16 ms·
Study first to link weed killer Roundup to convulsions in animals
- chmaynard 4y agoIf the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) had the authority to regulate industrial chemicals along the lines of the FDA's regulation of pharmaceuticals, this type of clinical study would have been required before Roundup ever hit the shelves.
- jlmorton 4y agoThis is not exactly the first study on glyphosate. There are 857 studies on links on the links between glyphosate and Non-Hodgkin's Lymphoma alone. Pubmed finds 4,585 studies mentioning glyphosate, going back to 1975. It's an extremely intensively-studied chemical.
- h2odragon 4y agoWhen Roundup first hit shelves, "soil erosion" was the big concern and it was a miracle chemical that enabled "no till" agriculture. Now erosion is not a concern anymore, hardly anyone does more than disc their fields once a decade. Of course while that helps erosion, it doesn't fully solve the problem, and it also took down the flood control benefits the erosion mitigation efforts gave us, too.
- meragrin_ 4y ago> hardly anyone does more than disc their fields once a decade. I guess nearly every single of the "hardly anyone" are near me. Pretty much every field seems to be tilled every year or every other year.
- stinos 4y agoNow erosion is not a concern anymore, hardly anyone does more than disc their fields once a decade. That's a bit of a stretch. Really depends on location and crop type. At least around this local village, lots of hills, it is still an issue. As in: every rainfall which is like a tad rougher than average results in several streets being flooded with mud. Totalling several metric tonnes (official measurements, weird these numbers are weight, not volume) of soil disappearing from only a couple of km^2 of farmland every single year. This isn't the type of issue Roundup or anything like that is going to solve, it really need thorough systematic change.
- h2odragon 4y ago> Really depends on location and crop type. Great point; around me they let the small fields on the hills go back to forest and stopped building little dams. Can still find traces of the horse drawn plowed fields, further up the hills, where they turned furrows to be terraces. Those last got plowed 100+ yr ago in some cases and now stand out from the gullies below them.
- ouid 4y agonot weird at all the the measurements are in mass. Mass is conserved, volume is not. For instance what do you get when you add half a yard of silt to a yard of pebbles? thats right, a yard of silty pebbles
- stinos 4y agoMakes sense, but only if interpreted as 'mass of dried material (i.e. soil only, not the water in it)' then I guess?
- chiefalchemist 4y agoRephrased a bit for those not familiar with the process: New chemicals can be introduced and are considered innocent until proven guilty. This was the entry point for forever-chemicals. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persistent_organic_pollutant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Persistent_organic_pollutant
- assbuttbuttass 4y ago
- SquareWheel 4y agoNobody would drink a glass of offered liquid from somebody who is clearly acting antagonistically towards them. Beyond that, there's clearly a difference between something being appealing and safe to drink. The way anti-GMO people tout this as a slam dunk is just intellectual laziness.
- mandmandam 4y ago> "anti-GMO people" There it is. The implication that anyone who isn't unquestionably pro GMOs, is against them, no matter the modification or the company pushing it. I mean, what kind of an anti-science rube uses "intellectually lazy" arguments, such as "asking a guy who said Roundup is safe to drink to actually drink some". This, from the guy who conflates RoundUp with it's active ingredient glyphosate. Scientific evidence showing RoundUp is significantly more toxic - https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-17537-w- https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-022-17537-w- Hmm, that study was easy to find ... This, on an article which explicitly calls out how little we know of glyphosate's effect on the nervous system. This, on an article which notes the terrifying fact that 80% of US urine samples, children included, contain glyphosate. RoundUp is nasty shit. And I'm not anti-science for being worried about glyphosate in my piss.
- vel0city 4y agoIts a pretty common practice to include manure when fertilizing a field. Would you eat manure? There's lots of things that are safe to use in their expected capacities that I probably wouldn't eat.
- a2tech 4y agoThis comment made me chuckle and I think is an excellent illustration. There's a lot of people in these threads that don't understand how farming works and the sheer scale of the problem with growing plant matter for food and industry. There are people seriously encouraging manual farming as a solution to the worlds food/pest issues. It boggles my mind--have these people have hand worked a field? Even maintaining an acre of garden as a single person would illustrate the amount of effort you have to put in and the low amount of yield you get in return. I'd love to know how people would get 'selected' as field workers. Because I doubt you'd have people rushing out to till fields by hand unless they're pressed into service. Personally I'd rather deal with a little extra chemical buildup than reinventing a modern slave class.
- SquareWheel 4y agoSo the "animals" mentioned in the title refers to roundworms, a parasite that lives in soil. Not something you exactly want, but also not something you would expect to be targeted by a herbicide. Glyphosate discussions always brings out people with strong opinions, but the product is studied extensively by researchers and the majority of studies have not shown harm. That doesn't prove it's safe of course, but it's where we're currently at. Because Roundup is such an important part of our agricultural industry, it should continue to be studied in depth. This study and others like it are important to ensuring that farming at scale remains safe for human consumption, as well as minimizes environmental impact.
- slimsag 4y agoDo you know if there /are/ any studies done with smaller mammals, out of curiosity? My worry is always that we're poisoning our dogs/cats, where a toxic amount I imagine is much smaller
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoYou’re worried about dogs and not children or adults?
- serf 4y agoyou're worried about children and adults and not our global society, war abroad, disease, destitution, and human suffering? see what I did there? I presumed you didn't care about anything not explicitly mentioned -- was I accurate? I bet not. humans tend to (generally) wait until the produce is washed and on a dinner plate before they try licking it -- animals (and certainly some humans, too) may not. The specific worry may be towards the danger of the high volumes of raw chemical on the plant itself rather than the underlying danger of treating a plant with that chemical before preparation and wash.
- TedDoesntTalk 4y ago> wait until the produce is washed It is my understanding that the produce assimilates the chemical internally
- sokoloff 4y agoThe animal in question is C. elegans, a soil-dwelling roundworm. So, undeniably an animal, but probably not among the first 50 animals that the headline is likely to conjure in the reader’s’ imagination.
- crmd 4y ago> "A significant finding from our study reveals that just 0.002 percent glyphosate, a difference of about 300 times less herbicide than the lowest concentration recommended for consumer use, had concerning effects on the nervous system." Many toxicity studies feed animals millions of times more of the substance than a human would ever be exposed to, in order to produce a result. This is not the case here. Also, it seems to target the GABA-A receptor, which is pretty stable across species.
- jjtheblunt 4y ago
- brutusborn 4y ago300 times is definitely worrying, but it still seems higher than people would be exposed to. Surely after degradation of the chemical on surfaces, water flushing plants and dilution when ingested, humans would never be exposed to a concentration that high. The highest levels recorded in people in the US is ~2 µg/L [0]. It's probable that it still affects GABA receptors at this level but I'm hoping it has negligible effects. [0] https://www.cdc.gov/exposurereport/whats_new_071922_1.html https://www.cdc.gov/exposurereport/whats_new_071922_1.html
- dmos62 4y agoSide question: any sign of at least borderline-viable farming techniques without pesticides or herbicides? By viable I mean, as a complete replacement for current agriculture. I know next to nothing about this, but have had some shower thoughts that a different agriculture system could be viable if we increased our expectations for farming's labour intensity. I probably got the idea from permaculture videos, because they seem to get impressive results, but it also requires some skill and a lot of work. I'm half-expecting a hail of downvotes, but maybe I'll find other people that have been wondering the same.
- verisimi 4y agoYou can't run the corporate governance system on permaculture! People managing a small plot of land and getting an abundant amount of clean, good food won't fly. What we need are more massive farms, with just one crop, roundup ready seeds, imported fertiliser, etc - all owned by charitable (tax-free!) billionaire foundations for the betterment of us all! Get with the program! PS I'm being downvoted - but what's the problem? Bill Gates "owns less than 1 percent of the nation’s total farmland" (from https://nypost.com/2022/06/30/bill-gates-purchase-of-north-dakota-farmland-cleared/ https://nypost.com/2022/06/30/bill-gates-purchase-of-north-d...).
- m_coder 4y agoI believe you are on target. Small plots of land are on average far more productive per acre than large mono cropping plantations. "Dacha gardening accounts for about 3% of the arable land used in agriculture, but grows an astounding 50% by value of the food eaten by Russians." (from https://smallfarmersjournal.com/russian-dacha-gardens https://smallfarmersjournal.com/russian-dacha-gardens)
- pas 4y ago> Small plots of land are on average far more productive per acre than large mono cropping plantations. the bottleneck is not exactly land, but cost, manpower, etc. that's why industrial farming dominates the food and feedstock sectors.
- incomingpain 4y agoI feel like Glysophate is equivalent to leaded gasoline. Everyone knows it's bad for everyone but we keep using it. With some near future where we ban it.
- bluGill 4y agoThere is a difference. With leaded gasoline it was the chemists who study this stuff that knew it was bad trying to convince everyone else. With roundup it is the non-chemists "bloggers" and conspiracy theorists who know it is bad trying to convince everyone else.
- Kim_Bruning 4y agoJust to be sure, biologists use a number of model organisms which are well understood. C. Elegans is a model organism for studying genetics and neurophysiology. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caenorhabditis_elegans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caenorhabditis_elegans
- hirundo 4y agoWe're having a wet year and the weed growth is impressive. I've considered spraying Roundup to help control them but I'm concerned about the affect on my pets. Then I talked to my neighbor who regularly uses Roundup. He said that he sprayed a few weeks ago, and his weeds "just kinda look a little tired" instead of gone. If that's all the result I'd get why take the risk. But I've spent around 10 hours walking behind a weed whacker in the last month. That's not my favorite chore and I'm willing to take some risks to trim it down a bit.
- stinos 4y agoWhat did you do after weed whacker usage? If you didn't remove all cuttings, there's your main problem. (also: 10 hours? how large is that piece of land?)
- hirundo 4y agoI removed the cuttings in past years, but it doesn't seem to have an effect. I think every inch of soil is throroughly saturated with a large variety of seeds. After whacking it down it's just a smooth carpet of green. So I gave up on the removal as not worth the effort.
- stinos 4y agoIf you leave the cuttings they'll decompose and fertilize the soil, giving advantage to fast growing weeds. Possibly also add nitrogen deposition from surrounding industry/agriculture to that, and you have an ideal cycle for lots of biomass. Mowing like twice a year and removing cuttings on the other hand can and usually does break that cycle, can take some years, resulting in less fierce growth, and more slow-growing species.
- peteradio 4y agoIs this a garden of a yard you are maintaining? Cultivating a garden before you see weeds cuts down on the weed seed bank. One of those things that takes rigorous practice for a year or more before it is obviously having a long term positive impact.
- clarionbell 4y agoThis is possibly the first study demonstrating adverse Roundup effects I've read that doesn't have any immediately obvious issues. There could be some, obviously, but it's nothing like using animal strains prone to cancer. In this case the worms are mutants, but the strains are not noted to be more prone to convulsions. They still had electrocute them, but the time to recovery did seem to relate to chemicals administered.
- giantg2 4y ago
- algoatecorn 4y agoThe only reasonable study linking glyphosate to bee harm was designed to mimic large-scale farming application. They used huge concentrations and only found disorientation of bees, but not a reduction in bee population. Glyphosate is not a neonicotinoid, which is class of chemicals you are probably referring to.
- giantg2 4y agoThere are a number of agricultural chemicals that we see as being anecdotally harmful. Heres a meta study concluding that glycophosphate exposure can contribute to population reduction. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33636765/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33636765/
- londons_explore 4y agoWe keep asking ourself "is this chemical safe". But what we should be asking is "does use of this chemical have benefits to humans that outweigh the disadvantages to humans". A weedkiller that harms people might still be a good thing if it has overwhelming benefits too, like for example it saves far more peoples lives through greater food production. Regulators never seem to see this bigger picture - instead we allowed things that have small benefits and large known harm (eg. leaded fuels), and disallow things that could have huge benefits and tiny harm (gm crops). Regulators need to be the ones seeing the bigger picture, because the people getting the benefits (eg. farmers) are rarely the ones taking the downsides (eg. cancer risk of those eating the produced food).
- TheMiddleMan 4y agoYou say this like there aren't alternatives. We can find a way to grow crops that isn't harmful to people.
- londons_explore 4y agoEverything involves some harm to people. For example, if you use a tractor to plough that land, you'll be emitting some diesel particulates giving the people in the area worse health. If you ban machines and plant everything by hand, someone's going to get a bad back. Every option involves some harm. The trick is to minimize it.
- lizardactivist 4y agoI don't think we will ever understand the amount of death, literally, that Monsanto's products have caused. And what's worse is they were fully aware all along, and still the US government had their back.
- TheBigSalad 4y agoWhat do you mean? People are living longer and our food is safer than ever before. How could you argue otherwise?
- nemo44x 4y agoTheir products have probably caused more deaths indirectly that from the chemicals themselves. Their chemicals are a major reason starvation isn’t a problem (thus saving many lives) and have helped in growing crops so much that we use their byproducts in many things (line HFCS, etc) which has made processed food so incredibly cheap and accessible that we have a diabetes and obesity epidemic.
- _vdpp 4y agoThis is a bit hyperbolic - unless you mean excess deaths caused by obesity, heart disease and diabetes because of how abundant food has gotten. But starvation is less of a problem anymore, largely because of agricultural advances like fertilizers, machinery enabling better practices (like no-till farming) and yes, herbicides and pesticides. Undoubtedly there are harmful side effects but they need to be viewed with a sensible cost-benefit analysis.
- zackmorris 4y agoI think of the GMO/pesticide/herbicide approach like smoking. You may use it for years without issue, but then wake up one day and find yourself unable to eat whole wheat like I did. The gluten-free movement, the autoimmune diseases we're seeing, the continuing rise of neurological disorders like ADHD and autism.. they're caused by factory farming. The literature may not have reached consensus on that yet, but the trends are obvious and unmistakable now. My peer group called this out back in the 90s before it went big, but nobody ever listens to us because 1) I was a teenager and 2) the people I listen to and admire are all poor academics. There was profit to be made! It took 3 years, but I was finally able to get my digestive troubles into remission. I believe what happened is that my enteric nervous system got disrupted with neuropathy when I went through profound burnout in 2019. So the valves in my digestive system were opening and closing at the wrong times and I developed all kinds of food sensitivities. The cure is to take a B complex every day, specifically B1 (thiamine) and saturated fat to heal the nerves, so bacon and eggs is one of the best things I've found. I take a "stress" B complex that's less concentrated so I can have it every day. I've regained the ability to eat nightshades, but wheat/legumes/milk/nuts are still a problem. Does anyone know of any startups working to isolate and remove the GMO contamination from crops? There would be considerable money in bringing back pre-GMO crop varieties, since such a large percentage of the population can't eat what's on store shelves now. If we do, our digestion shuts down, we get severe inflammation, we get metabolic syndrome, we get diabetes, our quality of life diminishes to effectively nothing.. you see what I'm saying. They could call the crops heirloom or organic and charge twice as much and I and millions of other people would gladly buy them. Edit: since science is letting the population down at a level approaching conspiracy, I've embraced magical thinking in my own life. I find that holistic models simply perform better. I learned about the neuropathy issue here (no affiliation): https://www.youtube.com/c/WholeBodyHealingwithJen https://www.youtube.com/c/WholeBodyHealingwithJen
- adamgordonbell 4y agoWhat makes GMOs problematic?
- soperj 4y ago
- frazbin 4y agoIn the thread: bunch of tech workers acting like 19th century small farmers. The story here is that chemistry is a blunt tool and in 50 years we won't need it for agriculture. Biocontrols will have totally taken over. In the meantime anything we can do to remove incumbent chemical technologies and create economic room for their replacements is.. important. Why? cause we're gonna need those biocontrols anyway to keep farming at current yields under an evolving pest/weed regime. We got through the 20th century without sustainable farming. I'm OK with that, it led to things like me existing. Now it's time to focus a little more effort on doing the job properly.
- algoatecorn 4y agoBiocontrols have potential, but they have certainly not taken over. We will always use a combination of herbicides, genetic engineering, RNAi, and biocontrols. The key will be finding a balance between these technologies.
- algoatecorn 4y agoThese studies always bring out knee-jerk reactions in genpop, but you have to understand what herbicides and GMO crops have done to alleviate global hunger and malnutrition. In the most developed countries, we spend 7-15% of our income on food. The poorer you are, the higher that percentage is. In some African countries, families will spend upwards of 70% of their income for not just food, but for bags of rice. The bare minimum. In the past 4 decades, we've increased our crop yields by 4x. This is because of intensive farming. Now, is it destructive to the environment? Yes Does it create fragility in our food systems and supply chains? Yes Should we immediately stop using herbicides and large-scale monoculture systems? Think carefully about that one. When people say, we need to implement regenerative agriculture, or organic practices, or stop eating meat, etc, they rarely have a full understanding of how our agrifood system works. I'm an advocate for improving these systems, reducing herbicide use, and implementing sustainable practices (whatever that means at this point). But please, please, please try to fully understand how our food system really works. Try to understand the magnitude of cost reduction our current system has provided. Try to understand how global life expectancy has increased by >20 years due to these practices.
- Maursault 4y agoSo it has nothing to do with maximizing profits and greed? Good to know.
- bluGill 4y agoMaximum profit works best if you don't starve to death, and thus continue eating year after year. Even better if you decide you can afford to have a few kids (importantly feed them)
- algoatecorn 4y agoWho said that?
- malfist 4y agoThat's a false dichotomy and you know it. You can seek profit AND help make food less scarce at the same time.
- edumucelli 4y agoWe can reach high productivity of fruits and vegetables without fossil fuels: https://climateheroes.org/perrine-and-charles-herve-gruyer-permaculture-to-feed-us-and-heal-the-planet/ https://climateheroes.org/perrine-and-charles-herve-gruyer-p...