5 ms·
There's a public sector salary cap in many parts of Canada, despite roaring inflation. And a general vibe from the public and the government that generally des
by cmrdporcupine 4y ago
There's a public sector salary cap in many parts of Canada, despite roaring inflation.
And a general vibe from the public and the government that generally despises public sector unions and would almost certainly backlash against nurses and teachers should they sensibly decide to go on strike.
For two years they busted their asses for the public in tough straits and now COVID numbers in the hospital system are still crazy but the public is pretending they aren't, and basically expecting the health care system to "deal with it."
A prov government here in Ontario that screwed the public health care system and nurses in particular all through the COVID crisis, and has every intent on doing more of that ... was just re-elected with a landslide majority.
If you put foxes in charge the hen house, it's not a surprise when the nurses^H^H^H^H^Hhens start to disappear.
- nivenkos 4y agoIt's the same in the UK, junior doctors and nurses have had terrible compensation for years (the Conservatives even scrapped the student bursaries). And now they're surprised when they all leave for Australia and the USA where they can earn 3-4x as much...
- was_a_dev 4y agoMy partner is a junior doctor, currently doing a rotation on the local A&E department. She is the only junior doctor in that department that isn't waiting for their Australian work visa to come through.
- betaby 4y agoAt the same time there are plenty of medical specialists in the sunshine list making 400K+ CAD. Keeps me wondering why radiologists are paid that well, compared say with oncologists. Also do not forget 1) province caps on medial school admission and 2) administrative bloat. Nurses shortage is only one of the many issues with the healthcare in Canada.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoYes, I agree in general. However when I was taking a $300k+ CAD comp package at Google for a (relatively low ladder) SWE position, it was really hard for me to sympathize with people griping about anybody being overpaid in the public service. Pricing irrationality is one of the usual critiques that libertarian types have against state-run anything. Thing is that the US health care market also exhibits similar distortions. I think it's a constant struggle. I think the Canadian system (and probably UK NHS) is due for major reform. I just do not trust the people in power to make the right kind of reforms. Again, foxes and henhouses.
- Scoundreller 4y agoOnly the small fraction of doctors that are government/hospital employees will show up on that list. The vast majority that are contractors or under non-governmental employee arrangements will not. I think radiologists tend to be employees since they usually don't physically see most of their patients, but not sure. And those showing up on that list as employees may still have other revenue from services they can bill for as contractors.
- dmix 4y agoNo comment on unions but I never understood the salary caps, especially that new one for nurses. That's the opposite of what we should be doing.
- cmrdporcupine 4y agoIt's the opposite of what you'd be doing if you wanted the system to function correctly... But what if you didn't? Because you wanted to replace it, but it was dangerous to say that out loud? The Conservatives (and to some extent some Liberals as well) have been playing a long game -- since the 70s when it was introduced -- to get rid of medicare. It's incredibly popular with Canadians as a whole, but if you take conservative leadership aside, get them drunk, and get them to speak honestly ... they want it gone. Or at the very least, severely curtailed and a private option introduced. Klein tried to do it in Alberta in the 90s (bring in more extensive private services) and the feds (under Chretien) beat him back in the courts. But now they're getting quite open again about it in both Alberta and Ontario and pitching it as a solution to a crisis. A crisis they helped creat. EDIT: again, I think the system needs reforming. But likely not the way they want it reformed.
- raydev 4y agoI'm still an outsider (recent immigrant to Canada) but my impression of right vs left politicians here reminds me very much of Dems vs Reps in the US. When the right obtains power, they incrementally and consistently put the pieces in place to ensure that the quality of gov-provided services decreases over time. Then when the left obtains power, they simply maintain status quo, never improving or fixing the problems created by the previous administration. And of course, we have issues where practically no one shows up to vote and a widely-disliked premier gets a majority government, a premier who will continue to ensure the gov-funded options get worse.
- Scoundreller 4y ago> When the right obtains power, they incrementally and consistently put the pieces in place to ensure that the quality of gov-provided services decreases over time. My favourite was when one promised 'fiscal restraint' and no deficits, so they sold off a 99y lease on a tolled highway to plug their deficit. They promised prices wouldn't go up more than 30% in 15 years, but they went up 200%. https://www.thespec.com/news/canada/2019/09/03/birth-of-a-fiasco-how-the-ontario-tories-completely-botched-the-sale-of-highway-407.html https://www.thespec.com/news/canada/2019/09/03/birth-of-a-fi... While the public highways are gridlocked, there have been at least 2 aircraft landings on the tolled highway without injury: https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/plane-makes-emergency-landing-on-hwy-407-1.927535 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/plane-makes-emergency... https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/plane-highway-407-markham-1.6226951 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/toronto/plane-highway-407-mar...