5 ms·
Going to tread lightly here, but here is the section on 4 "facts" about long COVID: > In this note, I use two survey datasets to document four facts about long
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Going to tread lightly here, but here is the section on 4 "facts" about long COVID:
> In this note, I use two survey datasets to document four facts about long COVID in the United States. First, long-term COVID symptoms are much more prevalent among women, adults under 65, Hispanics and Latinos, and non–college graduates than among other demographic groups. Second, COVID "long haulers" cite specific physical and cognitive impairments commonly associated with the condition in media and medical reporting. Third, the share of working-age adults reporting serious difficulty remembering, concentrating, or making decisions has risen steadily since the start of the pandemic. Fourth, growing shares of women and of non–college graduates report simultaneously (i) being out of the labor force due to disability and (ii) experiencing these cognitive difficulties.
I'm generally interested in a good summary of what medical research tells us about long COVID. Reason being I think it's fair to hypothesize that the following facts are at least fair confounding factors:
1. Whenever economic situations become weaker, disability rates rise. This is largely because people who are "on the cusp" may find it worth it to find a job in good times, but in bad times find it's not worth it to "push through" their disability.
2. There has been so much news coverage about long COVID that it's difficult for me to tell how it compares to other long term viral syndromes. E.g. infection with Epstein Barr virus has long been implicated in a lost of long term conditions like CFS and MS. Is long COVID more common in COVID sufferers than these other syndromes are in EB infection?
3. There have been huge societal changes that have occurred in the past couple years that can make it difficult to tease out the effects of COVID alone.
Not trying to discount any individual suffering from long COVID symptoms, but I think caution is warranted when trying to ascertain the effects at a society-wide level, especially when all the data for this article appears to come from self-reports.
- strogonoff 4y agoCOVID is definitely not the only case where acute form might shift into a chronic one. For a recent overview see, e.g., Unexplained post-acute infection syndromes[0]. > As of now, the true extent of PAISs remains uncertain, as there is a significant risk that a lot of cases, especially under sporadic circumstances, remain unrecognized. > The research that is available concentrates on PAISs in the context of either well-monitored acute infectious diseases, or as a follow-up of outbreaks and epidemics. [0] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01810-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-01810-6
- AnonCoward42 4y agoAnd I want to add that side effects of the vaccination are often treated as long COVID as well. Long COVID is a representation of symptoms, therefore this is not unusual that it is classified the same, however one might mistake these as virus related when some are not.
- pezo1919 4y agoThey are very similar, but if you have the data from both set you can clearly see the difference. Unfortunately both long covid and vaccine side effects are underplayed.
- AnonCoward42 4y ago> They are very similar, but if you have the data from both set you can clearly see the difference. It depends also on case by case basis, however long COVID is diagnosed in some patients with/as vaccination side effect. Even if it might be possible that these can be clearly differentiated, it's not done. It is also not that clearly defined and therefore overlaps with some other syndroms like fibromyalgia, which might be a confounding factor as well.
- dmix 4y ago> I'm generally interested in a good summary of what medical research tells us about long COVID. Has there been any good summaries?
- dogmatism 4y agoYes, Eric Topol wrote one up for the LA times recently
- jointpdf 4y agoFrom his blog: https://erictopol.substack.com/p/some-light-on-long-covid https://erictopol.substack.com/p/some-light-on-long-covid
- bigDinosaur 4y agoI kind of don't care about most of the symptoms listed in the studies he cites. Getting headaches or random fatigue in no way compares to the PEM of CFS or persistent brain fog which causes severe executive dysfunction. I find the whole discussion around long covid to be frustrating: simultaneously inflating figures on one hand while underrating the truly severe outcomes (which can happen with all viral diseases).
- d0mine 4y agohttps://www.science.org/content/article/blood-abnormalities-found-people-long-covid https://www.science.org/content/article/blood-abnormalities-...
- nradov 4y agoYou might want to start with some of the original articles on post-viral fatigue syndrome going back to the 1980's. I suspect there's not much really new with long COVID. https://doi.org/10.1177/014107688808100608 https://doi.org/10.1177/014107688808100608
- __derek__ 4y ago> E.g. infection with Epstein Barr virus has long been implicated in a lost of long term conditions like CFS and MS. Sorry for the complete non sequitur, but this is the first time I've seen a reference to Epstein-Barr outside of the Sopranos (Tony's sister Janice is on disability because of it). I had no idea it was linked to MS.
- Terretta 4y agoThese four observations sound like a Rorschach test. If one thinks “long COVID” is imaginary, one can read these facts as confirmation of placebo effects or mass sociogenic illness. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_psychogenic_illness https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mass_psychogenic_illness Or, if one thinks it’s plausible, each can be read the other way, for instance: >> long-term COVID symptoms are much more prevalent among women, adults under 65, Hispanics and Latinos, and non–college graduates than among other demographic groups OK, so groups least likely to choose to isolate, or be able to isolate (because they have to work). >> Second, COVID "long haulers" cite specific physical and cognitive impairments commonly associated with the condition in media and medical reporting. Put another way, reporting and media sound like what people cite. >> Third, the share of working-age adults reporting serious difficulty remembering, concentrating, or making decisions has risen steadily since the start of the pandemic. Condition attributed to a disease known to be experienced by a steadily increasing population share, steadily increases share reporting — confirmed! >> Fourth, growing shares of women and of non–college graduates report simultaneously (i) being out of the labor force due to disability and (ii) experiencing these cognitive difficulties. So these go together, and see #1 — everything is as expected. Remarkable how simultaneously contradictory all four interpretations can be, almost as if crafted to be so.
- hn_throwaway_99 4y agoTo emphasize, though, and the point I was trying to make is that it's possible (and I think likely) that both of these statements are true: 1. Long COVID is a real disease that can cause debilitating symptoms. 2. A significant number of people who claim to suffer from Long COVID actually suffer from something else. The only thing that puts me more in the "I think #2 is a lot more prevalent than people think" camp is the astronomical amount of press that "Long COVID" has received, coupled with the fact that the majority of people in the US have been exposed to COVID, so it's easy to attribute any general feeling of being unwell (e.g. fatigue, brain fog, etc.) to the fact that you probably had COVID in the not-too-distant past.
- mlyle 4y agoI don't disagree with you. Even so: it's possible for most of it to be "not real" or "something else"-- but still carry a terrifically high disease burden.
- pezo1919 4y agoIf you are truly interested do more research focusing on clotting/microclotting. Dr Gustavo Aguirre is a true pioneer, his protocols (and others' protocols) which are based on that truly work, I manage a long covid group with 6K people.
- refurb 4y agoDerek Lowe did a nice write up of a serious study that found 189 long Covid cases and 120 controls. PCR positive and having long term Covid symptoms was the inclusion criteria. They then did a massive battery of tests - inflammation biomarkers, nerve damage biomarkers, lung function, congestive ability, etc. And the conclusion? There was no difference between the groups: there are no diagnostic findings that would allow you to even say for sure that post-Covid even exists, biochemically. https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/search-long-covid https://www.science.org/content/blog-post/search-long-covid
- pjc50 4y agoThat just means there's no diagnostic test, not that the symptoms aren't real! There aren't biomarkers for chronic pain, either, which presents a serious problem for people seeking treatment. This is the "I closed your bug report because it works on my machine" of medicine.
- refurb 4y agoThe challenge is when physical symptoms aren’t backed up by measurements of actual function. When people complain of lung or heart problems but all tests are normal (oxygen levels, cardiac efficiency, lung capacity, exercise tolerance). When people claim cognitive decline yet all measures of cognitive ability are normal. It would point to a strong psychological component for at least some people - which was found in the study. Symptoms were correlated with those having a history of anxiety disorders (prior to Covid). There was also another study (I can’t find it right now) of self-reported long Covid suffers. They ran tests and many of them had never even been infected with Covid..ever. This isn’t to say that post-viral syndromes aren’t real. But it does suggest that self-reporting isn’t all that accurate.
- austinjp 4y agoIt raises entirely valid questions, none of which should undermine the patient's experience. Listen to the patient: they're telling us something. To anticipate: "Objective" measures are of course useful, but only form part of any picture.