't. Actually, the Crew Dragon Heat Shield is designed for moon reentry. There might be a few updates for avionics but nothing to big. SLS/Orion/Orion SM and Falcon Heavy/Dragon stack are both underpowered. There are solution to this is you were willing to invest the smallest amount of money. Dragon could be extend by adding a extra fuel tank into the trunk. That would be a reasonably cheap solution. Alternatively a separately launched Service Module. That would likely cost a few 100M, but that is jump change compared to SLS/Orion. Or even better, don't launch the capsule to moon orbit at all, switch to the moon lander in LEO. Then you can simply use commercial crew to get the astronauts up and down and the lander to go to the moon and back. All of these idea would save 10s of billions.