6 ms·
Beware the Alan Turing fetish
- patio11 15y agoThe media has a strong, strong bias towards established narratives. (So do all of us, but they're in the professional business of telling stories, so it's relevant that one can tell in advance what collection of observations makes a "good story.") "Our benighted ancestors had it all going well but then they did really bad things due to a malign corrupting influence and we're still suffering as a consequence" is a very powerful narrative. It's so powerful that if you're telling a story which has e.g. all the elements but the snake that you'll invent a bloody snake because everyone knows this story needs a snake.
- jgrahamc 15y agoIn Britain I think the 'malign corrupting influence' in your example turns out to be ourselves. We seem to love a story where we failed to recognize something as important, or spend money on it, or overlook the genius in our midst.
- patio11 15y agoA lit-crit class could go alllllll day with this one, but I think in most versions of the Turning story [+] that I've seen that "we" are Eve, evil unseen British homophobes are the snake, and Turning would almost certainly be Adam. The apple is sex because the apple is always sex. I would not repeat the above in a lit-crit class that I had a desire to pass, because the kind of people who do lit-crit on persecution of homosexuals did not get their doctorates on "Gender Politics In Genesis: Pretty Much Peachy Keen", but I think it's the right call theory-wise. (Practically speaking, to get the A, a) mention the problem and b) recast Turing as Amaterasu. That's a pretty strained reading, but ahem the narratives one needs to pay attention to in a lit-crit class are not the narratives in the text.) +: n.b. I am not talking about any event which actually happened anymore, I am talking about talking about events that happened. The rough sketch of thought on this goes something like: "History doesn't insert snakes. Historians insert snakes. There is no history without historians."
- cicero 15y ago"The apple is sex because the apple is always sex." I can't speak for lit-crit classes, but I'll just say that in Catholic theology, the fruit (an apple is not mentioned) is not about sex. I suppose the apple=sex idea is another persistent narrative that got established somehow.
- patio11 15y agoMy bad: if it wasn't obvious, I was talking Bible-as-literature mode rather than Catholic-dogmatist mode. Anyhow, apologies for the tangent.
- RyanMcGreal 15y agoThe fruit is knowledge, aka knowledge of good and evil, aka sex. [A Recovering Catholic]
- cobrausn 15y agoAny Catholic who told you that was pushing an agenda. Well, another agenda. [Catholic...ish?]
- sp332 15y agoThe fruit == loss of innocence. So, in the original story, it's "knowledge of good and evil." But to most people, loss of innocence brings sex to mind, so the fruit is very commonly used as a metaphor for sex. OT: it is said that whatever the fruit was, it certainly wasn't a southern watermelon. If it was, Eve would never have repented :)
- zeteo 15y agoI agree that this has nothing to do with Turing himself and everything to do with journalistic low standards. However, I don't think it's an effort to fit Turing into the "forbidden fruit" story, and I really see no snake coming up in this. It's just sensationalism: making each bad story really bad, and each good story really good. It's hard to explain Turing's achievements to non-technical readers anyway. The documentary calls him a codebreaker, which is not exactly why they've named the Turing Award in his honor. But it's much easier to put across to the general public the point about Enigma (he helped win the war!) than about computability (huh?).
- eru 15y agoAnd to be fair, the code breaking machines (bomba) were important early computers.
- rhizome 15y agoIt's called "Lapsarianism" and is a pervasive and pernicious force on the (Western) world.
- thisrod 15y agoThat's the straight reading. Enigma, the biography that brought Turing widespread attention, follows a gay narrative: "we make modernity," and "the Nazis change, but they don't go away." And now, after we made this bit of the modern narrative, you lot are stealing it. Typical. :-p
- andyjenn 15y agoThanks for the notice, will watch that tonight. Sounds like an example of mediocre journalism picking up on well worn themes: brilliant outcast genius, untimely death and potential riches lost, extrapolated and simplified. As an aside, and I don't know if this will be covered in the programme, there was an interesting report on Radio 4 some time ago about the treatment Alan Turing went through to "cure" his homosexuality. Whilst I had previously thought this only to be barbaric acts by small minded people, the report suggested some of the medics genuinely thought that this science could actually change him and be a force for good. Doesn't really change much, but it altered my views...slightly.
- jgrahamc 15y agoThis is well covered in the program. The actual docudrama is very well done. Sure there are some TV moments with a few too many shots of Macbook Airs, but here's a very long thoughtful documentary mixed with very well acted drama that covers the life of a man and four very complex ideas: Turing machine, Turing test, morphogenesis and the Enigma break.
- rmc 15y agothe treatment Alan Turing went through to "cure" his homosexuality. Whilst I had previously thought this only to be barbaric acts by small minded people, the report suggested some of the medics genuinely thought that this science could actually change him and be a force for good. Yes there was attempts to turn homosexuals into heterosexuals, and they failed. There is amble scientific evidence, as a result of these abuses, that sexual orientation can't be changed.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoCould you please present your "am[p]le scientific evidence [...] that sexual orientation can't be changed". I'll present an anecdote which, amongst several I've seen/heard, suggests to me that you're wrong in your assertion. "On Freddie Mercury's Sexuality 'I think it was an undiscussed thing for a long time. The truth of the matter is nobody should care. Why should anyone care what sexual persuasion people have? It's about the music, and Freddie would have been the first to say that. He never hid the fact that he was turned on by men instead of by women, but strange enough, I don't think it was always the case. Because in the early days, we used to share rooms. So in the early days, I know who Freddie slept with, and they weren't men, but I think it gradually changed. And I have no idea how these things work, but it wasn't really anybody's business but his, and we never talked about it as if it were important. Why should it be important? We just made music together.'" quoted from http://m.npr.org/news/front/128935865?singlePage=true http://m.npr.org/news/front/128935865?singlePage=true
- stiff 15y agoTuring's work was almost always purely theoretical and his genius very much lied in his ability to think at a level of abstraction way higher then most of us can handle; the idea that he might have jump-started a new industrial revolution only seems to indicate that whoever came up with it had no understanding whatsoever of what Turing did besides hearing that Turing was "the father of the computer". This is so wrong I am surprised somebody went as far as to write an article about this, someone should just tell the Sunday Times guy to maybe do his homework next time he utters some sentences to thousands of people. Turing had more in common with Newton or Einstein (I think the mental leaps he did for example in his work on the Entscheidungs problem are almost of this order, even though again the abstract nature of his work make its applications and implications narrower and harder to see), then with Henry Ford or Thomas Edison.
- ggwicz 15y agoTuring had more in common with Newton or Einstein...than with Henry Ford or Thomas Edison. Yeah, I agree. It's really a shame more people aren't aware of his brilliance. His code-breaking literally did save a massive number of lives.
- tommorris 15y agoAbsolutely. What the newspaper piece seems to ignore is there's no reason to suppose that if Turing had lived longer he would have become the British Bill Gates rather than, say, enjoyed life as an academic computer scientist or mathematician?
- eru 15y ago> Turing's work was almost always purely theoretical [...] Turing also got his hands dirty, and actually build some computers. So I'd put him closer to Feynman, who also did more applied work, than the theorist Einstein.
- tripzilch 15y agoIf Turing had been still alive he'd have solved P?=NP by now! ;-)
- dspillett 15y agoI'm always irritated by the fact that these documentaries tend to paint hime as the codebreaker when that part of his work was very much a team effort with other mathmatical minds and the electrical/physical engineers that created and maintained the quipment they used. I feel this is wrong on two counts: it means very few people know of the other people working at Bletchly Park despite their significant contributions, and it ignores his "solo" work in the areas of computation/information that was incredibly significant in building up to the technological revolution that has taken place over the last fifty years or more.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- skrebbel 15y agoOoh, I love "what if" stories! Hey, if Turing had died even earlier, maybe the Valley would be in Germany! And I'd be eating pretzels and bratwurst.
- Retric 15y agoThere was a lot of code breaking that had nothing to do with Turing. The enigma was broken because some polish mathematicians showed up with pictures of the device and a method of deciphering it. And for comparison just about all of Japan's high level codes where broken by the US. So, while Turing was important, I suspect vary little would have changed if he had not been part of the decoding efforts. (Largely because you can't use information gained from decoding messages all that often or they notice and change the codes.)
- mietek 15y agoRejewski[1], Zygalski and Różycki have actually been reading the Enigma messages for over six and a half years before the war began. They built mechanical devices called "bomby kryptologiczne", known outside Poland as "bombas", which then inspired the British "bombes". [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marian_Rejewski http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marian_Rejewski
- nobody31415926 15y agoAnd if a rather more brilliant and more important code breaker, Bill Tutte, had been recognised by Canada they would have a silicon valley now.
- sbuk 15y agoAs far as 'if,but, maybes' go, if us British had recognised the brilliance of both men... However, one man is continually overlooked. Without Tommy Flowers' engineering brilliance, the work of both Tutte and Turing would have had less impact.
- agentgt 15y ago"At the same time an Alan Turing fetish means we might overlook the other great people who worked in early computing" --- They could have used many other words instead of fetish. I have to wonder if the word subconsciously chosen for the history of his personal life... I hope not.
- ggwicz 15y agoTuring allegedly killed himself by putting cyanide in an apple in and eating it. That is, according to urban legend, why the Apple logo has a bite taken out of it. Probably entirely false, but a neat idea. And re: established narratives, I think often times the people reporting on great minds like Turing, Tesla, Einstein, etc., just can't even fathom their abstraction and the level they think on.
- saljam 15y agoHow timely! Just this morning I learnt a few anecdotal factoids about Turing's stay in Manchester, and his quarrels with the "old engineering guard" (Williams and Kilburn.) This comes from one of the professors who just retired from the University -- where Turing worked for a few year on the Manchester SSEM, also known as the Baby. It was the first stored program computer - effectively the first Von Neumann computer (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manchester_Baby http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manchester_Baby http://www.computer50.org/ http://www.computer50.org/) The Baby was built by Freddie Williams and Tom Kilburn. They were both engineers who believed they were building a machine on which to do real science. At the time the only way to program the machine was by flipping switches and hacking away in binary machine code. Alan Turing was hired to come to Manchester and provide a sort of higher-level language so that scientists can use the machine, a sort of an assembler if you will. However, it turned out that Turing didn't mind all this bit twiddling at all! Instead of doing what the rest of the engineers were expecting, he ended up writing all sorts of AI and maths programs to work on problems he thought were interesting. Problems, which the "old guard" thought of as mere games. They were trying to do science, while this guy is just playing! Oh how the world changed... This lead to a great deal of friction between him and the engineers, the remains of which can still be seen today in Manchester. For example, none of the CS buildings were named after him -- the Alan Turing building was completed in 2007 and became the home of Mathematics and Theoretical Physics, but not CS. Some have suggested that in addition to the above, his sexuality didn't practically help when dealing with the alpha-male 1950s engineering types he was dealing with, but let's not go that way...
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>his sexuality didn't practically help when dealing with the alpha-male 1950s engineering types he was dealing with // I imagine it may well have been because in commong with other genius mathematicians he was [borderline] autistic. Anyone else want to share a stereotype? -- Not completely related reading: http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7736196.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/health/7736196.stm