4 ms·
It's great for you. But some of us are using Linux in industrial applications. You can't really put an Apple laptop inside e.g. an MRI machine. It may run highl
by amelius 4y ago
It's great for you. But some of us are using Linux in industrial applications. You can't really put an Apple laptop inside e.g. an MRI machine. It may run highly specialized software, needs specific acceleration hardware, etc.
It's going to be a very sad day when consumer electronics win over industrial applications.
- kergonath 4y agoWhat are you on about? A €5M MRI machine will have whatever computer its manufacturer will want to support. Which will probably be something like a Core 2 running Windows XP. None of these machines have used Macs, ever. Why would anything Apple does affect this market?
- amelius 4y ago> Why would anything Apple does affect this market? Apple is gobbling up its supply chain and using precious fab slots. It affects others.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> can't really put an Apple laptop inside e.g. an MRI machine. It may run highly specialized software, needs specific acceleration hardware, etc. This sounds more like a pitch for letting the MRI machine talk to the laptop than putting redundant chips in every device.
- rtlfe 4y ago> letting the MRI machine talk to the laptop than putting redundant chips in every device This sounds like a huge security risk.
- 1-more 4y agoWhile MRIs don't use ionizing radiation like the Therac-25 did, I can think of a few bad outcomes from someone finding a 0-day on anything that can control the machine. And of course if it's read only it still has sensitive medical info we wouldn't want leaked. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25
- amelius 4y agoNo. This is not a good universal solution. What if the machine needs more processing power than one laptop can provide? Do you want to put a rack of laptops inside the machine, waste several screens and keyboards? Log into every laptop with your AppleID before you can start your machine? It's such an inelegant solution. Instead, the x86/Linux environment lets you put multiple mainboards in a machine, or you can choose a mainboard with more processors; it is a much more flexible solution in industrial settings.
- heavyset_go 4y agoIt would be a gimmick given that real-time workloads can't be offloaded via some serial connection to consumer laptops. You'd still need hardware and software capable of driving and operating the machines embedded in the machines themselves.
- kergonath 4y agoNo. You want the computer running the thing to be as simple, known, and predictable as possible. So that is necessarily going to be a computer provided by true manufacturer, and not whatever a random doctor feels like using. Consumer devices are compeletely irrelevant or that use case.
- novok 4y agoApple hardware has never been about non-consumer, server or industrial applications outside of some film, music and movie studios using mac pros and the Xserve long time ago. And if your making an MRI machine or other industrial equipment that consumes a huge amount of power, the fact your attached computer uses 300W vs 600W doesn't really seem like much of a big deal. Apple has a head start with their ARM machines, but I'm also not really worried that the rest of the industry won't catch up in a few years eventually. You can only really pull off the new architecture trick once or twice, and being a leader has a way of inspiring competitors. Apple's software and OS is also horrible to use in server applications, you only do it if you need to do it, such as iOS CI, device testing and such. Otherwise you avoid it as much as you can.
- amelius 4y agoIt's not about the electrical power use. It's about one market player taking out the air from the market by integrating the entire supply chain.
- alwillis 4y agoYou can only really pull off the new architecture trick once or twice Apparently not. The Mac has gone from Motorola 68000 to PowerPC to Intel to ARM. And if needed, they could do it again.
- mindwok 4y agoI don’t think you need to worry about that, those are completely different use-cases and markets. ARM CPUs will be available and widespread in other applications soon enough, and Linux support is already strong in that regard.