6 ms·
> Straightforward grants that do not hinge on scrapping a motor vehicle have also been raised from €200 to €300 and up to €300 for lower income households and p
by lm28469 4y ago
> Straightforward grants that do not hinge on scrapping a motor vehicle have also been raised from €200 to €300 and up to €300 for lower income households and people with disabilities.
Emphasis on "lower income", the cap is 13k euros per year, which is under the annual min wage if you work full time. If you earn above that you get nothing at all
Also, all the options (lump sums and trade-ins) are capped to 40% of the price of the bike. So you'd have to trade your car for a 6000+ euros electric bike to get the full 3000 euros
- dmix 4y agoI’ve lost count of how many times good sounding government programs turn out to be lame once you read the fine print. I really can’t see many people fitting either of those categories, unless they were already going to get rid of their car. And I’m a big fan of e-bikes. Most e-bikes cost around $2-3k so it’s basically a $1k subsidy where you pay the other $1k for a bike.
- cheschire 4y agoWhy is it lame that they had a specific group of disadvantaged people they were trying to target? When governments make blanket payouts (i.e. what the US did during COVID) people complain about the money going to people who don't need it. In this case they had a very specific group, intent, and budget. Isn't this what "small" government is supposed to do? And the bikes they're trying to encourage people to buy probably aren't the high end ones, or even the mid-range bikes. I'm guessing someone did some research at some point.
- qaq 4y agopeople making under 13K a year are not really buying 6K bikes
- wolfram74 4y agocostco has a folding ebike that's under 400$[0]. [0]https://www.costco.com/jetson-bolt-pro-folding-electric-bike.product.100712067.html https://www.costco.com/jetson-bolt-pro-folding-electric-bike...
- Workaccount2 4y agoTotal aside... That bike looks like one of those mini circus bikes that clowns ride
- jstanley 4y agoBut a 40% subsidy on a $400 bike is only worth $160, not the €4k headline figure.
- kaibee 4y agoIf you give everyone a no questions asked 100% subsidy, you're gonna have a lot of people reselling bikes that the government paid for.
- jacquesm 4y agoThey'd have to resell them abroad though, the local market would be pretty much saturated, no?
- danielheath 4y agoIt's not difficult to get from Paris to Barcelona and back, with or without a bike.
- Scoundreller 4y agoIf I need to offload an ebike from Paris, I could think of closer countries that would value them higher!
- antasvara 4y ago
- JKCalhoun 4y agoProbably the ones least able to afford petrol though?
- LtWorf 4y agoYou think poor people living in the banlieu are going to get such bikes they can't even afford to have them stolen in 1 hour? This was probably made targeting some specific category that isn't the one you're thinking. Better give some money to people who don't need it than make some overly complicated plan that requires a specialist to access and only targets some friends.
- jeromegv 4y ago> Better give some money to people who don't need it than make some overly complicated plan that requires a specialist to access and only targets some friends. I personally agree with that. But then it always ending up hurting the politicians that came up with that policy because medias will broadcast 24-7 examples of the few people that received it that did not deserve it. Even 2 years after COVID stimulus, McConnel keeps repeating that people are still so rich from receiving thousands and thousands of dollars and that was responsible for 2022 labor shortage... (for $2000 distributed now more than a year ago)
- LtWorf 4y agoYeah that's true. In Italy they gave some money to low income people and I'm sure after the next elections the right wing government that will win will take that away. They never say how it made people able to avoid joining black market jobs or crime. They just show restaurant owners crying because they can't find (greatly underpaid) workers.
- dmix 4y agoObviously because of how they targeted people and not that they targeted a demographic. 13.5% of the population has access to $300, which is fine but is probably not a the typical market for expensive bikes, and $300 will only get you 5-20% off (not including a helmet). A lot of these programs are made to sound good on campaign platforms but don’t do much at all IRL Finding a way to subsidize conversion kits + local shops to do it would be a good way to actually help poor people https://www.autoevolution.com/news/skarper-s-revolutionary-e-bike-conversion-kit-may-be-the-best-that-money-will-buy-196485.html https://www.autoevolution.com/news/skarper-s-revolutionary-e...
- panick21_ 4y agoYou know what bikes are good for poor people. Bikes without electric motors.
- bjarneh 4y ago> I’ve lost count of how many times good sounding government programs turn out to be lame once you read the fine print. This is certainly true. Not sure if the one we had in Norway a few years ago can be classified as 'lame'. But it did more harm than good I think, as electric bikes became associated with a government subsidy for the rich. Most of the money went directly to the richest areas in Oslo (which are the richest areas in Norway probably). The subsidy gave buyers of electric bikes 5.000 NOK (~$500), but bikes were hard to come by and very expensive at the time (2016), so only the rich got on waiting lists for bikes and swooped up all the subsidies. Source (in Norwegian): https://www.aftenposten.no/oslo/i/O3Vl/el-sykkelsubsidier-gikk-til-vestkanten-og-nordstrand https://www.aftenposten.no/oslo/i/O3Vl/el-sykkelsubsidier-gi...
- andrepd 4y agoThe same thing happened/is happening with electric vehicle subsidies: it's essentially a 4000€ gift to the rich that can afford a 70k€ car. What needs to be done is: (1) End subsidies for electric cars, and give them for e-bikes instead. With the 4k on a 70k you're barely making a dent, and you can use it instead to give e.g. 5× 800€ subsidies on 1000-1500€ e-bikes. (2) Lump sum instead of percentage. say 800€ on a 1000€ bike or 800€ on a 5000€ bike. (3) Give the money directly on the purchase instead of returning it later. This latter mode essentially blocks out people who don't have the money upfront. With solar panels this is especially grating: in my country you can get 85% subsidy on solar panels, which is just ludicrously efficient (I installed mine for ~500€ 6 months ago and they have nearly paid themselves back). But for that to work you need to have >5k€ lying around that you don't mind only being paid back in the end of the year! That excludes ~80-90% of people, according to statistics.
- bombcar 4y agoIt's even worse in the US! The electrical rebate is against tax collected, so you not only have to have the money to buy (or borrow to buy) an electric car, but you have to have enough tax liability to take advantage of the whole rebate. Or lease the car and let the car company take it for you. If it was an above the line credit, I would have highly considered it.
- peteradio 4y ago> so it’s basically a $1k subsidy where you pay the other $1k for a bike. And you are out a car?
- Doctor_Fegg 4y agoWhich is 100% realistic in large parts of France and indeed the rest of Europe.
- peteradio 4y agoIndeed, its possible to bike into Geneva from countryside France without showing papers, at least it was. I almost got smoked in a roundabout there, good times.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoIn the U.S. your insurance obligation will then plummet, registration fees evaporate and I suspect maintenance costs wither as well.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JKCalhoun 4y agoA program might ultimately succeed if it invigorates the market - eventually helping to bring down the price of e-bikes. I feel like (home) solar subsidies did that.
- rb666 4y agoWe're talking about commuter bikes, replacing a car...a good Speedelec is indeed 6k-10k Euros.
- touisteur 4y agoFor e-cargos you get good value for <5kEUR. Can't imagine plunking down 6k-10k (yet) on a non cargo ebike. I've tried a lot of the more expensive cargos and it feels some are not even trying to sell an integrated product you can use. Things like unsafe breaks, non-intuitive gear change, front wheel runaway vibration...
- bko 4y agoWhy does it sound good to begin with? Realistically who would trade in their car for a bike? I would imagine it would be young upper middle class urban dwellers. Not people with a family, elderly or people that live in cheaper suburban areas. It sounds like its a wealth transfer from taxpayers to the relatively wealthy.
- tomjen3 4y agoI had a coworker who brought an ebike instead of a second car. Probably others would choose to not replace their car with a new one if an ebike made more sense.
- Ragnarokk 4y agoBecause French cities are now planned to forbid cars inside the center. A lot of cities like Paris or Lyon have already planned dates for it to happen. Plus, old city centers tend to not have any garage and the few parking places are very expensive. Bicycle lanes tend to replace car lanes and circulating in car is nightmarish on design.
- Scoundreller 4y agoAfter getting lost in a few: « what design? »
- Ragnarokk 4y agoFor example, in my city, lots of 2-way streets are replaced by 1-way with bicycle lane. As there is more 1-ways, you sometimes have to drive in circles to get somewhere. On the weekends, parts of the city that are normally drivable are closed to cars. There is a highway entrance near my workplace. Some months ago, there was a stoplight on pedestrian demand, now it is mandatory even though there are close to no pedestrian there. The cars have now to wait 2 minutes more to get on the highway. I can't think of more for now but there are surely other examples.
- andrepd 4y ago> Not people with a family, elderly or people that live in cheaper suburban areas. The dutch manage to do it (minus the elderly). Why is it so strange that a 40 year old dad and a 7 year old kid bike to work/school respectively?
- causi 4y agoAlso, all the options (lump sums and trade-ins) are capped to 40% of the price of the bike. So you'd have to trade your car for a 6000+ euros electric bike to get the full 3000 euros What possible reason do they have for that? All it does is encourage people to buy a more expensive bike.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoThe reason it is capped at a percentage of the bike's purchase price is to limit abuse. If people have to spend a good chunk of their own money they may think twice, if it's a free ebike everyone will take the offer and immediately resell the bike (yay free money). I'm any case 4k is huge as most ebikes are cheaper than that... I suspect this is just to generate headline with a big number...
- causi 4y agoHow is it a free bike if they have to give up their car to get it?
- mytailorisrich 4y agoIf I have an old car I need to replace I can now have a free ebike, and then I buy my new car...
- lm28469 4y agoOr you could sell your car, or trade in your car (+ money) for another car It's limited to one per person anyways, it's not like the mafia was going to buy 500k cheap cars and get 500k brand new free electric bikes.
- probably_wrong 4y agoYou could buy a really cheap, barely functional car for 1k. You trade it in, get a 6k bike for free, and then you sell the bike.
- Xylakant 4y agoCargo bikes easily reach 6k. No problem. And those are the ones that often make sense if a family wants to trade in a car.
- egman_ekki 4y agoExactly, starting price for an electric cargo bike is 3k€ (https://www.babboe.nl/babboe-big-e https://www.babboe.nl/babboe-big-e) and better models go for 6-7k€ (https://www.butchersandbicycles.com/mk1e-vario https://www.butchersandbicycles.com/mk1e-vario).
- whazor 4y agoFor people considering a cargo bike, counterintuitively: a two-wheeled cargo bikes are much easier to cycle than three-wheeled cargo bikes. Actually you are more likely to fall with a three-wheeled cargo bike. Even when parking you would think a two wheel cargo bike easily falls but the kick-stands are easy and it is not a problem.
- Xylakant 4y agoI’d say so-so. Depends on the use-case. Two wheeled are definitely easier to ride with a faster pace, but they’re much harder to balance when heavily loaded. I have tipped over with heavy loads on emergency stops. Two wheeled also wins when there’s little space or the track is bad. What’s better really depends on your cycling proficiency, your intended use case and the road network you’ll likely use. And whatever you do, test-ride a few different ones to figure out what works for you. Avoid buying something off the internet without ever trying. (Things are different if you’re buying your second, third,…)
- bombcar 4y agoThe stable three-wheel trikes have the dual wheels in the front which is found sometimes, but not terribly effective for cargo hauling. And if you have four wheels, people stop considering you a bike.
- throw0101a 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Timshel 4y agoFor the trade-in a 1500€ cap is available to everyone and depending where you live an additional 1000€ may be available (low emission zone which include at the moment 10 of the biggest cities).
- arkh 4y agoAnd it's the French administration. Get ready for months long of back and forth about missing documents or information before you can hope to see your money.
- Scoundreller 4y agoIn practice, I’ve found it variable. Drivers licenses are a lifetime thing: no need to renew every X years, because it’s not your photo ID. Another thing they do well (from a US/Canadian point of view) is identify their people. It’s all national: very little is state by state or city by city. Need a birth certificate or police report? Just sign in with your national ID and they’re in your mailbox in under a week. None of this North American garbage where you need to provide fingerprints or further details because you share a birth date with a criminal or have the same name as someone else born somewhere else on the same day. And when claiming a tax credit, that should make it straight forward, because it will be difficult to make the claim multiple times by varying your demographics. Tax returns are bloody simple if you’re a non-billionaire: log in and verify that, yes, the information that the government already has about your income and housing situation is correct and click Accept. Done. More Difficult to cheat on your rental property taxes since every property needs to be declared as an own-use or income property, with further details required for the latter.
- hokkos 4y agoI've done the 400€ scheme 2 years ago for an eMTB and although it was long like 2 months but just 1 form and no back and forth at all.
- saryant 4y agoDenver, CO is offering $1200-1800 ebike subsidies to low income residents and $400 to those above the threshold. It’s been enormously popular. https://www.5280.com/2022/07/everything-you-need-to-know-about-denvers-e-bike-rebate-program/ https://www.5280.com/2022/07/everything-you-need-to-know-abo...
- touisteur 4y agoI read the law some months ago and it was 13k per dependant ('part'). This is still a good deal for poor to struggling families. Trade your money pit for this new bike. This specific one is meant for poor families looking for a means of moving around. I can tell, looking at the yearly cost of owning a car, that this could really help some city folks getting out of the trap of auto-credit/insurance/maintenance cost that makes end-of-months a struggle. And be careful with such subsidies: when they created the 600eur subvention for e-cargo in Paris I observed a (maybe uncorrelated) substantial increase in price of e-cargos...