15 ms·
A great number of the cool designs from the 50's and 60's are illegal because the front of the car eats people. Swallows them, chews them up, and spits them out
by hinkley 4y ago
A great number of the cool designs from the 50's and 60's are illegal because the front of the car eats people. Swallows them, chews them up, and spits them out.
The sloped design of new cars isn't just about aerodynamics. In a low-speed impact a pedestrian is lifted onto the hood. Forward leaning grills, such as on the Dodge Charger, some of the beefier Mustangs, and any number of other muscle cars or sedans, instead clip pedestrians in the knee or hip, tip them over and drop them onto the ground, where the car then runs over them.
I think there was also an issue with those profiles and Jersey barriers, in that they were more likely to pole vault over them off the side of a bridge or onto - not into - oncoming traffic.
You are not ever going to get those designs back.
- boppo1 4y ago>because the front of the car eats people. Swallows them, chews them up, and spits them out. How so? Could we just use modern crumple materials in the same shape?
- metadat 4y agoMaterials that crumple when they impact a soft, squishy human? What? Edit: yep, @Buttons840 nailed it..
- Buttons840 4y agoA crumple material that will crumple in a car vs pedestrian collision? Like NERF foam or something?
- freeqaz 4y agoThis comment actually got a laugh out of me. I truly have no idea what would be feasible in a collision like this. Probably packing peanuts? Airbags on the outside of the car that deploy when a pedestrian is detected?
- wintermutesGhst 4y agoPedestrian airbags have been designed before, but don't seem to have caught on widely [1]. A more bizarre solution Google patented always stuck with me: A sticky car hood beneath an eggshell coating so that a struck pedestrian would stay on top of the car instead of falling and hitting their head or being run over [2]. 1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CiiBlirAG8w https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CiiBlirAG8w 2: https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/a20953/google-patent-sticky-car-hood/ https://www.popularmechanics.com/technology/a20953/google-pa...
- ordu 4y agoSuch airbags would throw a pedestrian away. A long way.
- User23 4y agoThere are wearable airbags on the market for motorcycle use. I don't know how effective they are for their intended use or how effective they might be protecting a pedestrian, but it's a technology that exists.
- homonculus1 4y agoIt's a far cry from Nerf, with fiberglass on top of it, but styrofoam is actually used inside bumpers
- bch 4y agoI recall one manufacturer popped the hood so that it could act as a shock absorber should a pedestrian land on it... Found it - Nissan has an actuator[0] that lets the cars hood be used as a damper for unlucky pedestrians in case of collision. [0] https://www.nissan-global.com/EN/INNOVATION/TECHNOLOGY/ARCHIVE/PUEHFPP/ https://www.nissan-global.com/EN/INNOVATION/TECHNOLOGY/ARCHI...
- boppo1 4y agoAhaha I was thinking of passengers. Hence "how do they get eaten?" But even so, were old car shapes really worse than modern car shapes? Seems like you get hit, you're gonna have a bad time no matter what.
- consp 4y agoThere is a reason RR and Mercedes don't sell hood ornaments any more in certain markets as an example. They first crush your legs and then shread everything above. I imagine some of the 50s and 60s designs will be worse with sharp corners and pointy spikes.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoEven for people in the car, some older car designs put the drivers legs under the engine block. In a head on collision at speed, the legs were the crumple zone (meanwhile the steering column was being pushed through your torso). edit: also recently people noticed that high 'trucks' would simply miss the crumple zones in the car they were crashing into > Another problem is "impact incompatibility" where the "hard points" of the ends of chassis rails of SUVs are higher than the "hard points" of cars, causing the SUV to "override" the engine compartment of the car.[18] In order to tackle this problem, more recent SUV/off-roaders incorporate structures below the front bumper designed to engage lower-height car crumple zones
- dumpsterlid 4y ago"Even for people in the car, some older car designs put the drivers legs under the engine block. In a head on collision at speed, the legs were the crumple zone (meanwhile the steering column was being pushed through your torso)." Anytime anyone waxes nostalgic about how "they dont make cars like they used" I think about this video. They sure as hell don't make cars like they used too, you can get out and walk away from a crash in your ugly newer car that would brutally end your life in one of those beautiful classic cars. For anyone that is curious the key thing to pay attention to in survivability here (besides yah know... the airbag) is.. does the interior cab of the car change shape? The cab of the old car violently changes shape in a way that would destroy parts of your body whereas the newer car's cab doesnt seem to be affected at all. Even if getting crushed between the seats and dashboard didnt kill you immediately in the bel air, I struggle to imagine how emergency first responders would even get you out of that. https://youtu.be/C_r5UJrxcck https://youtu.be/C_r5UJrxcck
- reneherse 4y agoUnfortunately you're being down voted, but the reality is there are crumple zones built into some hoods (bonnets) that help protect the pedestrian from immediately impacting the solid parts of the engine. So the concept isn't completely unexplored.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- namdnay 4y ago+ explosive charges that will deform the hood to better catch a pedestrian. I’ve seen one go off when somebody drove into a bollard
- distortedsignal 4y agoCould you point me to the car manufacturer that puts explosive charges in their cars? Asking for a friend... who is myself.
- adhesive_wombat 4y agoAirbags and seatbelt pre-tensioners have "explosives" in them (they convert very rapidly into gas, but I'm not sure all of them always meet the usual standards of explosives). The defective Tanaka airbags used ammonium nitrate, of Oklahoma City Bombing and Beirut port fame.
- tomashubelbauer 4y agoDon't all airbags deploy using electronically set-off explosives?
- splitbrain 4y agoAll of them. It's called an airbag.
- jacquesm 4y ago
- markvdb 4y agoEuro NCAP test suite features vulnerable road user protection tests [0] including for pedestrians and cyclists. The NHTSA might start recommending some limited technological additions for pedestrian protection in the future [1]. [0] https://www.euroncap.com/en/vehicle-safety/the-ratings-explained/vulnerable-road-user-vru-protection/ https://www.euroncap.com/en/vehicle-safety/the-ratings-expla... [1] https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/five-star-safety-ratings-program-updates-proposed https://www.nhtsa.gov/press-releases/five-star-safety-rating...
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoThat's exactly what we do. All that mostly air filled plastic that is used to shape the bulbous front ends of modern front ends on cars and crossovers serves this purpose. If you ever look at a car and wonder why there's so much unused space between the grill and radiator that's why.
- bregma 4y agoPeople are already made out of crumple material. Also splat material.
- calvinmorrison 4y agothe sloped design of... a current Escalade? I do doubt designers in the 50's were worried about the top of the grill hitting a full grown mans head on contact.
- Pxtl 4y agoOkay but then why is the rolling brick wall of a modern pickup allowed?
- Retric 4y agoIt’s more than just about style. As much as modern pickup trucks have become a fashion statement, many large pickup trucks are providing real utility to construction, farming, etc. And much like 18 wheelers they can’t scale down the front while maintaining utility because they need large engines and high ground clearance.
- NonNefarious 4y agoSo what? The question stands.
- Retric 4y agoYou asked why, and the answer is cost vs benefit. Car styling alone doesn’t justify the risk to pedestrians, large truck utility can. Yes, this tradeoff kills people, but so do all sorts of things like not physically preventing cars from driving 80+MPH.
- AlexandrB 4y agoThis is a non answer. Australia has a vehicle style commonly referred to as a "ute"[1]. I think it stand for "utility". Which is basically a car with a truck bed in the back. This provides many of the advantages of a pickup without the increased danger to pedestrians. Why are car companies not marketing/selling these to the average consumer instead of the monster RAMs and F150s? I suspect the reason has everything to do with styling and little to do with utility. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ute_(vehicle) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ute_(vehicle)
- bobthepanda 4y agoThe reason is because ANCAP and Euro NCAP test for pedestrian safety and US NCAP does not. They have been sitting on their hands since 2015. https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-20-419 https://www.gao.gov/products/gao-20-419
- cm2187 4y agoWell, what about if self driving cars become safe enough?
- Mikeb85 4y agoWell that's not anytime soon at this rate...
- throwaway0a5e 4y agoThose "forward leaning grills" you're crapping on are just flimsy plastic with a bunch of air behind them. If they strike a pedestrian at any speed they deform and crumple and whatnot and the pedestrian winds up on the hood. While not styled to lean forward like what Dodge does pretty much all the tall bulbous front ends that HN hates and are found on modern cars and crossovers are designed like this. A bunch of plastic with air behind it is the primary means by which OEMs meet the European pedestrian safety requirements. The styled plastic provides something that's softer than the quasi-structural radiator core support that all the front end cosmetic stuff attaches to for the pedestrian to hit.
- hinkley 4y agoThe context of my comments was someone asking about designing like the 1950's. I was trying to explain why we can't legally build those exact cars. If you ignore that bit of the conversation, you're right that in a modern car you've got a good foot of material before you reach the first bit of metal, which is the hood, and the hood as some others have said is designed - today - to have a little give when a human encounters it. Something I actually have limited first hand experience in. A lot of those muscle cars though, the hood of the vehicle extended all the way out past the bumper. So you wouldn't be able to build those exact designs. But maybe there's some compromise that incorporates your points with mine? The modern Mustang looks like an homage to the Mach era, but it's a shadow of that bad boy, and it only comes after decades of wandering in the proverbial desert. The problem is always when you ask why generations of smart people didn't see the obvious answer, occasionally the answer is only visible to outsiders (curse of knowledge) but more often the answer simply doesn't work because of other, bigger concerns than aesthetics. For every time Beginner's Luck works out, there are tens or hundreds of cases of Chesterton's Fence.
- kurupt213 4y agoTry not getting run over…problem solved