3 ms·
I watched this guy's Youtube video and think he's a kook, but interested in reading this to see what he says.
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
I watched this guy's Youtube video and think he's a kook, but interested in reading this to see what he says.
- philipkglass 4y agoThere are multiple questionable assumptions but I'll focus on one early one. "There is a current paradigm to phase out fossil fuels and all associated infrastructure. This will require an unprecedented volume of metals of all kinds. In particular, technology metals. Technology metals are the building materials needed to manufacture much of current state-of-the-art technology. Technology metals could include: Be, B, Sc, V, Ga, Ge, Se, Sr, Y, Zr, In, Te, Cs, Ba, La, Hf, Ta, Os, Tl, Li, Ru, W, Cd, Hg, Sb, Ir, Mo and Mg." This appears to be a random selection of metals, presented without justification. Nothing about transitioning away from fossil energy requires more mercury, osmium, strontium, barium, or thallium. They're not needed in wind turbines, batteries, solar cells, nuclear reactors, electric motors, electrolyzers, power electronics, or fuel cells. Did the author actually have other energy-transition-critical applications in mind or is he just trying to dazzle with quantity?
- HWR_14 4y ago> They're not needed in wind turbines, batteries, solar cells, nuclear reactors, electric motors, electrolyzers, power electronics, or fuel cells Except they are used in the production the semiconductors that control EVs, battery charging, etc. It's also used in the production of batteries. You're supposed to recycle your AA batteries, for instance, because of the mercuric-oxide.
- philipkglass 4y agoExcept they are used in the production the semiconductors that control EVs, battery charging, etc. What is thallium needed for in semiconductor manufacturing? I tried searching Google Scholar and didn't turn up anything relevant. I've never seen thallium mentioned alongside semiconductor production in chemistry handbooks or chemical engineering encyclopedias either. Global thallium production declined from 15,000 kilograms in 1994 [1] to less than 8,000 kilograms in 2018 [2] even as semiconductor production volumes increased enormously, so I am skeptical that thallium is needed for semiconductor production. Mercury is banned in alkaline batteries in the US since 1996: https://www.epa.gov/mercury/mercury-batteries https://www.epa.gov/mercury/mercury-batteries Panasonic claims that the battery mercury ban is worldwide now (and they should know), but unfortunately does not cite the relevant legislation: https://www.panasonic-batteries.com/en/news/mercury-batteries-why-they-were-popular-and-banned https://www.panasonic-batteries.com/en/news/mercury-batterie... [1] USGS mineral commodity summaries, "thallium", 1996: https://d9-wret.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/assets/palladium/production/mineral-pubs/thallium/thallmcs96.pdf https://d9-wret.s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/assets/palladium/... [2] USGS mineral commodity summaries, "thallium", 2018: https://d9-wret.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/assets/palladium/production/atoms/files/mcs-2019-thall.pdf https://d9-wret.s3-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/assets/palladium/...
- fallingfrog 4y agoHe's a senior researcher at the Geological Survey of Finland.. His conclusions may or may not be correct, but surely "kook" is unfair.
- legitster 4y agoI mean, if they can't 1 out of 5 dentists to recommend brushing your teeth, surely there can be kooks in academia.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt's possible, some might even say easy, to be both an academic and a kook, particularly so when you dive into areas that aren't your speciality and are 'political' like evolution, or climate change. I'm sure he knows lots about mining, but he has a Fox News level of understanding about renewables.
- scottLobster 4y agoPlenty of academics fall into the category of "unbalanced". That being they're amazing at one hyper-specialization that gives them a huge ego, and then they assume they're equally amazing at everything else and end up making complete fools of themselves. I wouldn't presume anything based solely on a credential. Intelligence is not correlated with wisdom or humility.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoHis heart seems in the right place, probably just been consuming too much of the wrong type of news leaving him with some very odd starting points. Key errors: * thinking ERoEI is a thing that matters (sub-error, thinking fossil fuels do better on this score if it did matter) https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/examining-the-limits-of-energy-return-on-investment https://www.greentechmedia.com/articles/read/examining-the-l... * following on from the above, expecting energy prices to rise long term as a result of this * a weird assumption that mining requires fossil fuels (which if true, would make the above thing worse, if it was true, which it isn't) https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/metals-and-mining/our-insights/creating-the-zero-carbon-mine https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/metals-and-mining/our-in... * thinking no-one else has thought of this and the whole net-zero thing is just some EU beaurocrats half-baked idea. His ideas for entirely replacing capitalism with something based on resource scarcity are interesting though.
- brutusborn 4y agoWhy doesn't ERoEI matter? And I think it's unfair so say he assumes mining requirs fossil fuels, he just highlights how dependant mining is on fossil fuels _now_ and for the forseeable future. Also, I had to check about how mining electrification is going, and I was pleasantly surprised to find a lot of electric mining vehicles currently available! https://www.epiroc.com/en-in/products/loaders-and-trucks/electric-trucks https://www.epiroc.com/en-in/products/loaders-and-trucks/ele...
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI linked an intro level article on why ERoEI is silly, but this one goes into more depth. "ERoEI is Unimportant and is being used incorrectly" https://bountifulenergy.blogspot.com/2016/06/eroei-is-unimportant-and-is-being-used.html?m=1 https://bountifulenergy.blogspot.com/2016/06/eroei-is-unimpo... > In this article I will show that ERoEI is unimportant by itself. It usually does not matter if ERoEI is increasing or decreasing. ERoEI provides no guidance about which sources of energy we should pursue, nor does it offer any guidance about how much net energy will be available to us in the future. By itself, ERoEI is a useless figure, unless it is lower than 1, which it almost never is. Although different sources of energy (such as coal or solar PV) have different ERoEI ratios, this means nothing important. Also: Why renewables have a higher eroei https://bountifulenergy.blogspot.com/2014/07/renewables-have-higher-eroei-than.html?m=1 https://bountifulenergy.blogspot.com/2014/07/renewables-have... > Renewables have ERoEI ratios which are generally comparable to, or higher than, fossil fuels. Although peak oilers reach a different conclusion, that is because they are carrying out the calculation incorrectly. They are ignoring or not including massive waste heat losses (generally 60% or more) from combustion engines which drastically reduces the ERoEI of fossil fuels. Those waste heat losses provide no energy services to society, and should be counted as losses, but are wrongly counted as "energy returns" by peak oilers. Furthermore, peak oilers are ignoring or not counting other large energy losses of fossil fuels. Those omissions exaggerate the ERoEI of fossil fuels relative to renewables. When the calculation is carried out correctly, renewables have higher ERoEI ratios than fossil fuels.