12 ms·
Facebook - and indeed every other content posting system on the internet - is always being bombarded by spam. It seems the spammers have briefly found a gap in
by pjc50 4y ago
Facebook - and indeed every other content posting system on the internet - is always being bombarded by spam. It seems the spammers have briefly found a gap in the wall and are pouring in.
This is your regular reminder that if you want a decentralized anything, you need to solve the spam problem again, which means censoring content.
- junofan 4y agoSpam needs censorship? But isn’t spam only profitable at scale? Can’t you just charge a nominal fee or something?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 4y agoI'm reminded of https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt https://craphound.com/spamsolutions.txt which is 20+ years old and remains true. > Spam needs censorship? Spam needs to be deleted or hidden by someone or something or your inbox/feed will be full of spam. Trying to manage this individually with keyword filters or even the more sophisticated Bayesian anti-spam is exhausting. > But isn’t spam only profitable at scale? Yes. So what? Spam scales. It's like cryptocurrency, you burn trillions of FLOPS of computing power to make a few cents. > Can’t you just charge a nominal fee or something? Fee? For Facebook? This absolutely kills customer acquisition. It has often been suggested and never worked; the only site I think that does it is Metafilter? Facebook went in the other direction with subsidised data plans that were free to access Facebook. The economics does not permit them to charge the eyeballs to look at Facebook. On the other hand, they can't afford to let people advertise for free on Facebook, since that's the service they do charge for. In practice this is why accounts get tied to phone numbers so often, because it's slightly more difficult to acquire another few thousand phone numbers after the first thousand are banned for spamming, than it is with IP4 addresses.
- stevage 4y agoIt seems so weird that we all happily pay $5 or $10 a month for a bunch of random services, but a central platform like Facebook or Twitter can't even charge a buck?
- dimva 4y agoYou pay for services where there isn't a network effect (streaming) or where the market isn't super competitive (telecom). Social is an incredibly competitive market with a huge network effect - if Facebook or Twitter charged money, young users would migrate somewhere else and would continue using that network when they got older. So that would be the end of any social network that decided to charge, unless it was trying to be a small niche network for adults to have more intellectual conversations (metafilter?)
- lbriner 4y agoThere is the network effect where to make it worthwhile, you need to have pretty much all of your friends on it, if not, it doesn't work. Most people won't pay for anything they don't have to pay for. There is also the fact that it can be hard to see the overall gain when each interaction is very marginal. For example, updating your timeline with a photo and a status by itself doesn't seem worth paying for even if the cummulative effect over an entire year could be very beneficial for your networks.
- bluGill 4y agoFacebook might be valuable enough for me to pay for, but it is marginal. For every friend who decides to get off facebook the value of facebook also goes down. I wouldn't pay more than a buck/month for facebook, and to get that they need to focus on the things that provide me value (that is they need to show me more about the life of my friends and cut all the memes and political garbage that my friends share). However I never would have joined facebook if there was a price and for years after I wouldn't have been willing to pay, it is only now that I realize the ability to share pictures of my kids with my parents and other friends is a valuable service.
- paulcole 4y agoCharging a fee is censorship. But there’s also nothing inherently wrong with censorship. It just tastes extra bad when the things we like get censored. There’s censorship right here on HN for example and that’s OK.
- kennu 4y agoBlockchain based decentralized social networks offer the interesting option of charging a small fee for every transaction, potentially making spam unprofitable. E.g. having to pay $0.001 for every post and comment or something similar.
- Crusoe123 4y agoWhy would you need a blockchain for this?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Vosporos 4y agoBecause they sell blockchain
- kennu 4y agoThe blockchain infrastructure allows decentralization of the transaction payments. Are there other ways to do that?
- philpem 4y agoIndeed, a periodical subscription (say $10) with a number of posts or comments included would serve the same purpose. Gee this sounds like telephone billing...
- unsupp0rted 4y agogMail used to be near impenetrable. Now every day I get `Confirmation receipt! You are the Lucky online-Winner !You've been chosen!#5646`
- david422 4y agoI keep winning a free Yeti Cooler. It's so odd - I barely get any other spam and yet this particular strain keeps showing up.
- ridgered4 4y agoI get a few of these every day lately with yahoo mail. I was getting a bunch of confirm delivery receipt phishing emails for costco, walmart, fedex as well as tractors and bitcoin recently as well. They all seemed to have the same wacky text style used in the subject line.
- jjav 4y agoSame, I've got a garage full of Yeti coolers by now (as soon as they show up, surely they will, I won!) Fortunately I don't really rely on my gmail email for anything important, but it's filling up with that spam and marking it spam doesn't make any difference. Interestingly I don't get any of those on my primary email which is self-hosted (and the address is a lot more public and older than my gmail address).
- xeromal 4y agoYeah, not sure what happened but I've been experiencing the same thing. My email was leaked onto the web many moons ago but the spam has been harassing me for just a year or so
- KineticLensman 4y agoBlocking the senders simply files the emails under the Spam label. I'm currently trying to get rid of them by filtering the messages. I do Settings --> Full settings --> Filters and Blocked Addresses Create a new Filter Add the display name or similar to the 'Includes the Words' field Create Filter Select 'Delete it'
- impossiblefork 4y agoI don't see why decentralization would lead to a spam problem. Presumably you would hardly see messages that haven't been approved by someone who has been transitively approved by you. Decentralized systems are usually networks, and if you got spam or uninteresting messages you would reduce the weight of that part of the network. You can't trust a centralized party to censor for you, because then that entity has power over you through what you see. It has to be your secretary, i.e. it has to actually work for you and be a reliable servant. What better to use as a secretary than network of people connected by who is interested in the output stream from whom?
- zinekeller 4y agolooks at e-mail and SMS Sure you could install filters, but decentralised networks in practice has spam (the only ones that don't have any spam and don't have any filters are those too niche that spammers won't bother).
- actionfromafar 4y agoThen we have to checks notes - make every network niche! I quip, but I think there are solutions in that kind of thinking. Not everything needs to connect to everything.
- impossiblefork 4y agoYes, but in both the case pf e-mail and SMS you are not looking at public streams, and neither uses a disyributed system. It uses a centralized system with a small number of telephone companies that are slow to respond to reports of spam. In a distributed system of the kind I propsed above, if you got a spam message you wpuld reduce your trust in those who transitively approved the source of the message, immediately. Someone spamming would be cut off quick, as would anyone with high trust in a spammer.
- zinekeller 4y ago> In a distributed system of the kind I propsed above, if you got a spam message you wpuld reduce your trust in those who transitively approved the source of the message, immediately. I won't think too deeply if your solution works theoretically, but in reality in our imperfect world most people would just choose to outsource the job to the point that we're back to the email problem. Majority of people liked Gmail - majority chosed Gmail and spammers galore we have. Even Mastodon is not resistant to centralization despite their efforts to be decentralized - most wouldn't bother to set up their server and so a lot ends up signing up to mastodon.social.
- samatman 4y agoIt means shunning users and avoiding Sybil attacks. If you can't avoid Sybil attacks, then you're stuck censoring content, and that's an unhappy job. Blockchain tech is good at one thing: making numbers expensive. That property has made them really unpopular, along with doing it by turning huge amounts of electricity into heat, but it's useful in that an identity is just a number, and if you can make identities allodial and somewhat expensive, you can solve the problem at the user level, by banning bad actors. If a user ID costs ten bucks, spammers have to make that plus labor back before everyone shuns them. That's discouragingly difficult to do.
- sph 4y agoHashcash is a similar solution to make spam computationally intensive, but minimally invasive for regular users. Bitcoin's proof-of-work system is inspired by Hashcash. But yes, the solution to spam is to make it expensive: either monetarily or energetically.
- xeromal 4y agoIf hashcash involves taking a penny or more from someone for it to work, it won't work.
- tenebrisalietum 4y agoIt does work, since when have you ever received spam from Hashcash?
- tomjen3 4y agoBy that logic the solution to spam is alcohol, since I have never received it from wine either :) I also don't ever remember having received an email with Hashcash.
- TakeBlaster16 4y agoHashcash does not require money, it only requires you to burn CPU cycles. But it's tough to implement fairly. A feature phone might take 60 seconds to do the same proof of work that a PC can do in 0.1 seconds. (And spammers would eventually just build ASICs anyway.) So those without powerful hardware are back to trusting some centralized entity to burn CPU for them and relay their message.
- twoxproblematic 4y ago