4 ms·
You're very kind calling it "hesitancy", too! I know that's the soft euphemism that the media has coalesced around, but "hesitancy" implies that one is on the f
by ryandrake 4y ago
You're very kind calling it "hesitancy", too! I know that's the soft euphemism that the media has coalesced around, but "hesitancy" implies that one is on the fence, unsure, open to debate and open to being convinced. That's not what America is exporting.
America's Anti-Vax movement is religiously sure of itself. They aren't on the fence. They're not weighing the pros and cons. They're convinced that they know the secret capital-T Truth, and that spreading their gospel saves lives. COVID brought it mainstream, but if you look back at the "Anti-vax Moms groups" long before COVID, there was still no hesitancy. Their minds were also made up.
- VLM 4y ago
- mongol 4y agoI understand it as they have faith in their beliefs despite lack of scientific evidence
- anigbrowl 4y agoThis seems to be a international effort, sadly. Article is also pre-covid. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6137759/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6137759/
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> America's Anti-Vax movement is religiously sure of itself. They aren't on the fence. They're not weighing the pros and cons. This is the activist wing of the movement. Many more Americans are genuinely, in many cases reasonably, hesitant.
- mentalpiracy 4y agoI don't actually believe this anymore. Hesitancy is a cover for those who lack the confidence to publicly affirm their anti-vaccination attitudes.
- epgui 4y agoYou don't have to guess, we have data on this. The vaccine-hesitant group is much larger than the anti-vaxx group, and the anti-vaxx group wields a very disproportionate influence on the undecided, vaccine-hesitant group, than actual real expert groups do. We know this.
- hilbert42 4y agoThe big question is why the 'undecided' are undecided and why anti-vaxx groups have such a large influence. I think we actually know the answers to these questions but we're too frightened to tackle the problem head-on.
- epgui 4y agoIMO the answer is clear: at the root, it’s a lack of basic science education intertwined with a deep anti-intellectualism culture in western society. (biochemist, no conflict of interest)
- hilbert42 4y ago"...are genuinely, in many cases reasonably, hesitant." Why? Are you saying they're too stupid to weigh up the facts? The amount of factual evidence is enormous, and it's a trivial exercise to evaluate it accurately.
- california2077 4y ago[flagged]
- Nursie 4y agoThere were no quarantine camps for antivaxxers in Australia. There was mandatory hotel quarantine for two weeks for incoming international travellers. Some states built 'camps' to take over from the hotels and provide future capacity, though these largely remained unused. You couldn't travel here at all for a while without a good reason, and even then you had to be vaccinated. The restrictions on incoming travellers have largely been lifted now. There were some restrictions on going to pubs and restaurants, and even to the liquor store if you were unvaccinated. Again, lifted now. But antivaxxers in Australia were never put in 'camps'.
- california2077 4y ago
- logic_beats_pro 4y ago
- elvis10ten 4y agoThere are hesitant people and there are anti-vax people. Unfortunately discourse here seems to lump both groups together. Why can’t we see nuances? Edit: Actually, it’s not just HN. It’s quite unfortunate.
- vibrio 4y agoI think fully differentiating anti-vax and vax-hesitatant lacks nuance. There is no way there is a sharp line between the groups. Is it a coincidence that the increase in prevalence of vax hesitance correlates with the increase in prevalence full-on anti-vax, which went from niche to mainstream? The data are clear. How we resolve and educate the fence sitters is the relevant question. Browbeating or shaming either group isn't productive. (arguably Trolling the mainstream is one goal of anti-vaxers.) Regrettably we are up against Brandolini's Law , where anti-vax misinformation has reached a critical mass with 'respected' personalities in media and politics participating, splashing this misinformation way beyond the niche conspiracy theorists that used to be the core.
- elvis10ten 4y agoWhat data are you referring to? My original comment was based on anecdotal data tho. None of the people I know that refused the Covid vaccine (initially) had any issues taking other vaccines. One friend for example who was a vocal critic of Covid vaccines, didn’t have any issues vaccinating his child this year against other things. Basically they wanted a vaccine with a “track record” was my conclusion. When you lump these type of people with people who think the vaccines are from the deep state or stuff like that, you can’t create good and effective policies IMO.
- epgui 4y agoAnti-vaxx and vaccine-hesitancy, while both extremely dangerous and concerning, are two different parts of the same spectrum. The origin of the term "vaccine hesitancy" is actually scholarly research on the subject, not the media.