7 ms·
I'm sorry, but no, and as a mutt user myself: email sucks. Spam. The protocol is insecure. Consolidation of major webmail providers is a huge problem on mul
by dredmorbius 4y ago
I'm sorry, but no, and as a mutt user myself: email sucks.
Spam. The protocol is insecure. Consolidation of major webmail providers is a huge problem on multiple fronts (censorship, third-party acceptance (of both delivery and non-GmailMicrosoftYahoo email accounts --- my Protonmail service can't talk to GetPocket's support email on Gmail for months, f'rex), spam, account hacking, authentication, repudiability (yes, that coin has two sides), workflow integrations, proprietary workflows, spam, account lockouts, lack of common email formatting and practice standards, HTML email, spam, pervasive surveillance, attachments, spam, mobile access, spam, spam, infinite diversity in proprietary messaging systems and platforms each fractally worse than email in a myrad ways, spam, spam, spam, inbox overflow, spam, spam, spam, spam, email bankruptcy.
I've had an email account nearly continuously since the mid-1980s. I've all but abandoned it in the past decade.
There is no viable replacement on the horizon, though postal mail is looking increasingly attractive.
- phil294 4y agoSpam is not Email's fault, but the mere result of its success/importance, which has only been possible due to its interoperability, which in turn facilitates spam. It would be the same if we had all been using - say- XMPP for the last 20 years.
- ChadNauseam 4y agoSpam is totally email’s fault. They should have had disposable email addresses built into the protocol so they would be easy to support. Then when an address starts getting spam, run the spam filter more aggressively on emails to that address or block it entirely. Or they should have included PoW so it takes a little bit of CPU time to send an email (wouldn’t do anything about botnets, but not every spammer has a botnet handy.) I can’t think of any other ideas off the top of my head, but it’s absolutely true that there are ways that email could have been designed to be less of a problem
- shadowofneptune 4y agoI mean, with the networks and processing speed of computers back when email was standardized, sending the email itself would be proof of work, no?
- dredmorbius 4y agoLess email as proof of work than having a known network address (this was when the hosts file was distributed manually, and bang paths were common) was proof of trust. There were from a few dozens to a few hundreds of hosts on the entire network at this time. Most were educational institutions, meaning a campus sysadmin could run herd over users (if students) or refer to deans / departments (faculty). This from the 1970s through the early 1990s, at which point things began evolving rapidly. Transacting email itself wasn't all that expensive, though for many sites it was batched via uucp or similar mechanisms.
- quickthrower2 4y agoGetting a PhD would have been the work required to get an email address so yes! Then eternal 09/ happened.
- derefr 4y agoProof of Stake as an accepted delegator to a university/government SMTP validator node.
- jrumbut 4y agoUltimately e-mail is a relic of a time when there was some level of trust (however small) among Internet users. It's always going to be a bit of an awkward fit to today's Internet where you can trust that any and every exposed service will face some attempt at abuse.
- quickthrower2 4y agoIsn’t it just how you handle mailboxes. Let fred@domain.com accept and receive email at any fred+X@domain.com address with ability to block any specific address getting spam. If the friends and family address gets spam, offer a way to create and distribute a new address. For business it is tricker as you want anyone to email you. Here regular antispam measure are probably best.
- jrumbut 4y agoI suppose I agree for the narrower claim that a protocol which allows anyone to message anyone is going to inevitably have spam. That said I can count on my fingers and toes the number of spam messages (via hijacked accounts) that have reached my Facebook Messenger/Instagram inboxes and have received zero spam in several years on Snapchat. Walled gardens have many downsides, but there are upsides as well.
- pwinnski 4y agoYou don't get spam on Snapchat? I think you might define it differently than I do. Since those walled gardens have a verification step before allowing sending messages, spam on those platforms consists of "friend requests" from unknown people. If one is foolish enough to accept one of those, the more traditional spam message soon follows. So yes, most walled gardens' two-step approach makes the spam more civilized, but they don't eliminate it.
- jrumbut 4y agoNot a single one! I suppose I occasionally see friend requests from unknown users, but they don't actually convey a message or achieve any possible advertising goal. That said, I only communicate with a couple dozen close friends on snapchat so perhaps a more active user will get spam.
- dredmorbius 4y agoWhether spam is or isn't email's fault, or a consequence of its architectural naivete, is arguable. What's not arguable is that spam is email's problem. What responses to my quite off-the-cuff though apparently resonating comment has (mostly) failed to recognise though is that spam is a problem not only for email users but across the spectrum for operators, administrators, senders, application designers, and a whole host of others. The fact, volume, and consequences of spam have a tremendous set of knock-on effects which are hard to express with any degree of coherence and sufficiency.
- gernb 4y agoI get spam on Whatsapp, and FB Messenger. Not as much as email but I'm assuming because email is where the spammers are concentrating. Which system gets it right and could email be fixed?
- mcv 4y agoReally? I've never had spam on Whatsapp. I was just about to mention it as an example of a very successful service that didn't suffer from spam.
- Anthony-G 4y agoInteresting. It goes to show how varied people’s experience can be. I get zero spam on my seven year old Postfix server as long as I have greylisting enabled (my only anti-spam measure) while I get the occasional spam message on Whatsapp (that I only use for work purposes on my work phone since 2020).
- Terretta 4y agoI don’t use WhatsApp. I don’t have contacts on WhatsApp. I only registered a username to hold it. I only get spam on it.
- wizofaus 4y agoWhatsApp doesn't have usernames?
- memling 4y agoI more or less diagree with you, but the comment was lovely, and for some reason I find myself craving lobster thermidor.
- dredmorbius 4y ago<https://yewtu.be/watch?v=_bW4vEo1F4E https://yewtu.be/watch?v=_bW4vEo1F4E>
- tecoholic 4y agoThis. I have been facing this issue recently more and more. Account creation emails aren't arriving to my custom domain recently. Some software companies seem to not send emails to custom domains. I use a well known commercial provider with DKIM and everything setup. Yet. I am beginning to use my custom domain only for human communication and all else gets directed into Gmail.
- snazz 4y agoHuh—I wonder if that has to do with your TLD? I’ve been using custom domains for a few years and I have more issues with my .xyz domain than I do with my .com for both sending and receiving. Both have all the authentication DNS records set up.
- lisper 4y agoI run my own email server with a custom spam filter that I wrote and one of the things I've done is blacklist certain TLDs that are so spammy that just this one mitigation cuts my spam by >50%. XYZ is one of those super-spammy TLDs, sorry. Here is the complete list: 'top','tv','biz','rocks','ru','science','bid','date','casa','buzz','xyz','click','online'
- doodlesdev 4y agoI hate you and SpamAssassin. I also completely understand and will probably do the same when self hosting. Sad state of affairs.
- snazz 4y agoNo apology needed :) That's why I use the .com for everything serious and I don't have issues sending or receiving with that one.
- Semaphor 4y agoI have zero issues with mail not arriving on my custom .me domain, and I’ve been using it for email for close to 10 years. Do you have an example of sites where account creation mails do not arrive?
- thayne 4y agoYou forgot about the mess that is SPF, DKIM, and DMARC.
- dredmorbius 4y agoSpam, spam, spam, spam, spam, eggs, bacon, spam, and spam.
- Jaruzel 4y ago"but I don't like spam."
- dredmorbius 4y agoFWIW, I also omitted what's perhaps the most telling sign: increasingly it is not possible to find an email address for an entity or know whether or not a found address is useful or monitored. That is: organisations are increasingly abandoning email, at least for public-facing work. Ironically, Google are perhaps most notorious for this (HN is one of numerous Google-email-contact alternatives for problem resolution). More generally, the end state of any universal communications medium of unlimited reach and access ... is abandonment. Absent some viable mechanism for curtailing usage, the only viable options become either shutting off the system entirely, or at best, randomly sampling from amongst submissions. Conversation, and communication, both scale poorly.
- smeagull 4y agoI feel most tech organisations are now using Slack, Discord or Teams. At this point my work gmail is more an auth tool than an email.
- walrus01 4y agoI am happy to deal with the spam problem (through appropriate use of spamassassin content scoring, and RBLs and spamassassin DKIM/SPF scoring) on my own smtpd in exchange for the great advantage of having a truly decentralized communication method that isn't controlled by any one company. My email works as long as I keep my domain name renewed and my personal postfix+dovecot server online and running properly. Nearly every other possible asynchronous, text based two way communications system that people say is a "possible replacement for email" requires centralizing communications through something run by some specific company. Email's great advantage is that it's a truly level playing field. Yes that also allows spammers to send outgoing shit smtp traffic, but I can deal with that. If you are greatly troubled by spam and it's an actual ongoing problem in your inboxes I would say that your inbound smtp content filtering and spam scoring is not set up properly.
- jjav 4y ago> Email's great advantage is that it's a truly level playing field. Yes that also allows spammers to send outgoing shit smtp traffic, but I can deal with that. Agree so much. I really don't get the spam complaint anymore. Commercial providers like gmail do get a lot of spam (I have a gmail account as well, it gets more spam than ham) but it doesn't need to be that way. I run all my own email infrastructure and spam is a non-issue. My primary email has been around very publicly since the mid-90s and is surely on every spam list ever but between a strict postfix configuration and a bayesian spam filter, spam is not a thing anymore. I'm trying to think the last time I got a spam email in my inbox and can't remember. It's so rare.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mcv 4y agoWhile I mostly agree, I'm not sure it's possible to set up spam scoring properly. Either spam gets through, or some non-spam doesn't. There's legitimate email that consistently gets marked as potential spam, and I don't know how to tell my mailreader to always trust that source. The tax service regularly mails me that there's a new message for me in my message box at the tax service site where I need to log in, which is a terrible way to communicate. Their paper mail does contain everything I need to know, but their email cannot because email is so insecure. Something like email, but with authentication and encryption built in from the start, would be a really nice improvement.
- neeleshs 4y agoRe: spam - I have given up on my inbox altogether. I found that if there is a really important message that needs my attention, it tends to make its way through other channels (slack, voicemail, people just walking over to me etc). Rest of it, is apparently not important to make a difference to me in any way.
- somenameforme 4y agoBy contrast I've also had email for decades, and suffer effectively zero spam. Perhaps one difference is that I use two emails. One I use exclusively for messaging friends/family and the other I use for everything else. And I don't use the former email on any mobile device either. The email I use for registering on sites, or using on mobile, is absolutely bombarded with spam. The email I use privately receives near zero spam (that isn't trivially filtered) even though it's a simple and common two word combination at a major mail server. Notably, I'm not registering for dodgy sites or anything like that on the spammed email. It's all major and ostensibly reputable sites. For sites I don't trust or care to receive a message from, I use throw-aways. I simply assume any site you register on is going to sell, leak, or accidentally expose your email (or any other information you offer them). Similarly for mobile devices. And that seems to be a consistently validated assumption.
- cobbaut 4y agoSomewhere in 1999 I started using unique email addresses for every single service or registration. For example, if I would register with Reddit today, then I would use 20220825_reddit_registration@example.com. This makes it really easy to filter out spam (and I also know who sold my address). It's also trivial to block unwanted 'subscriptions'. I use Thunderbird and create an identity for every one of these mails that require a reply (most don't) and TB automatically uses the unique address when replying.
- mro_name 4y agopostal services are awesome but tend to be forgotten. We need to use them more for personal, relevant things. Ideally handwritten. The contemplative nature of reading paper is a bliss.
- mro_name 4y agoYou were a trendsetter back then and are now, I guess.
- krageon 4y agoSpam is not this big of an issue - filters for it are easily available and work well, even if you host your own.
- dredmorbius 4y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32590389 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32590389
- krageon 4y agoYour response is essentially "yes it is". Apparently we disagree.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoConsolidation of "trusted" mail providers (as if Google is trustworthy with its scanning of mails) is a real threat to federated mail. One can only hope that IT isn't stupid or greedy enough to sell it as that. To forbid the usage of Gmail should be sensible policy for any enterprise. Spam is a problem, but honestly 15 year old slightly trained spam filter with a sensible config can filter all without any false positives. Not that mail is not without its problems, but any modern alternative will suck much more. It will be a service attached to a corporation you will again make yourself dependent on. I feel for those whose Google accounts get locked, but to a large degree it is their own fault. I don't know a lot of corps that block unknown mail servers. Have it sign outgoing mail with your known domains and your mail will not land in some sandbox or spam filter.
- shadowgovt 4y ago> To forbid the usage of Gmail should be sensible policy for any enterprise. Instead, more than 60% of mid-sized companies use Gmail. https://emailanalytics.com/gmail-statistics/ https://emailanalytics.com/gmail-statistics/
- wizofaus 4y ago> 15 year old slightly trained spam filter with a sensible config can filter all without any false positives. If it were that easy why do all the big players do it so badly? I'd rather get more spam in my inbox than miss the false positives (in fact most of what's in my spam folder is technically legitimate, but usually just broadcast emails from organizations I happen to have used my email address for at some point in the past). But I haven't found a way to sufficiently lower the threshold for spam detection for any email service I've used to avoid that problem.
- Avamander 4y agoIt isn't easy, big players are doing very well percentage wise.
- falcolas 4y agoIf you don't like spam, postal mail is not any better. Worse, really, because there are no automated filters for it. Four out of five trips to the mailbox result in nothing but junk mail.
- Yaa101 4y agoThe biggest problem of email is non verifiable routing due to header manipulation and lack of source authorization. If these were in place then it would be able to send all spam back to sender, instead of putting it a spam folder due to filtering, your email client just would send it back to the origin address. It also would help if each send would cost a token (of some monetary system) that would be returned on delivery at the legitimate destination. This would help against bulk sending. Email is a system that will always cripple at some point if there aren't real world cost incentives in place. People are the biggest problem with email, which is hard to solve with mere technical solutions.