9 ms·
Suppose you have five lasers on your nuclear aircraft carrier, they have 20km range, they need five seconds on target to destroy it (plus an insignificant amoun
by kragen 4y ago
Suppose you have five lasers on your nuclear aircraft carrier, they have 20km range, they need five seconds on target to destroy it (plus an insignificant amount of time to switch to the next target), and your radar/OpenCV/whatever is good enough to detect all the incoming drones. Suppose they go 200 km/h (56 m/s), which is a pretty leisurely clip for aircraft. If they all come into range at the same time, you have six minutes to burn them all up.
In this scenario it takes 361 drones to land one on an aircraft carrier, sinking it unless the attacker totally fucks up. If they're like these Turkish Bayraktar TB2 drones the article says have destroyed 750 land vehicles (I guess in the Ukraine war alone?) that cost US$5M each, that's US$1.8 billion dollars to sink the aircraft carrier. That's not too bad; you can build a new aircraft carrier for US$9 billion or so.
But what if the drones cost US$5000 each? Or US$50? Or what if they travel at mach 2? Or are submarines, like loitering torpedoes or guided mines?
It may be more economical to just send drones to the country where the aircraft carrier is from to kill the family members of its military officers, or at least the ones who don't cooperate.
Although I have no particular love for US foreign policy and military adventurism, I fear we are passing out of a period of relative peace and entering a period of extreme unpredictability. There is no guarantee that the new stable equilibrium will have states or civilization in it.
- AnonMO 4y agoMy comment wasn’t this serious but I don’t think any munition that can damage an aircraft carrier will be that cheap. Also im no expert but with more energy isnt the distance at which the heat from the laser remains effective becomes longer right? So if the tech is truly mature isn’t 20km a bit naïve also what if each laser system is an array of lasers with independent movement maybe 10-20 laser per system this configuration will definitely out power drones at the scale you speak of. The future is hard to predict.
- kragen 4y agoI think that beyond 20km the horizon is between the laser and the drone. Maybe aircraft-mounted lasers could defend the carrier over a wider area. If each drone costs US$50 then you can launch 180 million drones for the cost of an aircraft carrier. I don't think increasing the number of lasers from my 5 to 10-20 is going to help much. I don't know what is needed for a munition to damage an aircraft carrier, but I feel like once it's on the deck it's already past the strong defenses and into the soft targets. It could be as simple as a wheeled robot that runs around stabbing random people, or a poison gas canister that fills the interior of the ship with mustard gas, or hundreds of hand-grenade-sized mini-claymores that deploy to random parts of the ship and conceal themselves quietly until a sailor happens to walk by.
- dogcomplex 4y agoShaped charges can blast a sizable hole through any material, likely big enough to fly the next drone through. Only so many hits to get through a hull.
- kragen 4y agoYeah, in a realistic scenario, if the carrier can take out 360 drones before the drone wave reaches it, the adversary would launch 700 drones, not 361. I hadn't even thought about hitting the carrier in the same place over and over again. But supposedly carriers aren't even designed with thick armor?
- ThrowawayR2 4y agoIf drones are so magically cheap, the carrier deploys its own magically cheap defensive drone swarm to protect itself when attacked by drones and remains unscathed.
- marshray 4y agoWhat if a defensive drone swarm, to be effective, must be generations more advanced than the attacking drone swarm? There could be an interim period of many years where very important stuff is very vulnerable.
- dogcomplex 4y agoWould expect this to be the dominant countermeasure in the case where drones are a significant threat, yeah. Though actually I'm coming around to the idea that a bunch of AI-targeted flak guns are sufficient, and that carriers are probably fine either way due to how close a series of missiles containing the swarm would have to get anyway.
- kragen 4y agoYeah, that's the future I'm pointing to: the aircraft carrier itself is no longer militarily relevant, because what counts are the drone swarms. But there's no particular reason to expect that this future will be a Mohist one in which peace is ensured because magically cheap defensive drone swarms make every fortress impregnable and thus combatants' home territories always remain unscathed; at least as likely is a Second Variety future in which drone swarms are more effective for attack than for defense, perhaps even after all the human combatants are dead.
- jiggawatts 4y ago> any munition that can damage an aircraft carrier will be that cheap It's all about targeting smarts and precision! This has been well demonstrated in Ukraine, where GPS-guided missile artillery can simply "reach out and touch someone" 50 miles away. Even tiny drones could do fantastic damage if precisely targetted using on-board AI. They could target personnel, fuel, electrical equipment, optics. Don't think about a 50kg bomb dropped on the deck. Think of a swarm of 500g drones with 100g shaped charges making a beeline for the control tower, and the engine intake of every parked plane.
- ThrowawayR2 4y ago> "a swarm of 500g drones" Which have laughable range and can't handle anything heavier than a stiff breeze, let alone weather conditions at sea.
- asdff 4y agoPack them in a torpedo that releases them right next to the boat.
- ThrowawayR2 4y agoSurely you are joking. If a hostile can get a torpedo that close to the target without being detected, they would just use a ordinary torpedo and warhead instead.
- asdff 4y agoMaybe the ordinary torpedo with a warhead is too large and visible on radar. The drone torpedo could be much smaller, maybe the size of a common fish in the area. Maybe you have a bunch of them herded together traveling under water in the same manner as a school of fish might appear on radar.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoTorpedoes aren't visible on radar, you mean sonar. You're not going to sink a ship with 500g explosive fish-shaped torpedo-launched drone things. This plan boils down to a really weird and elaborate method of throwing hand grenades at a super-carrier until it sinks. This whole line of discussion is absurd.
- asdff 4y agoImagine you had a drone that could dive to the ocean floor, pick up a chunk of rock, fly up one foot above the deck and drop the rock, then fly back down and repeat. Imagine you had 10 thousand of these swarming a single aircraft carrier. You'd be able to sink it before long, and the poor sailors aboard will have no defence against 10 thousand tiny machines that only appear for a second and are all around the ship. Anything you fire at them is liable to damage the ship itself. Maybe you wouldn't even need to have them come above the water line. Maybe the drone is just a weight and a magnet that can clamp onto the ships haul below the water line. Again, you can't combat that without having thousands of divers below your ship scraping the hull.
- CamperBob2 4y agoImagine you had a drone that could dive to the ocean floor, pick up a chunk of rock, fly up one foot above the deck and drop the rock, then fly back down and repeat That would take a ridiculous amount of energy.
- kragen 4y agoIf we suppose we have to stack 100'000 more tonnes of rock on top of a 100'000 tonne displacement aircraft carrier to sink it, and the ocean is 2 km deep at that point, it takes about 1.96 terajoules at 100% efficiency. At 46 MJ/kg that's 43 tonnes of gasoline. That is a ridiculously small amount of energy to sink a carrier; it's maybe a large gas station. Of course the question is open: how efficient would the rock-stacking drones be? If they're 50% efficient the scale of the operation is different than if they're 0.05% efficient.
- CamperBob2 4y agoSeems that energy will need to be expended in both directions, given that you're working in the opposite direction of the usual diving practice where a weighted diver sinks to the bottom and releases ballast to come back up. Is that being accounted for? Also, I imagine somebody will notice this rock-stacking activity at some point over the (days? weeks?) it will to swamp the aircraft carrier, and take care of the problem with plain old birdshot. Or just a bunch of sailors with brooms or fire hoses. Failing that, just cruise away from the drone swarm. They'll run out of gas long before the carrier runs out of U235.
- Pelic4n 4y agoSo, in your described scenario, drones are functionally no different than a missile barrage, except slower, cheaper and maybe easier to deploy. So: - Effective countermeasures already exists against this kind of threats, like CIWS. - Carriers don't exists in a vacuum, there are a lot of other systems in a modern carrier group. - Just like launching a missile barrage, deploying the tens/hundreds of thousands of drones is going to be quite the logistical achievement, especially bringing it in range of a modern carrier group, designed to project force against threats hundreds of kilometers away. - Drones have significant range/projection issues. The Bayraktar, at $2M a piece, has ~300km of range and can only bear a very small payload designed to engage armored ground targets, nothing that would threaten carriers or destroyers, even deployed en masse. - The bigger the range, the bigger the payload, the bigger the size/costs. The effectiveness of your drone swarm is always limited by this equation. Millions of small aliexpress drones bearing the equivalent of a hand grenade are not going to do anything against a carrier provided it can be deployed at all. You would need to be <10km away due to their range limitation and at this stage, there are already fighter jets and destroyers sitting on top of you. - No single munition under the kiloton order of magnitude will sink an aircraft carrier. For a drone or anything under the scale of cruise missiles/MOAB, this means nuclear. Hand-grenade sized nuclear explosives in drone swarms? I wish! But to quote the fantastic game Highfleet, once you get the genie out, you cannot put it back in the bottle. If you plan to bring nuclear weapons to a war, everybody already has ICBMs. tl;dr: Drones swarms don't disrupt the current status quo: Nothing except nuclear attacks or another modern carrier group will defeat a modern carrier group in a single engagement. The usefullness of drone swarms is not against modern carrier groups but small-scale asymmetrical engagements, such as the guerilla operations currently carried in Ukraine or in Syria, in which small drones are incredibly effective weapons. This is still a big deal, as it is the most likely form of conflict we're going to see in the rest of this century, not full-on peer-to-peer conflicts between superpowers.
- sbierwagen 4y ago>Effective countermeasures already exists against this kind of threats, like CIWS. Phalanx has a magazine of 1,550 rounds, and each burst fires 100 rounds. Firing continuously, it would expend its magazine in 20.6 seconds. Firing perfectly, (with no hostile ECM) it could splash fifteen incoming targets. What if they launch thirty?
- usrusr 4y agoA drone able to sink an aircraft carrier with a single hit? (sink, not inconvenience) Those are usually called cruise missiles and not exactly novel. I do share the sentiment expressed in the last paragraph.
- avereveard 4y agoPayload size and speed are major consideration for unit price. Besides there already are standoff autonomous munitions, we have had missiles carrying their own guidance hardware for more than fifty years now, and if you want speed, rocket will definitely beat propellers Tldr you've built an argument on top of a triad of features that actually are more of a 'pick two' deal.