5 ms·
Hetzner bans running Ethereum PoS nodes
- latchkey 4y ago"Using our products for any application related to mining, even remotely related, is not permitted. This includes Ethereum. It includes proof of stake and proof of work and related applications. It includes trading. It is true for all of our products, except colocation. Even if you just run one node, we consider it a violation of our ToS. We are aware that there are many Ethereum users currently at Hetzner, and we have been internally discussing how we can best address this issue. If you, or any other potential customers are unsure about whether your use case will violate our ToS, please reach out to us. There is a general support form here (https://www.hetzner.com/support-form https://www.hetzner.com/support-form) for people who aren't yet customers. Plus there is a live chat. You can see a chat icon here (https://www.hetzner.com/dedicated-rootserver https://www.hetzner.com/dedicated-rootserver) on the far right side of the screen during our normal business hours, and click on it to chat directly with our technicians. If you are already a customer, you can reach out to us via your account on Robot/Cloud Console/konsoleH. --Katie"
- arthurcolle 4y ago"Bakery does not permit usage of buns for use in sandwiches or any bread-related multilayer meal"
- pmyteh 4y ago"Warehouse does not permit usage of storage space for rotten seafood or any kind of living quarters"
- capableweb 4y agoTitle as it stands right now ("Hetzner bans running Ethereum PoS nodes") is incorrect. Hetzner disallows running any software related to any cryptocurrencies, so be it mining, trading, storage of blockchain data for analysis, operating a node (mining/staking/farming/whatever). It doesn't seem to be specific to Ethereum (PoS or PoW) but generally about any sort of software that interacts with cryptocurrencies (or data coming from cryptocurrencies).
- latchkey 4y agoA bit more context as to why the title is absolutely correct. https://twitter.com/Hetzner_Online/status/1563083561975984130 https://twitter.com/Hetzner_Online/status/156308356197598413...
- capableweb 4y agoThat tweet links to https://old.reddit.com/r/hetzner/comments/wucxs4/is_it_allowed_to_run_a_crypto_block_chain_node/ilfoj8u/?context=3 https://old.reddit.com/r/hetzner/comments/wucxs4/is_it_allow... which says: > Using our products for any application related to mining, even remotely related, is not permitted. This includes Ethereum. It includes proof of stake and proof of work and related applications. It includes trading. It is true for all of our products, except colocation. Even if you just run one node, we consider it a violation of our ToS. That context just shows the title is incorrect, because it's not specifically about Ethereum, and not specifically about PoS. It includes those, but also includes any other cryptocurrencies, and any other proof-of-X methods.
- latchkey 4y agoIf you unroll the tweet thread, it starts with a reply from Hetzner to Maggie Love who's talking about ETH PoS. https://twitter.com/maggielove_/status/1562915484659601409 https://twitter.com/maggielove_/status/1562915484659601409 Regardless, talking about the title of the post is bike shedding. Let's move on.
- londons_explore 4y agoAnd the main reason for doing that is because cryptocurrency related projects have a much much higher rate of fraud - ie. Someone will use a stolen credit card to pay for a bunch of mining compute. If you could convince the CEO that you were not a fraudster, I'm sure the 'no crypto' policy is flexible.
- latchkey 4y agoLarger picture is that this is just running some software and now a provider is telling you what you can and cannot run on there. It becomes moral high ground vs. fraud. It is also entertaining that ETH PoS is supposed to be more decentralized in the switch from PoW to PoS... yet here we are with a large provider, that is currently hosting 17% of the network, telling people to go away. I used to work in the porn industry writing software (no, not in front of the camera). Years ago, we were using a web analytics tool that got bought by a Mormon company. We were one of their largest customers. We were told we couldn't use the software any more. This is what we are facing here.
- rvz 4y agoDoesn't look good if 14% of these nodes are sitting on Hetzner and we already have a concerning amount of centralization on more than 51% of these servers on AWS. It seems that the centralization will get worse with the move to PoS in both cases. It doesn't matter what the Ethereum maximalists / supports or even the Ethereum foundation says otherwise at this point. [0] https://ethernodes.org/networkType/Hosting https://ethernodes.org/networkType/Hosting
- mypastself 4y agoI’ve yet to find a strong argument against the claims of centralization via outsourced hosting. Hypothetically, a devastating attack on the mainnet could be triggered by a network outage, or Amazon simply complying with U.S. laws.
- PretzelPirate 4y agoI don’t think there are many (if any) who understand Ethereum who aren’t concerned around a large percentage of validators running in 3rd party clouds. On the bright side, if AWS has a large outage or simply shut down any nodes running validators, all of the validator operators would need to set up somewhere else quickly to avoid large inactivity leaks (which grow in relation to the number of offline nodes). The worst outcome would be that people would move from AWS to Azure and simply move the problem elsewhere, but ideally it will solve itself as validators get penalized more for supporting centralization of certain aspects of the protocol. The protocol has a built-in mechanic to dissuade centralization that hasn’t had an impact yet since there hasn’t been a large-scale outage affecting a single host. Once that happens, people will get a bit more cautious.
- zinekeller 4y agoIt seems that it's already in the ToS since 2021-10-27 (https://www.hetzner.com/assets/Uploads/downloads/AGB-en.pdf https://www.hetzner.com/assets/Uploads/downloads/AGB-en.pdf, Wayback Machine provides evidence of non-tampering https://web.archive.org/web/20220209111333im_/https://www.hetzner.com/assets/Uploads/downloads/AGB-en.pdf https://web.archive.org/web/20220209111333im_/https://www.he...), just enforced today presumably due to electricity usage (at least at the time that document was drafted).
- latchkey 4y agoProof of Stake doesn't increase electricity usage. It is just some software running...
- sokoloff 4y agoOK, keep going; you’re almost there… (Yes, it doesn’t require nearly as much power as proof of work, but it obviously consumes power.)
- capableweb 4y ago> (Yes, it doesn’t require nearly as much power as proof of work, but it obviously consumes power.) With that same reason, they should ban their customers from running any sort of stress-tests as well, as that'll consume more power than just assuming your web server can handle the load.
- latchkey 4y agoI was assuming the OPs comment was in relation to how PoW on CPU/GPU uses up 100% of the power that it can get. PoS doesn't work in the same way... Plus what others said... the price of power is factored into their end user pricing.
- nix23 4y ago>increase electricity usage. Even if...hell you pay for it! Really none of their business if it's not illegal.
- londons_explore 4y agoCrypto comes with more regulatory risk, and the risk of being a bigger target for cyber attacks - I bet Hetzner doesn't want to take that on. Also, if someone is storing a billion dollars of cryptocoins in one of Hetzners servers, who should pay for the extra security guards, staff vetting, etc?
- sschueller 4y agoI think we are running into a real issue where private industry with too much power can effectively make something that is legal illegal. For example Visa refusing to process credit cards for adult websites. Maybe it is time for government to step in and even though these companies are private, of it becomes a system wide problem they need to force them to host such legal content. Especially companies that want to be considered transparent carriers such as the phone company. For example requiring all business to accept cash as payment. What is the point of having laws of industry in the end decides what is legal?
- true_religion 4y agoThey just don't want the wear and tear on their servers. It's just like car rental places saying you can use their cars for business but you can run a taxi business.
- Doctor_Fegg 4y agoHetzner has what percentage of the hosting market? I find it hard to consider them "private industry with too much power". (Writing as a contented Hetzner customer.)
- latchkey 4y agoHetzner has 17% of the ETH PoS market. https://twitter.com/maggielove_/status/1562915484659601409 https://twitter.com/maggielove_/status/1562915484659601409
- missedthecue 4y agoIt looks like there are no shortage of alternatives. Monopoly isn't when "better product than dozens of competitors"
- pmyteh 4y agoFWIW businesses are not required to accept cash. 'Legal tender' status only matters for paying off a debt; if the company doesn't extend credit to you then it's free to accept whatever payment methods it wishes.
- josephcsible 4y agoEven as someone who's not a fan of cryptocurrency, I think this is dumb. If you're paying for a dedicated server, you should be allowed to do anything you want on it as long as it's legal.
- martin_a 4y agoJust look for a provider who allows it. I don't get the problem some people are trying to make here. This is capitalism, Hetzner does not want cryptocurrency stuff on their servers, that's fine. Lots of other providers do not want chat applications, filehosting and whatnot as it stresses their systems more than usual. That's fine, there's a place for everybody.
- latchkey 4y agoThe issue is that today there is 17% of the ETH PoS network running on Hetzner. It is beyond capitalism when it comes to just running a piece of software that doesn't use any more resources than anything else. It also is not illegal. Certainly they can decide what they do and do not want running on their network, however it becomes a slippery slope quickly... what will they ban next? What will others ban?
- eropple 4y agoSpeaking as a very happy Hetzner customer: if that slope gets slippery about anything I think has a reason to exist beyond techno-optimist grift, I promise to you that I'll care. I'll be right there on that line. Crypto though? Nah. Good on Hetzner for this. I appreciate their decision.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- latchkey 4y agoDo you think Render will come out with a similar policy soon? I haven't read the ToS.
- nibbleshifter 4y agoTbh, I wouldn't run a node on hetzner anyway. My experience running uptime sensitive stuff there (on cloud and baremetal) has been suboptimal.
- throwaway67743 4y ago
- redox99 4y agoUnironically a good thing. There is currently a fair amount of centralization based on hosting site[1]. AWS is first at 48%, Hetzner second at 14%. These percentages are among cloud nodes, which account for 62%. If taken as percentage of total Eth nodes, they would be lower[2]. People are encouraged to host at home, or at least in some small hosting provider. There was a hashtag going on a few days ago, #stakefromhome[3], with people showing their setups. [1] https://ethernodes.org/networkType/Hosting https://ethernodes.org/networkType/Hosting [2] https://ethernodes.org/network-types https://ethernodes.org/network-types [3] https://twitter.com/hashtag/stakefromhome https://twitter.com/hashtag/stakefromhome Edit: Clarified hosted vs residential
- mckirk 4y agoNot sure why that's a good thing; I'd expect the 48% to rise in the wake of this, and that's certainly not what you'd want.
- redox99 4y ago> I'd expect the 48% to rise in the wake of this Why do you expect that? People that use Hetzner usually pick it because it's very cheap. I don't see many moving to AWS, which is very expensive. They'll probably move to OVH, maybe Digital Ocean or Linode or other.
- yamrzou 4y agoNow the big question is: Why?